Lecture 6-2: Telling Honestly: Manipulation, Power and Care
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Story, Not Explanation
- Lecture 1-2: Scene, Character, Plot
- Lecture 1-3: Repetition, Tension and Key Words
- Lecture 1-4: What the Narrator Does Not Say
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene
- Lecture 2-1: Choosing and Bounding a Story
- Lecture 2-2: Adding Nothing, Taking Nothing Away
- Lecture 2-3: Hard Texts I: Violence
- Lecture 2-4: Hard Texts II: Sexual Content and Age
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Skeleton and a Faithfulness Check
- Lecture 3-1: Voice and Breath
- Lecture 3-2: Silence and Pause
- Lecture 3-3: Body, Eyes and Space
- Lecture 3-4: Memory and Your Own Words
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Tell a Story and Give Feedback
- Lecture 4-1: Children
- Lecture 4-2: Teenagers
- Lecture 4-3: Adults, Newcomers and Mixed Cultures
- Lecture 4-4: After the Story: Questions and Sharing
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Story, Two Listeners
- Lecture 5-1: Oral Cultures and How Stories Travel
- Lecture 5-2: Chronological Bible Storying
- Lecture 5-3: Telling Where Few Read
- Lecture 5-4: How the Churches Have Told the Story
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Stories and a Retelling
A story is strong. It can open a listener's heart in a way an argument cannot. That strength is exactly why a teller must be careful with it. A teller stands in front of people who have chosen to listen, often trust the teller, and sometimes (children, newcomers, people in pain) cannot easily protect themselves.
This lecture is about the teller's honesty and the teller's power. It looks at five ways a telling can go wrong, none of which is a mistake about the text: emotional pressure, invented stories told as true, using other people's stories without their permission, the teller's own authority and pride, and the trust of children. For each, it gives a plainer and better way.
The lecture is not a rule book. It does not say that stories may not move people; they do, and rightly. It asks that the moving be done by the story and not by a trick, and that the listener leave as free as they came.
이 19분으로 얻는 것
- Tell the difference between a story that moves a listener and a telling that pressures one.
- Say what to do when an illustration is invented, and why it must be said.
- Explain why a story of someone's suffering or abuse is not the teller's to use, and what to do instead.
- Name how a teller's authority and pride can take over a telling, and one habit that guards against it.
- State what to do if a listener, especially a child, says something that suggests harm.
He spoke also this parable to certain people who were convinced of their own righteousness, and who despised all others. “Two men went up into the temple to pray; one was a Pharisee, and the other was a tax collector. The Pharisee stood and prayed to himself like this: ‘God, I thank you, that I am not like the rest of men, extortionists, unrighteous, adulterers, or even like this tax collector. I fast twice a week. I give tithes of all that I get.’ But the tax collector, standing far away, wouldn’t even lift up his eyes to heaven, but beat his breast, saying, ‘God, be merciful to me, a sinner!’ I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other; for everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, but he who humbles himself will be exalted.”" — Luke 18:9-14
World English Bible
Jesus told this parable. Luke gives, before the parable, the people it was told to.
The parable is told against pride, and it is told to listeners who were sure of their own goodness. Notice, too, who prays "to himself" and who prays to God. A teller is also someone who stands up and speaks. The temptation of the one who stands up is often the first man's.
Take care with this parable in one other way. A Pharisee in this story is one man in one picture. The Pharisees were many, and Jesus' picture is not a verdict on all of them. Tellers should not use this story to look down on a group of people, whether then or now.
1. Moving a listener and pressuring a listener
A story moves the listener by what happens in it: a father running, a boy left alone, a man who cannot lift his eyes. The listener feels something, and that feeling is theirs.
Pressure begins when the teller uses the feeling for a purpose the story does not carry. Four signs are common:
- Tears as a tool. The teller lowers the voice and lingers on the sad part, not because the text lingers, but to bring the listener to tears.
- Guilt as a lever. The teller says, or lets it be understood, that a good person would respond now, and that those who do not are hard-hearted.
- Fear as a lever. The teller leaves the listener afraid of what happens if they do not respond.
- The pressured moment. "Close your eyes. If you want to be saved, put up your hand. Now. This may be your last chance." Or, to children: "Come to the front now, everybody is waiting."
The test is not whether a telling made someone cry, or whether someone responded. It is whether the listener could have said no, and left with nobody looking at them. A story that gives the listener something to think about, and room to think, respects them. A telling that makes the room uncomfortable until they act does not.
Invitations are not wrong. People may be invited to pray, to talk, to come and learn more. The mistake is to make the invitation a pressure, to hurry it or to attach a threat. An honest invitation can be refused without cost.
2. An invented example
(An invented example.) Here is the end of a telling, made up for this lecture. It is not from any real speaker.
"...and the little girl never saw her father again. And I want you to think tonight about her father, lying in that cold hospital. Maybe it is your father. Maybe tonight is the last night you will have to make this choice. I am not going to let you leave this room until I have seen your hand. Every head bowed. Every eye closed. Is there one hand? Is there one?"
The deliberate weakness is in the last lines, and there are several: an invented story presented as if it were true; a threat of "the last night"; a promise not to let people leave; and a request for a public hand with every head bowed, where a person's answer is made under pressure. A teller who wants to end gently could say instead: "That is the story. If it has made you want to talk or pray, I will be here afterwards, and so will others. You do not have to say anything tonight."
3. Invented stories told as true
Illustrations are useful. A teller may say, "Imagine a man who owes a great debt," and the listeners know it is a picture. That is honest. Jesus himself told parables, and nobody mistook them for reports.
