Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
- Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
- Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
- Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
- Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
- Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
- Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
- Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
- Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
- Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
- Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
- Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
- Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
- Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
- Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
- Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
Two ten-year-olds are arguing at the end of a group meeting. "She took more than her share!" "I did not. You always say that." A third child stands to one side and says nothing. Later the adult hears that this child was told, "You cannot sit with us." (an invented example)
Ask any adult who works with children between roughly seven and twelve what they notice, and many will say the same: fairness. "That is not fair" may be the most frequent sentence of the age. Children are building a sense of how a shared world should work, and they test it everywhere: on the playground, in games, at the table, in the rules of the room. They also care intensely about who their friends are, who is in and who is out.
This lecture asks what the adult beside such children should do with that energy. The answer has three parts. First, take the child's sense of fairness seriously, because it is the seed of something good. Second, put grace under the rules, so that a child does not conclude "I must be good to be loved." Third, notice the child who is left out or hurt by others, and pass it on to the right person.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why fairness, rules and friendships matter so much to children of roughly seven to twelve.
- Describe, with its criticisms, Kohlberg's account of moral reasoning as a map and not as a verdict.
- Explain how a faith made only of rules can harden into "I must be good to be loved", and how grace answers it.
- Describe how an adult can teach repair and forgiveness without forcing a quick apology.
- State the posture of notice, stay and pass on when a child is being bullied or left out.
He has shown you, O man, what is good. What does Yahweh require of you, but to act justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God?" — Micah 6:8
World English Bible
If therefore you are offering your gift at the altar, and there remember that your brother has anything against you," — Matthew 5:23
WEB
leave your gift there before the altar, and go your way. First be reconciled to your brother, and then come and offer your gift." — Matthew 5:24
WEB
But God commends his own love toward us, in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us." — Romans 5:8
WEB
Micah joins justice, mercy and humility in one sentence. Matthew 5:23-24 shows that a wrong between people matters in worship. Romans 5:8 says where love begins: not after people have become good, but while they were still far from it.
1. A world of rules
Children in the school years often love rules. They invent them for games, argue about them, and are quick to say when someone has broken one. They also begin to see that rules can be fair or unfair, and that people can break them for reasons. These are the early steps of a moral life, and they are not a nuisance to be managed.
Why do rules matter so much to the age? Many children have moved out of the world of the home and into larger groups where nobody can rely on being the favourite. Rules are what make a group safe and predictable. A child who knows the rules knows where they stand. This is why children can be so hard on a classmate who "cheats" and so hurt by an adult who changes a rule without saying why.
The adult can use this. Rules that are few, clear and explained are welcomed by most children of this age. A rule that is announced and then applied differently to different children is a wound, because it teaches the child that the world is not fair. If an exception is needed, the best course is often to say it plainly: "Sam needs to sit near the door today. That is because of something Sam needs, and if you ever need something, we will do the same for you."
2. Kohlberg as a map
You may meet the name of Lawrence Kohlberg, an American psychologist who studied how people reason about right and wrong. He described a sequence in which people first reason from avoiding punishment and gaining reward, then from the expectations of their group and the rules of their society, and later, for some, from principles that they judge to hold beyond any one society. He built this by asking children and adults about difficult moral dilemmas.
The map offers a useful picture. Many children in the school years do reason from rules, rewards and the approval of the group: "It's wrong because you get in trouble", "It's wrong because everyone says so." A child reasoning like this is not morally empty. The child is doing what a child of this age often does.
The map has well-known criticisms, and the course asks you to carry them with it. Carol Gilligan, a psychologist who worked with Kohlberg, argued that his scheme stressed justice and rules and gave too little room to an ethic of care, to relationships and responsibility. Others have pointed out that the dilemmas and the highest stage reflect a particular tradition of Western philosophy, and that people in other cultures may reason morally in ways the scheme does not capture well. And there is the gap between what a person says about a dilemma and what that person does, which the interviews do not measure. Use Kohlberg to ask "How might this child be thinking about right and wrong?", never to rank a child's goodness, and never to decide where a child's faith stands.
