FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH202E The Church in the Modern World

Lecture 1-3: The Puritans: Holiness, Conscience, and the Crown

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 33
CH202E The Church in the Modern World
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Modern Church History Is, and Why It Is Worth Studying
  1. Introduction: What Modern Church History Is, and Why It Is Worth Studying
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Protestant Orthodoxy and the Puritan Movement
  1. Lecture 1-1: Building the System: Lutheran and Reformed Orthodoxy
  2. Lecture 1-2: Arminius, Dort, and the Doctrine of Grace
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Puritans: Holiness, Conscience, and the Crown
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Westminster Assembly and its Catechisms
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Thirty Years War and the Making of Denominations
  1. Lecture 2-1: The War That Discredited Holy War
  2. Lecture 2-2: Westphalia — A Peace Nobody Loved
  3. Lecture 2-3: Denominations — A Word for People You Cannot Destroy
  4. Lecture 2-4: An Errand into the Wilderness
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Pietism and the Great Awakening
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Revolt Against Cold Orthodoxy: Spener and Francke
  2. Lecture 3-2: Zinzendorf, Herrnhut and the Moravian Missions
  3. Lecture 3-3: John Wesley and the Methodists: Grace and Holiness
  4. Lecture 3-4: The First Great Awakening in North America
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Enlightenment and the Challenge of Liberal Theology
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Age of Reason and the Scientific Revolution
  2. Lecture 4-2: Deism and the Search for a God Nobody Has to Fight About
  3. Lecture 4-3: Biblical Criticism and the Quest for the Historical Jesus
  4. Lecture 4-4: Schleiermacher and the Liberal Century
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Missionary Century
  1. Lecture 5-1: William Carey and the Invention of the Missionary Society
  2. Lecture 5-2: Hudson Taylor, the China Inland Mission and the Cost of Going Inland
  3. Lecture 5-3: David Livingstone — Explorer, Abolitionist, Failed Pastor
  4. Lecture 5-4: Missions and Empire — The Argument That Will Not Settle
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Two World Wars and Neo-Orthodoxy
  1. Lecture 6-1: 1914 — The Year the Future Stopped Working
  2. Lecture 6-2: Barth's Romans and the Theology of the Word
  3. Lecture 6-3: The German Christians, the Confessing Church, and Barmen
  4. Lecture 6-4: Bonhoeffer — Costly Grace and Guilty Hands
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Pentecostalism and the Charismatic Renewal
  1. Lecture 7-1: Azusa Street, 1906
  2. Lecture 7-2: Spirit Baptism and Tongues: An Experience Becomes a Doctrine
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Second Wave: Renewal Inside the Old Churches
  4. Lecture 7-4: Why the South Grew
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Ecumenism and Global Christianity
  1. Lecture 8-1: Edinburgh 1910 and the Making of the World Council of Churches
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Second Vatican Council, 1962–1965
  3. Lecture 8-3: Lausanne 1974 — Evangelism, Justice, and What the Covenant Settled
  4. Lecture 8-4: Where the Church Is Now — and How Four Centuries Got Us Here

Jump to the key points ↓

24 min

The word "Puritan" was an insult. Nobody used it about themselves if they could help it; they preferred "the godly," or "professors of religion." It was coined in the 1560s by people who found their neighbours' religion tiresome, and it has kept that flavour in English ever since — a Puritan, in ordinary speech, is a person who cannot enjoy anything.

That caricature is worth clearing away at the start, because it is almost the reverse of the truth about what these people were after. Puritanism began as a demand for a fuller experience of God, not a smaller one. Its central texts are about assurance, joy, the presence of the Spirit, and the sanctifying of ordinary work. Its characteristic literary form is not the rulebook but the spiritual diary.

The problem is what happened when that inward demand met an established church, and then a crown. This lecture traces a movement that started with a complaint about clerical dress and ended with a king's head on a block — and then, twelve years after that, with two thousand Puritan ministers ejected from their livings by the church they had failed to reform.

What these 24 minutes give you

  • Explain the "psychology of piety" and covenant thought as the two theological pillars of Puritan spirituality, and describe what each gave the ordinary believer.
  • Describe the liturgical conflict with the Church of England — the vestments controversy, the Prayer Book, and the dispute over church government.
  • Explain how the theory of the divine right of kings collided with the Puritan and covenanting case for resistance, and trace the political outcome.
  • Assess the movement's legacy, including the claims commonly made for its influence on modern political liberty, and say which of those claims the evidence supports.

