Lecture 3-1: Faith Seeking Understanding
Contents 21
- Lecture 1-1: How East and West Became Strangers
- Lecture 1-2: Iconoclasm — Images, Empire and the Incarnation
- Lecture 1-3: One Word in the Creed — the Filioque
- Lecture 1-4: 1054, and What Made It Permanent
- Lecture 2-1: From Just War to Holy War
- Lecture 2-2: What the Crusades Cost
- Lecture 2-3: Poverty as Protest
- Lecture 2-4: Francis and Dominic
- Lecture 3-1: Faith Seeking Understanding
- Lecture 3-2: The Aristotle Shock
- Lecture 3-3: Aquinas and the Summa
- Lecture 3-4: The University
- Lecture 4-1: Avignon, and Then Two Popes
- Lecture 4-2: The Church That Nearly Got a Constitution
- Lecture 4-3: The Black Death
- Lecture 4-4: Going Around the Institution
Around 1077, in a monastery in Normandy, an abbot named Anselm was trying to find a single argument. Not a collection of arguments — one, self-contained, that would need nothing outside itself to prove that God exists and is what Christians say he is.
He records that the search made him miserable. He tried to give it up, and the attempt to give it up made him more miserable. Then it came to him, and he wrote it down in a book he first called Faith Seeking Understanding.
That phrase names the whole movement this chapter covers. It does not mean "faith looking for evidence". Anselm was not an anxious believer trying to reassure himself. He was a man who already believed, working on the conviction that what he believed was intelligible — that it had a structure, and that a mind given to it could follow that structure and find it beautiful.
This lecture covers the shift from monastic theology to scholastic theology, the revival of dialectic that made it possible, and the two arguments of Anselm's that are still taught: the ontological argument and the satisfaction theory of the atonement.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Distinguish monastic from scholastic theology, and explain what the revival of dialectic changed.
- Explain what *credo ut intelligam* means and, just as importantly, what it does not mean.
- Set out the logical structure of Anselm's ontological argument, and the standard objections to it.
- State the core of Anselm's satisfaction theory, and distinguish it from later penal substitution.
Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ." — Ephesians 1:3
World English Bible
But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts. Always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear." — 1 Peter 3:15
WEB
The second verse is the charter of this whole chapter. Note the two halves. There is a demand — always be ready to give a reason — and a manner — with humility and fear. was magnificent at the first. Chapter 4 will ask what happened to the second.
1. Two ways of studying God
For six hundred years, Western theology was done by monks, in monasteries, and it had a characteristic shape.
Monastic theology was slow reading. Its central practice was : taking a passage of Scripture, reading it aloud, repeating it, chewing on it — the medieval writers use the word ruminatio, the chewing of cud — until it worked into memory and prayer. Its aim was not primarily to reach a conclusion. It was to be changed by the text. Its natural literary forms were the sermon, the commentary, the meditation. Bernard of Clairvaux, whom you met in lecture 2-2 preaching a crusade, was its greatest exponent.
Scholastic theology was a different discipline in a different room. Its central practice was the question. It took a disputed point, gathered what the authorities said on both sides, found the contradictions, and reasoned to a resolution. Its aim was to settle something. Its natural forms were the disputed question, the commentary on the Sentences, and eventually the summa.
The move from one to the other happened between roughly 1050 and 1150, and it was driven by a tool.
2. Dialectic, and a book of contradictions
Dialectic
Dialectic — logic, the art of reasoned argument — was one of the seven liberal arts, and in the eleventh century the West's grasp of it improved sharply. Boethius's translations of Aristotle's logical works, which had sat almost unused for five hundred years, came back into circulation and into teaching.
A generation of teachers discovered they had a machine for testing claims. And they promptly pointed it at theology, which caused alarm, some of it justified.
The decisive book was Peter Abelard's Sic et Non — "Yes and No" — written in the 1120s. Abelard collected around 158 theological questions and, under each, lined up quotations from Scripture and the Fathers that flatly contradicted one another. He supplied no answers.
This looked like an attack, and Abelard was a man who enjoyed looking like an attack. But read his prologue and the intent is constructive. The authorities do disagree. Pretending otherwise is not reverence; it is inattention. So Abelard proposed rules for handling apparent contradiction: check whether the text is authentic, whether the word is being used in the same sense, whether the author later retracted it, whether the two statements address different situations.
