Lecture 6-1: The Power and Responsibility of the Pulpit
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Many Ways of Preaching
- Lecture 1-2: Between the Passage and the Hearers
- Lecture 1-3: Saying It in One Sentence
- Lecture 1-4: A Week of Preparation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, One Passage, One Sentence
- Lecture 2-1: A Road the Ear Can Follow
- Lecture 2-2: Several Shapes
- Lecture 2-3: Beginnings and Endings
- Lecture 2-4: Stories and Illustrations, Honestly Told
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A One-Page Outline
- Lecture 3-1: Writing for the Ear
- Lecture 3-2: Reading the Scripture Aloud
- Lecture 3-3: Full Text, Notes, or No Script
- Lecture 3-4: Borrowing Honestly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Paragraph Aloud
- Lecture 4-1: The Voice
- Lecture 4-2: Body, Eyes and Place
- Lecture 4-3: Fear, Failure and Recovery
- Lecture 4-4: The Sermon Inside the Service
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Three Minutes Aloud
- Lecture 5-1: Why Preachers Need Other Ears
- Lecture 5-2: Watching and Saying
- Lecture 5-3: Receiving
- Lecture 5-4: Running a Preaching Group
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The Observation Sheet
For five weeks this course has treated the sermon as a craft: finding one sentence, giving it a shape, writing it for the ear, delivering it, and asking others how it sounded. All of that is technique. This week asks what the technique is for, and what it can do to people if it is used badly.
A preacher who does these things well gains something. People listen. They stay quiet while the preacher speaks, they do not interrupt, and many of them trust what they hear because it is said in the name of Scripture. That is the power of the pulpit. The same skill that lets the Word reach people can also be used to push them. The better you are at holding an audience, the more it matters what you do with it.
This lecture does not say that preaching is dangerous and should be avoided. It says that the preacher holds something for other people, and that holding it well means knowing where the edges are. We look at the main ways the pulpit is misused, a short test you can put to your own text, and the hardest case: what a preacher must never do when someone has been harmed, and what to do when harm is suspected.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain why a preacher has power over hearers, and why this is true in more than one tradition.
- Tell the difference between a call to respond that is drawn from the passage and pressure that serves the preacher.
- Rewrite a sentence that shames a person, uses a confidence, or demands money or loyalty.
- State three things a pulpit must never do when harm has been done to a hearer.
- Describe the steps a preacher follows when harm is suspected, in general terms, without investigating alone.
Shepherd the flock of God which is among you, exercising the oversight, not under compulsion, but voluntarily, not for dishonest gain, but willingly;" — 1 Peter 5:2
World English Bible
neither as lording it over those entrusted to you, but making yourselves examples to the flock." — 1 Peter 5:3
WEB
You haven’t strengthened the diseased, neither have you healed that which was sick, neither have you bound up that which was broken, neither have you brought back that which was driven away, neither have you sought that which was lost; but with force and with rigor you have ruled over them." — Ezekiel 34:4
WEB
For they bind heavy burdens that are grievous to be borne, and lay them on men’s shoulders; but they themselves will not lift a finger to help them." — Matthew 23:4
WEB
Peter writes to those who lead a community. Ezekiel speaks to the shepherds of Israel, who were its leaders. Jesus speaks of the teachers of his day. None of the three is a lecture on sermon technique. They are warnings to people who hold authority over others, and a preacher holds a share of that authority whenever the community gathers to listen.
1. Why the pulpit has power
Think about the situation as a hearer sees it. One person speaks. Many people listen. For the length of the sermon, nobody answers back. The speaker stands where the community has agreed that the Word is spoken, and the words come with the weight of Scripture. Some hearers are children. Some depend on the community for friendship, for work, for help with food or a visa. Some have been taught from childhood that the person in this place speaks for God.
None of this is the preacher's fault, and none of it is a flaw in preaching. It is what the situation is. Even in communities where the sermon is a shared conversation and people speak up, the person who prepared and who leads the conversation still shapes it. The form changes how large the power is. It does not remove it.
This lecture asks you to see the power first, because a person who does not think they have power cannot be careful with it. (An invented example.) A young lay preacher told her friends, "I am only reading what is in the passage, so I have no influence." Then she noticed that four people in her small assembly had changed how they spent their Saturdays after her last two talks. She had influence. What she needed was a way to ask whether she was using it as a servant uses it.
