Lecture 4-2: Body, Eyes and Place
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Many Ways of Preaching
- Lecture 1-2: Between the Passage and the Hearers
- Lecture 1-3: Saying It in One Sentence
- Lecture 1-4: A Week of Preparation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, One Passage, One Sentence
- Lecture 2-1: A Road the Ear Can Follow
- Lecture 2-2: Several Shapes
- Lecture 2-3: Beginnings and Endings
- Lecture 2-4: Stories and Illustrations, Honestly Told
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A One-Page Outline
- Lecture 3-1: Writing for the Ear
- Lecture 3-2: Reading the Scripture Aloud
- Lecture 3-3: Full Text, Notes, or No Script
- Lecture 3-4: Borrowing Honestly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Paragraph Aloud
- Lecture 4-1: The Voice
- Lecture 4-2: Body, Eyes and Place
- Lecture 4-3: Fear, Failure and Recovery
- Lecture 4-4: The Sermon Inside the Service
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Three Minutes Aloud
- Lecture 5-1: Why Preachers Need Other Ears
- Lecture 5-2: Watching and Saying
- Lecture 5-3: Receiving
- Lecture 5-4: Running a Preaching Group
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The Observation Sheet
When a preacher stands up, the hearers receive more than sound. They see where the preacher looks, how the preacher stands, what the hands do, what is behind and beside the preacher, and what is worn. None of this is the sermon. All of it is part of how the sermon is received.
Lecture 4-1 dealt with the voice. This lecture turns to what can be seen. The rule that governs it is the same: nothing should cover the Word. Anything that calls attention to itself, a nervous habit, a costume, a screen, a prop, a dramatic movement, stands between the hearers and what is being said. Anything that helps the hearers feel that the preacher is speaking to them helps the Word reach them.
The lecture will also say plainly that cultures and traditions differ here more than in almost any other part of preaching. What counts as respectful eye contact in one country is rude in another. A gesture that is warm in one place is odd or offensive in another. So the lecture does not give a list of correct postures. It gives a set of questions, and some examples of how they have been answered.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain how to use the eyes when speaking from a script, from notes and without either, and how local custom changes the advice.
- Describe, in your own setting, a standing position and a set of gestures that serve the hearers and do not distract them.
- Prepare for preaching on camera or through a screen, and name what changes there.
- State what slides, notes and clothing should and should not do.
Paul stood up, and beckoning with his hand said, “Men of Israel, and you who fear God, listen." — Acts 13:16
World English Bible
Agrippa said to Paul, “You may speak for yourself.” Then Paul stretched out his hand, and made his defense." — Acts 26:1
WEB
He closed the book, gave it back to the attendant, and sat down. The eyes of all in the synagogue were fastened on him." — Luke 4:20
WEB
Luke records three different postures: Paul standing and beckoning to get a crowd to listen, Paul with a hand stretched out in a courtroom setting, and Jesus sitting down after the reading while every eye is on him. The Scripture does not fix one posture for the speaker. It shows the speaker's body used in the setting at hand, and it shows hearers who are looking.
1. Why the body is part of the hearing
A hearer takes in a speaker through two channels at once. One carries the words. The other carries what the hearer sees: whether the speaker is looking at the people, whether the speaker seems at ease or afraid, whether the speaker's face matches what is being said. When the two agree, the hearer is free to attend to the words. When they disagree, the hearer notices the disagreement, and attention goes there.
A preacher who says, "I want to tell you something that matters to me," while reading from the page without looking up, is sending two signals. The words say, "I am speaking to you." The body says, "I am speaking to the page." Most hearers will believe the body.
This does not make the body the main thing. It means that the body is rarely neutral, and a little attention to it removes obstacles.
2. The eyes
The most important use of the eyes is simple: look at the people. A speaker who looks at the hearers makes it possible for the hearers to look back, and a sermon is received differently when the room is looking at the speaker than when everyone is looking at their own thoughts.
Here is how that works in each of the three ways of preaching from lecture 3-3.
With a full text. The risk is the page. The habit that helps is to read a phrase, look up, and say it. The eyes go down to take in a thought and come up to give it. This works well if the text has been written in short sentences, as lecture 3-1 recommended, and if the print is large enough to read at a glance. Many preachers find it useful to mark the first words of each paragraph so that the eye can find its place after a glance at the people.
With notes. The danger is not the page but the long glance down, when the preacher looks for the next point while the hearers wait. Keep notes brief enough to be seen at a glance. When you need to look for your place, stop speaking while you look; do not keep talking with your eyes down.