That is the birth of theological method in the West — and it is the ancestor of every seminary course on you have ever taken.
Bernard of Clairvaux fought Abelard bitterly and had him condemned. The monastic objection was not stupid: a method that can question anything can also corrode anything, and reverence is not a quality that arguments generate. Both men were defending something real. That tension runs through the rest of the chapter, and in chapter 4 it comes due.
Abelard's questions were domesticated by Peter Lombard, whose Sentences (c. 1150) arranged the same material in order with answers supplied. It became the standard theology textbook for four hundred years; commenting on it was the medieval equivalent of writing a doctoral thesis. Aquinas wrote one. So did Bonaventure, Scotus, Ockham — and, later, Luther.
3. Credo ut intelligam
Anselm (c. 1033–1109) was an Italian who became abbot of Bec in Normandy and then, unwillingly, archbishop of Canterbury. His formulation is in the first chapter of the Proslogion:
"I do not seek to understand in order that I may believe, but I believe in order that I may understand. For this too I believe, that unless I believe, I shall not understand."
Read that carefully, because it is easy to get backwards.
What it does not mean: that you must believe first and then evidence will be supplied. Anselm is not asking anyone to switch off their judgement.
What it does mean: faith is the starting position from which the thinking is done. You do not stand outside Christian belief, weigh it neutrally, and step in. You begin inside, and reason from there — the way a person learning music begins by trusting that the notes mean something, and only then finds out how much they mean.
There is a discipline in this that modern readers sometimes miss. Anselm holds himself to arguing from reason alone — in the Proslogion, and even in his book on the , he sets out to argue without appealing to Scripture as a premise. He believes on the authority of Scripture and argues without leaning on it, because he wants to show that what faith holds is not arbitrary. Faith supplies the destination; reason must walk there on its own legs.
4. The ontological argument
Here is the single argument Anselm was looking for. It is short.
- God is that than which nothing greater can be conceived. Even someone who denies God can hold this definition in mind — that is what the word means.
- It is greater to exist in reality than to exist only in the mind.
- Suppose that than which nothing greater can be conceived existed only in the mind.
- Then we could conceive of something greater — namely, the same thing existing in reality.
- But then that than which nothing greater can be conceived would be something than which a greater can be conceived, which is a contradiction.
- Therefore it exists in reality.
Notice what kind of argument this is. It uses no observation of the world at all — no motion, no causes, no design. It works, if it works, purely from what the word "God" means. That is why it is called ontological, an argument from being itself, and it is the only argument of its type in the classical tradition.
The objections came at once, and they came from inside the monastery. A monk called Gaunilo wrote a reply On Behalf of the Fool, arguing that by the same reasoning you could prove the existence of an island than which no greater island can be conceived — which is absurd. Anselm answered that the argument works only for a being whose greatness is unlimited; an island is a limited kind of thing, and there is no such thing as an unsurpassable one. Whether that reply succeeds is still debated.
Seven centuries later Kant made the objection that most people now repeat: existence is not a property. Saying a thing exists does not add to the description of it, so "existing" cannot be one of the perfections that make something greater.
And yet the argument will not die. Twentieth-century philosophers — Norman Malcolm, Charles Hartshorne, Alvin Plantinga — reconstructed it using modal logic, arguing about necessary rather than merely actual existence. Anselm's argument has been refuted more often and more thoroughly than almost anything in philosophy, and it is still in the journals. That is worth knowing when someone tells you the medieval schoolmen produced nothing of value.
5. Cur Deus Homo: why God became man
Anselm's other lasting work, and arguably the more important, is Cur Deus Homo — Why God Became Man, finished around 1098.
He is answering an objection: why the incarnation? Could God not simply have forgiven?
Anselm's answer, compressed:
- Human beings owe God complete obedience. Rendering it earns nothing extra; it is only what was owed.
- Sin does not merely break a rule. It withholds from God the honour due to him, and so disorders the whole created order.
- Justice requires that this be put right — not by punishment but by satisfaction, the restoring of what was taken, with something added to make good the insult.
- The debt is owed by humanity, so a human being must pay it. The debt is infinite, because it is against an infinite God, so only God can pay it.
- Therefore the one who pays must be both: a God-man. Christ, who owed no debt of his own, offers his life freely, and the of that offering is available to those he represents.
