FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH102E Medieval Church History › Review by summary

Review by summary

All 21 lectures of CH102E, as nothing but their summaries. For the night before an exam.

Chapter 0 Introduction: What Medieval Church History Is, and Why We Study It

  • The course covers the Western church from 1054 to the eve of the Reformation. It is a bridge between early church history (CH101) and the Reformation (CH201).
  • The same institution produced both the intellectual summit and the collapse, within about 150 years. Its strengths, such as legal reach and confidence, made its failure total.
  • The course says openly that it is taught in a Protestant school. It tries to state each position as its own adherents would, and it marks contested judgements.
  • It is a history of institutions and ideas. It leaves out most ordinary religious life, treats women mostly as excluded, and follows the Western church only after 1204.
  • The five chapters run: the division of East and West, crusades and mendicant orders, scholastic theology, decline and collapse, then the dawn of the Reformation.
  • Students should read in order, read the primary sources, take each chapter quiz, and answer the reflection questions, including arguing positions they dislike.

Topic: This lecture explains what the course covers, what it leaves out, and why the summit and the collapse of the medieval church belong together.

Remember: The same strengths that made the medieval church powerful made its failure total. The summit and the collapse came from one institution, almost in the same breath.

Caution: The course does not claim to have no position, and it leaves out most ordinary medieval devotion. It is not a full picture of medieval Christian life.

One line to carry into ministry: Ask what your church is very good at, and what that same strength would look like if it went wrong.

Chapter 1 Chapter 1: The Division of East and West (1054)

  • East and West drifted apart in language until bishops could not read each other. Greek and Latin words such as ousia and hypostasis were heard differently, so disagreement began to look like heresy.
  • The East held the pentarchy, five sees governing together by council. The West held Petrine primacy, one see with the final word. Each side had a serious argument.
  • Chalcedon's canon 28 gave Constantinople equal privileges with Rome. Rome objected, and the question was not resolved, only filed.
  • Disputes about bread, beards and married priests mattered because, without a shared theological language, practice became the visible sign of belonging.
  • The East saw the church as a community of theosis, deification by grace. The West saw a community of grace and order. The lecture says these are not contradictory.
  • What made the division permanent was that each side stopped reading the other in its strongest form. Identity then did the work that theology had done.

Topic: This lecture explains how language, authority, practice and two views of the church slowly made East and West strangers long before 1054.

Remember: The break was not one heresy but four layers of drift: language, who decides, practice, and what the church is for. Each side stopped hearing the other's strongest case.

Caution: The lecture does not say either side was heretical. Some Protestant theologians hear theosis as blurring Creator and creature, and Orthodox theologians reply that grace crosses that line without erasing it.

One line to carry into ministry: Before judging another tradition, state its case in a form its own members would recognise.

  • Iconoclasm tore the Byzantine Empire for about 120 years. Under Leo III, from around 726, imperial policy turned against images, after military defeat and the question of why God was angry.
  • The sources for the early period come mostly from the winners. Brubaker and Haldon argue the early measures were smaller than the traditional story, so the dates are held loosely.
  • The iconoclast argument at Hieria in 754 was that painting Christ divides his natures or tries to paint the divine. John of Damascus answered that an icon depicts a person, who truly took a body.
  • John of Damascus separated latreia, worship owed to God alone, from proskynesis, honour or reverence. The honour paid to an image passes to the one it represents.
  • Nicaea II in 787 restored icons, and 843 ended the controversy. A Latin translation turned both Greek words into adoratio, so the Frankish Libri Carolini rejected a council it had not read.
  • The result was agreement on doctrine but lasting damage: Rome lost jurisdictions and turned to the Franks, and a mistranslation shaped Frankish views of the East.

Topic: This lecture treats the icon controversy as a dispute about the incarnation and imperial power, and shows how it left East and West further apart.

Remember: The question was whether Christ, who took a visible body, may be painted. Both sides defended Chalcedon, and East and West both venerate images without worshipping them.

Caution: The lecture says the traditional account of Leo III's early measures is not secure. Historians disagree on how far politics or theology drove the policy.

One line to carry into ministry: When a dispute turns on two words, check first that both sides mean the same thing by them.

