Lecture 1-3: Saying It in One Sentence
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Many Ways of Preaching
- Lecture 1-2: Between the Passage and the Hearers
- Lecture 1-3: Saying It in One Sentence
- Lecture 1-4: A Week of Preparation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, One Passage, One Sentence
- Lecture 2-1: A Road the Ear Can Follow
- Lecture 2-2: Several Shapes
- Lecture 2-3: Beginnings and Endings
- Lecture 2-4: Stories and Illustrations, Honestly Told
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A One-Page Outline
- Lecture 3-1: Writing for the Ear
- Lecture 3-2: Reading the Scripture Aloud
- Lecture 3-3: Full Text, Notes, or No Script
- Lecture 3-4: Borrowing Honestly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Paragraph Aloud
- Lecture 4-1: The Voice
- Lecture 4-2: Body, Eyes and Place
- Lecture 4-3: Fear, Failure and Recovery
- Lecture 4-4: The Sermon Inside the Service
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Three Minutes Aloud
- Lecture 5-1: Why Preachers Need Other Ears
- Lecture 5-2: Watching and Saying
- Lecture 5-3: Receiving
- Lecture 5-4: Running a Preaching Group
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The Observation Sheet
Imagine that a hearer meets a friend after the service. The friend asks, "What was the sermon about?" The hearer thinks for a moment and says, "It was about fear. Or maybe trust. It was good." The sermon may have been careful, and the preacher may have worked all week. But if the hearer cannot say what it said, then something went missing between the passage and the ear.
This lecture is about the repair. Before the outline, before the opening, before the illustration, a preacher needs to be able to say, in one sentence, what this sermon says and what it is for. The sentence is not the sermon. It is the spine the sermon hangs on. When a sermon has no such sentence, the preacher usually does not notice, because the preacher knows the passage well and hears all of it at once. The hearers hear it one word at a time and only once.
We will look at what the sentence is, what makes a sentence good, how it fails, and how to repair it.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain what the one sentence is, and name at least three of the terms that different traditions use for it.
- State six conditions that a good sentence meets.
- Recognise and name common failures of the sentence: the topic word, the packed sentence, the claim the passage does not make, and the command with no ground.
- Take a weak sentence and repair it, using a short passage.
They read in the book, in the law of God, distinctly; and they gave the sense, so that they understood the reading." — Nehemiah 8:8
World English Bible
Beginning from Moses and from all the prophets, he explained to them in all the Scriptures the things concerning himself." — Luke 24:27
WEB
When I came to you, brothers, I didn’t come with excellence of speech or of wisdom, proclaiming to you the testimony of God. For I determined not to know anything among you, except Jesus Christ, and him crucified." — 1 Corinthians 2:1-2
WEB
Giving the sense of a reading is the work. Paul's resolve to know one thing among the Corinthians is an example of how a speaker's attention can be gathered, not scattered.
1. What the one sentence is
The one sentence is a single plain sentence that says two things at once: what this sermon says, and what it is meant to do for the hearers.
Teachers of preaching have used different names for it. You will meet the main idea, the proposition, the focus statement, the central thought, the thrust, the big idea, and, in some liturgical communities, simply the one thing I want them to take home. The names come from different traditions and sometimes carry slightly different shades of meaning. Underneath, they point at the same discipline: a preacher who can say in one sentence what the sermon is about.
It is a discipline and not a rule about form. A sermon that is a story, a testimony, a six-minute homily after a reading, or a conversation around a table can still be built around one sentence. In a conversation, the sentence may never be spoken in those words; the leader holds it, and uses it to decide which questions to ask.
2. Why one
There are three reasons, and the first two come from how people hear.
First, a hearer hears once. A reader can pause and go back. A hearer receives each word and then it is gone. A sermon that carries several equal ideas gives the hearer several things to hold and no way to know which one matters. One sentence tells the ear where to put its weight.
Second, a hearer is also a person leaving a room. The sermon is finished when people stand up and go back into their week. What goes with them is not a transcript. It is something they can carry. A single sentence can travel through a Tuesday; a list of six points usually does not.
Third, the passage itself is one thing at a time. Nehemiah 8:8 says that they "gave the sense, so that they understood the reading." To give the sense is to say what the passage is saying. A passage has many details and may bear many sermons across many years. In one sermon, a preacher chooses to bring one.