Two ideas, easily confused
A distinction English-speaking Protestant readers should hold on to. Anselm's theory is satisfaction, not . In Anselm, Christ's death restores God's honour and repairs a debt; it is not Christ receiving the punishment humanity deserved. Penal substitution — Christ bearing the penalty — is a later development, worked out by the Reformers. The two are related and often confused, and the difference matters: one is framed by debt and honour, the other by law and penalty.
Notice also the world Anselm is thinking in. Honour, debt, satisfaction, a lord dishonoured by an inferior — this is feudal vocabulary, and Anselm was a feudal lord's archbishop. That is not a refutation; every theologian thinks in some available language. But it should make you ask what vocabulary your own atonement theology is borrowing, and from whom.
6. What this chapter is building toward
Anselm gave the medieval West something genuinely new: the conviction that Christian faith has a rational structure that can be traced from the inside, and the confidence to try.
Everything in this chapter follows from that confidence. It produced the Summa, the university, the disputation, the degree — an entire civilisation of the mind.
And it should be said now, at the beginning rather than the end: that confidence had a blind spot, and it was not an intellectual one. The men who could prove God's existence from the meaning of a word did not notice that the institution they served was on its way to Avignon. Faith seeking understanding builds cathedrals of thought — and cannot, by itself, keep a church honest.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Monastic theology | Scholastic theology | |
|---|---|---|
| Aim | To be transformed by the text | To resolve a question |
| Method | Lectio divina, meditation, prayer | Objections, authorities, argument |
| Literary form | Sermon, commentary, meditation | Disputed question, Sentences commentary, summa |
| Setting | Monastery | Cathedral school, then university |
| Exemplar | Bernard of Clairvaux | Abelard, then Aquinas |
| Anselm's two contributions | Credo ut intelligam; the ontological argument | Satisfaction theory in Cur Deus Homo |
5. Going to the Sources
- Anselm, Proslogion, chapters 2–4 — three pages, and the argument in full. Then read Gaunilo's reply and Anselm's answer, printed with it in most editions.
- Anselm, Cur Deus Homo, Book I — a dialogue, and much easier reading than its reputation suggests.
- Abelard, the prologue to Sic et Non — the rules for handling contradictory authorities. Astonishingly modern.
- Bernard of Clairvaux, On Loving God — read this next to Anselm to feel what monastic theology actually was, rather than taking the contrast on trust.
In short
- Monastic theology was slow reading, such as lectio divina, aimed at being changed by the text. Scholastic theology took the question as its method and aimed to settle disputed points.
- The revival of dialectic, logic, drove the change. Abelard's Sic et Non lined up contradictory authorities without answers, and offered rules for handling them. Bernard of Clairvaux opposed him as a danger to reverence.
- Peter Lombard's Sentences arranged the material with answers and became the standard textbook for four hundred years. Aquinas, Bonaventure, Scotus, Ockham and Luther all commented on it.
- Anselm's credo ut intelligam means faith is the starting place for thought, not a demand to believe before evidence. He argued from reason alone while believing on Scripture's authority.
- The ontological argument defines God as that than which nothing greater can be conceived. Gaunilo and Kant objected, and twentieth-century philosophers such as Plantinga reconstructed it.
- In Cur Deus Homo, sin withholds honour from God, and only a God-man can repay the infinite debt. This is satisfaction, not penal substitution, which the lecture says came later.
Topic: This lecture explains the move from monastic to scholastic theology and Anselm's two best-known works.
Remember: Faith seeking understanding means beginning inside faith and reasoning from there. It does not mean looking for evidence to reassure an anxious believer.
Caution: The lecture does not say Anselm's argument succeeds, and Protestants should not confuse his satisfaction theory with penal substitution. It also warns that a method that can question anything can corrode anything.
One line to carry into ministry: Be ready to give a reason for your hope, with humility and fear, as 1 Peter 3:15 says.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Explain *credo ut intelligam* to someone who thinks it means "believe first and the evidence will come". Where is the difference, exactly?
- Anselm argued for the incarnation without using Scripture as a premise, while believing it on Scripture's authority. Is that a valuable discipline or a dangerous concession? Argue both.
- Bernard thought Abelard's method would corrode faith. Given what chapter 4 will show about the following century, was he right, wrong, or right about the wrong thing?
- Anselm's atonement theology borrows the vocabulary of feudal honour. What vocabulary does your own church's atonement theology borrow, and from where?