FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS102E Ministry Ethics and Boundaries: Power, Money, Relationships, Accountability

Lecture 6-1: Mistake, Violation, Abuse

Contents 31
FS102E Ministry Ethics and Boundaries: Power, Money, Relationships, Accountability
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Power Given to Build Up
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Power Given to Build Up
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Power and Spiritual Authority
  1. Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
  3. Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
  4. Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Money and Gifts
  1. Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
  2. Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
  3. Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
  4. Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Relationships and Sexual Boundaries
  1. Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
  2. Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
  3. Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
  4. Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Confidence, Information and Honesty
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
  2. Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
  3. Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
  4. Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Structures of Accountability
  1. Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
  2. Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
  3. Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
  4. Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
Chapter 6 · Week 6: When Wrong Comes to Light
  1. Lecture 6-1: Mistake, Violation, Abuse
  2. Lecture 6-2: Taking Responsibility
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Harmed Person First
  4. Lecture 6-4: Forgiveness, Restoration and Return
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, A Plan for the Day It Comes

Jump to the key points ↓

27 min

Sooner or later, something a minister has done turns out to be wrong. It may come to light because the minister notices it, because a colleague asks a question, or because a person who was hurt finds the courage to speak. The first minutes after that moment matter a great deal. People tend to say the first thing that protects them, and the first thing that protects the minister is often not the thing that protects anyone else.

This lecture gives one tool for those minutes: a way to tell three kinds of wrong apart. A mistake is an error made in good faith. A violation is the breaking of a promise, a rule or a duty that the minister knew about. Abuse is the use of power over another person to harm that person. The three need different responses. Treating abuse as a mistake is one of the gravest failures a church can make. Treating a mistake as abuse is also a failure, though a smaller one, because it makes honest people afraid to speak.

The lecture also looks at the ways people explain a wrong away, and at King David, whose repentance is read in Scripture beside the harm that still followed. The central claim of the course applies here as everywhere: ministry ethics is the limiting of your own power for the sake of the people who trusted you. When wrong comes to light, the first test of that is whether the harmed person, and not the minister's reputation, is at the front of the mind.

What these 27 minutes give you

  • Define mistake, violation and abuse, and give the response that fits each.
  • Explain why the person who did the wrong should not be the one who decides which kind it is.
  • Recognise five common shapes of an excuse, including the staged apology.
  • Explain what David's repentance did and did not change, using 2 Samuel 12 and Psalm 51.
  • Read a small invented case and say which kind of wrong it shows and what the first step is.

Nathan said to David, “You are the man. This is what Yahweh, the God of Israel, says: ‘I anointed you king over Israel, and I delivered you out of the hand of Saul." — 2 Samuel 12:7

World English Bible

Why have you despised Yahweh’s word, to do that which is evil in his sight? You have struck Uriah the Hittite with the sword, and have taken his wife to be your wife, and have slain him with the sword of the children of Ammon." — 2 Samuel 12:9

WEB

David said to Nathan, “I have sinned against Yahweh.” Nathan said to David, “Yahweh also has put away your sin. You will not die." — 2 Samuel 12:13

WEB

However, because by this deed you have given great occasion to Yahweh’s enemies to blaspheme, the child also who is born to you shall surely die.”" — 2 Samuel 12:14

WEB

Have mercy on me, God, according to your loving kindness. According to the multitude of your tender mercies, blot out my transgressions." — Psalm 51:1

WEB

For I know my transgressions. My sin is constantly before me." — Psalm 51:3

WEB

Against you, and you only, have I sinned, and done that which is evil in your sight; that you may be proved right when you speak, and justified when you judge." — Psalm 51:4

WEB

He who conceals his sins doesn’t prosper, but whoever confesses and renounces them finds mercy." — Proverbs 28:13

WEB

The prophet Nathan has told David a story about a rich man who took a poor man's only lamb. David has said the man deserves to die. Then:

The psalm that is read beside this story begins:

Nathan names the wrong in plain words. David does not argue. The forgiveness he is told of and the loss that follows are both in the same passage.

1. The first question

When wrong comes to light, the usual first question is "How bad is it for us?" The better first question is "What kind of wrong is this, and who has been hurt?" The first question looks at the minister and the community's name. The second looks at the people.