Without a script. The danger is the opposite: looking everywhere except at people, at the ceiling, the floor or the back wall. If you are working from memory, the eyes tend to go inward as you search for the next thought. Plan a moment, a pause, when you will look at someone while you collect the next idea.
Whichever way you preach, spread your looks over the room, not over the same two or three friendly faces. Look at one person for the length of one thought, then another. In a large room, think in regions: left, centre, right, front, back. Hearers at the edges and the back notice when they are never looked at.
This is where local custom matters. In many places direct, steady eye contact is a sign of honesty and respect. In others it is not: it may be rude to look steadily at an , or at a person of the other sex, or at someone of higher rank. In some places it may be normal for a speaker to look slightly above the heads of the hearers, or toward the whole room rather than a single person. A preacher should learn what is expected and not carry rules from another place. If you are unsure, ask a respected person in the community what looks respectful, and follow it. The principle stays the same everywhere: let the way you look at people say, "I am speaking to you, and I am glad you are here."
3. Posture and place
Posture should be steady enough that the hearers do not notice it. The common faults are not dramatic. Weight shifted from foot to foot, leaning on the lectern, hands gripping the edges, pacing in the same short line, turning the shoulders away from part of the room. Each of these tells the hearers that the preacher is uneasy, and the hearers begin to watch the unease.
A few general points hold in most places.
- Stand where the hearers can see you and you can see them. If a pillar blocks part of the room or the light is behind you so your face is dark, move, or ask for the light to be changed.
- Let your weight be even on both feet and your knees not locked. A steady stance steadies the voice as well.
- Move for a reason. A step toward the people when you ask a question, a step back as you begin a new movement, can be useful. Wandering is not.
- In some places the preacher sits to teach. Luke 4:20 shows Jesus sitting after the reading, and some traditions keep the custom of the teacher's seat. Others keep to a fixed place, a lectern, an ambo, a raised pulpit. Still others have the preacher stand among the people, on the same floor. These are not better or worse. They reflect different pictures of the preacher's relation to the people. A preacher should work well within the place the community has given.
4. The hands
Hands are the place where nerves show most. The question is not how to find the right gesture, but how to stop the hands from being a problem.
Start with an easy rest position, a hand on the edge of the lectern, hands loosely at the sides, hands lightly together. Then allow gestures to arise from what you are saying, as they do in ordinary talk. A hand that opens when you say "everyone," a hand raised to ask for attention when you say "listen" (compare Acts 13:16, where Paul beckons with his hand), are natural. What distracts is the repeated, unrelated movement: tapping, jingling things in a pocket, pointing a finger at the hearers, adjusting glasses, hair or clothing again and again.
The size of a gesture varies by culture. In some places broad movements are normal in speech and a still speaker seems cold or controlled. In others even small hand movements in public speaking seem excessive, and a speaker who moves a lot looks as if performing. Do not take a rule from a book or a video of a preacher from another country. Watch how respected speakers in your own community use their hands, and aim for what feels natural in that setting.
Pointing at an individual hearer can feel like accusation, even when it is not meant so. An open palm is usually received more gently.
5. Preaching on a camera and through a screen
Preaching for people who are at home, in a recording, a live stream or a video call, is now ordinary in many places, and it differs from preaching in a room in ways that matter.
The eyes go to the lens, not the screen. When you look at the faces on your own screen, the people watching see you looking slightly away from them. When you look at the camera lens, they see you looking at them. This feels strange, because the lens is not a face. Some preachers put a small mark or a picture of a person beside the lens to give the eyes a place to go.
The frame is smaller. The camera sees your head and shoulders, and large gestures vanish or look wild. Bring the hands up into the frame if you gesture, and keep movements smaller than in a hall.
The voice is closer and lower. The microphone is near. Speak as if to one or two people across a table, not to a hall. Lecture 4-1 mentioned this.
The setting speaks. What is behind you is part of what is seen. A tidy plain background and light on the face, in front of you rather than behind, help. Check the sound by recording a short test and listening to it.
Hearers at home are in different situations. They may be in the kitchen, on a bus, with children or with a poor connection. Sentences should be a little shorter and the point repeated a little more. If the broadcast is live and there is a way for hearers to respond, someone other than the preacher should watch it.
