Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
- Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
- Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
- Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
- Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
- Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
- Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
- Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
- Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
- Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
- Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
- Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
- Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
- Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
- Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
- Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
(An invented example.) Tomas is seventeen. He has been in the church since he was a baby; his parents are both active members, and his mother teaches the youngest class. One Sunday after the meeting, he says to a youth volunteer, almost in passing, "I don't know if I actually believe any of this. I think I just do it because everyone else does."
The volunteer feels a small shock. Her first thoughts come quickly: Does his mother know? Should I say something to the pastor? What should I say now? There is a pull to reassure him at once ("Of course you believe!"), a pull to correct him ("You need to pray about that"), and a pull to hurry away. Tomas, who has said something he has been carrying for months, is waiting to see what she will do.
This lecture is about that moment, and the long road around it. A young person who questions the faith of the family is, often but not always, doing what is needed to make that faith their own. Some young people, after questioning, do leave. The adult cannot control which; the adult can decide how to receive the question. The lecture asks the reader to receive doubt without panic, to practise the honesty of "I do not know" and "let us look together," and to remember Thomas.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why questioning the faith one was raised in can be part of owning it, and say honestly that it is not always so and that some young people leave.
- Describe, with its limits, how Fowler’s account places questioning in the teen and young adult years.
- Name three ways an adult receives a doubt without panic, and three ways of answering that tend to close a young person down.
- Say why "I do not know" and "let us look together" are honest and pastoral answers to a hard question.
- Describe what the story of Thomas (John 20:24-29) shows about how Jesus received a doubter.
But Thomas, one of the twelve, called Didymus, wasn’t with them when Jesus came. The other disciples therefore said to him, “We have seen the Lord!” But he said to them, “Unless I see in his hands the print of the nails, and put my hand into his side, I will not believe.” After eight days again his disciples were inside, and Thomas was with them. Jesus came, the doors being locked, and stood in the midst, and said, “Peace be to you.” Then he said to Thomas, “Reach here your finger, and see my hands. Reach here your hand, and put it into my side. Don’t be unbelieving, but believing.” Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!” Jesus said to him, “Because you have seen me, you have believed. Blessed are those who have not seen, and have believed.”" — John 20:24-29
World English Bible
How long, Yahweh? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me?" — Psalm 13:1
WEB
How long shall I take counsel in my soul, having sorrow in my heart every day? How long shall my enemy triumph over me?" — Psalm 13:2
WEB
But I trust in your loving kindness. My heart rejoices in your salvation." — Psalm 13:5
WEB
I will sing to Yahweh, because he has been good to me." — Psalm 13:6
WEB
On some have compassion, making a distinction," — Jude 1:22
WEB
Thomas says plainly what he needs, and is given it. The psalm shows a believer who asks "how long?" aloud to God, and the same psalm ends in trust. Jude’s verse is only part of a sentence (the thought goes on in the next verse), and in this lecture we use only the part that is complete in itself: some who are uncertain are to be met with compassion.
1. Why questions come
A child usually takes faith from the people who give it. A young child does not ask whether God exists; the child prays because the family prays. This is not a lesser faith. Lecture 1-3 explained that a child’s faith is whole for the child’s age.
As a young person grows, several things change at once. The ability to think about thinking develops, so that a young person can now ask, "Why do I believe this? What would I think if I had been born somewhere else?" Contact widens: school, friends, the internet and travel bring in people who believe different things, or nothing. The young person also begins to separate from the family, as lecture 4-2 described, and to wonder what is theirs and what is only inherited.
Put these together, and questions are no surprise. They would be more surprising if they never came.
2. One map, with its limits
James Fowler, whose work lecture 1-3 introduced, described a stage in which faith is largely held through the community around a person, taking its shape from the family and the group, and not much examined. He called this synthetic-conventional faith, and placed it often (not always) in the early teen years and, for many adults, for life. He described a later movement, which he called individuative-reflective, in which a person begins to step back, examine what they have received and take responsibility for it. He placed this typically later than the teen years, in young adulthood or beyond, though it can begin earlier.
The map helps us see that questioning can be a move towards a more personal faith, not just away from the old one. It also helps explain why a faith that has never been examined can feel hollow to the person who holds it.