The answer decides what happens next: who must be told, who may act, and what the minister must stop doing at once. So it is worth learning the three kinds before the day comes.

2. Three kinds of wrong

Three words used in this course

A mistake is an error made in good faith, without breaking a known duty, and without using power over someone. The wrong date was announced. A hospital visit was forgotten. A budget figure was added up wrongly. It can still hurt people, and it still needs to be put right.

A violation is the breaking of a promise, a rule or a duty that the minister knew about: a written code, a shared-control rule for money, a promise of confidence, a limit on contact. Someone chose, or allowed, the breach. Nobody need have been deliberately harmed, though people often are.

Abuse is the use of power, trust or office over another person to harm that person. It can be sexual, emotional, spiritual, financial or physical. It is always more serious when the person is a child, or is dependent, grieving, new, or afraid. Lecture 1-3 explained why the other person's consent does not change this when the minister holds power.

A short test may help. Ask three questions. Did the minister know of a duty and break it? If no, it may be a mistake. Was there a person with less power on the other side? If yes, take extra care. Was someone harmed through the minister's power or position? If yes, the matter may be abuse, whether or not it was meant.

The words are tools for choosing a response. They are not labels to win an argument. A wrong can sit between two of them, and a mistake that is hidden, repeated or defended can become a violation. That is why the next section matters.

3. Why the difference matters: the response that fits

Kind What the minister does Who else must be involved
Mistake Say so quickly and plainly, put it right, and tell those affected. Learn what let it happen. Those affected. A colleague or overseer, if the matter touches money, records or other people's trust.
Violation Say so, tell the body that holds the minister to account (lecture 5-2), repair what can be repaired, and accept the consequences it decides. The overseer, council, board or other body. A person who was harmed, if there is one.
Abuse Stop all contact the harmed person has not asked for. Do not try to investigate, explain or settle it alone. Let others protect the harmed person first. Accept removal from duties while others examine it. The harmed person's chosen supporters, those who protect people in your community, the authorities your local law names, and qualified professionals.

In the third row the minister is not the one in charge of the process. That is deliberate. When a person with power has harmed a person with less power, a process that the first person runs or shapes repeats the harm.

Reporting duties, and the way such matters are handled, differ by country and by region. This course gives no legal advice. Follow local law and your community's written rules, and ask a qualified person where the law may apply.

4. Three small cases

(An invented example.) The double booking. A parish priest promises two families the church hall on the same Saturday, one for a baptism party and one for a funeral meal. He discovers it on Thursday. He telephones both families that evening, says plainly that the error is his, and finds a second hall for one of them at the parish's cost. He tells the parish council at its next meeting and asks the secretary to keep one shared calendar. This is a mistake, and the response fits it: quick, plain, repair, and one change so that it does not repeat.

(An invented example.) The heating money. A pastor in a small church is also the treasurer. The council has agreed that money given for a repair fund may be used only for repairs and that two people must sign every payment. In winter the heating bill cannot be paid. The pastor pays it from the repair fund on his own signature, meaning to put the money back in spring. He tells no one. This is a violation. He knew the rule. He may not have meant harm, and the money may be restored. But he broke a duty that existed so that nobody would have to rely on his good intentions. The fit response is to tell the council at once, repay, accept whatever the council decides about his role with money, and join the council in setting up a second signature. If he waits until spring and hopes nobody notices, he has moved from a violation toward concealment (lecture 4-4).

(An invented example.) The messages. A youth worker has sent private messages of a romantic kind to a sixteen-year-old girl in his youth group, and has asked her to keep them secret. The girl has told her mother. This is abuse of power over a young person, whatever the youth worker feels or says about it. The first concern is the girl and her family: their safety, their wishes and their need for support. The youth worker should have no contact with her and should not explain or defend himself to her or her family unless they ask. Those whose work is to protect young people, and the authorities that local law names, must be told by those in charge. The church leaders do not decide the matter among themselves. The leaders' fear of scandal has no place in the decision.

