Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
- Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
- Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
- Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
- Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
- Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
- Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
- Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
- Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
- Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
- Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
- Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
- Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
- Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
- Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
- Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
This is the third Practice Lab of the course. As in the others, you do something and do not only read.
Today's task is small and exact. Take one invented question from a child of about seven to eleven and write down, before you ever need it, your first sentence in reply, what you would not say, and whom you would involve. The question is given to you. You write the answer in your own words.
The first four lectures of this week gave you ideas: a child of this age is strong with stories and concrete thinking (3-1), cares about fairness and needs grace under the rules (3-2), is beginning to make faith their own and may doubt (3-3), and belongs whether or not the child is easy (3-4). This lab asks you to hold those ideas against one question. Knowing that a child's question is a gift is different from having a sentence ready when the gift arrives, in a corridor, with a cup in your hand, and four other children waiting.
이 23분으로 얻는 것
- Complete the sheet "Answering One Child's Question" for your own place, for an observed scene, or for an invented scene.
- State the four promises of privacy that govern this lab.
- Write a first sentence that is short, honest and warm, and name something you would not say and why.
- Say whom you would involve, and when, for a question that touches the child's home, grief or safety.
- Explain how to run the lab in a small group so that nobody is exposed.
Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, “I believe. Help my unbelief!”" — Mark 9:24
World English Bible
Keep this verse in front of you while you write. The father says two things in one breath and is not told to choose. As you write, look for the place where an honest answer admits what is not known, and for the place where the child is allowed to hold two feelings at once.
1. Why one question
A principle can sound right and change nothing. A sentence changes something. When a child says, "Did I not believe enough?" the adult has perhaps two seconds before the silence says something of its own. In those seconds, a prepared adult can say a true and gentle thing. An unprepared adult often says whatever comes first: a reassurance that is not quite true, a theological summary, a change of subject, or "Ask your mother."
The lab uses one question because a general intention ("I will answer children honestly") slides past. One question has edges. It has an age, a feeling underneath, a place where it might be asked, and one or two wrong answers that a kind adult is tempted to give.
The goal is not a perfect answer. No answer is perfect, and the child will ask again. The goal is a first sentence that keeps the door open.
2. The four promises of privacy
Say these before you begin. If you are leading a group, say them out loud.
- Nobody reads what you write. The sheet is yours.
- Nothing is marked or graded. There is no right answer to write.
- You may pass on any part. Leave a box empty if you wish; that is a complete answer.
- The leader fills in a sheet too. The person at the front is not an examiner.
One more rule goes with these: do not write the name of a real child, parent or colleague on the sheet, and do not write down anything private that a real child has told you. The question below is invented. If you think of a real child while you write, write "a child I know" and leave the details out.
3. The invented question
Here is the question for the lab. It is invented, as is the child.
An invented example. Tomás is nine. He is helping to stack chairs after the children's group. Without looking up, he says, "We prayed for my gran to get better and she didn't. Did we not believe enough?"
You do not know anything else. You do not know whether the gran has died or is still ill. You do not know what his family has told him. You do not know whether he is asking you or just talking. You know only the question.
Look at what the question carries. It is a question about prayer, and about God. It is also a question about guilt: Tomás wonders whether he caused the outcome. It touches grief, or fear of grief, in his home. A child of nine thinks in concrete terms (lecture 3-1), cares about fairness (3-2), and may be holding a whole theology of cause and effect that nobody has taught him, in which good prayers get good results. This is a lot for an adult to hold in two seconds.
4. How to do it
The steps, whichever way you choose
Step 1. Choose your way from the three below. You may change your mind part way through.
Step 2. Copy the sheet in section 4 onto a page by hand, or reproduce its headings on a blank page. Do not skip the headings; they are the exercise.
Step 3. Read the question once, slowly, and fill in box B before the others. Write a word or two for what you feel when you read it. Fear, tenderness, wanting to fix it, wanting to run: all are allowed.
Step 4. Fill in boxes C to G, one or two sentences each. Box D is your first sentence, in the words you would actually say aloud. Say it aloud once, quietly, to hear whether it sounds like you.
Step 5. Read the sheet once to yourself, and underline one word that surprises you.