  • The Filioque means "and from the Son". It first became normal in Spain around 589, as a defence against Arianism, which taught that the Son is a creature. It was not aimed at the East.
  • The Frankish court at Aachen used it to show the Greeks were deficient. Pope Leo III agreed with the doctrine but refused to change the creed and had the original wording set on silver shields.
  • The East stresses the monarchy of the Father as the single source. Photius argued that adding the Son gives two sources or blurs the Persons.
  • The West starts from the unity of the divine essence, and the Persons are their relations. Augustine's picture of the Spirit as the bond of love lies behind it.
  • Greek ekporeuesthai and Latin procedere differ in sense. The Vatican in 1995 stated that the Spirit proceeds from the Father alone in the strict sense, so some disagreement may be smaller than it looks.
  • The decisive issue was procedure: Ephesus in 431 forbade a new creed, and the East saw a unilateral change as a claim of jurisdiction. The real question became who decides.

Topic: This lecture traces how one word added to the creed grew from a local defence of the Son's divinity into a dispute about who may change a creed.

Remember: The Filioque divided the churches less over whether it is true than over who has the authority to put it in the creed. Rome held back for two centuries before accepting it.

Caution: The lecture does not close the theological question. Orthodox theologians disagree about whether the 1995 clarification is enough, and the link to the West's view of the church is left for the reader to judge.

One line to carry into ministry: Before changing words a whole community says together, ask who has the authority to change them, and consult them.

  • The excommunications of 16 July 1054 were issued by legates, after Pope Leo IX had died, against Cerularius and his associates only. Their charges were partly false, including one about the Filioque.
  • The setting was southern Italy, where Normans imposed Latin practice on Greek churches and Cerularius closed Latin churches in reply. A reforming papacy, with Humbert as its sharpest voice, was ready for conflict.
  • For the Eastern church, the deeper wound is 1204, when the Fourth Crusade sacked Constantinople. Innocent III condemned it, but afterwards reunion became a problem of memory.
  • Reunions at Lyons in 1274 and Florence in 1439 were agreed by rulers under military pressure and rejected by the church. Mark of Ephesus refused to sign at Florence.
  • In 1965 Paul VI and Athenagoras removed the mutual excommunications from the memory of the church. Communion was not restored, and the churches do not share the Eucharist.
  • The lecture concludes that doctrine is rarely what breaks a church. It is what people are willing to do to each other while defending it.

Topic: This lecture asks why the quarrel of 1054 never healed, and finds the answer mostly in what happened afterwards, especially in 1204.

Remember: 1054 gave the division a date, but 1204 gave it a memory. After the sack of Constantinople, every attempt at reunion meant negotiating with that memory.

Caution: The 1965 declaration did not restore communion. It ended the claim that a valid sentence of condemnation keeps the churches apart, while the divergence remains.

One line to carry into ministry: Union imposed from the top under pressure is a treaty, not communion. Seek agreement the whole body can receive.

Chapter 2 Chapter 2: The Crusades and the Mendicant Orders

  • Europe was ready: population grew, landless younger sons of knights fought each other despite the Peace of God, and a confident reforming papacy wanted to show it could summon armies.
  • Emperor Alexios asked for mercenaries under Byzantine command. What arrived was an independent army with a religious aim of taking Jerusalem. That mismatch poisoned relations and leads to 1204.
  • Augustine's just war criteria are legitimate authority, just cause and right intention. They restrict violence, and he never said fighting benefits the soldier's soul.
  • At Clermont in 1095, Urban II offered that going to Jerusalem out of devotion counted as full satisfaction of owed penance. Calling it armed pilgrimage gave the army a pilgrim's merit.
  • The question changed from "when may this evil be permitted?" to "how much good does this earn?" The old limits stayed on paper with little left to restrain.
  • Motives were mixed: devotion, fear of hell, Jerusalem, land, loyalty and a sense of Christendom. Crusading was ruinously expensive, and the lecture argues it was popular because it was sincere.

Topic: This lecture explains what made Europe ready for the First Crusade and how Christian thinking moved from just war to holy war.

Remember: Augustine treated war as a tragic necessity, never a merit. Holy war made fighting itself a meritorious act, and that reversal took about six hundred years.

Caution: The lecture rejects both the picture of unprovoked Western aggression and the picture of pure self-defence. It also warns against reducing the crusades to cynicism or to any single motive.

One line to carry into ministry: Be wary of any teaching that turns a permitted evil into a source of spiritual reward.