3. When rules harden: "I must be good to be loved"
Here is a risk that is easy to miss, because it grows out of something good. A child who loves rules, who wants to be fair and who is rewarded for good behaviour can conclude something nobody intended to teach: "I am loved when I am good, and not otherwise."
Imagine a faith that teaches a child the rules of the community, praises the child for following them, and says little about what happens when the child fails. The child who is naturally careful may become anxious. The child who struggles may decide that he is a bad child. The child who does everything right may grow proud, or exhausted, or both. In each case the child has met a God who keeps accounts. (this is a pattern to watch for, not a prediction about any one child)
The old name for the opposite is grace. Romans 5:8 says that God's love arrived "while we were yet sinners", before anyone had earned it. This is not a lesson about rules being unimportant. It is a lesson about order. In the story of the lost son (Luke 15), the father runs to his son before the son has finished his prepared speech. The rules are not abolished. But the love comes first, and the rules live inside it.
Traditions describe this differently. Some speak of by grace through faith; others of the sacraments as the way grace is given; others of , a growth into God's life; others of a . They do not agree on what grace is or how it reaches us. Yet all of them, in their own words, say that the child does not earn being loved. What this course asks is only that a child never be given the impression that love is a wage.
How does this look in practice? An adult can say, when a child has broken a rule, "I'm not happy about what happened, and you are still welcome here." An adult can praise effort, kindness and honesty and not only results. An adult can avoid using belonging as a punishment: "If you do that again, you will not be allowed to come." A community can let children see adults who have failed and been forgiven. These small habits teach more than a lecture on grace.
4. Friends, groups and the sting of being left out
Friendship becomes more central in these years. Many children have a best friend, a group, a rival, and a sharp sense of who is "in". They compare themselves with others: who is better at reading, at football, who has the newest thing. They can be generous and cruel within the same afternoon, and often without noticing which they are being.
Children's groups form and re-form quickly. A child who was the centre of attention on Tuesday may be shut out on Thursday. Adults often remember this less sharply than children feel it. A message such as "just ignore it" may be well meant, but it can leave a child feeling that the pain is not real. A fairer response is to say, "That sounds hurtful. Thank you for telling me."
In a church or similar community, two things deserve attention. One is exclusion. A child who is always chosen last, who has no one to sit with, or who is teased about clothes, accent, family or ability needs an adult who notices. The other is comparison. A community that praises the same children again and again for being good, clever or musical teaches the rest that they are second. A fair community looks for the gifts of every child, including the quiet ones.
5. Repair and forgiveness
Children quarrel. A community that wishes to grow children in faith cannot avoid this, and should not want to, since quarrels are where repair is learned. Matthew 5:23-24 gives a striking instruction: if you remember that someone has something against you, leave your gift at the altar and go first to be reconciled. The picture is of worship interrupted for the sake of a relationship.
What can an adult do with this? Some principles help.
Hear each child. Before anything is decided, let each child say what happened, without interruption, in a few sentences.
Aim at repair, not at a winner. The question "Who started it?" rarely helps. A better one is "What would help to make this right?"
Do not force a quick apology. A child made to say "sorry" through clenched teeth learns that apology is a ritual to escape trouble. Better to say, "When you are ready, you could tell her you are sorry. In the meantime, I am going to help you both." Some children need time. Some will offer an apology without being asked.
Let the one who was hurt decide how much to say. A child should not be required to forgive on the spot. Forgiveness is a gift, not a performance, and it often follows rather than precedes feeling safe.
Let adults model it. The most powerful teaching of forgiveness is an adult saying, "I was too sharp with you earlier. I am sorry." Children notice.
Communities understand reconciliation differently. A Catholic or Orthodox child may be prepared for confession, and a free-church child may be taught to pray together and make peace. These are different forms with a shared root. What the course requires is that repair be taught as a way of loving, and that no child be shamed in public for failing at it.
