FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT726E Preaching Practicum: Manuscript, Delivery, Feedback

Lecture 5-2: Watching and Saying

Contents 31
PT726E Preaching Practicum: Manuscript, Delivery, Feedback
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Sermon Is Heard Once
  1. Introduction: A Sermon Is Heard Once
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Ways of Preaching, and One Sentence
  1. Lecture 1-1: Many Ways of Preaching
  2. Lecture 1-2: Between the Passage and the Hearers
  3. Lecture 1-3: Saying It in One Sentence
  4. Lecture 1-4: A Week of Preparation
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, One Passage, One Sentence
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Shape of a Sermon
  1. Lecture 2-1: A Road the Ear Can Follow
  2. Lecture 2-2: Several Shapes
  3. Lecture 2-3: Beginnings and Endings
  4. Lecture 2-4: Stories and Illustrations, Honestly Told
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A One-Page Outline
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Writing for the Ear
  1. Lecture 3-1: Writing for the Ear
  2. Lecture 3-2: Reading the Scripture Aloud
  3. Lecture 3-3: Full Text, Notes, or No Script
  4. Lecture 3-4: Borrowing Honestly
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Paragraph Aloud
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Delivery
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Voice
  2. Lecture 4-2: Body, Eyes and Place
  3. Lecture 4-3: Fear, Failure and Recovery
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Sermon Inside the Service
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Three Minutes Aloud
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Feedback
  1. Lecture 5-1: Why Preachers Need Other Ears
  2. Lecture 5-2: Watching and Saying
  3. Lecture 5-3: Receiving
  4. Lecture 5-4: Running a Preaching Group
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The Observation Sheet
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Standing for the Long Run
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Power and Responsibility of the Pulpit
  2. Lecture 6-2: Preaching to the Hurt
  3. Lecture 6-3: Hard Texts and Contested Questions
  4. Lecture 6-4: Growing Over the Years
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, A Three-Month Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

20 min

The last lecture asked why a preacher needs other ears. This one is for the person who lends them. It may be you, listening to a friend, a student or a member of a preaching group. It may be a person who never preaches at all.

Good feedback is a skill, and most of us were never taught it. We were taught to say "that was nice" or to find a fault. Neither helps a speaker. What helps is a precise account of what one hearer heard, said in a way that describes the sermon and leaves the speaker's worth alone.

This lecture gives you a simple sheet to listen with, a simple form of words to speak with, and a rule for keeping a difference of belief apart from a comment about craft.

What these 20 minutes give you

  • Fill in an observation sheet with five parts while listening to a sermon or a talk.
  • Rewrite a vague or personal comment as a particular comment about the sermon.
  • Say feedback in the form "what I heard, what helped, what I wonder."
  • Separate a difference of belief from a comment about craft.
  • Describe what a listener who does not preach can contribute.

but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ;" — Ephesians 4:15

World English Bible

Faithful are the wounds of a friend; although the kisses of an enemy are profuse." — Proverbs 27:6

WEB

Now these were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of the mind, examining the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so." — Acts 17:11

WEB

Paul joins two words that are often set against each other: truth and love. The proverb says that a friend's honesty, even when it hurts, is worth more than a flatterer's warmth. The Berean listeners show a third thing: hearers who are active, who weigh what they have heard. Hold all three in mind as you read.

1. What a listener is for

A listener who gives feedback is not a judge of the preacher, and not an editor who has been asked to fix the sermon. A listener is a witness to what happened in one pair of ears. That is a small role, and a valuable one, because it is the only thing the preacher cannot get alone.

This has a useful consequence. You do not need to know how to preach well to give good feedback. You need to listen carefully, write down what you notice, and say it plainly. Everything else comes from practice.

The Bereans in Acts 17:11 are a picture of the first part. They did not sit back and take in the words. They "received the word with all readiness of the mind" and also examined it. The feedback in this lecture is not the same as their testing: they examined whether the teaching agreed with the Scriptures, and that is a question of belief and teaching, which other courses deal with. But their habit of attention is worth borrowing. A hearer who listens as if something depended on it will give better help than one who waits to be entertained.

2. An observation sheet

When you listen in order to help, a few lines of structure keep you from drifting into "I liked it" or "I did not." The sheet below has five parts. Keep it small. You are writing notes during the sermon, not an essay.

1. The sentence I heard. At the end, write in one sentence what the sermon said. If you cannot, that is itself the most important thing you have to report.

2. Where the road was clear. Mark the places where you always knew where you were: a clear beginning, a signpost that told you what was coming, a point where you could have said, "I see why we are here."

