Lecture 3-1: The Big Picture Across Ages
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Curriculum Is a Promise
- Lecture 1-2: Looking at What You Already Have
- Lecture 1-3: Who Plans With You
- Lecture 1-4: Starting Small: A One-Year Frame
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Survey of What We Have
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Doing, Becoming
- Lecture 2-2: Writing Goals You Can Observe
- Lecture 2-3: Goals and Your Tradition's Teaching
- Lecture 2-4: Goals for People Who Start From Different Places
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Three Goals for One Group
- Lecture 3-1: The Big Picture Across Ages
- Lecture 3-2: The Shape of a Year
- Lecture 3-3: Designing One Unit
- Lecture 3-4: Order, Pace and Return
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Unit on One Page
- Lecture 4-1: Judging a Published Curriculum
- Lecture 4-2: Adapting and Making Your Own
- Lecture 4-3: One Room, Many Ages
- Lecture 4-4: Cost, Time and Language
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Checking One Material
- Lecture 5-1: What to Look For
- Lecture 5-2: Asking Teachers
- Lecture 5-3: Hearing Learners and Parents
- Lecture 5-4: Records and Privacy
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Questions to Look Back on One Unit
A coordinator in a small parish has a problem that she cannot quite name. The children's group works through the life of Moses in autumn. The young people's group, meeting in the next room, also works through the life of Moses in autumn. The adults' study, led by a visiting teacher, begins a long series on Exodus. Nobody planned it. Three teachers chose a good story on their own. Meanwhile, no group has met the prophets for five years, and nobody can say whether that is a gap or a choice.
This lecture is about the first map a curriculum needs: one view of the whole, from the youngest child to the oldest adult. Chapters 1 and 2 gave you a survey of what exists and goals that say what you promise. Now you decide what is met, by whom, and at what stage. This map is usually called a scope chart: scope means how much ground the teaching covers, and the chart shows it for each age group on one page. The ideas behind scope and sequence belong to PT5E, Christian Education. This lecture is the craft: how to draw one, and how to keep it small enough to use.
이 20분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why a congregation needs one picture across all ages, and what goes wrong without it.
- Draw a scope chart with age bands, main content, practices and a reason for each row.
- Explain why the same stories are met again at different stages, and mark each return so that it adds something new.
- Say where a scope chart ends and the study of child development (PT706E) begins.
- Test a scope chart against your promise and your tradition, and name its gaps honestly.
Assemble the people, the men and the women and the little ones, and the foreigners who are within your gates, that they may hear, and that they may learn, and fear Yahweh your God, and observe to do all the words of this law; and that their children, who have not known, may hear, and learn to fear Yahweh your God, as long as you live in the land where you go over the Jordan to possess it.”" — Deuteronomy 31:12-13
World English Bible
One generation will commend your works to another, and will declare your mighty acts." — Psalm 145:4
WEB
Whom will he teach knowledge? To whom will he explain the message? Those who are weaned from the milk, and drawn from the breasts? For it is precept on precept, precept on precept; line on line, line on line; here a little, there a little." — Isaiah 28:9-10
WEB
The first passage gathers everyone, "the men and the women and the little ones", and names the children who "have not known" as the reason to teach. The second sees teaching as a chain from one generation to the next. The third is a question about who can be taught what, followed by a description of slow teaching: "here a little, there a little." Together they describe a community that teaches all ages, in order, by steps.
1. Why one picture is needed
Most congregations teach several groups, and most of those groups are planned alone. This is natural. Each teacher knows the people in front of them, and the person who leads the youth group is not often in the room with the person who leads the adults. But when every group plans alone, three things tend to happen.
Stories repeat without a reason. The same well-loved stories appear in every group in the same season, and others are never touched. A child may meet the same four stories each year and never hear that the Bible has poems, letters or laws.
Gaps hide. If the whole picture is not on one page, no one can see that a part of what the church says it believes has no place in any group. The congregation may promise that its people will know the creed, and yet no group is assigned to teach it.