6. Bullying: notice, stay, pass on
Teasing is part of childhood. Bullying is different: it is repeated, it hurts, and the child on the receiving end often cannot make it stop by themselves. It may be spoken, physical, hidden among messages and pictures online, or a matter of being cut out of a group on purpose. It happens in churches as it does anywhere.
This course does not teach a method for dealing with it, and what follows is not legal or medical advice. The posture is the same as for any sensitive subject: notice, stay, pass on.
Notice. Look for a child who does not want to come, who is alone, who has lost friends, who has damaged belongings, or who is suddenly anxious or angry. A sign is not a proof, and there may be other reasons. But a sign is worth a quiet question.
Stay. If a child tells you something, listen. Do not promise to keep it secret, because you may need to tell someone. Do not say "Just ignore it" or "Hit back." Thank the child for telling you. Say that it is not their fault.
Pass on. Tell the person responsible for children in your community, following its written policy, so that the matter can be dealt with properly and the family informed as the policy directs. If a child is in immediate danger, call the local emergency number. What the law requires of an adult, and how bullying between children is handled, differs from country to country. The adult is not a judge, a detective or a rescuer, and should not confront the children involved alone.
And the child who is doing the bullying? That child is a child as well. Often that child is hurting, or copying, or afraid. This does not excuse harm, and the child must be stopped. But the community should not give up on that child or label them. The term "bully" is often used for a child, and it is better to speak of what the child did.
7. Rules and grace in liturgical and free-church settings
In a liturgical parish, a child may live inside many rules: when to stand and kneel, what to say, how to approach the altar or the icon. These can give a child a deep sense of belonging, since the rules are the shape of a shared life. The risk is that a child learns them as demands. The remedy is that the same child also hears, again and again, the words of mercy that run through the .
In a free-church or Pentecostal assembly, the rules may be fewer and less formal, such as dress, behaviour or the expectation to take part. They may be unwritten, and so harder for a child to read. The remedy there is to say the rules plainly and to let the child see the assembly forgive. In either setting, a child needs two things in the same room: clear expectations and a grace that is bigger than them.
Diagram 1. Rules inside grace, and what happens when the order is reversed
핵심 요약
- Children of roughly seven to twelve care deeply about fairness, rules and friends; this is a seed of moral life, not a nuisance.
- Kohlberg's account of moral reasoning is a map with known criticisms; it is never a ranking of a child's goodness or faith.
- A faith made only of rules can teach "I must be good to be loved"; grace puts love first, and the rules live inside it.
- Teach repair by hearing each child, aiming at making things right, and not forcing a quick apology.
- Matthew 5:23-24 puts reconciliation before the gift at the altar.
- When a child is bullied or left out: notice, stay, pass on to the person responsible; for immediate danger call the local emergency number.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why do rules and fairness matter at this age? | Children are building a sense of how a shared world should work; clear, fair rules make a group feel safe. |
| Kohlberg: use and limit | A map of how people reason about right and wrong; criticised for stressing justice over care and for cultural limits. Never a ranking of a child. |
| "I must be good to be loved" | A risk of rule-centred faith; grace puts love first (Romans 5:8), and the rules live inside it. |
| Bullying: notice, stay, pass on | Notice the signs, listen and promise no secrecy, tell the person responsible; immediate danger means the local emergency number. |
One sentence to remember Let the rules be the shape of a shared life, and let grace be under every one of them.
This week's action The next time a child breaks a rule, say one sentence that holds both truths: what happened matters, and the child is still welcome.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What was the unfairness you felt most sharply as a child? How did the adults around you respond?
- Where have you seen a child grow anxious about being "good enough" in a religious setting? What might an adult have said that would have helped?
- Kohlberg's map is drawn from certain societies and has been criticised. What does it help you see in children you know, and what does it miss?
- How does your community teach repair after a quarrel? What happens to a child who is made to say sorry?
- Which children in your community are rarely chosen, praised or invited? What would it take to notice them?
- If a child told you they were being left out or hurt by others, what would you say first? Whom would you tell, and what does your community's written policy say?