2. Three ways the power is misused
Manipulation. To manipulate is to move people by a route that does not go through their judgment. A sermon can do this by repeating a fear until it takes over the room, by telling a story built to make people cry so that they will say yes, by setting a deadline ("if you do not decide tonight, there may not be another chance") that the text does not set, or by slowing the voice and lowering the lights so that the hearers' guard comes down. Each of these may feel like sincerity from the inside. The test is not whether the preacher means well. It is whether the hearer is still free to weigh what is said.
Guilt used as a tool. Scripture does call people to repent, and a sermon that never makes anyone uncomfortable has probably not read the passage. But guilt that comes from the text, about a thing the text names, is different from guilt that is spread over the room to produce an outcome: more volunteers, more giving, a quiet congregation that does not ask questions. This is a mood that the preacher needs, not a conviction that the passage gives.
Demands for money, loyalty or obedience. Some passages do speak about giving, about faithfulness to a community, and about respect for those who lead. A preacher may preach them. The danger lies in who is speaking and who gains. When the one who asks for money is the one who will spend it, or the one who asks for loyalty is the one who will be served by it, the hearers are right to expect extra care: the passage in full, the reasons given openly, and nothing hidden about where the money goes. A call to give that cannot bear that kind of light should not be made. Whether your community has written rules about collections and accounts is something to find out before you stand up. Follow them.
Here is a before-and-after. (Both are invented examples.)
Before: "Anyone who does not give this month is robbing God. I will know who you are, and God will too."
After: "This passage asks what we do with what we have been given. I will say what our community plans to do with this month’s collection, and where you can see the accounts. Give as you decide, and in private."
The second version still preaches the passage. It does not use the preacher’s position to make anyone afraid.
3. A test for your own text
Before a sermon is finished, put three questions to every call to respond in it.
- Does the passage ask this? If the call is "give", "forgive", "come forward", "leave your job" or "obey your leaders", find the words in the text that carry it. If you cannot, the call is yours, and you should say so or remove it.
- Could a hearer say no and be safe? Safe means not shamed in front of others, not told they are rejected by God, not watched afterwards. If a refusal would cost the hearer something that comes from your anger or your community’s pressure, the call is not an invitation but an order.
- Who gains if they say yes? If the answer is the preacher, the preacher’s position or the preacher’s project, slow down. This does not always mean the call is wrong. It means you owe the hearers more openness than usual.
These questions do not make a sermon bland. A sermon can ask a great deal of people and pass all three.
4. Naming, shaming, and what you were told in confidence
A preacher must not use the pulpit to shame a person. The worst form is naming. A less obvious form is the thin disguise: the sermon describes a situation so exactly that everyone in the room knows who is meant. If the person is present, they are humiliated before the community. If the person is absent, the community learns to be afraid of the pulpit. In either case the passage did not need it. The point of the text can be made without a victim.
Confidences belong to the same family. What a person told you in counselling, in a private visit or at confession was given to you for one purpose. It is not material for illustration, even with the name changed, even years later, even if you think they will not mind. Traditions differ in how strict the rules of confidence are, and some communities treat them as absolute. You should know your community’s written rule and keep to it. As a minimum, do not use a private matter in a sermon without the clear and free permission of the person it concerns, and do not suppose that permission asked in the doorway of the church counts as free.
Children are in the room more often than preachers remember. A story with a violent death, a threat of hell given in detail, or a description of a parent who leaves can frighten a child badly, and the child will hear it without any of the adult's context. This does not mean you should avoid hard subjects. It means you should ask who is listening at the lowest level and decide whether you are willing to say it to them.
5. The passage says, and I think
Preachers carry two kinds of statement into the pulpit and often do not label them. One kind is what the passage says. The other is what I think about the matter. Hearers cannot tell which is which unless the preacher helps them. If everything is said in the same firm voice, then the preacher’s opinion about politics, about a neighbouring church, about how a family should be run, comes to carry the same weight as the Word itself. That is a quiet way of making one’s own view into a command.
The remedy is a small habit of speech. Say "The passage says…" when the words are in the text. Say "I think…" or "In my judgment…" when they are not. Say "I do not know" when you do not. Lecture 6-3 returns to this when we come to politics and hard texts.