3. Where the road broke. Mark the places where you lost the thread. Write down the place, not a verdict: "after the story about the well," "when the second point started." Say what happened to you: "I did not know how this connected."

4. What came alive. Mark the sentence, the picture or the moment that stayed with you. It may be one word. Preachers learn a great deal from what a hearer remembers.

5. What helped in the delivery. Notice things that carried the words: a pause before an important sentence, a voice that dropped, a reading that made the story clear. Notice also the opposite, in neutral terms: "I could not hear the end of sentences," "the pace was fast in the middle." Delivery is lectures 4-1 to 4-4; use what you learned there, but say only what you noticed.

Here is the sheet filled in by an invented listener. (An invented example.) The sermon was on the parable of the two debtors.

Sentence I heard: "Because we have been forgiven much, we can forgive." Road clear: The opening question about the bank. Each of the three parts began with the same four words. Road broke: After the second part, the story of the shopkeeper. I did not see how it fitted. Came alive: "A debt does not go away because we stop talking about it." Delivery: Long pause before the last line. I could not hear the middle of the second part because the voice dropped.

Notice that every line on this sheet describes either the sermon or what the listener experienced. Nothing in it says the preacher is good, lazy, clever or dull.

3. Speaking in particulars

A comment is useful in proportion to how specific it is. "It was good" gives the preacher nothing to repeat. "It was confusing" gives nothing to mend. A particular comment names the place and what happened.

A vague comment A particular comment
"It was too long." "In the last third I started to wonder where we were going. The story about the market made me forget the first point."
"Very powerful." "When you stopped after 'he did not say a word', I stopped breathing for a moment."
"You went too fast." "In the middle part I could follow every third sentence. In the opening I could follow all of them."
"I did not get it." "I heard that God forgives. I did not hear what you wanted us to do about it."
"Good illustrations." "The picture of the empty chair told me the second point better than the explanation did."

A good particular comment answers three questions: where, what happened to me, and sometimes, what might have helped. The last is optional. Many listeners do best to leave suggestions out and let the preacher draw the conclusion.

4. The sermon, not the person

Compare two sentences.

  • "You are disorganised."
  • "After the second point, I lost the order in which things were coming."

The first sentence is a statement about the preacher. The second is a statement about what the listener heard. The first can only be received as a verdict; the second can be fixed on Wednesday.

This is what Paul's pairing of truth and love asks for in practice. Truth is not softened: the listener does say that the road broke. Love is not an extra layer of cushioning: it is the decision to describe the thing that happened and to leave the person's worth out of the account. The proverb about the "wounds of a friend" is a reminder that the helper's honesty is a gift. It is not a permission to wound. A friend is faithful in what is said, and takes care in how it is said.

Two further cautions follow.

  • Do not say what the preacher "always" does. "You always rush the ending" turns one sermon into a character. "In this sermon, the last two minutes were fast" speaks about what you heard.
  • Do not guess at motives. "You were trying to look clever" claims to know the preacher's heart. You do not. You know how a sentence sounded.

5. What I heard, what helped, what I wonder

Here is a simple form for saying aloud what you have written. It has three parts, always in this order.

  1. What I heard. The sentence, and anything else you took away. This is the part that matters most, because it shows the preacher whether the sermon arrived.
  2. What helped. The places where the road was clear or something came alive. Name two or three, with particulars.
  3. What I wonder. The breaks and the questions, stated as wonderings, not as faults. "I wonder whether the story about the market could come before the second point." "I wonder what you wanted us to do on Monday."

A short invented example. (An invented example.) "What I heard was that being forgiven frees us to forgive. What helped: the question about the bank at the start, because I knew straight away what kind of day this was. And the pause before the last sentence. What I wonder: I lost the thread when the shopkeeper came in. I wonder whether it could have gone with the first point instead."

Notice what has happened. The preacher has heard a sentence back, two things to keep and one place to look at. Nobody has been attacked, and nothing has been left out. The word "wonder" does not hide a criticism. It states, honestly, that there is a gap and invites the preacher to look at it. A preacher who disagrees can say so; the form leaves room for that.

Order matters. If the first thing a preacher hears is a fault, the rest of the comments will be heard through it. If the first thing is the sentence that arrived, the preacher is better able to take the difficult part.

6. A difference of belief is not a comment on craft

Sometimes the thing a listener most wants to say is "I do not agree with what was said." That may be a perfectly reasonable response. It belongs to a different conversation.