It misses a good deal. Fowler worked mainly with people in the United States, and critics have asked whether the stages fit other cultures, women’s experience, or traditions where faith is deliberately received through the community, as in the Orthodox churches or in much Catholic life, without the expectation of a stepping-back. Others object that faith is God’s gift and does not move up a ladder. This course uses the map for one purpose: to help an adult stay calm when a young person asks a question. It is never used to say that a young person who does not question is behind, or that one who questions is further on.
3. Questioning is often, not always, owning
Here is a sentence that must be said carefully. Questioning the faith of one’s family is often a way of making it one’s own. It is not always that. Some young people question and return with a faith that is more personal and more settled. Some question and settle on a quieter faith than their parents had. Some question and move to another tradition. Some question and leave, perhaps for a time, perhaps for good. Some never ask anything out loud and find their faith deepening quietly.
An adult who says "doubt is always a stage on the way to stronger faith" is saying something that comforts the adult and may not be true for the young person. An adult who says "doubt is the beginning of losing faith" is saying something that frightens the young person into silence. The honest position is in between: we do not know where a question will lead, and we stay with the person while it does its work.
4. Receiving doubt without panic
When a young person says something like Tomas’s sentence, the adult is being given a gift: the young person has trusted them with something unguarded. What the adult does in the first minute matters a great deal.
Here are three things that help.
Stay still, and thank them. "Thank you for telling me. That sounds like something you have been carrying" costs nothing and keeps the door open. It does not agree or disagree. It says, I can hear this.
Ask a real question and listen to the answer. "What is it that you doubt?" "When did you start to wonder?" "Is there something that happened?" An adult who asks these is not preparing a rebuttal. A young person’s doubt may be about God’s existence, or about the church, or about one painful experience, or about something a family member said or did. These are very different doubts. A young person may use the word "believe" for several of them.
Do not promise to keep it secret, and do not rush to tell. Doubt itself is not a secret to hide, and it is not usually a danger. The young person should know who you may talk to. If a parent should know, it is usually better to ask the young person: "Would you like to tell your mother, or would you like me to be there when you do?" Where a young person says they are in distress, or that they are being harmed, the posture of lectures 5-2 and 5-4 applies instead.
Here are three ways of answering that tend to close a young person down.
- The quick reassurance. "Oh, you do believe, you're just tired." This tells the young person they were not heard.
- The quick argument. A prepared answer to every objection, delivered at once, turns a person into a debate opponent. Even a good argument heard too soon may be heard as "you have no right to ask."
- The alarm. A look of horror, an urgent call to the parents, a long solemn prayer for the young person’s soul: any of these tells the young person that doubt is dangerous, and next time they will not say it.
5. Hard questions: suffering, science, other religions, sexuality
Young people often bring particular questions, and they are worth naming because the adult may be asked any of them without warning.
- Why does God allow suffering? Often this arrives in a particular form: a death, an illness, a friend’s family breaking up. The question is then a grief before it is a puzzle.
- Does science show that faith is false? Some young people have been taught that faith and science stand against one another. Christians have held many views about how they relate, and an adult need not claim to hold the answer.
- What about other religions? Young people have friends and neighbours who believe differently, and may ask whether those friends are loved by God. Christians answer in different ways, and the adult does not need to conceal that.
- What does the church teach about sexuality and identity? The question may be asked by a young person who is asking about themselves, or about a friend. Lecture 4-1 gave the posture on teaching, and the young person must be treated with dignity. Do not speak about any present-day group in a way that judges its members, and do not promise what you cannot promise.
For each of these, the same honest pair of sentences is available. "I do not know." And "Let us look together." Neither is a defeat. A young person can tell the difference between an adult who knows and is sure, an adult who does not know and pretends, and an adult who does not know and says so. The third earns trust, because it shows that the faith being offered does not need every answer in advance.
"Let us look together" is also a promise to do something: to read, to ask someone wiser, to come back next week with what was found. It should be kept. Where the question is beyond the adult’s reach, the adult can say, "I think it would help to talk to [a priest, pastor, teacher, or a friend who knows more]," and offer to make the introduction. This is not passing the young person on; it is bringing more people to the table.
6. The psalms of "how long?"
Psalm 13 begins with four repeated questions, "How long?", spoken to God in complaint. It does not begin with praise. The psalm is in Scripture, and it has been prayed for centuries in worship. It also ends in trust, but the trust does not erase the questions, which were asked honestly first. The Bible gives young people a language of honest asking.
An adult who knows this can say to a young person, "You are allowed to say this to God. People have been saying it to God for many centuries." That sentence is not an answer. It is a permission, and it may be what the young person most needs.