No one of these cases is hard to sort. The hard cases come when the minister or the community has reasons to want the wrong to be smaller than it is.

5. Who decides which kind it is

The person who did the wrong should not be the only one to decide which kind it was. A minister who is frightened or ashamed will usually choose the smaller word. This is not always lying. People really do see their own acts more kindly than other people see them.

So a simple rule helps: when you are not sure, treat the matter as the more serious kind until someone who is not involved has looked at it. If you made a mistake, little is lost by having a colleague look. If you did not make only a mistake, a great deal is saved.

The same rule applies to a community. A church council that hears of a wrong done by someone it loves is in the same position as the minister. It will want the smaller word. It needs people outside the friendship to read the facts.

A caution in the other direction: the rule is not meant to treat every error as a crime. Most of what goes wrong in ministry is ordinary. A community that responds to every mistake as a scandal teaches its ministers to hide. Be quick to put a mistake right and slow to give it a bigger name than it earns.

6. The shapes of an excuse

An excuse is an attempt to answer a charge without admitting what was done. Excuses come in a few common shapes. Learn them, first in yourself.

Shrinking. "It was only a few messages." "It was a small amount." "It happened once." The words only, just and a little point away from the harmed person and toward the size of the act as the minister would like it to be.

Blaming others. "She misunderstood me." "The board pushed me." "Nobody told me the rule." Some of these may contain a fact. But when a sentence about my act turns into a sentence about someone else, I have changed the subject.

it spiritual attack. "The enemy wants to destroy this ministry." Scripture does speak of opposition, and ministers do meet real hostility. The difficulty arises when the words are used to answer a charge of wrong. A good test: does the sentence answer what was done? If a person says that something happened, and the reply is that the person is being used by the enemy, the harmed person has been turned into the problem. No act becomes right by being renamed as an attack.

The staged apology. "I am sorry if anyone was offended." "I regret that this has become public." "Mistakes were made." An apology of this kind is shaped to protect the speaker. It says "if" about a harm that has happened. It names the discovery, not the deed. It is often given in public to end the matter, and then the person asks that everyone move on. Lecture 6-2 describes what a real apology contains.

Hurrying to the pardon. "I have asked God to forgive me, and he has. Now let us move forward." God's forgiveness is real, and the Scripture for this lecture says so. But the sentence is used as a way to close the matter before the people who were hurt have been heard. The forgiveness a minister receives from God does not settle the account the minister has with those people, and it does not decide who may hold office. Lecture 6-4 treats this at length.

7. David: repentance and what still followed

King David is the person Scripture shows at this moment, and he shows both the right and the hard parts. The reading in this lecture is brief and cautious.

The story begins before Nathan comes. The narrative of 2 Samuel 11 says that David sent messengers and took Bathsheba, the wife of Uriah, and that later he arranged for Uriah to die in battle. David was king. The people involved were a soldier and a woman, and neither had power equal to his. This is the shape this course keeps in view: the one with the greater power was the one who acted, and the greater responsibility was his.

Nathan comes to him with a story, and then with a direct sentence: "You are the man." He names what David did, using plain verbs: David struck down Uriah and took his wife. He does not soften the deed, and he does not speak of David's reputation. A person with less rank than the king says the true thing to the king. That is one scene of accountability the Bible keeps for us.

David says, "I have sinned against Yahweh." The answer comes at once: the sin is put away and David will not die. Then the passage continues. There are consequences. The sword will not leave David's house. The child will die. Forgiveness was real, and the harm did not undo itself. The text does not offer the child's death as a pleasant lesson. It is a loss that falls on the household.

Psalm 51 is read beside the story, and it has a heading that ties it to the time Nathan came to David. Readers differ on how old and how reliable such headings are, but reading the psalm beside the story is what the heading invites. In it David says, "Against you, and you only, have I sinned." Some people have used this verse to say that the wrong is a matter between a sinner and God alone. That reading goes beyond what the passage needs. The story has just said that David struck down Uriah. The psalm is a prayer of confession addressed to God, who is the final judge, and for whom the wrong is the deepest offence. It does not tell us that Uriah and Bathsheba were not wronged. A minister who quotes this verse to say "this is between God and me" has stopped at the first half of what the story teaches.

