FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH102E Medieval Church History

Lecture 4-4: Going Around the Institution

Jump to the key points ↓

21 min

Suppose you are a devout Christian in the Rhineland in 1380. There are two popes. Your parish priest was ordained in a hurry after the plague and can barely read the Latin he recites. Rome is a fee schedule and Avignon is a French court, and the men arguing about which is the true one are the same men who take a cut of every appointment in your diocese.

You have not lost your faith. You have lost your confidence that the institution is where your faith is best served.

What do you do?

This lecture is about what a great many people did. They went around it — not out of it. Almost nobody in this lecture left the church; most would have been horrified at the suggestion. They simply built their religious lives at one remove from the machinery: in lay communities without vows, in a spirituality of the interior, and in schools that taught ordinary people to read Scripture and pray in their own language.

And then those schools educated Erasmus, and possibly Luther, and chapter 5 begins.

What these 21 minutes give you

  • Describe the Beguines and explain what made a movement of unenclosed religious laywomen both attractive and suspect.
  • Explain Meister Eckhart's teaching on the ground of the soul and the character of Rhineland mysticism.
  • Describe the *Devotio Moderna* and the practical piety of *The Imitation of Christ*.
  • Assess, with appropriate caution, how far these movements prepared the ground for the Reformation's doctrine of the priesthood of all believers.

But you go and learn what this means: 'I desire mercy, and not sacrifice,' for I came not to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance." — Matthew 9:13

World English Bible

Christ quotes Hosea against a religious establishment that had the ritual correct. Every movement in this lecture read that verse as addressed to their own century.

1. The Beguines: a religious life with no rule

From the late twelfth century, in the towns of the Low Countries and the Rhineland, women began living together in religious communities that fitted no existing category.

They were not nuns. They took no permanent vows, were not enclosed, belonged to no order, and followed no approved rule. They could leave and marry. They supported themselves — spinning, weaving, lace, nursing, teaching, care of the dying — and they lived in houses, and later in whole walled courtyards called beguinages, some of which still stand in Belgian cities and are worth visiting.

They were called Beguines, a name of uncertain and probably originally mocking origin.

Understand why they existed. There were more women than the convents could take, and convents required a dowry, so a poor woman with a had nowhere to go. The towns were full of unmarried women working in the cloth trade. The Beguines were the religious life made available to women who were neither rich nor willing to be enclosed for ever, and at their height there were thousands of them in a single city.

Now understand why they were suspect. They were women, living religiously, outside male supervision — not under an abbess appointed through an order, not enclosed, not answerable to a rule a bishop had approved. They read, and some of them wrote, in the vernacular. They discussed theology.

The suspicion hardened into condemnation. The Council of Vienne (1311–12) issued decrees restricting the Beguines and condemning a set of errors labelled the heresy of the Free Spirit — the alleged teaching that a soul perfected in love is beyond the need for virtue, sacraments or the church. Whether any organised group actually held that is disputed by historians on much the same grounds as Catharism in lecture 2-3.

And in Paris, in 1310, Marguerite Porete was burned for refusing to withdraw her book, The Mirror of Simple Souls, a work of mystical theology written in French for lay readers. She is the first person known to have been executed for mystical writing in the West, and her book survived anonymously and was widely read by people who did not know its author had been killed for it.

Hold that beside lecture 2-3. The pattern is the same, and it is now being applied to women. The material was orthodox or arguably orthodox; the offence was operating outside authorisation.

2. Eckhart and the ground of the soul

The Beguines needed preachers, and their Dominican chaplains had to preach to them in German, since most Beguines had no Latin. Out of that pastoral necessity came the most demanding vernacular theology of the Middle Ages.

Meister Eckhart (c. 1260–1328) was a Dominican, a Paris master, and a senior administrator of his order — as institutionally respectable as it was possible to be. His German sermons, preached largely to Beguines and nuns, teach three linked ideas.

Meeting place with God

The ground of the soul (Seelengrund). In the deepest part of a human being there is a point that is uncreated and untouched, where God and the soul meet without mediation. Eckhart calls it the ground, the spark, the castle. It is not something achieved; it is already there.

The birth of the Word in the soul. The eternal begetting of the Son by the Father is not only an event in the or a fact of history. It happens in the ground of the soul, now. The Christian's task is not to add something but to be the place where that birth occurs.

Gelassenheit — releasement, letting-go. The obstacle is not sin in the ordinary sense but attachment, including attachment to one's own spiritual attainments. Eckhart's most quoted and most startling line is a prayer that God would rid him of God — that is, of every idea of God he has constructed, so that God himself can be present rather than the image.

Two observations, and both matter for this course.

This is not anti-institutional preaching. Eckhart never told anyone to leave the church or skip Mass; he was a loyal Dominican who died in the church's service. But it is preaching in which the decisive event happens in a place no institution administers, and it was delivered in German to laypeople. That combination is the point, whatever Eckhart intended.