7. Thomas
John 20 tells of a disciple who was not there when the others saw the risen Jesus. His friends tell him; he does not simply accept it. He says what he needs: to see and touch. A week later Jesus comes and offers exactly that. Jesus says, "Reach here your finger, and see my hands."
Notice what does not happen. Jesus does not send Thomas away or make him wait outside the circle. He does say, “Don’t be unbelieving, but believing,” and some readers hear a note of challenge there; yet he says it while offering the very thing Thomas asked for. Thomas was still with the group when Jesus came again: his doubt had not driven him out, and the others had not driven him out. Jesus gives Thomas what he asks for, and Thomas’s answer, "My Lord and my God!", is one of the strongest confessions in the Gospel.
There is a final line: "Blessed are those who have not seen, and have believed." Readers take this differently. Some hear in it a gentle caution about Thomas’s condition for belief; others hear a blessing on every later believer, including every young person who has never seen what Thomas saw. For this lecture, notice only that the blessing is spoken to Thomas’s face, after he has been received. The one who doubted is not told he is a failure.
A caution. Thomas’s story does not promise that every doubter will receive a sign, and it should not be used to tell a young person that their doubt will certainly end in a confession. It shows a posture: the risen Lord meets the doubter where he is.
8. Some do leave
It would be dishonest to end a lecture on doubt as if every story ended well. Some young people leave the faith they were raised in. Some leave the community and keep the faith. Some leave both. The reasons are many: a question that no one would hear, a hurt inflicted by a member of the church, a change in friends, a different way of living, a sense that the community did not welcome the whole of them, or simply a changed mind.
The adult’s task here is also stated in Jude 1:22, even in its incomplete form: "On some have compassion." Compassion means keeping a door open, not chasing, not guilt-tripping, not announcing that the person has fallen away to the congregation. It means a card at a birthday, a greeting if you meet in the street, and a plain message, passed on once: "You are welcome here whenever you want, and I will not ask you why." Lecture 6-1 returns to those who leave.
9. The same facts in two kinds of community
In a liturgical community where young people have been baptised in infancy and perhaps later confirmed or chrismated, a young person’s doubt may come after the public steps have been taken. The risk is that the community assumes the matter is settled. The remedy is to make sure there is someone whom the young person can speak to who is not their teacher or priest in an official role. In a free-church community where a personal profession of faith is central, a young person’s doubt may come after a decision made at a younger age, and may feel like betrayal of that decision. The remedy is to say clearly that a person may come back to a question many times, and that this does not cancel what was earlier said in sincerity. Both communities need to tell young people, in so many words, that questions are allowed here.
Diagram 1. What an adult can say in the first minute
핵심 요약
- Questioning the faith of one’s family is often, not always, a way of owning it; some young people do leave, and the adult cannot control which.
- Fowler’s map places stepping back from a received faith in later years; it comes from limited research and never ranks a young person.
- Receive doubt by staying still, thanking, asking a real question and listening; avoid quick reassurance, quick argument and alarm.
- "I do not know" and "let us look together" are honest answers to hard questions, and "let us look together" must be kept.
- Thomas was received with his doubt in the room; Psalm 13 gives a language of honest asking; to those who leave, show compassion and keep a door open.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Doubt and owning faith | Questioning is often, not always, a way of making faith one's own; some young people leave. |
| Three closing answers | Quick reassurance, quick argument, alarm; each teaches the young person not to speak. |
| Two honest sentences | "I do not know." "Let us look together." And keep the promise. |
| What Thomas shows | The doubter was kept in the circle and given what he asked; the risen Lord met him where he was. |
One sentence to remember A question that is welcomed can be walked through; a question that is feared goes underground.
This week's action Practise one sentence aloud: "Thank you for telling me. What is it that you wonder about?" Say it until it sounds like you.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of a question about faith that you once held and did not speak aloud. What would you have needed for it to be safe to say?
- Which of the three closing answers (quick reassurance, quick argument, alarm) is your own habit? What are you protecting when you use it?
- Is there a hard question you dread being asked by a young person? What could you honestly say if it came?
- In your tradition, what stands behind a young person’s faith besides their own decision (baptism, community, sacraments, family)? How does that change what doubt means?
- How does your community treat someone who stops coming? What would a door left open look like in practice?
- Read Psalm 13 aloud. What do you notice about the order of its lines, and what does it permit?