  • The First Crusade succeeded and took Jerusalem in July 1099. The first killings came earlier, in 1096, when crusading bands under Count Emicho attacked Jewish communities in Speyer, Worms, Mainz and Cologne.
  • Church teaching protected Jews, and some bishops tried to shelter them. Yet the theology of merit for killing enemies of Christ created a category the crowd could not be trusted to limit.
  • The massacre at Jerusalem was received in the West as proof of God's favour. Success counted as vindication and failure as the crusaders' sin, so the premise was never questioned.
  • The Second Crusade failed, the Third did not take Jerusalem, and the Fourth sacked Constantinople without reaching a Muslim opponent. Saladin's restraint in 1187 was noticed by Western writers.
  • The costs fell on Jews, Muslims, Eastern Christians, the Western church itself and Christian mission today. Historians disagree on how Muslims experienced the crusades at the time.
  • John Paul II asked forgiveness in 2000 and expressed sorrow for the sack of Constantinople in Athens in 2001. The lecture calls this worth marking, though very late.

Topic: This lecture counts the human and theological cost of the crusades from 1096 to 1204 and asks what the church owes in memory.

Remember: The crusades were an application of the church's thinking, not a lapse from it. A theology that reads both success and failure as confirmation stops being answerable to evidence.

Caution: The lecture does not treat the course as a tribunal or ask readers to feel superior. It also says historians disagree about reading the crusades through modern Christian-Muslim relations.

One line to carry into ministry: Beware any movement where both victory and defeat prove it right, and keep words and teaching honest about their past.

  • The medieval church grew rich largely through gifts of land for prayers for the dead. Simony, lay investiture and clerical dynasties followed, and the eleventh-century reform wanted a free church, not a poor one.
  • The vita apostolica, the apostolic life, held that Acts and the sending of the apostles show what the church should look like. It was a lay movement with a critique built in.
  • Peter Waldo was allowed his vow of poverty in 1179 but forbidden to preach. He preached anyway and was excommunicated at Verona in 1184. Distinct doctrines followed after condemnation.
  • The Cathars were dualists: spirit is good and matter evil, so the incarnation and the sacraments were denied. Their perfecti were visibly holy, while papal legates arrived with horses and fine clothing.
  • R. I. Moore and Mark Gregory Pegg argue Catharism was largely a construct of inquisitors. Other historians hold the dualist theology is well attested. The course flags the challenge.
  • The church preached the Albigensian Crusade in 1209 and began the Inquisition. It also approved poor preaching orders inside obedience, so its real test was obedience, not orthodoxy.

Topic: This lecture compares the Waldensians and the Cathars and shows how the church answered a lay demand for apostolic poverty.

Remember: The church applied the criterion of obedience, not orthodoxy. It destroyed the movement that left its authority and canonised the one that stayed inside it.

Caution: The Waldensians were orthodox and the Cathars held a different religion, so they should not be merged. The lecture notes that the traditional picture of the Cathars is under challenge.

One line to carry into ministry: Condemnation can create the dissent it names. Before expelling a critic, ask what would keep that zeal inside the church.

  • Cities and a money economy outgrew the rural monastery, and monasteries had become landlords. The mendicant orders owned no property, moved to cities and lived on alms and work.
  • Francis spoke of Lady Poverty as a bride and named his followers minores, the lesser ones, after the lower class of Italian towns. His delight in creation answered the Cathar view of matter.
  • In 1219 Francis crossed the lines at Damietta to speak with the Sultan. The 1221 Rule allows friars to live peaceably among Muslims, a mission of presence that permits silence as witness.
  • Dominic answered the Cathar perfecti with people poorer and more persuasive. His order took veritas as its motto and made study a form of poverty, and it produced Albert the Great and Thomas Aquinas.
  • The orders also changed church life through mobility, preaching, confession and third orders for laypeople. Readers disagree whether this renewed the church or domesticated a dangerous movement.
  • The dark side was the Inquisition, staffed largely by Dominicans, and the Spirituals, Franciscans who were burned as heretics for demanding total poverty.

Topic: This lecture describes Francis, Dominic and the mendicant orders, and what they changed and cost.

Remember: The same energy produced armed crusade and poor preaching. Francis walked out of a besieging army to talk, and the mendicants answered the lay hunger of the age.

Caution: The lecture does not call the approval of the orders simply good or simply a containment. Both readings are given, and it notes that each order was soon turned to coercion or disputed.

