Lecture 5-2: Guiding Without Shame
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: More Than Minding Children
- Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Children's Ministry
- Lecture 1-3: Roles, Calling and Limits
- Lecture 1-4: What a Children's Ministry Is For
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Children's Ministry
- Lecture 2-1: Why Safety Comes First
- Lecture 2-2: Safe People
- Lecture 2-3: Safe Places and Safe Routines
- Lecture 2-4: When You Are Worried
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Safety Walk Round One Room
- Lecture 3-1: From Arrival to Going Home
- Lecture 3-2: Rooms, Spaces and Materials
- Lecture 3-3: Few Children, Mixed Ages
- Lecture 3-4: Choosing and Adapting Materials
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Our Hour on One Page
- Lecture 4-1: Telling a Bible Story to Children
- Lecture 4-2: Hard Stories
- Lecture 4-3: Praying, Singing and Worshipping With Children
- Lecture 4-4: Welcome Without Pressure
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Preparing One Story
- Lecture 5-1: Understanding Behaviour
- Lecture 5-2: Guiding Without Shame
- Lecture 5-3: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Is Struggling
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence in a Hard Moment
Lecture 5-1 asked what a child's behaviour is telling us. This lecture asks what the adult does next. Sometimes looking for the need is enough: the child is given a snack and the trouble ends. Often it is not enough. A child still hits, or still will not stop, and the adult must do something. The question is what.
Every community has an answer, and many answers are inherited from the adults' own childhoods. Some of us were struck. Some were shouted at in front of others. Some were sent away alone. Some of us remember a teacher who was firm and kind at once, and we have never forgotten her. The lecture asks us to look at what we carry, and to choose on purpose.
The course takes one line that does not move. A child is guided with respect, never with force and never with shame. That line is stated at the start because it is a fixed rule. The rest of the lecture says what guidance can be: a few clear rules, a choice, a calm place, repair, and a word with the parent. It also states fairly the disagreement about how strict a children's ministry should be.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- State what is never used in guiding a child in this course, and give the reason.
- Describe a small set of clear, kind rules and say how they are taught.
- Use a choice, a calm place and repair in an ordinary difficult moment.
- State fairly two views on strictness and say what this course requires of both.
- Say when and how to speak to a parent, and when to pass the matter to the person responsible.
You fathers, don’t provoke your children to wrath, but nurture them in the discipline and instruction of the Lord." — Ephesians 6:4
World English Bible
Fathers, don’t provoke your children, so that they won’t be discouraged." — Colossians 3:21
WEB
but whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to stumble, it would be better for him that a huge millstone should be hung around his neck, and that he should be sunk in the depths of the sea." — Matthew 18:6
WEB
The first two verses are addressed to fathers, in households of the first century, and speak of the ways in which a parent can wear a child down. The third is the words of Jesus about anyone who causes a "little one" to stumble. The lecture takes from them a plain concern: the people with power over children are answerable for what that power does to the child's spirit.
1. What is never used
Begin with what is ruled out, because a rule that is not stated plainly is usually not kept.
Physical punishment is never used. No hitting, slapping, smacking, shaking, pinching, pulling by the arm in anger, or any act that causes a child pain or fear in order to make the child behave. This is true whatever the custom of the country or the habit of the family. A helper is not a parent. A helper has been trusted with someone else's child for an hour, for a purpose, and has no standing to hurt that child. In many countries the law also forbids it, and the community's written policy will say so; but this course does not make it depend on the law. It is a rule of the work.
Public shaming is never used. No mocking, no name-, no sarcasm, no standing a child in front of the group, no announcing a child's fault to the room, no comparing a child unfavourably with another, no using a child's weak point as a joke. Shame teaches a child that he or she is bad. It does not teach what to do instead.
Isolation that frightens is never used. A child is not shut in a cupboard, in a dark room or in a corridor alone. A child is not locked out of the group or sent out of sight of an adult. A child who is calm and sitting a little apart, with an adult close by and in view, is a different matter. We will come to that.
Threats are not used. "God will punish you." "I'll tell your mother and you'll be beaten." "The police will take you." These are not guidance. They are fear, borrowed from things far larger than the adult.
Withholding food, a drink or the toilet is never used.