But Peter and the apostles answered, “We must obey God rather than men." — Acts 5:29

World English Bible

Rejoice always. Pray without ceasing. In everything give thanks, for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus toward you." — 1 Thessalonians 5:16–18

WEB

This one verse does more work in seventeenth-century England than any other. It is the text a minister cites when refused a licence, a text on the scaffold, and eventually a text in a political pamphlet. Notice what it does not say: it does not say the apostles were entitled to depose the council. Whether the step from disobedience to resistance is a short one or a long one is the argument of this lecture.

Three imperatives with no religious setting attached — no temple, no hour, no season. That is the whole Puritan programme of holiness in ordinary life, and it is the reason a Puritan household kept a diary: if the will of God is in everything, then everything is worth examining.

1. The inward engine: assurance and how to test it

Start with a pastoral problem, because that is where starts.

If salvation rests on God's eternal and not on anything you contribute, then the most urgent question a believer can ask is not "what must I do?" but "am I one of them?" And that question cannot be answered by looking upward into the decree. It can only be answered by looking inward, at whether the marks of a changed life are actually present.

William Perkins (1558–1602), a Cambridge preacher and the most widely read English theologian of his generation, made this the centre of a whole practical theology. His Golden Chain (1590) — the English version of a Latin treatise — laid out the as a chain running from election through , , and , and then asked how a person moves through it in real time.

What emerged is often called the psychology of piety: a detailed account of Christian experience, stage by stage, so precise that a believer could locate themselves on it. Conviction of sin. Humiliation. Faith, often weak at first. The beginnings of repentance. The slow work of sanctification. Perkins and his successors — Richard Sibbes, John Preston, Thomas Goodwin, and later Richard Baxter and John Owen — wrote hundreds of pages on how to distinguish real faith from its counterfeits, and how to comfort a believer who could find none of the marks in themselves.

Take the pastoral seriousness of this seriously. These men were not manufacturing anxiety; they were meeting it. Sibbes's The Bruised Reed (1630) is one of the gentlest books in English devotional literature and is entirely occupied with people who believe they are too far gone.

But the method has a shadow, and the sources show it plainly. If assurance is confirmed by self-examination, then self-examination never finishes. The diaries of the period — Samuel Rogers, Nehemiah Wallington and others — record long stretches of genuine spiritual misery in people whose lives were, by any outside measure, exemplary. Wallington attempted his own life more than once. The system built to give assurance could, in a scrupulous temperament, withhold it indefinitely.

That is this chapter's principle in a single life. A doctrine designed to protect the believer's confidence in grace became, for some believers, the instrument by which they lost it.

2. The outward engine: covenant

The second pillar is , and it is what carried Puritan religion out of the closet and into the parish, the household and eventually the state.

Covenant thought — the Reformed system described in lecture 1-1 — did three things in England that it did less dramatically elsewhere.

It made the household a church in miniature. The father catechised, led prayer, examined the children. Puritan literature on household duties is vast, and it is the reason Puritan piety survived periods when Puritan preaching was suppressed: it did not need a pulpit.

It made work a calling. This is the "worldly asceticism" that Max Weber made famous, and Weber's larger thesis about capitalism is heavily disputed, so hold it loosely. But the narrower point stands and is well documented: Puritan writers taught that a shoemaker's bench and a magistrate's court are both places where God is served, which removed the medieval gradation of holy and secular occupations.

It made the nation a covenanting party. If God covenants with a people, then a nation can keep or break covenant, and its magistrates are bound by terms. This is the step with political consequences, and Scotland took it further than England: the National Covenant of 1638 was signed across the country, in some places by crowds in churchyards.

3. The quarrel with the Church of England

Elizabeth I's settlement of 1559 gave England a church that was Reformed in its doctrine and largely traditional in its worship and government. To Elizabeth this was a solution. To the godly it was a job abandoned halfway.

