FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH102E Medieval Church History

Lecture 2-3: Poverty as Protest

Jump to the key points ↓

20 min

Around 1173 a rich merchant of Lyons heard a travelling singer perform the legend of Saint Alexis, a nobleman who gave up his wealth. The merchant went home, provided for his wife and daughters, gave away everything else, and began to preach in the street.

Within twenty years his followers were excommunicated. Within a hundred and fifty years the church was burning them.

Thirty-odd years after Waldo, a young man in Assisi did something remarkably similar and was made a saint.

The difference between those two outcomes is the subject of this lecture, and it is not what you would expect. It was not, in the main, a difference of doctrine. Both men wanted to live as the apostles lived. Both preached repentance. The difference was obedience — whether the movement would accept the church's authority over where and whether it might preach.

This lecture covers the wealth of the twelfth-century church, the ideal of the vita apostolica that rose against it, and the two movements it produced: the Waldensians, who were orthodox and were condemned, and the Cathars, who genuinely were not Christians in any recognisable sense and against whom a crusade was preached.

What these 20 minutes give you

  • Describe the wealth and the structural corruption of the institutional church in the eleventh and twelfth centuries, including simony.
  • Explain the *vita apostolica* as the essential motive of the poverty movement.
  • Distinguish the Waldensians' apostolic poverty from Cathar dualism, and explain why each was condemned.
  • Assess the church's response to the poverty movement, and what it reveals about the church's own criteria.

Jesus said to him, 'If you want to be perfect, go, sell what you have, and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven; and come, follow me.'" — Matthew 19:21

World English Bible

Almost every figure in this lecture, on every side, could quote this verse. What divided them was whether it was addressed to everyone, to a specialised class of Christians, or to no one in particular any more.

1. A church that had become rich by accident

Nobody planned it. The medieval church's wealth accumulated for a reason that is almost sympathetic: people left it property when they died, because prayers for the dead were the most valuable thing anyone could arrange, and land was how you paid for them. Do that for five hundred years across a continent and the result is an institution holding perhaps a quarter to a third of the cultivated land in some regions.

Wealth on that scale changes what a church office is. A bishopric was now a substantial estate with revenues, and estates attract people who want revenues.

Simony — named for Simon Magus in Acts 8, who tried to buy the power of the Spirit — is the buying and selling of church office. By the eleventh century it was normal. So was lay investiture, in which a king or count appointed bishops and abbots in his territory, treating a see as a piece of property in his gift. So were clerical marriage and clerical dynasties, in which church property descended to a priest's sons.

The reform movement of the eleventh century, which lecture 1-4 met in its Roman form, attacked all three. It won a great deal. But the reform had a limit built into it, and the limit is the subject of this lecture. The reformers wanted a church free from lay control and morally serious. They did not want a poor church. Freedom from a king's control was, in practice, secured by having independent wealth and an independent jurisdiction.

So the reform produced a church that was cleaner, more centralised, more legally competent, better financed — and, to a certain kind of reader of the Gospels, more obviously unlike the church in Acts than it had been before.

2. The vita apostolica: an idea with a hook in it

Out of that gap came the most powerful religious idea of the twelfth century: the vita apostolica, the apostolic life.

The claim was simple. The church of Acts held everything in common and had no property (Acts 2:44–45; 4:32–35). The apostles were sent out with no purse, no bag, no second tunic (Matthew 10:9–10; Luke 9:3). That was not a temporary arrangement for the first generation. It was what the church is supposed to look like.

Two features made this idea explosive in a way that earlier reform movements had not been.

First, it was a lay movement. had long offered a version of apostolic life, but inside a cloister, under a rule, under a bishop. The new movement's participants were merchants, weavers, ordinary townspeople in the fast-growing cities. They did not withdraw. They stayed in the street.

Second, it came with a critique attached. If the apostolic life is the standard, then an institution holding a third of the land is not merely imperfect. It is on the wrong side of the standard — and the laypeople saying so could read the Gospels, or hear them read, in their own language.

Notice what this does to authority. If the argument is decided by "which of us looks more like Acts 4?", the wandering preacher with nothing wins it against the bishop every time.

3. The Waldensians: condemned for preaching, not for heresy

Peter Waldo of Lyons — the sources also call him Valdes — gave away his property around 1173, commissioned translations of parts of Scripture into the vernacular, and began to preach. His followers were called the Poor of Lyons.

Watch the sequence carefully, because it is the point of the lecture.

