Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
- Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
- Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
- Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
- Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
- Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
- Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
- Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
- Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
- Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
- Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
- Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
- Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
- Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
- Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
- Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
This is the fourth Practice Lab of the course. Like the others, it asks you to do something and not only to agree with something.
The task is small. Put on one page how you would meet a hard question from a sixteen-year-old: how you feel when you hear it, the first sentence you would say, what you would not say, and who else you would involve. You do this before the question comes, because the first sentence is often decided in the first few seconds, and it is much easier to find it in a quiet hour than in the moment.
The question in this lab is an invented one, so that nobody has to reveal a real young person or a real conversation. Here it is.
(An invented example.) Sam, who is sixteen, says quietly after a youth evening: "I don't think I believe any of it anymore. Does that make me a fake for coming here?"
Chapter 4 gave you ideas that meet in this question: a young person is making a self (4-1, 4-2), questions are often a way of owning faith (4-3), and the adult stays steady, honest and within limits (4-4). The lab asks you to hold those ideas against one question that has just been asked, and to find the sentence that comes first.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- Complete the sheet "Before a Hard Question" for your own place, for a scene you observe or remember, or for an invented scene with a partner.
- State the four promises of privacy that govern this lab.
- Say what you feel when you hear a hard question, and say why naming that feeling helps the first sentence.
- Write a first sentence that keeps the door open, and name at least two answers that tend to close it.
- Explain how to run the lab in a small group so that nobody is exposed.
Then he said to Thomas, “Reach here your finger, and see my hands. Reach here your hand, and put it into my side. Don’t be unbelieving, but believing.”" — John 20:27
World English Bible
Keep this verse in front of you while you write. Jesus meets the doubter in the room, and answers the doubt with what is needed. As you fill in the sheet, ask: what would it look like to meet Sam in the room, and not at a distance?
1. Why a sheet, and why before
Most of us do not choose the first sentence we say to a young person who has just said something hard. It comes out of habit, fear, or what our own parents or teachers said to us. In the moment there is no time to consider it. If the sentence is a good one, there is no harm done. If it is a closing one ("Of course you believe!" or "You shouldn't say that"), a door may shut that is not easily opened again.
A sheet filled in beforehand gives you a little time. It lets you notice your own feelings, which are the usual source of the first sentence. It lets you try a sentence on paper, and cross it out. It lets you decide, in advance and quietly, whom you would involve and when. None of this takes the place of listening to the real young person. It gives you somewhere steady to start from.
The goal is not to produce a perfect answer. There is no perfect answer to Sam’s question. The goal is to find a first sentence that says: I heard you, and you are not in trouble.
2. The four promises of privacy
Say these before you begin. If you are leading a group, say them out loud.
- Nobody reads what you write. The sheet is yours.
- Nothing is marked or graded. There is no right answer to write.
- You may pass on any part. Leave a box empty if you wish; that is a complete answer.
- The leader fills in a sheet too. The person at the front is not an examiner.
One more rule goes with these: do not write the name of any real young person, parent or colleague on the sheet, and do not write down any private information about a child. The lab is about your own response. A name or a private detail turns a pattern into a case file, and a case file does not belong in a lab.
3. How to do it
The steps, whichever way you choose
Step 1. Choose your way from the three below. You may change your mind part way through.
Step 2. Copy the sheet in section 4 onto a page by hand, or reproduce its headings on a blank page. Do not skip the headings; they are the exercise.
Step 3. Read Sam’s question once, slowly. Notice, before you write anything, what happens in your body and your thoughts. Then fill in box B.
Step 4. Write your first sentence in box C, in the words you would really use. Then fill in boxes D and E.
Step 5. Read the sheet once to yourself, and underline one word that surprises you.
4. The three ways into this lab
Way 1: In your own place. Use this way if you teach, lead, mentor or parent young people. You may use Sam’s question, or you may think of a kind of question that you dread, without recording who asked or when. Fill in the sheet from your own habits: what you usually say, what you feel, and whom you would tell. If a real conversation comes to mind, keep the young person’s name and details off the page.