He was condemned. In 1329, a year after his death, twenty-eight propositions from his work were censured by papal bull. His pupils Johannes Tauler and Henry Suso carried the teaching forward in a more pastorally cautious form, and the anonymous Theologia Germanica came out of the same current — a book Luther admired so much that he edited and published it in 1516 and again in 1518, and said that apart from the Bible and Augustine no book had taught him more about God and man.

3. The Devotio Moderna: religion as a practice

The last movement is the least dramatic and by far the most consequential.

Geert Groote (d. 1384), a well-off and well-educated man of Deventer in the Netherlands, underwent a conversion, gave up his benefices, and began preaching repentance. Around him gathered people who wanted to live seriously without becoming monks.

What they formed were the Brethren and Sisters of the Common Life. Note the constitution, because it is deliberate: they took no vows. They lived together, held goods in common, worked for their living — largely by copying manuscripts, which is to say by making books — and were free to leave. A related branch, the Windesheim congregation, did take vows as canons, so the movement had both a lay and a religious wing.

Their spirituality — devotio moderna, "the modern devotion" — had a definite character, and it is best defined by what it refused.

  • Interior and practical, not speculative. The aim was a changed life, not a settled question.
  • Christ-centred, focused on the humanity and the passion of Jesus.
  • Methodical. Daily self-examination, structured meditation on set passages, spiritual reading in the vernacular, a written rule of life. Religion as a discipline you practise, like a craft.
  • Suspicious of . Here the movement turns and looks straight at chapter 3.

That last point deserves its own line, because it is where this chapter's principle bites. The Imitation of Christ, the movement's classic, opens with this:

"What good does it do you to be able to discuss the Trinity learnedly, if you lack humility and thereby displease the Trinity? I would far rather feel contrition than be able to define it."

That is a verdict on chapter 3, delivered by the fifteenth century. It is not a fair verdict — Aquinas would have agreed with the sentiment and said the two are not alternatives — but it is an entirely intelligible one from people who had watched the best-trained church in history produce Avignon.

The Imitation of Christ, compiled by Thomas à Kempis in the 1420s, became the most widely read Christian book after the Bible. Short chapters, plain sentences, no technical vocabulary, addressed to the individual reader. It has been read by Catholics and Protestants, by Ignatius Loyola and John Wesley, ever since.

And the Brethren ran schools — good ones, in Deventer, Zwolle, 's-Hertogenbosch and elsewhere, teaching boys Latin, Scripture and the devout life.

Erasmus was educated in them. Chapter 5's last lecture is about what he did with it. Luther attended a school at Magdeburg where the Brethren's influence is likely, though the details are argued. The pipeline from this lecture into the next chapter is not a metaphor; it is a set of school registers.

4. Did this cause the Reformation?

Now the caution, because this is where courses like this one usually overclaim.

The tempting story runs: lay religion without clergy → the → Luther. Do not tell it that way. Three corrections.

These people were not proto-Protestants. The Devotio Moderna was intensely sacramental and devoted to the Eucharist. Thomas à Kempis wrote a whole book of the Imitation on receiving communion. Eckhart was a Dominican in good standing until the end. Every figure in this lecture would have rejected the sixteenth-century solution.

Mysticism cuts both ways. The same Rhineland tradition fed the Catholic renewal of the sixteenth century — Teresa of Ávila and John of the Cross stand in a line that includes these writers. A movement is not owned by whoever cited it later.

And what they did prepare was not doctrine but conditions. That is the accurate statement, and it is enough:

  • A lay readership accustomed to serious devotional books in its own language.
  • The habit of a religious life not organised around the parish priest.
  • The assumption that the decisive transaction is between the individual soul and God.
  • Schools producing men trained in Scripture and personally devout.
  • And a widely shared, publicly expressed impatience with theology that had not made anyone better.

None of that is Protestantism. All of it is what Protestantism needed to be intelligible when it arrived, and a Luther preaching to a population without those habits would have been preaching to nobody.

Prelude or its own movement

This is a point where readers will not agree. John Van Engen has argued that the Devotio Moderna is best read on its own terms rather than as anyone's prelude, and it nourished the Counter-Reformation as much as the Reformation. Heiko Oberman, from the other side, made the case that late medieval theology and the Reformation are far more continuous than either party has liked to admit. Protestant historians tend to read it as a movement whose logic pointed past the institution it stayed inside. The movement is large enough to support both readings, and this course does not pretend to settle it.

5. What actually happened here

Chapter 4 has described an institution losing its authority in four ways — politically at Anagni, constitutionally at Basel, pastorally in the plague, and financially at Avignon throughout.

This lecture describes what people did about it, and the answer is the most ordinary answer in the history of religion. They did not rebel and they did not leave. They quietly relocated their religious lives to where they could still be lived, and they went on attending Mass while doing it.

