FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT726E Preaching Practicum: Manuscript, Delivery, Feedback

Lecture 5-1: Why Preachers Need Other Ears

Contents 31
PT726E Preaching Practicum: Manuscript, Delivery, Feedback
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Sermon Is Heard Once
  1. Introduction: A Sermon Is Heard Once
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Ways of Preaching, and One Sentence
  1. Lecture 1-1: Many Ways of Preaching
  2. Lecture 1-2: Between the Passage and the Hearers
  3. Lecture 1-3: Saying It in One Sentence
  4. Lecture 1-4: A Week of Preparation
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, One Passage, One Sentence
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Shape of a Sermon
  1. Lecture 2-1: A Road the Ear Can Follow
  2. Lecture 2-2: Several Shapes
  3. Lecture 2-3: Beginnings and Endings
  4. Lecture 2-4: Stories and Illustrations, Honestly Told
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A One-Page Outline
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Writing for the Ear
  1. Lecture 3-1: Writing for the Ear
  2. Lecture 3-2: Reading the Scripture Aloud
  3. Lecture 3-3: Full Text, Notes, or No Script
  4. Lecture 3-4: Borrowing Honestly
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Paragraph Aloud
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Delivery
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Voice
  2. Lecture 4-2: Body, Eyes and Place
  3. Lecture 4-3: Fear, Failure and Recovery
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Sermon Inside the Service
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Three Minutes Aloud
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Feedback
  1. Lecture 5-1: Why Preachers Need Other Ears
  2. Lecture 5-2: Watching and Saying
  3. Lecture 5-3: Receiving
  4. Lecture 5-4: Running a Preaching Group
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The Observation Sheet
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Standing for the Long Run
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Power and Responsibility of the Pulpit
  2. Lecture 6-2: Preaching to the Hurt
  3. Lecture 6-3: Hard Texts and Contested Questions
  4. Lecture 6-4: Growing Over the Years
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, A Three-Month Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

23 min

A preacher has one hearer who can never listen to the sermon properly: the preacher. You know what you meant. You know what comes next. You know the story behind the story. When you listen to your own voice, your mind quietly fills every gap, and the sermon sounds clear to you because you already hold the whole of it.

Your hearers do not. They have the words, once, in the order you gave them. So the people best placed to tell you what the sermon was like are the people who heard it without your private knowledge.

This lecture is about asking them. It names the people to ask, the moment to ask, and three questions that bring back useful answers. It also deals with the criticism you did not ask for, and with two dangers around feedback that is spoken to the wrong people: praise in public and blame in public.

What these 23 minutes give you

  • Explain why a preacher cannot judge a sermon reliably from the inside.
  • Name four kinds of people a preacher can ask for feedback, and say what each is good for.
  • Ask the three feedback questions in your own words.
  • Describe a sensible first response to criticism that nobody invited.
  • Explain why feedback is given directly and privately, and what rumour does to it.

Iron sharpens iron; so a man sharpens his friend’s countenance." — Proverbs 27:17

World English Bible

Where there is no counsel, plans fail; but in a multitude of counselors they are established." — Proverbs 15:22

WEB

This man had been instructed in the way of the Lord; and being fervent in spirit, he spoke and taught accurately the things concerning Jesus, although he knew only the baptism of John." — Acts 18:25

WEB

He began to speak boldly in the synagogue. But when Priscilla and Aquila heard him, they took him aside, and explained to him the way of God more accurately." — Acts 18:26

WEB

The two proverbs say that people are made sharper and wiser by other people. The scene in Acts shows it once, with a gifted speaker and two listeners. Watch what the listeners do, and where they do it.

1. The one hearer who cannot hear

The central claim of this course is that a sermon is a service of the Word to people who must follow it by ear, once. That has a consequence for the preacher. If the sermon exists to be followed by someone else, then someone else is the only one who can say whether it was followed.

Think of three things you cannot do from the pulpit.