Way 2: The observer’s way. Use this way if you do not now work with young people. There are two choices. You may recall, from your own teenage years, a time when you asked an adult a hard question, or wanted to and did not. Fill in the sheet from the young person’s side: what did you hope the adult would say, what did they say, and what did it do? Or, only where the community’s policy and the person responsible allow it, you may watch one ordinary scene of adults and young people together, for example the minutes after a youth evening, as a quiet observer. You are not there to judge any young person or any adult. Note how adults respond to what young people say, and what they say first. Write no names. Then fill in the sheet as if Sam’s question had been asked in what you saw. In box A, tick "a place I observed or remember."
Way 3: The partner’s way. Use this way if you have a trusted partner and no other way suits you. You will act a short scene that is entirely invented, so that no personal story is needed.
The scene (invented). Priya is a volunteer who helps at a youth evening. Sam, who is sixteen, waits until the others have left. Sam says: "I don't think I believe any of it anymore. Does that make me a fake for coming here?"
- The adult (Priya) answers as herself, using the first sentence she would really say. Her task is to keep the door open, listen, and not hurry.
- The young person (Sam) chooses quietly, before the scene starts and without telling Priya, one of three ways to continue: Sam goes silent and looks at the floor; or Sam says "Please don't tell anyone"; or Sam says "Everyone here seems so sure, and I'm not."
- The scene lasts about three minutes. Then talk for five minutes: how did it feel from each chair? What helped? What would have helped more?
- Swap roles. The second time, try a different continuation from the young person.
Afterwards, each partner fills in the sheet for the character they played, as if the character were real.
5. What the sheet asks, box by box
Box B, "What I feel when I hear it." This asks you to name your first reaction. Common ones are alarm, a wish to fix it, a wish to defend the faith, fear for the young person, fear of what the parents or leaders will think, or relief that the young person has been honest. None is wrong. A feeling that is named is much less likely to speak for you.
Box C, "My first sentence." Write it in your own words. A first sentence that tends to help is short and is about the young person, not the question. Examples: "Thank you for telling me." "That sounds like something you have been carrying." "You are not a fake. Can you tell me more?" Notice that none of these answers the question yet. The first sentence keeps the door open. The answer, if there is one, comes later.
Box D, "What I would not say." Write one or two sentences you would want to avoid. Examples: "Of course you believe." "You must be tired." "You need to pray more." "Don't say that." "What would your mother think?" Notice why each tempts you. Most come from wanting the discomfort to stop.
Box E, "Who I would involve, and when." This is the part of the sheet that lecture 4-4 prepared. Sam’s doubt is not a danger and does not by itself need to be reported. But the adult should know whom to ask for help if the question turns out to be bigger than it looks. Write down: whom would you talk to if you wanted advice (a pastor, a priest, a mentor, an experienced leader)? Would you tell the young person's parent, and if so, how would you ask Sam first? What would you do if Sam said something that suggested distress or harm, in which case the postures of lectures 5-2 and 5-4 apply? And what is the one thing you would not promise: secrecy.
Box F, "One thing I will practise." One sentence. For example: "I will say 'thank you for telling me' aloud ten times so that it is my first sentence."
6. What usually goes wrong
Three reactions come up often. None means you have done it wrong.
"My first sentence is a defence of the faith." Many people find this. It usually comes from love. Write it down, and then ask whether Sam, hearing it, would feel heard. Put the defence in box D if it would not.
"I do not know what I would say." That is a complete answer. Write "I do not know" in box C, and in box F write that you will practise one open sentence. The honest silence of an adult is often better than a confident wrong word.
"I am afraid of getting it wrong." There is no single right answer to a young person’s doubt. A first sentence that is imperfect but kind, followed by listening, is better than a perfect speech. And an adult who gets it wrong can apologise, as lecture 4-4 said.
A fourth reaction is less common and matters more. Sometimes the lab brings back a time when you asked a hard question and were hurt by the answer. If that happens, put the pen down. Speak this week to a pastor, priest, mentor or trusted friend. That is not a failure of the exercise. It is the exercise finding something real.