Moves between groups feel like starting again. A young person who moves from the children's group to the youth group should find that something is built on what came before. If each group begins from nothing, learners are bored or lost.
None of these is a failure of the teachers. They come from the lack of a shared page. A scope chart is that page.
2. What a scope chart is, and what it is not
A scope chart is a table. The rows are stages of life or groups. The columns say what each group meets. It is a plan on paper, not the thing itself, and it is not a syllabus for each lesson. Think of a map of a country: it shows the main roads and where they join. It does not show each step you will take.
A useful chart for a congregation has about five columns:
| Column | The question it answers |
|---|---|
| Group | Who is this row for? (An age band, or a mixed-age group.) |
| Meets | What stories, texts and teachings are met in this stage? |
| Practices | What do they learn to do (pray, sing, serve, read, keep a season)? |
| Builds on | What does this stage assume from before? |
| Why here | Why at this stage and not another? |
The last two columns are the ones that people skip. They are the ones that make the chart a plan, because they force you to give a reason. Without "builds on" you cannot see whether the stages join. Without "why here" the chart is a list of preferences.
3. The same stories, met again
A chart across ages will show that some stories appear more than once: the creation, the exodus, the birth and death of Jesus, the early church. This is not a mistake. Teaching has always worked by return. The Isaiah passage above, with its "line on line, here a little, there a little", is often read as a complaint, and it is also an accurate picture of how people learn slowly.
But a return should add something. A helpful way to mark it is to ask three questions of each repeated story:
- What is new in the way it is told? A young child may hear it as a story to act out. A teenager may meet it as a question to argue with. An adult may read it beside other parts of the Bible.
- What is new in what is asked? Remembering the story, then linking it to other texts, then living it out.
- What is new in the context? The same story told in worship, in a small group, in a service project.
If you cannot answer any of the three, the return is probably only a repeat. A repeat is not forbidden, since children like to hear a loved story many times, but it should be chosen, not accidental. Lecture 3-4 looks at pace and return in more detail.
4. How to draw one
Here is a method that a small team can follow in an evening.
Step 1. List your groups. Use the survey from chapter 1. Write one row for every group that really meets, not the ones you wish you had. If you have only one mixed-age group, you have one row, and lecture 4-3 will help with that. If you have six groups from nursery to elderly adults, six rows.
Step 2. Write your goals above the chart. Take the knowing, doing and becoming goals from chapter 2. If you have fewer than three for a group, write the ones you have.
Step 3. Fill in the "Meets" column for one group first. Start with the group you know best. List the main content for the whole year in no more than five lines. If it takes ten, it is a list of lessons, not a scope.
Step 4. Fill in the "Builds on" column of the next group up. Ask: what must these learners already have met? Go back and adjust the group before.
Step 5. Write "Why here" for each row. One short sentence. "Because children of this age love stories that can be acted out." Or "because this is the age when many ask hard questions." Or "because the community celebrates first communion (or baptism, or confirmation) at this stage and the teaching leads up to it."
Step 6. Look down each column. Does any story or teaching appear in no row? Does any appear in every row, in the same way? Mark both.
5. A note on stages of life
It is natural to ask how a scope chart should respond to how children grow. This course does not teach child development. That belongs to PT706E. What you need here is smaller. Ask the people who know the age group, such as parents, teachers and the leaders of children's and youth work, what the group can usually do and enjoy at each stage, and write what they say in the "Why here" column. Do not write a universal statement about what all children of a given age can do. Children differ, and a chart with a firm claim about every child will be wrong for some. Write "usually" and keep room for exceptions.