The words of Paul to the Corinthians show that attention gathered on one thing is not an invention of modern teachers. "I determined not to know anything among you, except Jesus Christ, and him crucified" (1 Corinthians 2:2). We should not push this verse harder than it will go: Paul is not laying down a rule that every sermon has the same one sentence. He is showing a speaker who decided what he would hold in front of his hearers, and held it.
3. A question some traditions ask
This is a point where readers will not agree, and it concerns what the one sentence has to include. Luke 24:27 says that the risen Christ, "beginning from Moses and from all the prophets," explained to two travellers the things concerning himself in all the Scriptures. Some preachers take this to mean that every sermon, whatever the passage, should reach Christ in its one sentence, so that the sentence always names him or the gospel. Others hold that a sermon should say what this passage says, and that the passage's own words may lead to Christ by way of the larger story of Scripture and not in a single move inside one sermon. Still others, in churches whose whole service is shaped around the Eucharist, point out that the sermon is one part of a rite that already proclaims Christ, so the homily's sentence may stay close to the reading. Each has a reason, and each has a risk (the first can make every passage say the same thing; the second can leave a hearer without a clear word about Christ).
This course requires only that the sentence be something the passage actually says or shows, and that you can explain where in the passage it comes from. Whether and how it reaches Christ is for your tradition and your reading of the passage.
4. Six conditions of a good sentence
A good sentence is not found by luck. Check any candidate against these six.
- It is one idea. If you need "and also" to finish it, you may have two.
- It is a whole sentence, with a verb. A word or a phrase is a topic. A sentence says something about it.
- It comes from the passage. You can point to where the passage says or shows it.
- It says something about the subject, not only the subject. "Forgiveness" is a subject. "God forgives before we ask" is a claim about it. Teachers sometimes put this as two parts: what the passage is talking about and what it says about that.
- It points toward the hearers. It says, or clearly implies, what the sermon is for: what hearers may know, trust, or do. A sentence that is true but goes nowhere has not yet been turned toward the room.
- It can be said aloud and remembered. Plain words. Short enough to say from memory in one breath. Nothing that needs a footnote.
A simple frame can help when you are stuck. It is a frame to try, not a form to obey:
This passage says (what) about (subject), so that these hearers may (know, trust, or do) (response).
You will usually reshape the sentence so that it does not sound like the frame. The frame is scaffolding.
5. How a sentence fails
Four failures account for most weak sentences. Learn to name them, because a failure with a name can be fixed.
The topic word. The "sentence" is a subject: Fear. Prayer. The Good Shepherd. Grace. It tells the preacher where the sermon will wander and tells the hearer nothing. Repair: add what the passage says about the subject.
The packed sentence. Three ideas have been folded into one: Jesus calms storms, we should pray more, and faith matters in hard times. It looks like a sentence, but it is three sermons. Repair: choose the one that the passage actually carries, and let the others go, or wait for another week.
The claim the passage does not make. The sentence says something attractive that the passage does not say: God will always calm the storms in your life. The passage reports one event; it does not make a promise about every storm. Hearers who are in a storm now may leave believing a promise that the text never gave. Repair: go back to the passage and write only what it says or shows.
The command with no ground. We must pray more. We should trust God. Be kind. A command with no reason is a scolding; the hearers do not know why, and the passage is no longer doing any work. Repair: put the reason first, then the response that follows from it.
Two other failures are worth a mention. The sentence from somewhere else is true, but it belongs to a different passage; the preacher has a familiar message and has laid it over this text. The private sentence uses words that only the preacher and perhaps a few trained listeners understand ("the eschatological tension of the already and the not yet"). Repair is the same in both cases: go back to the passage, then write for the ear of a person who has never heard these terms.
6. Two worked examples
Here are two passages, each with a weak sentence and its repair. Notice that the repair does not come from clever wording. It comes from returning to the passage and asking again what it says.
Example 1: a story. Mark 4:35-41 (the storm on the lake). In the passage, Jesus is asleep in the boat, the wind rises, the disciples wake him and say that they are perishing, he speaks to the wind and the sea and there is a great calm, he asks them why they are afraid, and they ask each other who he is.
| Attempt | The sentence | What is wrong |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Fear." | A topic word. |
| 2 | "Jesus calms storms, we should pray more, and faith matters in hard times." | Three ideas packed. |
| 3 | "God will always calm the storms in your life." | A claim the passage does not make. |
| 4 | "We should trust God." | A command with no ground. |
| Repaired | "In the storm, the disciples find that the one asleep in the boat is the one the wind obeys, so we may bring our fear to him." | One idea, from the passage, points toward the hearers. |
Notice what the repaired sentence leaves out. It does not promise a calm sea. It does not say whether a given storm will pass. It says what the passage shows, and it gives the hearers a direction.
