Lecture 2-2: What the Crusades Cost
Contents 21
- Lecture 1-1: How East and West Became Strangers
- Lecture 1-2: Iconoclasm — Images, Empire and the Incarnation
- Lecture 1-3: One Word in the Creed — the Filioque
- Lecture 1-4: 1054, and What Made It Permanent
- Lecture 2-1: From Just War to Holy War
- Lecture 2-2: What the Crusades Cost
- Lecture 2-3: Poverty as Protest
- Lecture 2-4: Francis and Dominic
- Lecture 3-1: Faith Seeking Understanding
- Lecture 3-2: The Aristotle Shock
- Lecture 3-3: Aquinas and the Summa
- Lecture 3-4: The University
- Lecture 4-1: Avignon, and Then Two Popes
- Lecture 4-2: The Church That Nearly Got a Constitution
- Lecture 4-3: The Black Death
- Lecture 4-4: Going Around the Institution
The First Crusade succeeded. That is the first thing to say, and the hardest to hold alongside everything else, because it is the reason the movement continued for two hundred years. Against every reasonable expectation, an army that had walked from France took Jerusalem in July 1099.
Then it killed most of the people it found there.
This lecture follows the crusades from 1096 to 1204 and counts the cost. It is a lecture about consequences rather than causes, and it has to be honest about four different sets of victims: the Jewish communities of the Rhineland, who were the first to die and who were not even the stated enemy; the Muslim and Jewish inhabitants of Jerusalem; the Eastern Christians whose city was sacked by a Western army in 1204; and the Western church itself, which did lasting damage to its own understanding of what the gospel authorises.
A word on how to read this. A church history course is not a tribunal, and the point of the lecture is not to feel superior to the twelfth century. But neither is it to explain the killing away. These were Christians, acting on the teaching of their church, with the blessing of their pope. The account has to be able to say that plainly.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Describe the massacres of Rhineland Jews in 1096 and explain their relationship to crusading theology.
- Explain the theological significance contemporaries attached to the taking of Jerusalem in 1099, and what the massacre there did to that claim.
- Trace how later expeditions drifted from the stated aim, using the Second, Third and Fourth Crusades.
- Assess the long consequences of holy war — for Christian–Muslim relations, for European Jews, for the Eastern church, and for Christian mission today.
Then Jesus said to him, 'Put your sword back into its place, for all those who take the sword will die by the sword.'" — Matthew 26:52
World English Bible
Spoken while an armed disciple was defending Jesus from arrest — that is, in the single most defensible case of religious violence in the New Testament.
1. 1096: the first killings were in Europe
The expedition Urban called was not the first thing to leave. Before the organised armies moved, a large, poorly led popular movement set out under preachers including Peter the Hermit, and part of it went east through the Rhineland.
In the spring of 1096, bands led by Count Emicho of Flonheim attacked the Jewish communities of Speyer, Worms, Mainz and Cologne. Thousands were killed. Many Jews died in what Hebrew chronicles record as acts of kiddush ha-Shem — killing their own families and themselves rather than accept forced baptism.
The logic, as the chroniclers report it, was simple and terrible: why travel two thousand miles to fight the enemies of Christ when the people who killed Christ live in the next street?
Three things must be said about this, and all three matter.
First, this was not the crusade's official purpose. Church teaching held that Jews were to be protected, not killed, and some bishops tried to protect them — the bishop of Speyer sheltered his city's Jewish community and had attackers punished. Others took bribes for protection they did not provide, or found the mob beyond their control.
Second, it followed from the theology anyway. Once you have taught that killing the enemies of Christ earns the killer , you have created a category, and you do not control who gets put into it. The distinction between "the enemy in Jerusalem, whom you may kill for merit" and "the enemy in Mainz, whom you may not" is not one an armed and enthusiastic crowd is likely to sustain.
Third, it did not end in 1096. The Rhineland massacres mark the beginning of a pattern of anti-Jewish violence recurring with each subsequent crusade and continuing, in Europe, for eight centuries.
2. 1099: the city taken, and what happened in it
The main armies took Antioch in 1098 after a brutal siege and reached Jerusalem in June 1099. The city fell on 15 July.
What followed was a general massacre of the city's Muslim and Jewish inhabitants. Numbers are disputed and the Latin chroniclers' figures are unreliable — one of them, Raymond of Aguilers, describes riding through blood to the knees, which is physically impossible and tells us something about what he wanted the scene to mean. Muslim and Jewish sources describe slaughter over days, and the killing of those who had taken refuge in the al-Aqsa mosque and in a synagogue.