  • You cannot hear your own pace. Fast speech feels normal to the one speaking.
  • You cannot tell which of your sentences were clear. You know what you meant, so every sentence seems to say it.
  • You cannot see which part of the road was lost. You were never on it as a stranger.

None of this is a fault in you. It is how speaking works. A musician who plays alone does not hear the room; a cook cannot taste the dish as the guest will taste it, hungry or not, with a different tongue. The remedy is also ordinary: put another pair of ears in the room, and ask them what they heard.

This is a reason to ask. It is not a reason to doubt your or your preparation. A preacher who asks is not confessing weakness. A preacher who asks has understood what the work is.

2. What Priscilla and Aquila did

The story in Acts 18 is short, and it is worth reading closely, because it is the Bible's picture of one speaker being helped by his hearers.

Apollos comes to Ephesus. He is eloquent, he knows the Scriptures, and he teaches accurately about Jesus. He is also, the text says, a man who "knew only the baptism of John." Something in what he taught was incomplete. Two listeners, Priscilla and Aquila, heard him in the synagogue. They did not stand up and correct him in front of the people. The text says they "took him aside" and "explained to him the way of God more accurately."

Notice four things.

  1. They listened first. They heard him speak before they said anything.
  2. They spoke privately. "Took him aside" means the correction did not happen in front of the assembly.
  3. They added; they did not tear down. They explained the way of God more accurately. They did not tell him he was a poor speaker or a poor man.
  4. He is called eloquent and fervent in the same passage. The correction did not cancel the praise. A gifted speaker can still be helped.

Be careful about what this passage does not say. It does not say that Apollos asked to be helped, and it is a matter of doctrine, not delivery, that Priscilla and Aquila addressed. We use it as a picture, not as a rule: hearers can serve a speaker, they do it best when they speak privately and kindly, and a gifted preacher is not above it. The rest of this chapter takes that picture and turns it into a practice.

3. Whom to ask

Not every listener is the right one. The first rule is to choose people who will tell you the truth gently, and who will tell it to you, not about you. Here are four kinds of person. Most preachers need more than one.

A trusted partner. One person who hears you often and whom you trust. This is the simplest and often the most useful arrangement. A partner can be another preacher, but need not be. A spouse, a friend, a fellow member of the choir may hear more clearly than a trained preacher because they are not listening for technique.

A preaching group. Three to six people who meet on a regular basis to hear and help one another. Lecture 5-4 is about running one. A group gives you several ears at once, which helps you see which comments are shared and which are one person's taste.

A colleague or senior. Someone who preaches or has preached for longer: a pastor, a priest, a , a teacher, an older lay preacher. A colleague can say things about the craft that a hearer cannot, such as where a transition was thin. Some communities have a formal arrangement for this. In some, a bishop, an or a senior pastor hears and comments; in others, the matter is handled informally. Either can work. What matters is that you can speak to the person plainly.

A few ordinary hearers. Choose them on purpose. A young person, a person who hears in a second language, a person who has been in the community for fifty years, a person who is new. Each hears a different sermon. A listener who works in a second language will notice at once what an idiom, a long sentence or a fast pace cost, and the preacher will rarely notice it from the front.

Some preachers hesitate because, in their culture, it is disrespectful to question a speaker in the pulpit, or because the preacher is an elder and others will not criticise. Do not push this. You can honour the custom and still ask. You might ask a younger hearer what he or she found easy to follow, or invite a friend to tell you what stayed with them. The question is about the hearer's experience, and an experience is not a criticism of anyone.

4. When to ask

There is no rule, and the following is a suggestion to adjust to your own place.

Not at the door. Immediately after the service, you are tired, the hearer is often talking to many people, and the line behind them is waiting. People at the door are usually kind; they say "thank you" or "that was good," and that tells you little. An hour is better than a minute, and a day later is often better than an hour, because by then what remains in a hearer's mind is what actually held.

