Lecture 3-1: The Way of Love: the Cistercians and Bernard
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Spirituality" Means and How to Read a Classic
- Lecture 1-2: The Desert Fathers and Mothers
- Lecture 1-3: Benedict's Rule and the Western Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Women and Households of the Early Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Page of a Classic
- Lecture 2-1: The Confessions: Writing the Inner Life
- Lecture 2-2: God in the Dark: Eastern Mystical Theology
- Lecture 2-3: Hesychasm and the Philokalia
- Lecture 2-4: The Spiritual Father and the Elder
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Classic, Two Pairs of Eyes
- Lecture 3-1: The Way of Love: the Cistercians and Bernard
- Lecture 3-2: Poverty and Brotherhood: Francis and Clare
- Lecture 3-3: Women and Laity: Julian, Catherine and the Cloud of Unknowing
- Lecture 3-4: The Imitation of Christ and the Modern Devotion
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Gift and Shadow
- Lecture 4-1: Ignatius and Carmel: Spirituality in Catholic Reform
- Lecture 4-2: The Calling of Ordinary Life: Luther, Calvin and Protestant Spirituality
- Lecture 4-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians and Wesley
- Lecture 4-4: Devotional Classics for Ordinary Readers: Bunyan and Law
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of a Day
- Lecture 5-1: Songs under Slavery: the Spirituality of the Black Church
- Lecture 5-2: Holiness and Pentecost: Experience at the Centre
- Lecture 5-3: Ways Around the World
- Lecture 5-4: Hymns as Spiritual Classics
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Song
Week 2 ended in the East, with a God who is more than words can hold. This week turns west and forward in time, to the Latin Christian world of the twelfth to the fifteenth centuries. Its first voice is a voice about love.
The way begins with a small group of monks who walked out of a rich and busy abbey and built a new house in a quiet valley. They were called Cistercians, after the place where the movement began. One of them became the most famous preacher of his century. He taught his own brothers that the Christian life is, from first to last, a school of love.
This lecture does three things. It looks at what the Cistercians tried to do and what daily life in their houses was like. It reads the gist of Bernard of Clairvaux's teaching on love, as a spiritual classic and not as a theological argument. And it asks the question that this whole course asks of every way: what gift did it give, and what shadow or question did it leave?
이 21분으로 얻는 것
- Describe what the Cistercians wanted to recover and how their way of life showed it.
- Summarise, in your own words, the gist of Bernard's teaching on the stages of love.
- Explain why Bernard's sermons on the Song of Solomon count as a spiritual classic and how Christian readers have read that book.
- Name at least two gifts and two shadows of the Cistercian way, without ranking it above or below other ways.
He brought me to the banquet hall. His banner over me is love." — Song of Solomon 2:4
World English Bible
We love him, because he first loved us." — 1 John 4:19
WEB
The first verse comes from a book of poetry that Christians have read for many centuries as speaking of the love between God and the soul. The second is a plain sentence that sets the order: God's love comes first, and ours answers it. Both stand behind the way of Bernard and his brothers.
1. Why begin with love
Many of the ways in this course are known by what people did: they left the city, they begged, they wrote letters, they sang. This first medieval way is known by what it was about. Its centre was a single word, love, used again and again of God and of the soul.
That choice of centre matters for the reader of today. A person who hears the word "spirituality" may think first of techniques, or of feelings, or of hardship. The Cistercians would have recognised none of these as the heart of the matter. For them the heart of the matter was to be loved by God and to learn to love in return. Everything else (the labour, the silence, the plain building) was there to serve that.
2. A new house in the woods
At the end of the eleventh century a group of monks left an older abbey in France and settled in a place called Cîteaux. Their reasons, as the tradition of the order tells them, were not complicated. They wanted to follow the Rule of Benedict, which lecture 1-3 described, more closely than they believed their neighbours did. Hence the name that grew up around them: Cistercians, from the Latin form of the name of the place.
What did "more closely" mean? Three things stand out in what historians of the order describe.
Simplicity. Their churches and houses were plain. Some earlier abbeys, famous for their long and splendid services and their rich furnishing, seemed to the Cistercians to have grown away from the poverty a monk had promised. The Cistercians chose bare stone, little decoration and a habit of undyed wool, which is why they came to be called the white monks.