Be careful what you show and say. A recording may be copied and shared far beyond the people for whom it was made. Do not show, name or describe identifiable people, especially children and those who are vulnerable, unless your community's written rules and local law allow it and the people concerned have agreed. Where you are unsure, ask the person responsible in your community.
6. Slides, notes and the things you carry
Some communities use slides or projected text and others never do. Where they are used, a few cautions apply.
- A slide should be read in a glance. A few words or a single verse is enough. A slide full of text asks the hearers to read while you speak, and they cannot do both.
- Do not read the slide aloud word for word unless the slide is the Scripture itself. Hearers who have already read it are being made to wait.
- Keep the room light enough to see the preacher's face. A dark room with a bright screen turns the speaker into a voice.
- Know how to go on if the equipment fails. A sermon that cannot be given without a projector is more fragile than it needs to be.
Notes and manuscripts are objects too. A pile of loose sheets can slip; a page turned noisily becomes a distraction; a tablet's screen can dim or lock at the wrong moment. Number the pages, fasten them if you can, and learn how to turn them without making an event of it. If you use a tablet, switch off notifications and set the screen not to sleep.
Held things deserve the same question: does this help the Word to be received, or does it call attention to itself? A Bible in the hand, a book, a single object that belongs to a story, can be right. A collection of props that become the show is a different matter.
7. Clothing and vestments
Traditions differ widely on this. Some wear robes, albs, stoles or other vestments with a long history, and the clothing says that the preacher speaks as a servant of the Church and not in a private capacity. Some wear a plain dark suit or the best clothes of the community. Some wear everyday clothes, so that the preacher is seen as one of the people. Each has reasons, and none is more faithful than the others.
What this course asks is smaller and more practical. Follow your community's custom. Make sure the clothes allow you to move, breathe and stand without discomfort, and that a microphone can be attached where it will not rub. Avoid anything that will draw the eye away from the face or that you will keep adjusting. When in doubt, choose the clothing that attracts the least attention in your setting.
8. An invented example
(an invented example) A lay preacher in a small house church is invited to give a short word on Luke 15. She reads her text from a printed page and, in the first rehearsal, never looks up. A friend watching says, "You looked at the paper for four minutes." She is not offended, and she decides to do one thing only: at the end of each paragraph, she will look up and say the last sentence to the person in front of her. In the second rehearsal she is slower and her face is easier to see. She changes nothing else. A week later, she asks the friend to watch for one more habit, her hands, which she keeps in her pockets. The change is small each time. That is the point. Delivery improves by fixing one thing and then another, not by trying to become a different speaker.
Diagram 1. Where the eyes go
Diagram 2. Three questions for any visible choice
| Question | Example |
|---|---|
| Does it help the hearers receive the Word? | Looking up at the end of a paragraph; a slide with one verse |
| Does it fit this community and this place? | Eye contact, gesture size and clothing follow local custom |
| Is it something I do again and again without noticing? | Tapping, adjusting, pacing, pointing |
In short
- The hearers receive the speaker through the ear and the eye at once; when the two disagree, attention goes to the disagreement.
- Look at the people: down to take the thought, up to give it. Spread your looks across the room.
- Eye contact, gesture size and clothing differ from culture to culture and tradition to tradition; follow the custom of the place.
- Posture and hands should be steady enough not to be noticed. Repeated unrelated movement distracts.
- On camera, look at the lens, keep gestures within the frame, speak closer and lower, and do not show identifiable people without permission.
- Slides, notes and clothing are good when they help the Word be received and bad when they call attention to themselves.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Using the eyes with a text | Down to take the thought, up to give it. |
| On a camera | Look at the lens; keep gestures in the frame; speak closer and lower. |
| Local custom | Eye contact, gesture size and clothing differ by culture; follow the place. |
| The test for anything visible | Does it help the Word be received, or does it call attention to itself? |
One sentence to remember Nothing you wear, carry, show or do with your body should stand between the hearers and the Word.
This week's action Ask a trusted person to watch you speak for two minutes and name one visible habit; then work on that one thing only.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In the place where you worship or study, what is the custom about eye contact between a speaker and the people? How should a preacher follow it?
- Which of the three ways of preaching (full text, notes, no script) is most natural to you? What is its characteristic fault in the eyes?
- What would you want to ask a trusted friend to watch for in your standing and your hands?
- If you preached on camera tomorrow, what would you have to change from what you do in a room?
- The lecture says "nothing should cover the Word." Name a visible thing in a service you know that helps the Word be received and one that might cover it. How would you tell the difference?