Example 2: a letter. Philemon 8-17. Paul writes to Philemon about Onesimus, who has been away from Philemon and whom Paul is sending back. Paul says that he could command Philemon but would rather appeal to him in love, and he asks Philemon to receive Onesimus no longer only as a servant but as a beloved brother.
| Attempt | The sentence | What is wrong |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Reconciliation." | A topic word. |
| 2 | "Paul asks Philemon to be kind to people." | Too general; the passage is about something particular. |
| Repaired | "Paul asks Philemon to welcome Onesimus back as a brother, appealing to love and not to rank, so that we learn to ask for what is right in a way that honours the other person's freedom." | One idea, from the passage, turned toward the hearers. |
The repaired sentence is longer than the first two, and it is better because it is about the letter. If the sermon is for a community where such a matter is sensitive, the preacher can then decide what a hearer should do with it. The sentence does not decide that for them.
7. Testing the sentence
When you have a candidate, try four tests.
The breath test. Say it aloud. Can you say it in one breath, from memory? If you stumble, it is too long or too tangled.
The passage test. Put your finger on the verse, or verses, where the passage says or shows it. If you cannot, the sentence is yours and not the passage's.
The swap test. Could the same sentence be preached from five other passages? If so, it may be too general. A good sentence belongs to this passage even if it does not belong only to it.
The hearer test. Say it to a trusted person who has not read the passage, then ask them to say it back in their own words. If they say something quite different, the sentence is carrying more than you thought, or less.
The sentence will change as you work. A sentence written on the first day is usually a first guess; by midweek it should be settled, and during writing and rehearsal you may sharpen a word or two. We will see how it fits in a week of preparation in lecture 1-4.
8. What the sentence is not
It is not the title. A title can be clever, short and vague; a sentence is plain and specific.
It is not the whole sermon. Much of a good sermon is the passage, the movement, an illustration and a closing. The sentence is the spine, not the body.
It is not a way to flatten the passage. The passage may be richer than any one sentence, and that is a reason to come back to it in other weeks. It is not a reason to say five things in one.
And it is not an excuse for simplicity at any cost. A hard passage may call for a sentence that admits the difficulty: this passage is hard, and what it asks of us is to keep reading. An honest sentence can say that.
Diagram 1. Three weak sentences and their repair
Diagram 2. The six conditions in one table
| Condition | A quick check |
|---|---|
| One idea | Can you finish without "and also"? |
| A whole sentence | Does it have a verb? |
| From the passage | Can you point to the verse? |
| Says something about the subject | Is it more than a topic word? |
| Points toward the hearers | Is it clear what it is for? |
| Can be said aloud and remembered | Can you say it in one breath? |
In short
- The one sentence says what the sermon says and what it is for. It is the spine of the sermon, not the whole of it.
- Traditions call it the main idea, the proposition, the focus statement, or the one thing to take home.
- One sentence matters because a hearer hears once and carries away what is simple enough to carry.
- Six conditions: one idea, a whole sentence, from the passage, says something about the subject, points toward hearers, can be said aloud.
- Common failures: the topic word, the packed sentence, the claim the passage does not make, the command with no ground.
- Test by breath, by the verse, by swapping passages, and by asking a hearer to say it back.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The one sentence | A plain sentence saying what the sermon says and what it is for. |
| Six conditions | One idea; a whole sentence; from the passage; says something about the subject; points toward hearers; can be said aloud. |
| Four common failures | Topic word; packed sentence; claim the passage does not make; command with no ground. |
| Four tests | One breath; point to the verse; swap the passage; ask a hearer to say it back. |
One sentence to remember If a preacher cannot say the sermon in one sentence, the hearers cannot carry it out of the room.
This week's action Choose a passage you may preach or teach, write four candidate sentences, and test them with the six conditions.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a sermon or talk you have heard. Could you say what it said in one sentence? If not, what do you remember?
- Why do different traditions use different names for the one sentence? Does the name change what the discipline does?
- Take a passage you know well. Write a topic word, then a sentence about it. What did the passage have to tell you in order to move from one to the other?
- A preacher says, "My passage has five things to say, and I cannot leave any of them out." What might you answer, fairly, in favour of keeping all five? What might you answer in favour of choosing one?
- How would a leader of shared reflection use the sentence without ever saying it aloud?