Labour. Benedict had said that a monastery's life included work of the hands, and the Cistercians took that seriously. They built their houses in remote valleys where land was cheap and could be cleared, and they farmed it. In time they also employed lay brothers, men who took vows and lived in the community, but who did not follow the full round of Latin services and spent much of their time on farm work. This arrangement allowed the houses to grow. It also left two kinds of members in one community, a point we will return to.
A shared constitution. The houses were bound to one another by a common set of rules and by regular visits from one house to another. This was meant to keep each house from drifting into its own habits.
For the wider history of in this period, including why reform movements arose, see the course on medieval church history (CH102E). Here we need only the picture: a determined attempt to live the old rule plainly, in places where nothing distracted from it.
3. A school of love: what Bernard taught
The best known of the early Cistercians was Bernard of Clairvaux, who lived from about 1090 to 1153. He came from a landowning family in the region of Burgundy, entered the new community as a young man, and a few years later was sent with a group of brothers to found a house of his own at a place called Clairvaux. He was its abbot for the rest of his life. The thought of the person, including his arguments on points of doctrine, belongs to CH403E. Here he matters as the author of a spiritual classic, and the classic is a set of talks.
One scene. Picture the gathering room of the abbey at Clairvaux. The brothers have finished their work for the day and are seated. The abbot speaks to them, in Latin, as he did many times. His subject is not a rule of life or a point of law. He is taking, verse by verse, a love poem: the Song of Solomon. He began these talks to his own brothers, and he did not finish them; they run to well over eighty sermons, and they were still unfinished when he died. The brothers wrote them down, and he went over them for others to read. They were copied, kept and read in many houses, and later outside the cloister as well. They were received, in other words, not as one man's private reflection but as a book for a community.
The Song of Solomon is a strange book to choose. It is poetry about lovers. Christian readers have read it in more than one way. Many read it, as Bernard did, as speaking of the love between God and the soul; many also read it as speaking of Christ and the church; and many today read it first as a poem of human love and give it no other meaning. This course does not need to settle that. What matters here is that for Bernard and his brothers, the language of lovers was the most honest language they had for what they were trying to say about God.
The gist of his teaching on love. Besides the sermons, Bernard wrote a short work on the love of God. Readers have usually summarised its thought as a path with stages, and the summary below is the gist only, not a translation.
- A person begins by loving themselves, because that is where everyone begins. It is natural, and it is not yet wrong.
- Then, finding that they cannot live well alone, they turn to God because they need him. Their love for God is real, but it is still for their own sake.
- As they come to know God, they begin to love God because God is good. Their own need drops into the background.
- In the last stage, the soul loves even itself in God and for God's sake.
Bernard did not say that most people reach the last stage in this life, and he said that it comes as a gift, not as a reward for effort. That is the other half of the picture: the 1 John verse that opens this lecture. The order is first God's love, then ours.
A way, not a ladder to climb
The stages are not a scoreboard. Bernard does not teach that a person earns each step by trying harder. He describes a growth in love that begins and ends in God's own love. A reader who turns the stages into a measure of how spiritual someone is has taken the gist and left the point.
4. What the Cistercian way gave
Look at the way as a whole and ask the first of our two questions: what did it give?
- A clear centre. Love was named as the aim, and the labour and the silence were arranged around it.
- A language for the inner life. Bernard's talks gave many readers words for longing, for doubt and for gratitude that they could not find in a rule or a creed.
- Dignity for plain work. Farming and building were part of the life, not a distraction from it.
- A texture of ordinary shared life. Houses were bound together, visited one another and corrected one another. The way was not only a private inward journey.
- A book for others. The sermons and the short works on love were read far beyond Clairvaux. Later readers of many traditions, including Protestant writers such as Luther and Calvin, quoted Bernard with respect, while differing on many things he held.
5. What it left us asking
The second question: what shadow, or what question, did the way leave?
The crusade. In the 1140s Bernard preached in support of a new crusade, a military expedition to the Holy Land. The expedition failed, and the failure was a heavy blow to his reputation. Whatever one makes of the argument for it, it stands in the record as a place where a teacher of love lent his voice to a campaign of war. We note it here in one sentence and leave the history to CH102E.