Why such a plain list? Because Ephesians 6:4 and Colossians 3:21 say it is possible to wear down a child even when you are right, and Jesus' words in Matthew 18:6 are about a "little one who believes", someone whose trust in God can be damaged by the people who stand for God. A children's worker stands in a place where the child can easily learn, "These are God's people, and they are afraid of me, or ashamed of me, or hurt me." No lesson on the page repairs that.
2. A few clear, kind rules
Good guidance begins before anything goes wrong. It begins with a small number of rules that are said in the first week, said again often and said in the same way by every adult.
(An invented example.) A group of children aged five to eight meets in a borrowed hall. The leader, Mrs Adebayo, keeps three rules and has them on a card with a picture beside each: "We use gentle hands. We use kind words. We listen when someone is speaking." Every week, in the first minute, a child reads one aloud. When a child pushes, a helper says quietly, "Gentle hands, please," and nothing else.
What makes a set of rules good?
- Few. Three or four. Children cannot hold twelve, and neither can adults.
- Positive. "We walk in the hall" is better than "No running", because the child hears what to do.
- Clear. Each rule describes something that can be seen: gentle hands, quiet voices when someone is praying.
- The same for every adult. If one helper allows climbing and another forbids it, the children learn that the rule belongs to the adult and not to the room.
- The same for every child. A leader's own child and a visitor's child follow the same rules.
- Reasonable for the age. A three-year-old cannot be still for ten minutes. A rule that asks it is a rule that will be broken. (How children grow is the work of PT706E.)
- Taught, not announced. The rule is shown, practised and thanked. "I saw you wait for your turn. Thank you."
Notice that thanking is half of the method. A child who is told many times what not to do and rarely noticed for what was done well will conclude that the adult only speaks when displeased. Aim to notice good behaviour at least as often as you correct bad.
3. Give a choice
When a child will not do something, the adult has two options: to force or to offer a choice. Force is ruled out. A choice is often both kinder and more effective.
A choice has a plain shape: two options, both acceptable to you, and the child decides. "Do you want to put the blocks in the box or on the shelf?" "Will you sit here or next to me?" "Do you want to tidy with a friend or by yourself?" The child keeps some control, and the adult gets what the session needs.
A few warnings. Offer a choice only when you can accept either answer. Do not offer "Would you like to stop now?" if the answer must be yes. Do not turn the choice into a threat ("Stop now or you'll be sorry"). And do not offer a choice in a moment of danger: if a child is about to run into the road, the adult acts at once and explains afterwards.
4. A calm place
Sometimes a child is too upset to hear anything. The child is crying hard, or shouting, or has hit someone and is frightened by what has happened. The best help is a way to settle.
A calm place is a part of the room, a cushion in a corner or a chair near the wall, where a child can sit until ready to rejoin the group. It must be:
- In sight of an adult at all times. The place is never out of the room and never behind a closed door.
- Never a punishment. The adult says, "Let's sit here for a moment until your body feels calmer," and not, "Go there and think about what you've done."
- Short. A minute or two for a young child, and it ends when the child is calm and not when a timer says so.
- Accompanied when the child wants it. A frightened child may need the adult nearby, or even a hand held. A child who is pushed away at the moment of greatest need learns that comfort is for the good only.
- Offered, not forced. A child who does not want to go there is not carried there. The adult tries another way, such as going outside together to walk.
If your room is too small, or your community has no corner, "a calm place" can be a short walk with an adult, or a drink of water at the table. The point is the settling, not the furniture.
5. Repair
The last step is the one most often forgotten. When harm has been done, the child needs to put it right. This does not mean a forced apology. A child who says "sorry" through clenched teeth has learnt only to say the word.
Repair can be simple. Help the child who knocked down the tower to rebuild it with the others. Help the child who snatched a toy to give it back, or to ask for a turn in words. Help the child who was unkind to sit beside the one who was hurt, and let the child offer something: a drawing, a cup of water, a turn first. If the child is not ready, the adult says, "We'll try again in a moment," and returns to it.
Repair keeps the relationship between the child and the group whole. Shame breaks it. It also teaches what the child can do, not only what the child should not have done.
Throughout, the adult comes back to warmth. After the difficult moment, say something kind. "Thank you for coming back." "It's good to have you here." A child who is guided and then welcomed learns that the community's love does not depend on a perfect day.