One line to carry into ministry: Answer opponents who persuade by their poverty with people who are poorer and more persuasive, not with wealth and authority.

Chapter 3 Chapter 3: Scholastic Theology and the Rise of the University

  • Monastic theology was slow reading, such as lectio divina, aimed at being changed by the text. Scholastic theology took the question as its method and aimed to settle disputed points.
  • The revival of dialectic, logic, drove the change. Abelard's Sic et Non lined up contradictory authorities without answers, and offered rules for handling them. Bernard of Clairvaux opposed him as a danger to reverence.
  • Peter Lombard's Sentences arranged the material with answers and became the standard textbook for four hundred years. Aquinas, Bonaventure, Scotus, Ockham and Luther all commented on it.
  • Anselm's credo ut intelligam means faith is the starting place for thought, not a demand to believe before evidence. He argued from reason alone while believing on Scripture's authority.
  • The ontological argument defines God as that than which nothing greater can be conceived. Gaunilo and Kant objected, and twentieth-century philosophers such as Plantinga reconstructed it.
  • In Cur Deus Homo, sin withholds honour from God, and only a God-man can repay the infinite debt. This is satisfaction, not penal substitution, which the lecture says came later.

Topic: This lecture explains the move from monastic to scholastic theology and Anselm's two best-known works.

Remember: Faith seeking understanding means beginning inside faith and reasoning from there. It does not mean looking for evidence to reassure an anxious believer.

Caution: The lecture does not say Anselm's argument succeeds, and Protestants should not confuse his satisfaction theory with penal substitution. It also warns that a method that can question anything can corrode anything.

One line to carry into ministry: Be ready to give a reason for your hope, with humility and fear, as 1 Peter 3:15 says.

  • From about 1150, Aristotle's complete works reached Latin Europe through Arabic translations, made at places like Toledo, with commentaries by Avicenna, Averroes and Maimonides.
  • The new Aristotle seemed to threaten doctrine: an eternal world, a soul that may not survive, a God who neither knows nor cares, and a nature that explains itself.
  • Europe tried three answers: ban the books (Paris, 1210 and 1215, which failed), separate philosophy from faith (Siger of Brabant), or synthesise them (Aquinas).
  • The charge of "double truth" against the Averroists is disputed. Most historians now see it as opponents' polemic, and Siger denied holding it.
  • Aquinas held that grace does not destroy nature but perfects it. Reason reaches far, but not to the Trinity, the incarnation, or a proven beginning of the world.
  • Bishop Tempier condemned 219 propositions in 1277, some of them Aquinas's own. Aquinas was canonised in 1323, and the condemnation was annulled as to his teaching in 1325.

Topic: How Aristotle's philosophy reached the Latin West through the Islamic world, and how Europe responded, above all through Aquinas.

Remember: Grace does not destroy nature but perfects it: reason is God's work, reaches far, and knows where it stops.

Caution: The "double truth" charge may never have been anyone's real position. Also, Aquinas's synthesis was brilliant but did nothing for the church's coming institutional crisis.

One line to carry into ministry: Concede the limits of reason precisely, and you protect what reason can show from the charge of being mere piety.

  • Aquinas wrote the Summa Theologiae as a textbook for beginners. After something happened to him at Mass in 1273, he stopped, saying all he had written seemed like straw.
  • Grace perfects nature. This forbids contempt for nature and also forbids self-sufficiency for nature. Reformed theologians such as Bavinck argue Aquinas underestimates the damage of sin; Thomists disagree.
  • Each article follows four steps: objections, sed contra, respondeo, replies. Objections come first and are stated at full strength, so honesty is built into the method.
  • The Summa follows exitus and reditus, out from God and back to God. Part II, on human moral life, is the longest. Some, such as Barth, criticise Christ appearing only in Part III.
  • The Five Ways claim only that a first mover, first cause and necessary being must exist, and that this is what people call God. They do not prove the Trinity.
  • Law has four levels: eternal, natural, human and divine. Cardinal virtues are acquired by practice; theological virtues (faith, hope, love) are given by God, and love is greatest.

Topic: Aquinas's Summa Theologiae: its governing principle, its method, its structure, the Five Ways, and its account of law and virtue.

Remember: Nature is good but incomplete, and grace completes it without humiliating it. This one principle shapes the whole Summa.

Caution: The Five Ways do not claim to prove the Trinity or God's love, and they are not the foundation of the Summa. Also, Reformed and Barthian critics raise real objections.