Step one. Waldo and his followers went to Rome, to the Third Lateran Council in 1179, and asked for approval. The pope approved their vow of poverty — and forbade them to preach without the permission of the local clergy.

Step two. They preached anyway. Their reasoning was straightforward: we are telling people the gospel, we are saying nothing false, and Acts 5:29 says we must obey God rather than men.

Step three. In 1184, at Verona, they were excommunicated — not for doctrinal error, but for unauthorised preaching and contempt of the church's authority.

Step four. Excommunication drove them outside the church's structures, where over decades they did develop distinctive doctrines: rejection of , of oaths, of the sacraments of unworthy priests. The condemnation created much of the heresy it named. That is a pattern worth remembering; you will see it again with Wycliffe and Hus in chapter 5.

The Waldensians were hunted for centuries and survived in Alpine valleys, and in the sixteenth century they joined the Reformation. There are Waldensian congregations in Italy today. They are the one medieval dissenting movement that never died.

The uncomfortable question is this. Waldo asked permission, was refused the one thing he most wanted to do, and disobeyed. Francis of Assisi, thirty years later, asked permission and got it. Some of the difference lies in the men, some in the popes, and some in the fact that by 1209 the church had learned from the Waldensian experience what refusal cost. But the criterion the church actually applied in both cases was obedience, not orthodoxy.

4. The Cathars: a different religion

The Cathars are usually mentioned in the same breath as the Waldensians, and they should not be. The Waldensians were orthodox Christians disobeying a church; the Cathars, as far as we can reconstruct them, held a religion that was not Christianity in any recognisable sense.

The Cathar system, as described in the sources, was dualist — with resemblances to the Bogomils of the Balkans and, at a distance, to ancient Manichaeism. Two principles: a good God who made spirit, and an evil principle who made matter. The material world is a prison. Human souls are spirits trapped in flesh.

The consequences run through everything. If matter is evil, the is impossible — God would not enter a prison — so Christ only appeared to have a body. There is no resurrection of the body, because a body is what you are being saved from. The sacraments, which use bread, wine, water and oil, are worthless. Procreation is a further imprisoning of a soul in flesh, and therefore a wrong.

Their structure had two levels: the perfecti, an elite who received a spiritual baptism called the consolamentum and thereafter lived in strict asceticism; and the ordinary credentes, believers who lived normally and received the consolamentum near death.

And here is why this became so dangerous to the church. The perfecti were visibly, undeniably holy. They were poor, chaste, honest, hardworking, and they lived among the people. Sent to argue against them, papal legates arrived with horses, servants and fine clothing. The argument was lost before anyone opened their mouth — a fact that Dominic noticed, and that lecture 2-4 turns on.

Historians question Catharism

This is a point where readers will not agree, and the disagreement is recent and serious. R. I. Moore and Mark Gregory Pegg, among others, now argue that "Catharism" as an organised counter-church with a settled dualist theology is substantially a construct of the inquisitors — that what existed in Languedoc was more diffuse, more local and less doctrinally coherent than the picture drawn from inquisition records, which were produced by interrogators asking leading questions of frightened people. Other historians hold that the dualist theology is well enough attested to stand. This course states the traditional account because you will meet it everywhere, and flags that it is under challenge.

5. What the church did about it

In 1209 Innocent III preached a crusade against the Cathars of southern France — the Albigensian Crusade. The theology of lecture 2-1 was now being applied to Christians in Europe. It ran for twenty years, destroyed the distinctive culture of Languedoc, and killed an unknown number of people, most of whom were Catholic.

The most notorious moment is the sack of Béziers in 1209, where the population of the town, Catholic and Cathar together, was massacred. The line attributed to the papal legate — kill them all, God will know his own — is reported by a chronicler writing later, and may well be invention. It has survived because it captures something people recognised as true about the campaign.

Out of this came the Inquisition, established in the 1230s as a permanent procedure for identifying and prosecuting heresy.

But the church did something else at the same time, and it is the more interesting response. It approved the impulse in a different container. In 1215 the Fourth Lateran Council reformed preaching and across the church. And the papacy authorised two new orders whose members would be poor, mobile, urban, and licensed to preach — which is to say, everything the Waldensians had asked to be, with the one thing the Waldensians had refused: permission.

6. What actually happened here

The twelfth century produced two responses to the same recognition — that the institutional church did not look like the church in Acts.

One response was to conclude that the church was therefore not the church, and to leave. The other was to live the apostolic life inside the church's obedience. The church destroyed the first and canonised the second, and for a long time the destroying and the canonising were done by the same men in the same years.