The trouble starts when an invented story is told as if it happened: "I once knew a man who..." when no such man existed; "A woman wrote to me last week..." when no letter came. Listeners then trust the point because they trust the facts. When they learn, later, that the facts were made up, they may stop trusting the teller and, sadly, what the teller was teaching.
A simple rule: if you invented it, say it. "Here is a story I made up." "Imagine..." "Suppose a child..." Such phrases cost nothing and keep faith with the listener. The same rule applies to a story from a book or a film: say where it comes from. And a story that happened to you is yours; tell it as it happened, without adding for effect.
4. Other people's stories
Some of the strongest stories a teller knows are other people's: a friend's illness, a church member's loss, a person who survived abuse. A teller may feel that using such a story would help the listeners. But a story of someone's suffering belongs to the one who suffered.
Three things follow.
Ask first, and accept no. If you want to tell something about a real person, ask them privately and plainly, and be ready to hear no. Do not make the "no" difficult. A person who agrees under pressure has not agreed.
Changing a name is not enough. In a small church or town, listeners may know who it is from the details. If the person could be recognised, the story is still theirs. If you cannot ask, do not tell it.
Abuse and violence stories need special care. Do not tell a story of someone's abuse as an illustration, and do not tell it to move a room. In any group, someone may have been hurt in the same way. The telling can reopen the wound, and it uses the suffering for an end the sufferer did not choose. If a person who has been hurt wants to tell their own story, that is different: it is theirs, in their time, in a setting they have chosen, with support. The teller's job is to listen and to point to care, not to use it.
If you must refer to a harm, speak in general terms and move on.
5. The teller's authority and the teller's pride
A teller usually stands higher, speaks longer and is listened to with respect. That is a kind of power, and like all power it can be used badly, even without meaning to.
Signs that the telling has become about the teller:
- The teller's voice, skill or story becomes the thing people remember, rather than the story.
- The teller is never questioned, and questions are treated as an attack.
- The teller tells stories mostly about themselves: their own courage, their own rescue.
- The teller enjoys the tears or the praise afterwards a little too much.
This is not a reason for false modesty. A good teller may enjoy telling, and that is honest. But the parable of Luke 18 is a gentle warning to anyone who stands up to pray or to speak: the one who prays "to himself" has already left the room.
Here are some habits that guard against it:
- Tell in the open. Let a trusted person hear you tell, and listen to what they say. Lecture 3-5's order (what I noticed, what worked, one suggestion) is built for this.
- Let the listener have the last word. Leave a pause. Ask a question you do not answer.
- Credit the text. "The story says..." keeps the weight where it belongs.
- Be answerable. Tell within a church, a group or a community that can say to you, kindly, "that went too far."
6. Children and trust
Children usually believe the teller. A child will take a story as true because an adult has told it, and will take a frightening picture as a promise. That trust is a gift, and it brings a duty.
- Do not frighten a child into belief or behaviour. Do not use the fear of hell, death or losing a parent as a way to bring children forward.
- Do not ask a child to keep a secret from their parents. A teller who says "this is just between us" is doing what safeguarding rules exist to stop.
- Do not pressure a child to respond publicly. A child's "yes" to a room full of waiting adults is not a free answer.
- Hear what a child says. A child may say something in or after a story that suggests harm: about home, about another adult, about themselves. Listen calmly. Do not ask leading questions. Do not promise to keep it secret. Say that you are glad they told you. Then follow your organisation's written safeguarding rules and tell the safeguarding lead at once; and where the law requires, report. (The details are in PT710E.)
These duties apply to anyone telling in any place where children are, whether they are teachers or visitors.
7. What the text says, what I imagine, what I do not know
The table below applies the three-way sort to the parable itself. It shows how much is easy to add.
| Luke 18:9-14 | |
|---|---|
| What the text says | Two men went up to the temple to pray; one prayed thanking God that he was not like others, and spoke of fasting and tithing; the other stood far off, would not lift his eyes, beat his breast and asked for mercy; Jesus says the second went down justified. |
| What I imagine | The tone of each prayer; the look of the temple court; whether the first man was a hypocrite or sincere. |
| What I do not know | The tax collector's circumstances; whether he changed his work; what became of either man. |
Diagram 1. Moving and pressuring
핵심 요약
- A story moves a listener by what happens in it; pressure uses tears, guilt, fear or a hurried invitation for an end the story does not carry.
- If you invented an illustration, say so; an invented story told as true wears away trust.
- A story of someone's suffering or abuse belongs to them: ask first, accept no, and do not use it to move a room.
- A teller's authority can turn a telling toward the teller; credit the text and be answerable to others.
- With children, no frightening, no secrets, no public pressure; listen, do not question, and tell the safeguarding lead.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Moving versus pressuring | Moving is done by the story; pressure uses tears, guilt, fear or hurry for something the story does not carry. |
| Invented illustrations | Say they are invented: "Imagine..." or "Here is one I made up." |
| Other people's stories | Ask first and accept no; changing a name is not enough; do not use abuse stories to move a room. |
| A child who says something worrying | Listen calmly, do not question or promise secrecy, tell the safeguarding lead, and report where the law requires. |
One sentence to remember The story may move the listener, but the listener must leave as free as they came.
This week's action Look at one illustration you often use and ask: is it true, is it mine to tell, and have I said whether I made it up?
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of a telling or a talk that moved you. How could you tell, afterwards, whether you were moved by the story or by a method?
- In the invented ending, which line would be hardest for a speaker to give up? Why?
- Why does the lecture say that "Imagine a man who owes a debt" is honest, while "I once knew a man who..." may not be?
- Why is changing a name not enough when you tell about someone from your own church?
- What is one habit that would help you hear, kindly, that a telling had gone too far?
- A child says something at the end of a story that worries you. What are the first three things you would do, in order?