6. What a pulpit must never do
Some limits are firm. If a hearer has been harmed, or is raising a concern about harm, the pulpit must never:
- Cover for the harm. It must not be used to defend an accused person’s character in the abstract, to hint that accusers are troublemakers, or to preach on "unity" or "gossip" in order to close the subject. A sermon that arrives at the wrong moment on those themes tells everyone what will happen to the next person who speaks.
- Silence the person who raises a concern. A person who speaks up about something wrong is often frightened. Treating them from the pulpit as divisive, as lacking faith, or as an enemy teaches the whole community to say nothing.
- Press a hurt person to forgive on a timetable. Scripture speaks of forgiveness, and a preacher may preach it. But a sermon on forgiveness is heard by everyone, including the person who is being harmed now, and the message "forgive and the matter is finished" can be taken as "do not tell". Forgiveness is not the same as silence, and it does not require a person to stay near someone who is harming them. Preach the text, and leave the pace of the heart to the person and their pastoral carer.
These three are short to write and hard to keep when the person accused is your friend, your leader, or the one who pays for the building. That is exactly when the limit matters.
7. When harm is suspected
Suppose someone tells you, or you see for yourself, that a child, a vulnerable adult or any hearer is being hurt or threatened. The pulpit is not the place to deal with it, and you are probably not the right person to deal with it alone. A general path, to be adjusted to your community and to the law where you live, looks like this.
- If there is danger now, call the local emergency number. Do this before anything else.
- Listen, do not question closely, and do not promise to keep it secret. Say that you believe they were right to tell you and that you will have to speak to the person responsible for these matters. Do not promise what you may not be able to keep.
- Go to the person named in your community’s written policy. Many communities name a safeguarding person, a bishop, a council or a senior pastor. If your community has no written policy, find a trusted senior person, and ask that one be written down.
- Do not investigate alone, do not confront the person accused, and do not discuss the matter with others who do not need to know.
- Know that some places have laws about reporting. This course cannot tell you what yours says. Ask the responsible person in your community and, where needed, a qualified person such as a lawyer or the local agency that handles these matters.
A preacher who has not thought about this beforehand tends to improvise at the worst moment. Find out now who the responsible person is in your community, and write the name where you can find it.
Diagram 1. Three questions, and the edge of the pulpit
Diagram 2. Pressure and invitation, side by side
| Pressure (serves the preacher) | Invitation (serves the hearer) | |
|---|---|---|
| Where the call comes from | The preacher’s need or mood | The words of the passage |
| What a "no" costs | Shame, watching, loss of standing | Nothing |
| Money or loyalty | Asked for without account | Asked for with reasons given openly |
| A person in the story | Named or easily recognised | Not named; a composite, labelled as such |
| Doubts and questions | Treated as disloyalty | Welcome; heard after the service |
In short
- The preacher has power because one voice speaks, many listen, nobody answers during the sermon, and the words carry the weight of Scripture. The form of the service changes its size, not its presence.
- The test of manipulation is not the preacher’s intention but whether the hearer remains free to weigh what is said.
- Put three questions to every call to respond: does the passage ask it, can a hearer say no safely, and who gains if they say yes?
- Do not shame a person from the pulpit, name them, or describe them so closely that everyone knows. Do not use a confidence without clear and free permission.
- Say "the passage says" for the text and "I think" for your opinion, so that your view does not carry the Word’s weight.
- The pulpit must never cover for harm, silence a person who raises a concern, or press a hurt person to forgive on a timetable.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why the pulpit has power | One voice, many listeners, no reply during the sermon, and the weight of Scripture on the words. |
| The three questions | Does the passage ask it? Can a hearer say no safely? Who gains from a yes? |
| Three things the pulpit never does | Covers for harm; silences a person who raises a concern; presses a hurt person to forgive on a timetable. |
| When harm is suspected | Danger now: local emergency number. Otherwise the person named in the written policy. Do not investigate alone or promise secrecy. |
One sentence to remember The preacher holds the pulpit for other people, and it is never held for the preacher.
This week's action Find out who is responsible in your community when harm is suspected, write the name and how to reach them, and keep it with your preaching notes.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Where in your own setting do hearers have the least chance to answer back, and what does that ask of the preacher?
- Take a call to respond from a sermon you know well (your own or an invented one). Put the three questions to it. What changes?
- Why is "the preacher means well" not a sufficient test for manipulation?
- How could you say "I think" rather than "the passage says" in a sermon without weakening the sermon?
- Do you know the name of the person in your community who is responsible when harm is suspected? If not, whom could you ask this week?