One line to carry into ministry: Before you answer a view you reject, state it so well that its holder would sign it.

  • The university grew from monastic and cathedral schools. A universitas was a guild, a legal corporation, not a campus. Bologna was a students' guild; Paris was a masters' guild.
  • The licentia docendi was a guild licence to teach. A bachelor was an apprentice and a master a qualified practitioner, so graduation is still an admission ceremony.
  • Students studied the seven liberal arts, the trivium and quadrivium, then law, medicine or theology. Theology took fifteen years or more and was never studied first.
  • Lectio was a master reading and commenting on a text. Disputatio was public argument in which your opponent was present, and the Summa's form is its transcript.
  • Universities gave Europe a common language, institutional independence, trained administrators and the form of learning itself. Women were excluded entirely, though some, like Hildegard of Bingen, wrote anyway.
  • Paris did not prevent Avignon or the Schism, because that crisis was one of money, power and nerve, not of ideas. A church that gives excellent answers cannot thereby act.

Topic: How the medieval university began, what and how it taught, and why it could not save the church from its institutional crisis.

Remember: A universitas was a guild, and the degree began as a guild qualification to teach.

Caution: Do not read the university as simply a triumph. It excluded women, and the lecture says good training did not stop the crisis of the next chapter.

One line to carry into ministry: Study of God is not a beginner's subject, and good training does not replace integrity, courage and accountable structures.

Chapter 4 Chapter 4: Decline and the Collapse of a Paradigm

  • Boniface VIII issued Unam Sanctam in 1302, the largest claim for papal authority ever made. In 1303 agents of Philip IV arrested him at Anagni, and no one came to help.
  • By 1300 France and England were real states, but the papacy kept making claims suited to a vanished world of weak rulers.
  • Seven French popes ruled from Avignon from 1309 to 1377. The papacy looked French and grew expert at raising money, so many Christians met it chiefly as a bill.
  • In 1378 the same cardinals elected Urban VI and then Clement VII. Europe divided along the lines of the Hundred Years' War, and each pope excommunicated the other's followers.
  • There were saints on both sides: Catherine of Siena backed Urban, Vincent Ferrer backed Avignon. Who held Christ's authority became undecidable, and an unchecked claim stops being treated as one.
  • The Council of Pisa in 1409 deposed both popes and elected a third, but neither accepted. Its authority rested on the theory it was trying to prove.

Topic: How the papacy moved from the Unam Sanctam claim of 1302 to Avignon, the Great Western Schism and three rival popes.

Remember: The papacy lost the assumption that its central claim could be checked, and that loss was more serious than any single scandal.

Caution: Historians debate how far the Avignon popes were really tools of the French crown, and the lecture notes that none of the steps was a heresy.

One line to carry into ministry: An institution can lose authority faster than it built it, and the people inside are often the last to notice.

  • Conciliarism grew out of canon law, from the question of how to judge a heretical pope. The schism turned that emergency rule into a general theory.
  • Gerson and d'Ailly argued that Christ gave authority to the church as a body. Papal primacy is real but given for the church, so a council may act when the head fails.
  • Constance, backed by Emperor Sigismund, issued Haec Sancta in 1415, removed the rival claimants and elected Martin V in 1417. Frequens required councils at fixed intervals.
  • Constance never delivered the reform it also claimed authority over. It also burned Jan Hus, who had come under a safe conduct.
  • Basel overreached, deposed Eugene IV and elected an antipope, creating the kind of schism it existed to end. Execrabilis in 1460 forbade appeals from a pope to a council.
  • Abuses were publicly admitted, yet no mechanism could correct them against the papal court. Later reformers therefore appealed over its head, to Scripture, princes and conscience.

Topic: The rise and collapse of the conciliar movement, which tried to make the church accountable through representative councils.

Remember: The church came close to a constitutional government in which its head answered to an assembly, then lost it, and the Reformation grew from that loss.

Caution: Historians disagree. Tierney and Oakley see a genuine tradition, forgotten rather than refuted, while others call it an emergency doctrine that broke at Basel. Do not call Constance a liberal parliament.

One line to carry into ministry: Reform that depends on one assembly or one office can fail; an institution needs ways to correct itself that outlast the crisis that created them.