Focus on Raymond's image rather than his arithmetic. He is not confessing. He is exulting. He reaches for the blood-to-the-bridles imagery of Revelation because he wants his reader to understand this as the winepress of God's wrath — a scene from the Apocalypse, a divine judgement in which he had been permitted to take part.
That is what makes 1099 a theological event and not only a military one. The taking of Jerusalem was received in the West as proof. God had granted an impossible victory; therefore God had authorised the enterprise; therefore the theology of 2-1 was vindicated. Success functioned as revelation.
Ask yourself what argument could have persuaded such a movement that it was wrong. Failure could be read as sin needing purification; success could be read as divine endorsement. A theology that can absorb both outcomes as confirmation has stopped being answerable to evidence.
3. The drift: 1147, 1189, 1204
Nothing afterwards worked, and each failure taught the movement something worse.
The Second Crusade (1147–1149). Preached by Bernard of Clairvaux, the most respected churchman in Europe, and led by a king of France and a German emperor. It achieved nothing and ended in a botched siege of Damascus — a city that had been an ally against a common enemy until the crusaders attacked it. Bernard, in the aftermath, wrote in genuine anguish trying to explain how an enterprise God had commanded could fail. His answer was the sins of the crusaders. Note the structure: the theology is not what gets questioned.
The Third Crusade (1189–1192). A response to Saladin's recapture of Jerusalem in 1187 after the battle of Hattin. Richard I of England won battles and did not take Jerusalem; a truce gave Christian pilgrims access to the city.
The comparison contemporaries themselves drew is worth making. When Saladin took Jerusalem in 1187, there was no general massacre. Inhabitants were ransomed, many were freed, the Eastern Christian population remained. That was a political and religious choice, and it was noticed. Western writers had to account for a Muslim commander behaving with more restraint than their own grandfathers had shown in the same city. Some did so by inventing a Christian ancestry for him.
Richard's own record includes the killing of some 2,700 prisoners at Acre in 1191 after negotiations over their ransom broke down.
The Fourth Crusade (1202–1204). Lecture 1-4 covered it in detail. An expedition aimed at Egypt, diverted by debt and dynastic politics, that sacked Constantinople instead — the largest Christian city in the world. It never reached a Muslim opponent at all.
Read the three together and the trajectory is plain. An idea licensed for one enemy did not stay pointed at that enemy. were subsequently preached against Cathars in southern France (lecture 2-3), against pagan Balts, and against Christian political opponents of the papacy. The category, once created, was available.
4. What it cost, and what is still owed
For Muslims. The crusades were, in the scale of medieval Islamic history, a regional disturbance on the frontier; the great trauma of the period was the Mongol destruction of Baghdad in 1258, not the Franks. But the memory was revived and made central in the modern period, and it now functions as a defining story of Western Christian aggression. That is a real fact about the present whatever its medieval proportions, and it is not helped by the continued use of "crusade" as a word of approval in English political and religious speech.
For Jews. Here the damage is not disputable and not marginal. The First Crusade inaugurated mass anti-Jewish violence in Christian Europe.
For Eastern Christians. 1204, and the failure of every reunion afterwards.
For the Western church. It had made an argument that violence in God's name can sanctify the violent. That argument, once made, was available for reuse — against heretics, against dissenters, and later in the wars of religion.
For mission. This is the practical legacy. Christian mission in Muslim-majority contexts today works against a memory in which the last time these two faiths met at scale, one arrived with an army and a papal blessing. The word "crusade" has been quietly dropped from the vocabulary of most evangelistic organisations that once used it, and the reason is this history.
How to read this history
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some historians argue that reading the crusades primarily through modern Christian–Muslim relations distorts them, since medieval Muslims did not experience them as the defining catastrophe later polemic makes them. Others answer that a church assessing its own past is not doing history alone — it is asking what it did and what it owes, and that question is not settled by proportionality. This course thinks both are saying something true.
5. What repentance looked like, and when
It is worth knowing that the church did eventually say so.
In 2000, John Paul II led a public request for forgiveness for sins committed by Christians against other groups, including Jews and members of other faiths, describing it as a purification of memory. In 2001, in Athens, he expressed sorrow for the sack of Constantinople in 1204.