Take an invented case. (An invented example.) A listener from one tradition hears a sermon that presents a passage in a way that her tradition reads differently. She has two things to say. One is "I did not follow the connection between your second and third movements," and that is a comment on craft. The other is "I read this passage differently," and that is a difference of reading.

Mixed together, they are bad for both. The preacher will hear the second as an attack on the first, and the craft comment is lost. Kept apart, both are useful. The craft comment goes on the sheet. The difference of belief goes aside, perhaps into a separate conversation, perhaps to a teacher or a pastor, perhaps nowhere at all, if the community's tradition allows such differences to stand.

In a preaching group, agree in advance where such differences go. Many groups set aside a short time at the end, or a separate meeting, for matters of interpretation and teaching. Some groups do not discuss them, because the group exists for craft. Neither is wrong. What matters is that everyone knows which conversation they are in.

Where a sermon says something that a hearer believes is seriously wrong about the faith, or something that harms people, the matter goes to the person responsible for teaching in that community, according to its written rules. It does not belong in a feedback circle.

7. What a listener who does not preach can do

If you never preach, you may think this lecture is for others. It is not. In fact you may be the most valuable listener a preacher has, because you hear as hearers hear. You can do four things well.

  • Say the sentence back. This is the most useful single thing any listener can do, and it needs no training.
  • Say where you drifted. Drifting is a fact about hearing, and you are the expert on yours.
  • Say what stayed with you. The picture, the phrase, the story.
  • Say what helped you hear. Whether the reading was clear, whether you could hear the end of the sentences, whether the pace allowed you to think.

What you need not do is suggest a better structure, correct the reading of the passage or advise about technique. Leave those to people who have studied them. A listener's honest report of a hearing is a gift that a trained preacher cannot get any other way.

If you are using a second language, your report is especially valuable. You can tell the preacher which sentences were too long for you, and which words were idioms you had to guess at. Do not hold it back out of politeness; the preacher cannot see it from the front.


Diagram 1. The observation sheet and the three-part form

Watching, then Saying Five things to notice while listening. Three things to say afterwards. WATCHING: the sheet 1. The sentence I heard 2. Where the road was clear 3. Where the road broke 4. What came alive 5. What helped in the delivery Each line names a place and what happened to you there. Each line describes the sermon or the hearing. None describes the preacher. SAYING: three parts, in this order What I heard The sentence, said back. What helped Two or three places, with particulars. What I wonder The break, stated as a wondering. The first thing the preacher hears is whether the sermon arrived. Keep apart: a comment on craft, and a difference of belief "I lost the thread after the second point" goes on the sheet. "I read this passage differently" goes to another conversation, agreed in advance.

Diagram 2. Vague comment, particular comment

Instead of Say
"You are disorganised." "After the second point I lost the order."
"You always rush." "In this sermon, the last two minutes were fast."
"You wanted to look clever." "The quotation in the opening was hard for me to follow."
"Very moving." "The pause before the last line made me stay with it."

In short

  • A listener is a witness to what happened in one pair of ears. You do not need to preach well to give good feedback.
  • The observation sheet has five parts: the sentence heard, where the road was clear, where it broke, what came alive, what helped in the delivery.
  • Particular comments name a place and what happened to the hearer. Vague ones, in praise or complaint, give the preacher nothing to work with.
  • Speak about the sermon heard, not about the preacher's character, habits or motives.
  • Say it in order: what I heard, what helped, what I wonder.
  • A difference of belief is not a comment on craft. Keep them apart, and agree beforehand where each goes.
Front Back
The observation sheet Sentence heard; road clear; road broke; what came alive; what helped in the delivery.
A particular comment Names where, and what happened to the hearer. Not "it was good" or "it was long."
The three-part form What I heard, what helped, what I wonder, in that order.
Craft or belief? A craft comment goes on the sheet. A difference of belief goes to another conversation.

One sentence to remember Say what you heard and where you lost the road, and leave the preacher's worth out of it.

This week's action Listen to a sermon, a reading or a talk with the five-part sheet, and write one comment in each part.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why does a listener who has "only heard it once" have something the preacher lacks?
  • Rewrite "It dragged" as a particular comment about a sermon you remember, without naming the preacher.
  • In the three-part form, why does "what I heard" come first?
  • What is the difference between a comment on craft and a difference of belief? Give one example of each from your own experience, without names.
  • Proverbs 27:6 says the wounds of a friend are faithful. What would make an honest comment wound without being faithful?
  • If you never preach, which of the four things a listener can do would you find easiest? Which hardest?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.