  • The Black Death reached Sicily in 1347, and between a third and a half of Europe died. The usual teaching that suffering is punishment or testing did not fit its scale.
  • It did not separate the wicked from the good, and the clergy died in higher numbers, since they sat beside the dying.
  • Flagellants began to treat their own scourging as a way to forgiveness and then incited massacres of Jews. Clement VI protected Jews and condemned the movement, but had little leverage left.
  • The danse macabre shows death levelling all ranks in order, including the pope, and the ars moriendi (art of dying well) addressed the dying person and those in the room.
  • With priests dying or replaced hastily, the bishop of Bath and Wells in 1349 allowed confession to a layman, even a woman, in an emergency. That opened a lasting question.
  • Religious life moved inward, toward the laity, and toward mysticism, as in Julian of Norwich. Historians such as Duffy argue the plague did not make Europe less religious, only differently so.

Topic: What the Black Death did to medieval belief, the clergy and the sacramental system, and where religious life then moved.

Remember: The plague did not make Europe less religious. It made it religious in a different way, with the institution nearer the edge.

Caution: Historians disagree about how far religion was shaken. Eamon Duffy and others say the effect is overstated, since church building and endowments rose in some regions after 1350.

One line to carry into ministry: When explanations fail and ministers are unavailable in a crisis, a church must not rely on office alone; people will look for God elsewhere.

  • Many devout people did not leave the church but went around it, building religious life at one remove from the machinery of an institution they no longer trusted.
  • Beguines were unenclosed women living religiously without vows or a rule. They were suspected, restricted at Vienne in 1311-12, and Marguerite Porete was burned in 1310.
  • Meister Eckhart taught the ground of the soul, the birth of the Word in the soul, and letting go. Twenty-eight propositions were censured in 1329, and Tauler, Suso and Theologia Germanica followed.
  • The Devotio Moderna, from Geert Groote, formed lay Brethren of the Common Life without vows. Its practical, Christ-centred piety produced The Imitation of Christ and schools that taught Erasmus.
  • These movements were not proto-Protestant. They were sacramental, and the same mysticism fed Teresa of Avila and John of the Cross.
  • They prepared conditions, not doctrine: lay readers of devotional books, religion apart from the parish priest, and impatience with theology that had not made anyone better. Historians read this differently.

Topic: How lay people, women and mystics built religious life around a distrusted institution, and how far this prepared the Reformation.

Remember: People did not rebel or leave. They moved their religious lives to where those lives could still be lived, and went on attending Mass.

Caution: Do not tell the story as lay religion leading straight to Luther. The lecture says these figures would have rejected the sixteenth century's solution, and historians such as Van Engen and Oberman read the movements differently.

One line to carry into ministry: Ordinary believers will quietly relocate their faith if an institution stops serving it, so a church should ask where its people actually find God.

Chapter 5 Chapter 5: The Dawn of the Reformation

  • Wycliffe's dominion theory held that all lordship is held from God on condition of righteousness, so a bishop in mortal sin has no true right to his estates.
  • John of Gaunt protected him mainly because this argument justified confiscating church wealth, and the protection lasted only as long as he was useful.
  • He taught that the true church is the congregation of the predestined, which no one can identify. Even the pope may not belong, and this fitted the time of the Schism.
  • He made Scripture outrank later church legislation, but this is not yet Luther's sola scriptura, since he still treated the Fathers as authoritative. He denied transubstantiation in 1381 and lost his protectors.
  • Lollards preached in English, and the Wycliffite Bible was the first complete English Bible, made from the Vulgate. Arundel's Constitutions of 1409 banned unauthorised English translations.
  • He died in 1384, and his bones were burned in 1428. His dominion principle could be turned on anyone and cannot be checked.

Topic: John Wycliffe's ideas on dominion, the church and Scripture, and the Lollards and the English Bible that followed him.

Remember: Wycliffe left a doctrine of the church, an English Bible and the belief that ordinary people may read Scripture, though he seemed to fail in his lifetime.

Caution: Do not call Wycliffe simply the Morning Star of the Reformation, or equate his Scripture principle with sola scriptura. The lecture says he was abandoned, not burned, in his lifetime.

One line to carry into ministry: A reformer who depends on a powerful protector should remember Wycliffe, who was dropped once he touched the Eucharist.