5. The three ways into this lab
Way 1: In your own place. Use this way if you teach, lead, mentor or parent children. Use the invented question above, or, if you wish, a real kind of question that children in your place have asked, with all names and details removed. Write the sheet as if the child were in front of you. Think about the place where this might happen: the corridor, the car, the table, the bedside.
Way 2: The observer's way. Use this way if you do not work with children now. Where your community's policy and the person responsible allow it, and only then, spend an hour as a quiet observer of one ordinary scene with children aged seven to eleven: a group meeting, a family at a meal after a service, a classroom or a park. Listen for the questions that children ask and how adults answer. You are not there to judge a child or an adult, and you write no names. If you cannot observe, recall a scene from your own childhood: a question you asked, and what the adult said. In box A, tick "something I observed or remember", and fill in the sheet for that question instead of the one printed above.
Way 3: The partner's way. Use this way if you have a trusted partner and no other way suits you. You will act a short scene that is entirely invented, so that no personal story is needed.
The scene (invented). Priya, aged ten, is waiting for a lift after a Saturday morning club at a church hall. She looks at a poster of a lamb and a shepherd and says to the adult beside her, "Does God really know my name? There are so many people."
- The adult has no script. The task is a first sentence that is short, honest and warm, and then one question back to the child.
- The child plays Priya for about three minutes, and may answer in one of three ways, chosen quietly before the scene starts and not told to the adult: she is satisfied; she wants to know more; or she shrugs and changes the subject.
- Then talk for five minutes: how did the question feel from each chair? What helped? What would have helped more?
- Swap roles, and try a different answer from the child.
Afterwards, each partner fills in the sheet for the question they were asked, in the role of the adult.
6. What a good first sentence looks like
There is no right sentence. But most good first sentences have three features.
It is true. It does not claim more than the adult knows. "I don't know why your gran didn't get better" is true. "God needed her more" is a claim many adults cannot defend, and a child may hear it as God taking people away on purpose.
It is short. One or two sentences, in the words a child uses. A paragraph is a wall.
It answers the feeling as well as the question. A child asking "Did we not believe enough?" is often asking "Is it my fault?" A reply such as "No, it is not your fault, and I'm so glad you told me" answers the child under the question.
After the first sentence, a second move often helps: ask a gentle question back. "What made you think of that?" "Who have you talked to about your gran?" The child's answer shows what they are carrying, and may show that the real question was a different one.
7. What not to say
Lists of "do nots" can seem harsh, and the adult who says the wrong thing is usually trying to help. Yet it is worth knowing the common ones.
- A comforting untruth. "She is fine." "Everything happens for a reason." Children often notice, and they learn that adults do not tell them the truth about hard things.
- A frightening claim. "If you had more faith, she would be well." Mark 9:24 shows belief and unbelief in the same person, and Jesus answering the request.
- A long explanation. The question deserves a pause before an answer.
- A promise the adult cannot keep. "God will make her well." "I'll never tell anyone."
- A change of subject. Even a kind one tells a child that the topic is unwelcome.
- Taking over the family's place. If a death, a divorce or a diagnosis is in the child's home, the family may have told the child in their own way and with their own beliefs. The adult does not contradict the family, and does not explain what has not been explained.
8. Whom to involve
Most questions need nothing more than a warm adult and a few good words. Some need the child's family or the person responsible. For the lab, think about three groups.
The parent or guardian. If a child's question reveals worry, grief or confusion about the home, say to the child, honestly, "I would like to tell your mum (or dad, or the person who looks after you) that you've been wondering about this, because they would want to help. Is that all right?" Do not trick the child or make a promise of secrecy. Then, follow the community's practice about speaking to parents.
The person responsible in your community. A pastor, priest, children's leader or the safeguarding lead, if the question touches the child's safety or if you need advice.
A professional. When the child's distress is heavy or lasting, the family may need help beyond the community. The adult is not a doctor or counsellor, and the right step is to tell the family and the person responsible, who may suggest where to look.
If a child says something that suggests they are in danger, or that someone is hurting them, the question has changed. Lecture 5-4 deals with this in full. For now: listen, do not promise secrecy, tell the person responsible at once, and if the danger is immediate, call the local emergency number. The duties of an adult differ by country and by role, so know your community's written policy before you need it.