The first open break came over clothes, which sounds absurd until you see what clothes were doing. In the vestments controversy of 1565–66, Archbishop Parker required clergy to wear the surplice and, in cathedrals, the cope. About a third of London's clergy refused and roughly thirty were suspended.

Why fight over linen? Because of a principle. The godly held what later became known as the regulative principle: worship may include what Scripture commands, and nothing else. A vestment with no scriptural warrant is therefore not a neutral custom; it is a human addition to God's worship, and worse, it visibly marks the minister out as a priest of the sort the Reformation had abolished. Their opponents replied, reasonably, that Scripture nowhere legislates clothing, and that things indifferent may lawfully be ordered by the church for decency.

Both arguments are respectable. What made them irreconcilable was that the surplice had become a sign of which side you were on — and once a piece of cloth means that, no argument about cloth can settle it.

The same logic ran through the other disputes. The Book of Common Prayer, required by law, prescribed set forms; the godly wanted preaching and prayer conceived for the occasion. Kneeling to receive communion looked to them like the old adoration of the host. The sign of the cross at baptism, the ring in marriage, saints' days, organs — each a small thing, each a marker.

Then church government. The Church of England was governed by bishops appointed by the crown, which made the monarch effectively head of the church. Presbyterians wanted government by ministers and elders in graded assemblies, as in Scotland and Geneva. Congregationalists — a smaller and more radical party — wanted each gathered congregation to govern itself, and some of them left the country: the group that sailed on the Mayflower in 1620 was of this kind.

Under Charles I and Archbishop William Laud in the 1630s the pressure sharpened. Laud's programme — altars railed at the east end, ceremonial restored, uniformity enforced through the church courts — struck the godly as a march back to Rome. In 1637 three of its critics, William Prynne, Henry Burton and John Bastwick, were sentenced by the court of Star Chamber to be pilloried, fined, imprisoned for life and to have their ears cut off. They were pamphleteers, not rebels.

That same year Laud and the king attempted to impose a new prayer book on Scotland. The result was a riot in St Giles' in Edinburgh, then the National Covenant of 1638, then two wars that Charles lost, then a Parliament he could not do without.

4. Divine right and the case for resistance

The Stuart kings held, and James I published, the doctrine of the divine right of kings: royal authority comes directly from God, the king is answerable to God alone, and subjects may not resist even a bad king — they may only disobey unlawful commands and accept the punishment. James wrote it out in The True Law of Free Monarchies (1598) and repeated it to Parliament.

Understand why it was attractive. Europe in 1600 had recent memories of the French wars of religion, thirty years of massacre and assassination begun by theories of lawful resistance. A doctrine that removes the theological warrant for killing a king was, in that light, a doctrine for peace.

Against it stood a covenanting logic. If the king rules under a covenant with God and with the people, the covenant has terms; a ruler who breaks them may be resisted by the lesser magistrates — Parliament, or the nobility — acting to defend the constitution. This argument was not invented in England. It had been made by Huguenot writers in France after 1572, by Scots including George Buchanan, and by Reformed jurists in Germany. Its fullest English statement is Samuel Rutherford's Lex, Rex (1644): the law is king.

The collision came through money and religion together. Charles ruled for eleven years without calling Parliament and raised revenue by expedients of doubtful legality; the Scottish wars forced him to call one; the Long Parliament that met in 1640 refused to be dismissed. War began in 1642. Oliver Cromwell's New Model Army won it. In January 1649 Charles I was tried by a court his own subjects had constituted, convicted, and beheaded in Whitehall.

Now the part that a triumphalist telling leaves out. The regicide was not a national decision. Parliament had to be purged by the army first — Colonel Pride's soldiers physically excluded around 140 members who would have voted against a trial — leaving a remnant that could produce the verdict. The republic that followed was held together by the army, and Cromwell dissolved by force two parliaments of his own. In Ireland in 1649 his campaign at Drogheda and Wexford killed thousands, including civilians and clergy; the memory of it has shaped Irish politics for three and a half centuries.

And in England itself, the victorious godly did exactly what had been done to them. The Book of Common Prayer was abolished in 1645; using it, even in a private house, was made a punishable offence. Around two thousand clergy who would not conform to the new order were removed from their parishes during the 1640s. Then in 1662, after the monarchy returned, roughly the same number of Puritan ministers were ejected on a single day for refusing the restored Prayer Book.