6. When to speak to a parent
Most small incidents are dealt with in the room and need no more. Some should be shared with the parent. These are: an injury, however small; a pattern of the same difficulty; a distressing event, such as a child who was frightened or who frightened others; and anything that has affected the child's wellbeing during the session.
When you speak to a parent:
- Do it quietly, away from other families, and not in front of the child unless the child needs to be present.
- Say what happened and what you did, in plain words (an invented example). "Samuel pushed another child. We sat together for a few minutes and then he gave the toy back."
- Describe; do not label. "He found it hard to wait" is better than "He's aggressive."
- Ask, and listen. "Is there anything we should know that might help us?" The parent knows things you do not.
- Do not blame the parent, and do not ask the parent to punish the child at home on your behalf.
- Agree who will speak to the parent beforehand. Usually the leader, not the youngest helper. Lecture 6-1 says more.
If a parent says something that worries you about the child's safety at home, or if a parent's response to the news frightens you for the child's sake, do not argue and do not promise to keep it secret. Move to lecture 2-4 and tell the person responsible.
7. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree about how strict a children's ministry should be. One view stresses firm rules and clear consequences. It says that children feel safe when the limits are plain and are kept, that a leader who never says "no" leaves the children to carry a burden they are too young to carry, and that consistent consequences are fair, since the child learns that actions have results. It points out, rightly, that vague and permissive rooms can be unsafe, especially for the quietest children, who are the ones that get pushed around. Another view stresses relationship and repair. It says that a child behaves well because of trust in the adult, that consequences invented by an adult often feel like punishment to the child, and that the first work is to know the child well enough to see what is wrong. It points out, rightly, that a rigid approach can become harsh, and that the child who most needs patience is often the child who most often receives consequences.
Many communities, and many good helpers, hold something from both. This course does not choose between them. It requires two things from every community that holds either: respect and safety. The child is always treated with respect, whatever has happened. And the room is always safe, for the child who has misbehaved, for the others and for the adults. Within that, a community may be strict or gentle, and may arrange its consequences as it thinks right, so long as no consequence is physical, no consequence shames a child in front of others and no consequence frightens. Where the community has a written behaviour policy, follow it. If it has none, the leader should write a short one with the helpers, and parents should be told what it says.
8. In different kinds of gathering
In a parish with several rooms and a trained leader, the guidance can be written in a handbook and taught to new helpers at the start. In a small assembly or house church, the guidance may be a conversation among three adults who know the children well, and is no less real for being unwritten. In a liturgical community, where the child may be in a long service among all the people, the same habits apply in a different place: a quiet word, a hand on the shoulder, a book to hold, a door to step out of, with the parent's agreement, for a short walk. In a lively free-church setting, where noise is part of the worship, "gentle hands" and "kind words" still hold. In each case, the form is local; the rule against force and shame is not.
Diagram 1. From a difficult moment to repair: five steps and three nevers
핵심 요약
- Never used: physical punishment, public shaming, isolation that frightens, threats, and withholding food or the toilet.
- A few clear, kind, positive rules, the same for every adult and every child, taught and thanked.
- Offer a choice of two acceptable options; use a calm place within sight of an adult; help the child repair.
- Speak to a parent quietly, describing and not labelling; pass worrying signs to the person responsible.
- Communities differ on strictness; this course requires respect and safety, and following the written policy.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Never used | Physical punishment, public shaming, isolation that frightens, threats, withholding food or the toilet. |
| Good rules are... | Few, positive, clear, the same for every adult and child, taught and thanked. |
| The steps after trouble | A choice, a calm place within sight, repair, then warmth. |
| What the course requires on strictness | Respect and safety, whether the community is firm or gentle. |
One sentence to remember Guide the child in a way that leaves the child still welcome.
This week's action Write your group's rules on one card, with no more than four, each stated as what to do. Ask the other helpers whether they use them in the same way.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What did the adults around you do when you were a child and had done wrong? What do you carry from it, helpful or harmful?
- Which rules does your group keep? Are there more than four? Can every child say them? How are they taught?
- Think of a recent difficult moment. Where could a choice have been offered? What two options would both have been acceptable?
- Does your room have a calm place that is always within sight of an adult? If not, what could serve?
- Which of the two views on strictness is nearer to your own habit? What would you want to learn from the other?
- When you tell a parent about an incident, how do you decide what to say, where and who says it?