That is why the institution did not notice. There was no confrontation to notice. The Beguines paid their taxes, the Brethren copied manuscripts, and Thomas à Kempis wrote a book about humility. And a hundred years later, when a friar in Wittenberg said that a Christian's standing before God does not depend on the machinery, a great many people found the idea already familiar.

An institution can lose its authority faster than it built it, and no one inside notices in time — because authority does not usually leave through the front door with a manifesto. It is simply stopped being consulted.


Going Around, Not Going Out Nobody in this lecture left the church. That is why nobody noticed. BEGUINES · c. 1200– RHINELAND MYSTICS DEVOTIO MODERNA A religious life, no vows Unenclosed, self-supporting, free to leave and marry Open to women with no dowry The ground of the soul The Word is born in the soul now Gelassenheit — letting go, even of one's own idea of God Religion as a practice Brethren of the Common Life: no vows, common purse, and they made books for a living The cost Vienne 1311 · Porete burned 1310 The cost 28 propositions condemned, 1329 The legacy The Imitation of Christ · the schools "I would far rather feel contrition than be able to define it." — The Imitation of Christ A verdict on chapter 3, delivered by people who had watched the best-trained church in history produce Avignon What was prepared was not doctrine but conditions Vernacular devotional reading · a religious life not organised around the parish priest · the soul before God as the decisive transaction · schools that educated Erasmus Authority rarely leaves through the front door with a manifesto. It is simply stopped being consulted.

Diagram 1. Summary table

Beguines Rhineland mystics Devotio Moderna
Where and when Low Countries, Rhineland, from c. 1200 Rhineland, c. 1300–1360 Low Countries, from c. 1380
Key figures Marguerite Porete Eckhart, Tauler, Suso Geert Groote, Thomas à Kempis
Core idea A religious life without vows or enclosure The ground of the soul; the Word born within Methodical, practical, Christ-centred piety
Relation to clergy Outside supervision, not outside the church Loyal, but the decisive event is unadministered Sacramental and devout; impatient with speculation
Official response Vienne 1311; Porete burned 1310 28 propositions condemned, 1329 Tolerated; its schools flourished
What it left Lay religious life as a real option for women The Theologia Germanica, which Luther published The Imitation of Christ; the school that taught Erasmus

5. Going to the Sources

  • Thomas à Kempis, The Imitation of Christ, Book I, chapters 1–3 — six pages, and you will see immediately why it outsold everything else for five centuries.
  • Meister Eckhart, German Sermon 2 ("Jesus entered a certain village") — on the ground of the soul. Difficult, and worth the difficulty.
  • Marguerite Porete, The Mirror of Simple Souls, the opening chapters — read at least a little of the book someone was burned for.
  • The Theologia Germanica — short and anonymous. Luther published it twice; read it and judge what he saw in it.

In short

  • Many devout people did not leave the church but went around it, building religious life at one remove from the machinery of an institution they no longer trusted.
  • Beguines were unenclosed women living religiously without vows or a rule. They were suspected, restricted at Vienne in 1311-12, and Marguerite Porete was burned in 1310.
  • Meister Eckhart taught the ground of the soul, the birth of the Word in the soul, and letting go. Twenty-eight propositions were censured in 1329, and Tauler, Suso and Theologia Germanica followed.
  • The Devotio Moderna, from Geert Groote, formed lay Brethren of the Common Life without vows. Its practical, Christ-centred piety produced The Imitation of Christ and schools that taught Erasmus.
  • These movements were not proto-Protestant. They were sacramental, and the same mysticism fed Teresa of Avila and John of the Cross.
  • They prepared conditions, not doctrine: lay readers of devotional books, religion apart from the parish priest, and impatience with theology that had not made anyone better. Historians read this differently.

Topic: How lay people, women and mystics built religious life around a distrusted institution, and how far this prepared the Reformation.

Remember: People did not rebel or leave. They moved their religious lives to where those lives could still be lived, and went on attending Mass.

Caution: Do not tell the story as lay religion leading straight to Luther. The lecture says these figures would have rejected the sixteenth century's solution, and historians such as Van Engen and Oberman read the movements differently.

One line to carry into ministry: Ordinary believers will quietly relocate their faith if an institution stops serving it, so a church should ask where its people actually find God.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • The Beguines were condemned for being unsupervised rather than for being wrong. Compare this with the Waldensians in lecture 2-3. What does the church's consistency on that point reveal about what it was actually protecting?
  • Eckhart never told anyone to leave the church, but located the decisive event where no institution administers it. Can a church contain that teaching safely? Should it want to?
  • *The Imitation of Christ* prefers feeling contrition to defining it. State the strongest reply Aquinas could make, then say who you think is right.
  • The lecture warns against reading these movements as proto-Protestant. Where exactly is the line between "prepared the conditions" and "caused"? Why does the distinction matter for how you read your own tradition's history?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.