  • Wycliffe's writings reached Prague after the marriage of Anne of Bohemia and Richard II in 1382. Reform and Czech identity fused, in a university and church dominated by Germans.
  • Hus took Wycliffe's doctrine of the church as the body of the predestined with Christ as head, but never denied transubstantiation. He was condemned partly for articles he denied holding.
  • In 1412 Hus attacked a crusade indulgence, a hundred and five years before Luther's theses. He was excommunicated for it.
  • Utraquism gave the cup to the laity, citing 1 Corinthians 11 and John 6. Withholding it had been the most visible weekly sign of the divide between clergy and laity.
  • At Constance, Hus was arrested despite a safe conduct, refused open disputation, offered to recant anything shown wrong from Scripture, and was burned on 6 July 1415.
  • His death led to the Hussite wars, the 1436 Compacts of Basel granting both kinds, and the Unity of the Brethren, later the Moravian Church, which influenced John Wesley.

Topic: Jan Hus's teaching, the meaning of the chalice, his trial and execution at Constance, and what his death produced.

Remember: Hus asked to be shown from Scripture where he was wrong and was told to recant instead. That is why his case is still cited.

Caution: The lecture notes Constance was probably within its own law and still catastrophically wrong, and that Hus did not hold all the articles charged. He was not simply Wycliffe's translator.

One line to carry into ministry: Keep faith with those who come to you in good faith, since an institution that follows its own rules can still destroy its own credibility.

  • Florence was brilliant but run by one family, and in 1492 Alexander VI, who openly advanced his children, became pope. Savonarola, a Dominican, rose against this corruption.
  • He preached coming judgement, the need to purify the church from its head, and a holy Florence. Charles VIII's invasion in 1494 seemed to prove him right.
  • His Florence had a Great Council, laws against gambling and usury, and a public pawn bank. But boys policed dress and gambling, and the bonfires have been exaggerated in later retelling.
  • He was excommunicated in 1497, called for a council against the pope, and lost Florence's support after a failed trial by fire. He was hanged and burned on 23 May 1498.
  • The lecture names four flaws: law produces compliance, not holiness; children as enforcers; ties to a political faction; and authority resting on prophecy, which can fail publicly.
  • He was right that a church cannot preach repentance while its head lives like Alexander VI, and that reform must reach the head. Wycliffe and Hus sowed arguments; he sowed a movement.

Topic: Savonarola's attempt to reform Florence and the church, his orthodox faith, his execution, and the limits of a reform built on morals and one man.

Remember: Being right about the corruption is not enough: Wycliffe and Hus sowed arguments that outlived them, but Savonarola sowed a movement that depended on his person.

Caution: Do not treat him as simply a hero or a villain. Catholics, Protestants and others read him differently, and the lecture says the bonfires and the Botticelli story are exaggerated.

One line to carry into ministry: Reform by supervision produces compliance, not holiness, and a reform tied to one leader falls with him.

  • Humanism was a method, not a philosophy. Its slogan ad fontes means "to the sources": study a text in its original language and oldest manuscripts. Lorenzo Valla used it in 1440 to show the Donation of Constantine was a forgery.

  • Humanists said scholastic theology (the medieval school method) had become arguments about arguments and had lost the foundations. The lecture adds that this is unfair to Aquinas but fair about much fifteenth-century theology.

  • Erasmus was shaped by the Brethren of the Common Life. His "philosophy of Christ" wanted simple, Christ-centred faith for ordinary people, and The Praise of Folly (1511) made the clergy a target of laughter.

  • His 1516 Greek New Testament was rushed and used late manuscripts. Still, anyone educated could now check the Latin Vulgate against the Greek. Matthew 4:17 and Luke 1:28 show how a translation had supported church practice.

  • Authority moved to a text anyone competent could check, and meaning became historical. Greek and Hebrew entered theological training. Tyndale, Luther and the King James Version all depended on Erasmus's Greek.

  • Erasmus wanted reform without schism and broke with Luther over free will in 1524 and 1525. He is said to have replied that he laid a hen's egg and Luther hatched a fighting cock.

Topic: This lecture shows how Erasmus's printed Greek New Testament of 1516 gave Europe a checkable biblical text and ended the medieval period.

Remember: Authority moved from the Vulgate, the Fathers and the schools to a text in the original language that any competent scholar could open and check.

Caution: Erasmus's edition was rushed and flawed, and he never wanted a schism. The lecture says he supplied a text and a method, not the Reformation itself.

One line to carry into ministry: Go back to the text in its own language, and check what a translation has been carrying before building a practice on it.