9. What usually goes wrong
Three reactions come up often. None means you have done it wrong.
"I wrote a very long first sentence." Common. Shorten it by half, then half again. Read it aloud.
"I wrote a good theological answer." Perhaps it is good. Ask whether a nine-year-old could hold it, and whether it answers the feeling.
"I could not write anything." That is information. Perhaps the question touches something of your own. Leave the box empty if you wish. An empty box is a complete answer.
A fourth reaction is less common and matters more. Sometimes the question brings back your own hurt: a loss, a prayer that was not answered, a time you were told you lacked faith. If that happens, put the pen down. Speak this week to a pastor, priest, mentor or trusted friend. That is not a failure of the exercise. It is the exercise finding something real.
10. Leader's note, for running this in a group
Running the lab so that nobody is exposed
Say the four promises of privacy first, out loud. Before anyone picks up a pen, say: nobody will read what you write; nothing is marked; you may pass on any part; I am filling in a sheet too. Say it even if you said it last week.
Fill in your own sheet. Sit down and write alongside the group. A leader who watches while others write turns the room into an examination.
Let each person choose their way. In one group there may be a teacher using Way 1, a person who has watched a scene using Way 2, and a pair acting the scene of Way 3. All are equal. Do not ask anyone to say which way they chose.
Give ten quiet minutes for writing, then ten minutes in pairs for anyone who chose Way 3.
Ask about feelings, never about contents. Do not ask "What did you write?" Ask: "What was it like to write that?" Or, for those who acted the scene: "What was it like in the chair you sat in?" Allow anyone to pass, and move on without a pause that makes passing costly.
Do not ask for real stories of real children. If someone begins to describe a particular child, say gently, "You do not need to tell us about the child. Tell us what you felt."
Do not turn the lab into a debate about God and suffering. Theologies differ, and a group of adults can spend an hour on one question and leave nothing written. The lab is about a first sentence for a child, which most traditions can write honestly.
Do not answer a hurt with a defence. If someone describes a painful memory, stay with it for a moment. Follow it up privately after the meeting, and if what you hear is beyond you, say so and help the person find someone who can carry it.
Diagram 1. The form: Answering One Child's Question
Diagram 2. Leader's checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Said the four promises of privacy out loud before anyone wrote | [ ] |
| Filled in my own sheet alongside the group | [ ] |
| Let each person choose their way and did not ask which | [ ] |
| Gave ten quiet minutes, and ten for pairs | [ ] |
| Asked "What was it like to write that?" and not "What did you write?" | [ ] |
| Offered a real option to pass, and moved on cleanly | [ ] |
| Kept the group from naming real children or debating suffering | [ ] |
| Stayed with anyone who described a hurt, and followed up privately | [ ] |
핵심 요약
- The lab holds the ideas of the week against one invented question, so that a first sentence is ready before it is needed.
- There are three equal ways in: your own place, the observer's way, and the partner's way with an invented scene.
- Four promises of privacy: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass on any part, and the leader fills one in too.
- A good first sentence is true, short and answers the feeling under the question; a gentle question back often shows what the child is carrying.
- Avoid a comforting untruth, a frightening claim, a long explanation, a promise you cannot keep, and a change of subject.
- Involve the parent or guardian, and the person responsible, honestly and without promising secrecy; for immediate danger call the local emergency number.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way with an invented scene. |
| Four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills one in too. |
| A good first sentence | True, short, and answering the feeling under the question; then a gentle question back. |
| The leader's question | Not "What did you write?" but "What was it like to write that?" |
One sentence to remember Have one true, short, warm sentence ready before the child's question arrives.
This week's action Fill in the sheet on an actual page, say your first sentence aloud once, and keep the page where only you will find it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What was it like to write that? Answer with a feeling, not with the contents.
- Which box on the sheet was easiest to fill in, and which was hardest? What might that tell you?
- Read your first sentence aloud. Would a child of nine understand it? Would a child of nine feel heard by it?
- Which of the common things not to say is the one you are most tempted to say? Where does the temptation come from?
- If you chose the observer's way, what did you notice about how adults answer children's questions? If you chose the partner's way, what did it feel like in the chair you did not expect?
- If you wish to say how your first sentence might change, do so. If you would rather not, pass.