The distance between poverty and success. The Cistercians set out to be plain and poor. In time their houses became productive, even prosperous, and the order's own writers sometimes worried that the plainness of the founders was not being kept. A movement that sets out to leave the world's wealth behind may find the wealth following it into the valley. That pattern is old, and it is not special to this order.
The body. Cistercian life was austere: little sleep, long services, simple food, hard work. We should say plainly that this is history and not advice. Austerity of this kind could and did damage health, and the Rule of Benedict itself made provision for the sick and the old, because the founders knew that a community could not ignore the body. Nobody should take from this lecture a lesson that more hardship makes a person more devout. Illness, exhaustion and depression are not met by more discipline; they are met with care. For the disciplines of the life of faith, see LM107E.
A way for a few. The path of love as Bernard described it was lived in a monastery, in Latin, mostly by men who had left ordinary life. The two kinds of member in a Cistercian house, the choir monks who prayed the services and the lay brothers who farmed, show the limit. Most people could not join. In the next lectures of this week we meet voices from outside the cloister: friars in the town, a woman in a small room beside a church, laypeople who gathered in towns in the Low Countries.
A question of self. Bernard himself knew a danger in the language of love: that a person may love the feeling of loving. The four stages are partly his answer. They place the love of self at the start and the love of God for God's sake at the end, and they treat the sweetness of devotion as a gift to be received, not a goal to be pursued. Later readers asked whether every reader of such a book would draw that distinction. This remains an honest question about any literature of the inner life.
6. A tradition among traditions
Notice how the Cistercian way fits among the others we have met. Like the desert fathers and mothers of lecture 1-2, the Cistercians left ordinary life to listen. Like Benedict's Rule, they lived in community and under authority. Unlike the Eastern writers of week 2, they spoke of God chiefly in the language of the affections, of longing and desire, rather than of darkness and of the endless journey. These are differences of emphasis, not of rank. A reader from an Orthodox community may find the language of the heart familiar from their own tradition in other words, while a Protestant reader may be struck by the plain, Scripture-saturated style of the sermons. A Catholic reader will probably know the order and its buildings and may know it more warmly than a stranger does. None of this makes one reading the right one.
Diagram 1. The way of love in four stages (a gist, not a ladder to climb)
핵심 요약
- The Cistercians began at the end of the eleventh century as a reform seeking a plainer, stricter life under Benedict's Rule, centred on simplicity and manual work.
- Bernard of Clairvaux is read here as the author of a spiritual classic: talks to his brothers on the Song of Solomon and a short work on loving God.
- Readers summarise his teaching as four stages of love, from loving self for self's sake to loving self in God, each beginning in God's love first.
- Gifts: a clear centre, words for the inner life, dignity for plain work. Shadows: a crusade, growing wealth, harsh austerity, and a way open to few.
- Austerity in this way is history, not advice; illness and exhaustion are met with care.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Cistercians | Reformers from the end of the eleventh century who sought a plainer life under Benedict's Rule, with simplicity and manual work. |
| Bernard's teaching on love (gist) | Four stages from love of self for self's sake to love of self in God, each beginning in God's love first. |
| Song of Solomon in this tradition | Read by Bernard and many Christian readers as speaking of God's love for the soul; others read it first as a poem of human love. |
| A gift and a shadow | Gift: a clear centre in love. Shadow: a teacher of love who also preached for a crusade. |
One sentence to remember The Cistercians show that a way built around love can be plain and strong, and that it can still carry shadows of war, wealth and hardship.
This week's action Think of one way of faith you know well and one you know little. For each, write one gift and one shadow it has left, on a private sheet.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Why might the Cistercians have named love, and not discipline or knowledge, as the centre of the life?
- In the four stages, a person begins by loving themselves. Does that surprise you? What does it say about how the way takes ordinary human need seriously?
- The sermons were given to a community and then copied for others. How does it change a spiritual book if it begins as a talk to a particular group?
- The lecture names a crusade among the shadows of the way. What might it mean that a teacher of love could also speak for a war? What question does it leave for any spiritual teacher?
- The Cistercians sought plainness and, in time, grew prosperous. Can you think of other movements, in any tradition, that went the same way? Why might it happen?
- Which of the gifts named in the lecture would you most want to learn from? Which of the shadows would you most want to watch for?