6. A sample chart
Here is a sample from an invented parish. Read it as an example of the shape. It is not a model for your content. (an invented example)
The parish has about 250 regular members, a nursery group, two children's groups, one group for young people and one for adults. It follows the church year in worship but not in every class.
| Group | Meets | Practices | Builds on | Why here |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Little ones (3-6) | Creation; a few stories of Jesus with children; the Lord's Prayer in short phrases | Listening, singing, saying "thank you" prayers | Nothing assumed | Short stories, repeated, acted out |
| Children (7-11) | Abraham to Moses; the life of Jesus in Mark; the Lord's Prayer in full; the creed's first lines | Praying aloud, finding a Bible book, keeping a season | Little ones' stories | Children can follow a sequence and enjoy asking "why?" |
| Young people (12-17) | The prophets' calls; the Sermon on the Mount; the whole creed; stories of the early church | Discussing, serving, short Bible reading alone | Children's stories | Many ask hard questions and want to be taken seriously |
| Adults | The Gospels in order, then Acts; the creed line by line; Psalms for prayer | Reading in groups, praying the Psalms, giving | Whatever they have | Adults arrive with very different backgrounds |
Notice what the chart is honest about. The adults row says "whatever they have" in the "Builds on" column, because adults come in from many places and the plan cannot assume a path. And look at what the chart cannot yet say: where are the Epistles? Where is the Old Testament law? The parish can now see those gaps and decide whether they are choices or oversights. Many readers would say that this is the whole value of the chart.
7. What your tradition adds
A scope chart is built for a particular community. A cathedral parish with a catechetical programme may already have fixed stages: preparation for first confession, first communion, confirmation. Those become rows or marks on the chart. An Orthodox church school may follow the liturgical cycle and the lives of saints; those go in "Meets." A free-church assembly with one mixed group may have a single row and a simple chart, with the chart's work done by the years: Year 1 the Gospel of Mark, Year 2 Genesis, and so on. A house church without a building may have almost nothing written, and the chart is a list of what the group intends to read together in three years. Every one of these is a scope chart. The tool does not require a particular shape of church.
What it does require is honesty. Your chart should say what you really teach, not what you hope to teach. If you can only teach from two groups, draw two rows.
8. Testing the chart
When a draft chart exists, test it against three things.
Against your promise. Read the central claim of the course again: a curriculum is a promise to children and adults. Does each row move toward what you promise?
Against your tradition. Is there anything your church holds to be central that is missing from every row? Is there something heavily taught that your tradition would treat as a lesser matter?
Against your teachers. Can the people who will teach each row do it? A chart that needs a trained theologian in every room is a chart for another church.
Then, after you have tested it, write the gaps down. A chart with the heading "Not yet met" is more honest, and more useful, than one that hides them.
Diagram 1. A scope chart on one page
핵심 요약
- A scope chart puts every age group on one page, so that stories are not repeated by accident and gaps are not hidden.
- Five columns make a plan: group, what is met, practices, what it builds on, and why at this stage.
- The same story may be met again if each return adds something new in telling, in what is asked, or in setting.
- Child development belongs to PT706E; here, ask people who know each age and write "usually", not "always".
- Test the chart against your promise, your tradition and your actual teachers, and write the gaps down.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What does a scope chart show? | What each group meets across all ages, on one page, with a reason for each stage. |
| The two columns people skip | "Builds on" and "Why here"; without them the chart is only a list. |
| When is a return acceptable? | When it adds something: a new telling, a new demand, or a new setting. |
| What do you do with a gap? | Write it down as "not yet met" and decide whether it is a choice or an oversight. |
One sentence to remember Draw the whole community on one page, give a reason for every row, and write the gaps down.
This week's action List your teaching groups on a single sheet and write, in one line each, what each will meet this year.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- List every teaching group in your congregation. Does anyone hold a page that shows all of them together? If not, who could?
- Think of one Bible story that is told in more than one of your groups. What is new for each age when it is met again? Is the return chosen, or accidental?
- Which part of your tradition's teaching has no clear home in any group? Is that a choice or an oversight?
- The sample chart left the Epistles and the Old Testament law unmet. If you drew your own chart today, what would be its three biggest gaps?
- Who in your community knows most about what children and young people usually enjoy and can do at each age? How could you hear them before you fill in the "Why here" column?
- What would a scope chart look like for a community with only one mixed-age group, or no building?