Soon enough to remember. After a week or two, the sermon has blurred. If you want to know where the road broke, ask within a few days.

Before, as well as after. You can ask a partner for something specific beforehand: "This week I am worried my second point is too long. Will you listen for it?" A hearer who knows what to listen for gives sharper answers. This also makes the exchange safer, because the hearer is answering your question and not volunteering a judgement.

Not only when you are afraid. Ask when the sermon went well too. A preacher who asks only after a bad Sunday teaches the community that feedback is bad news.

5. Three questions to ask

Most people, asked "What did you think?", answer with a mood: it was good, it was fine, it was long. Those answers feel pleasant and tell you almost nothing. You will get far more from three questions that ask about what happened in the hearer, not about what they thought of you.

  1. "In one sentence, what did you hear me say?"
  2. "Was there a place where you lost me?"
  3. "What helped you follow?"

Here is an invented example of how the first question works. (An invented example.) A preacher intended the sentence, "Because God goes first to the lost, we are free to go with him." She asks a hearer, and he says, "I heard that we should look for lost people." That is close but it is not the same. The preacher meant to start with what God does; the hearer remembered what he must do. That difference is worth more to her than a hundred compliments, because it shows her where the sermon's weight fell, and she can now look at her second movement.

The second question finds the break in the road. A hearer who says "I lost you when you told the story about the road repair" has given you a place, a particular, which you can mend. A hearer who says "it felt long" has given you a mood.

The third question protects what is good. If you only ask where it went wrong, you may remove things that were serving the hearer. When a hearer says, "The three short sentences at the start made me sit up," the preacher knows to keep them.

You will notice that none of the three questions asks "Did you like it?" or "Was it a good sermon?" A hearer cannot answer those without judging you, and most will protect you with a kind word.

6. The criticism nobody asked for

Sooner or later someone speaks to you about your sermon who was not invited to. It may be in the doorway, in a message, in a letter, or passed to you through a third person. It may be wise, it may be careless, and it may be cruel.

You do not have to decide at once which. A response that works in most cases has four steps.

  1. Listen to the end. Do not defend, correct or explain while the person is still speaking.
  2. Thank them for speaking to you. You can do this without agreeing. "Thank you for telling me" is true whatever you later decide.
  3. Ask one question to understand. "Which part do you mean?" "What did you hear me say?" These keep you from guessing, and they turn a general complaint into a particular comment.
  4. Keep it, and wait. Write down what was said. Do not answer the big question that day. A comment that feels like an attack at ten o'clock on a Sunday morning may look different on Wednesday.

Lecture 5-3 takes up what to do with the comment afterward, including when it is not feedback at all but an attack. For now, hold on to this: a comment you did not ask for has a speaker who took some trouble, and the least you owe is to hear it.

7. Praise in public, blame in public

Two mistakes damage the practice of feedback in a community. Both come from talking about a sermon to people who cannot do anything about it.

Public praise. Praise given in front of others, such as a long compliment at the door, a message on a shared page or a rank order of preachers, feels kind. It can also mislead. The preacher learns only that the people were pleased, and not what actually worked. It also makes the next preacher, who may be a new or a nervous one, aware that he or she is being compared. Private thanks that names a particular ("when you slowed down at the cross, I stopped drifting") does more good than applause.

Public blame. Criticism voiced where the preacher cannot answer or where others pile on is almost never feedback. It is closer to a verdict. A sermon criticised in the car park, in a group message or on an open page becomes a topic of conversation, and the preacher is the last to hear of it.

Rumour is public blame that has lost its speaker. A comment passes from one person to a second and a third, changing at each step, until the preacher learns that "people say" something. A rumour gives the preacher nothing to work with: there is no person to ask, no particular passage to examine. A community that wants its preachers to grow agrees on one simple rule: say it to the preacher, or say it to the person responsible for the preaching, and do not say it to anyone else. If you hear a rumour about a sermon, the helpful thing is to send the person back to the preacher.