Proverbs 28:13 sets the same two movements side by side: to conceal does not prosper, to confess and renounce finds mercy. Renounce means to turn away from the wrong in action as well as in words. The verse does not say that confessing alone finds mercy.

8. Where the institution makes the same moves

The shapes of excuse are not only personal. A church, a school, a mission or an order can shrink a matter ("a misunderstanding"), blame others ("a disgruntled member"), call it an attack, issue a staged statement, or hurry to say that the matter has been forgiven. It can also move a person to another post without telling the people there, or keep a matter "in the family". Each is a way of protecting the institution at the cost of a person.

The rule of this course applies to the community as it does to the minister: the aim is never the protection of the institution. Its name, its income and its calm are not what is at stake. The people who trusted it are.

9. What a good response looks like

It helps to end with the good, not only the failures. A good response in the first week looks like this. The minister does not wait to be found. Someone who was hurt is told, in plain words and through a safe route, that it is being treated seriously. The matter is handed to people who are able to look at it fairly. The minister steps back from the duties that the wrong touches, without being asked twice. The community is told only what it needs to know, and the privacy of the harmed person is guarded. Nobody argues that the minister's long service is a reason to treat the matter as small.

Lecture 6-2 describes what a person who has done wrong does next. Lecture 6-3 describes what everyone else does when someone discloses harm.


Diagram 1. Three kinds of wrong, three responses

Three Kinds of Wrong Each needs a different response Mistake Error in good faith No known duty broken Admit, fix, learn Violation A known duty broken Rule, promise or limit Tell the body, repair Abuse Power used to harm Harmed person first Others lead the process Who decides which kind it is? Not the person who did it, alone When unsure, treat it as the more serious kind until others have looked The aim is never to protect the institution.

Diagram 2. Five shapes of an excuse

Shape A sentence that signals it What it avoids
Shrinking "It was only once." The size of the harm as the harmed person knows it
Blaming others "She misunderstood me." The minister's own act
Spiritual attack "The enemy is after this ministry." The question of what was done
Staged apology "I am sorry if anyone was offended." The deed and the people hurt
Hurrying to pardon "God has forgiven me. Let us move on." The people hurt, and the question of office

In short

  • A mistake is an error in good faith; a violation breaks a duty the minister knew; abuse uses power over another person to harm that person. The responses differ.
  • The one who did the wrong should not alone decide which kind it was. When unsure, treat it as the more serious kind until outsiders have looked.
  • In abuse, the harmed person's safety and voice come first, and the minister does not run, shape or judge the process.
  • Excuses take shapes: shrinking, blaming, calling it spiritual attack, the staged apology, and hurrying to pardon.
  • David was forgiven, and the harm still followed. Forgiveness from God does not settle the account with the people hurt.
Front Back
Mistake An error made in good faith, with no known duty broken and no use of power over someone; it is admitted quickly and put right.
Violation The breaking of a promise, rule or duty the minister knew about; it is reported to the body that holds the minister to account.
Abuse The use of power, trust or office to harm another person; the harmed person comes first and others lead the process.
Staged apology A statement built to protect the speaker: it says "if", names the discovery and not the deed, and asks everyone to move on.

One sentence to remember When wrong comes to light, first ask what kind of wrong it is and who was hurt, never how bad it looks for us.

This week's action Write down, in one line each, an example of a mistake, a violation and abuse from your own tradition's setting, and who would decide which kind a real case was.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of the three kinds of wrong. In your own place, who would decide which kind a given wrong was, if the minister could not? Is that person truly outside the friendship?
  • In the case of the heating money, the pastor meant to repay. Why does the lecture still call it a violation? What did the shared-control rule protect?
  • Which of the five shapes of an excuse is easiest for a person like you to fall into? What would be a sentence that does the opposite?
  • Psalm 51:4 says, "Against you, and you only, have I sinned." Explain, in your own words, why a minister should not use this verse to say a wrong is between God and the minister alone.
  • An institution can use the same excuses as a person. Name one way in which a community you know might shrink a wrong without meaning to.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.