Notice, finally, what this chapter's two halves have in common. The crusaders and the poverty movement were seized by the same conviction — that ordinary Christian life was insufficiently serious, and something total was demanded. Zeal aimed outward and zeal aimed inward come from the same energy. In the same decades, in the same country, the church was preaching a crusade against dissenting Christians and approving Francis of Assisi.

The next lecture is about what happens when that energy is given a rule.


Two Roads Out of the Same Complaint "This does not look like the church in Acts" — and what people did about it The vita apostolica — live as Acts 2 and 4 lived, with nothing of your own A lay movement, in the streets of the new cities, with a critique attached WALDENSIANS — orthodox CATHARS — a different religion What they held Apostolic poverty, Scripture in the vernacular, preaching to all What they held Matter is evil — so no incarnation, no bodily resurrection, no sacraments Why they were condemned Not doctrine — preaching without permission. Verona, 1184. Why they were destroyed A crusade preached against Christians in Europe. Albigensian, 1209–1229. What became of them Survived; joined the Reformation What became of them Extinguished; the Inquisition remained The third road: approve the impulse, licensed — the Franciscans and Dominicans, 1209–1216 The criterion the church actually applied was obedience, not orthodoxy.

Diagram 1. Summary table

Waldensians Cathars
Origin Peter Waldo of Lyons, c. 1173 Dualist currents in Languedoc and Lombardy, with Balkan links
Core conviction Live as the apostles lived; Scripture for everyone Spirit is good, matter is evil; the world is a prison
Christology Orthodox Christ only appeared to have a body
Sacraments Accepted, though later doubted for unworthy priests Rejected as material
The charge against them Preaching without authorisation Heresy proper — a rival religion
Church response Excommunication (Verona, 1184), then persecution The Albigensian Crusade, then the Inquisition
Outcome Survived; joined the Reformation in the 1500s Extinguished by the fourteenth century

5. Going to the Sources

  • Acts 2:42–47 and 4:32–37 — the text everyone in this lecture was arguing about. Read it first, and ask what you think it requires.
  • The Waldensian profession of faith (1180), which Waldo signed at Lyons — read it and try to find the heresy.
  • Bernard Gui, The Conduct of the Inquiry into Heretical Depravity — an inquisitor's practical handbook. This is where much of our knowledge of Catharism comes from, which is exactly the problem.
  • Innocent III's letters proclaiming the Albigensian Crusade — the theology of lecture 2-1, turned on Christians in Europe.

In short

  • The medieval church grew rich largely through gifts of land for prayers for the dead. Simony, lay investiture and clerical dynasties followed, and the eleventh-century reform wanted a free church, not a poor one.
  • The vita apostolica, the apostolic life, held that Acts and the sending of the apostles show what the church should look like. It was a lay movement with a critique built in.
  • Peter Waldo was allowed his vow of poverty in 1179 but forbidden to preach. He preached anyway and was excommunicated at Verona in 1184. Distinct doctrines followed after condemnation.
  • The Cathars were dualists: spirit is good and matter evil, so the incarnation and the sacraments were denied. Their perfecti were visibly holy, while papal legates arrived with horses and fine clothing.
  • R. I. Moore and Mark Gregory Pegg argue Catharism was largely a construct of inquisitors. Other historians hold the dualist theology is well attested. The course flags the challenge.
  • The church preached the Albigensian Crusade in 1209 and began the Inquisition. It also approved poor preaching orders inside obedience, so its real test was obedience, not orthodoxy.

Topic: This lecture compares the Waldensians and the Cathars and shows how the church answered a lay demand for apostolic poverty.

Remember: The church applied the criterion of obedience, not orthodoxy. It destroyed the movement that left its authority and canonised the one that stayed inside it.

Caution: The Waldensians were orthodox and the Cathars held a different religion, so they should not be merged. The lecture notes that the traditional picture of the Cathars is under challenge.

One line to carry into ministry: Condemnation can create the dissent it names. Before expelling a critic, ask what would keep that zeal inside the church.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Waldo was forbidden to preach and preached anyway; Acts 5:29 was his defence. When is that verse a faithful appeal and when is it a licence for anyone to ignore any authority? How would you tell the difference from inside?
  • The lecture argues that condemnation created much of the heresy it named. Trace the mechanism. Where might that be happening now?
  • The papal legates lost the argument in Languedoc before they opened their mouths. What is your church's equivalent of arriving on a fine horse?
  • The church destroyed one apostolic-poverty movement and canonised another within a generation. If you had to defend that as a coherent policy, how would you do it — and does the defence convince you?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.