7. What the sheet gives you
When you have finished, look at the sheet as a whole. You will probably see that your feeling and your first sentence are linked: when you named the feeling, the sentence changed. You will probably see that the sentences you would not say are all attempts to make the discomfort stop. And you will see whom you would involve, which may be fewer or more people than you expected. Keep the sentence in box F. It is the one you can act on.
8. Leader’s note, for running this in a group
Running the lab so that nobody is exposed
Say the four promises of privacy first, out loud. Before anyone picks up a pen, say: nobody will read what you write; nothing is marked; you may pass on any part; I am filling in a sheet too. Say it even if you said it last week.
Fill in your own sheet. Sit down and write alongside the group. A leader who watches while others write turns the room into an examination.
Let each person choose their way. In one group there may be a teacher using Way 1, a person recalling their own teenage years using Way 2, and a pair acting the scene of Way 3. All are equal. Do not ask anyone to say which way they chose.
Give ten quiet minutes for writing, then ten minutes in pairs for anyone who chose Way 3. Do not fill the silence with commentary or music.
Ask about feelings, never about contents. Do not ask "What did you write?" Ask: "What was it like to write that?" Or, for those who acted the scene: "What was it like in the chair you sat in?" Then allow anyone to pass. Say: "If you would rather not say anything, just pass," and move on without a pause that makes passing costly.
Do not ask anyone to name a real young person, parent or colleague, and do not let a story about a real child be told. If someone begins, say gently, "You do not need a name or a detail. Tell us the pattern."
Do not answer a hurt with a defence. If someone describes being hurt by an answer they received as a young person, do not defend the adult who gave it and do not move on quickly. Stay with it for a moment. Follow it up privately after the meeting, and if what you hear is beyond you, say so and help the person find someone who can carry it.
Do not turn the lab into a policy meeting or a plan. The sheet is for seeing, not for deciding. If a group notices that it has no written policy on contact with young people, note it on a board and take it to the person responsible, outside the lab.
Diagram 1. The form: Before a Hard Question
Diagram 2. Leader’s checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Said the four promises of privacy out loud before anyone wrote | [ ] |
| Filled in my own sheet alongside the group | [ ] |
| Let each person choose their way and did not ask which | [ ] |
| Gave ten quiet minutes, and ten for pairs | [ ] |
| Asked "What was it like to write that?" and not "What did you write?" | [ ] |
| Offered a real option to pass, and moved on cleanly | [ ] |
| Did not let anyone name a real young person, parent or colleague | [ ] |
| Stayed with anyone who described a hurt, and followed up privately | [ ] |
핵심 요약
- The lab asks you to find, before a hard question comes, how you feel, your first sentence, what you would not say, and whom you would involve.
- There are three equal ways in: your own place, the observer's way, and the partner's way with an invented scene.
- Four promises of privacy: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass on any part, and the leader fills one in too.
- A first sentence that keeps the door open is short, is about the young person, and does not yet answer the question.
- Never write the name or private details of a real young person; in a group ask "What was it like to write that?", never about contents.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way with an invented scene. |
| Four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills one in too. |
| A first sentence that helps | Short, about the young person, keeps the door open, and does not yet answer the question. |
| The one thing never promised | Secrecy. Say who you may need to tell, and ask the young person first where it is safe to do so. |
One sentence to remember Find your first sentence in a quiet hour, so that it is ready when the hard question comes.
This week's action Fill in the sheet on an actual page, keep it where only you will find it, and say the sentence from box C aloud once.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What was it like to write that? Answer with a feeling, not with the contents.
- Which box on the sheet was easiest to fill in, and which was hardest? What might that tell you?
- What is the difference between a first sentence that keeps a door open and one that closes it? Can you say the difference in one line?
- If you chose the observer’s way, what did you notice about the first sentences adults use? If you chose the partner’s way, what was it like in the chair you did not expect?
- If you wish to say what you will practise (box F), do so. If you would rather not, pass.