Nine hundred years is a long time. It is still worth marking that it happened, because chapter 2's principle turns on exactly this point: of the two movements this chapter covers, one eventually repented and the other did the repenting all along.
6. What actually happened here
The crusades were not a lapse in the medieval church's thinking. They were an application of it — a conclusion validly drawn from the premise that lecture 2-1 identified, that fighting a designated enemy is itself meritorious.
And the enterprise was self-confirming. Victory proved God's favour; defeat proved the crusaders' sin; neither could put the premise in question. It took two centuries of failure and a sacked Christian capital before the movement lost its hold, and even then it was exhaustion rather than repentance that ended it.
Zeal aimed outward and zeal aimed inward come from the same energy. The next lecture turns to people in the same generation who heard the same call to seriousness and answered it by giving away everything they owned — and who were, some of them, burned by the same church that blessed the armies.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Who bore the cost | What it was | What it left |
|---|---|---|
| Rhineland Jews, 1096 | Massacres by crusading bands before the armies left Europe | The beginning of mass anti-Jewish violence in Christian Europe |
| Jerusalem, 1099 | General massacre of Muslim and Jewish inhabitants | Read in the West as divine vindication of the enterprise |
| Eastern Christians, 1204 | Constantinople sacked by a Western crusade | A schism that no reunion could reach |
| Muslim memory | A frontier disturbance at the time; central in modern memory | "Crusade" as the defining word for Western Christian aggression |
| The Western church | The argument that violence in God's name sanctifies the violent | A category reusable against heretics and dissenters |
5. Going to the Sources
Read at least one from each side. The point of this list is that both sides left records, and the difference between them is instructive.
- Solomon bar Simson, Chronicle — a Hebrew account of the Rhineland massacres of 1096. Read it before anything written by a crusader.
- Ibn al-Qalanisi, The Damascus Chronicle of the Crusades — a Muslim contemporary, sober and administrative in tone.
- Usama ibn Munqidh, The Book of Contemplation — a Syrian nobleman's memoirs, including his puzzled and often funny observations of Frankish behaviour. The most humane book on this reading list.
- Raymond of Aguilers, on the capture of Jerusalem — the blood-to-the-knees passage, in context. Read what he thought he was describing.
In short
- The First Crusade succeeded and took Jerusalem in July 1099. The first killings came earlier, in 1096, when crusading bands under Count Emicho attacked Jewish communities in Speyer, Worms, Mainz and Cologne.
- Church teaching protected Jews, and some bishops tried to shelter them. Yet the theology of merit for killing enemies of Christ created a category the crowd could not be trusted to limit.
- The massacre at Jerusalem was received in the West as proof of God's favour. Success counted as vindication and failure as the crusaders' sin, so the premise was never questioned.
- The Second Crusade failed, the Third did not take Jerusalem, and the Fourth sacked Constantinople without reaching a Muslim opponent. Saladin's restraint in 1187 was noticed by Western writers.
- The costs fell on Jews, Muslims, Eastern Christians, the Western church itself and Christian mission today. Historians disagree on how Muslims experienced the crusades at the time.
- John Paul II asked forgiveness in 2000 and expressed sorrow for the sack of Constantinople in Athens in 2001. The lecture calls this worth marking, though very late.
Topic: This lecture counts the human and theological cost of the crusades from 1096 to 1204 and asks what the church owes in memory.
Remember: The crusades were an application of the church's thinking, not a lapse from it. A theology that reads both success and failure as confirmation stops being answerable to evidence.
Caution: The lecture does not treat the course as a tribunal or ask readers to feel superior. It also says historians disagree about reading the crusades through modern Christian-Muslim relations.
One line to carry into ministry: Beware any movement where both victory and defeat prove it right, and keep words and teaching honest about their past.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- The lecture argues the crusading movement was unfalsifiable: success proved God's favour and failure proved the crusaders' sin. Describe how you would recognise that pattern in a movement you belonged to.
- Church teaching protected Jews, and crusaders killed them anyway. What does that gap say about the relationship between a church's official doctrine and what its teaching actually produces in ordinary people?
- Contemporaries noticed that Saladin in 1187 behaved better than the crusaders in 1099. What should a Christian do with that fact — then, and now?
- Most evangelistic organisations have quietly stopped using the word "crusade". Was that right? What is gained and what is lost when a church retires a word?