One caution. Rumour about a preacher's conduct, as distinct from their sermon, is a different matter. If someone is hurt, in danger, or says that a preacher has harmed them, that is not a matter for sermon feedback at all. It goes to the responsible person named in your community's written rules, and, if anyone is in danger now, to the local emergency number.

8. What this practice rests on

The two proverbs at the head of this lecture say plainly what the Acts story shows. People become sharper by meeting other people, and plans stand where many counsellors have been heard. The text does not say that everyone's opinion is right. It says that a solitary judgement is poor equipment for any work that others must live with.

A preacher who asks other ears, and takes the answers well, is practising the same humility that the sermon asks of its hearers. The next lecture looks at what the helper does with the ears he or she has been given.


Diagram 1. Whom to ask, and what each gives you

Other Ears Around the Preacher The preacher cannot hear the sermon from the inside A trusted partner One person who hears you often Gives: honesty and a long view Ask: before and after A preaching group Three to six people, meeting regularly Gives: shared and single views See lecture 5-4 A colleague or senior Someone who has preached longer Gives: craft: transitions, shape Ask: on a set occasion A few ordinary hearers, chosen on purpose A young person -- a second-language hearer -- a long-standing member -- a newcomer Gives: what the sermon was like to someone who heard it once, from outside Three questions that ask about the hearer, not about you 1. In one sentence, what did you hear me say? 2. Was there a place where you lost me? 3. What helped you follow? finds the sentence that arrived finds the break in the road protects what is already working Say it to the preacher, or to the person responsible for preaching. Not to anyone else. Public praise misleads, public blame wounds, and rumour gives the preacher nothing to work with.

Diagram 2. Four steps for criticism nobody asked for

Step What to do What it protects
1. Listen to the end Do not defend or explain while the person speaks The person's willingness to speak again
2. Thank them "Thank you for telling me" is true even if you disagree The relationship
3. Ask one question "Which part do you mean?" A particular you can work with
4. Keep it and wait Write it down; decide later Your judgement, which is poor in the first hour

In short

  • A preacher cannot hear the sermon as a stranger hears it, because the preacher already knows what was meant. Another person's ears are the only reliable test.
  • Four kinds of helper: a trusted partner, a preaching group, a colleague or senior, and a few ordinary hearers chosen on purpose.
  • In Acts 18:26, Priscilla and Aquila listened, then took Apollos aside, and added to what he knew.
  • Three questions: what did you hear me say, where did you lose me, what helped you follow.
  • To criticism nobody asked for: listen to the end, thank, ask one question, and wait before deciding.
  • Say it to the preacher, or to the person responsible. Public praise misleads, public blame wounds, and rumour leaves nothing to work with.
Front Back
Why the preacher needs other ears The preacher already knows what was meant and cannot hear the sermon as a stranger does.
The three questions What did you hear me say in one sentence? Where did you lose me? What helped you follow?
Apollos in Acts 18:26 Priscilla and Aquila listened, took him aside, and explained more accurately. Private and kind.
Where feedback goes To the preacher or the person responsible, not to rumour, praise rankings or public blame.

One sentence to remember The one person who cannot hear the sermon as a stranger is the preacher, so ask someone who can.

This week's action Choose one person you trust and ask them the first question, in one sentence: what did you hear me say?

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • List three things you cannot judge about your own speaking. Which of the three would you most like another person to tell you about?
  • In Acts 18:26, why might it matter that Priscilla and Aquila "took him aside"? What would have changed if they had spoken in the synagogue?
  • Who are the four people you would ask? Name the kinds of people if you would rather not name individuals.
  • Why does "What did you think?" often return so little? What is different about "In one sentence, what did you hear me say?"
  • In your community, what makes it easy or hard to give a preacher feedback? Is there a custom you would want to respect while still asking?
  • What is the difference between hearing a comment and agreeing with it?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.