The symmetry is exact enough to be uncomfortable, and it should be. A movement that began by demanding liberty of conscience for itself did not, when it held power, extend that liberty to others. There were Puritans who saw this — the Independents in the army argued for toleration, John Milton wrote Areopagitica in 1644, and Roger Williams, exiled from Puritan Massachusetts, founded a colony on the principle. They were a minority, and they were arguing against their own side.

5. What the movement left, and what it did not

Something real survives, and it is not mainly political.

The devotional literature outlasted the politics: Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress, written in prison after 1660, has been translated into more languages than any English book except the Bible. The doctrine of vocation changed how ordinary Protestant Christians think about their jobs. The Westminster documents, which lecture 1-4 covers, became the standard of Presbyterian churches on four continents. Puritan preaching shaped the sermon as a form.

The political claim needs handling with more care, because it is where writers on this subject most often overreach. It is frequently said that Puritanism produced modern democracy, constitutional government and religious liberty.

Here is what the evidence will support. The English conflict established, in practice, that a monarch cannot tax or govern without Parliament — a constitutional outcome of the first importance. Puritan covenant thought supplied one of several theological vocabularies in which resistance to a ruler could be justified, and that vocabulary crossed to America and was still audible in 1776. Congregational church government — a gathered body electing its own officers — trained large numbers of ordinary people in something structurally like self-government.

Here is what it will not support. The Puritan regime was not a democracy and did not claim to be; Cromwell ruled as Lord Protector with the army behind him. Religious liberty as we now understand it was argued for by a Puritan minority and by groups the Puritan mainstream persecuted — Baptists, Quakers, and the Independents — and it was secured in England only slowly and largely after Puritan political power had collapsed. And the resistance theory itself was Huguenot and Scottish before it was English.

Too tidy a line

The tidy line from Puritanism to modern liberty is too tidy, and where you find it drawn confidently, someone is usually recruiting the seventeenth century for a present argument. The honest version is messier: this movement contributed one strand among several, and it contributed it partly by failing — by showing, in eleven years of godly rule, that a state church enforcing the true religion produces the same grievances whichever party holds it.


Four Fronts, and What Each One Cost How a dispute about vestments became a dispute about who may rule THE FRONT CROWN AND ESTABLISHED CHURCH THE GODLY Vestments 1565–66 Things indifferent; the church may order them for decency Worship admits only what Scripture commands — a surplice is an addition Prayer Book required by law A common form binds a divided realm into one worship Preaching and free prayer; a set form binds the conscience of the minister Church government bishops or elders Bishops appointed by the crown; the monarch heads the church Ministers and elders in assemblies, or each gathered congregation itself Political authority 1637–1649 Divine right — the king answers to God alone and may not be resisted The ruler is under covenant; lesser magistrates may resist a breach THE COST, ON BOTH SIDES 1637 Prynne, Burton and Bastwick mutilated by Star Chamber · 1645 Prayer Book abolished, its use punishable · 1649 Drogheda and Wexford · c. 2,000 clergy removed in the 1640s · 1662 c. 2,000 Puritan ministers ejected in a single day

Diagram 1. Summary table

The front Crown and established church The godly
Vestments (1565–66) Things indifferent; the church may order them for decency and order Worship admits only what Scripture commands; a surplice is a human addition
The Book of Common Prayer A common form binds a divided realm into one worship Preaching and free prayer; an imposed form binds the minister's conscience
Church government Bishops appointed by the crown; the monarch heads the church Presbyteries of ministers and elders, or self-governing congregations
Political authority Divine right; the king answers to God alone and may not be resisted The ruler stands under covenant; lesser magistrates may resist a breach of it
Where it ended The monarchy restored in 1660; conformity re-imposed in 1662 A king executed in 1649; a republic held together by the army; ejection in 1662

5. Going to the Sources

  • The National Covenant (Scotland, 1638) and the Solemn League and Covenant (1643). Both short. Read them for the language of a nation binding itself, and note how much of each is legal and constitutional rather than devotional.
  • James I, The True Law of Free Monarchies (1598), against Samuel Rutherford, Lex, Rex (1644). Read a few pages of each. James's case is stronger than a modern reader expects, and knowing why is the point of the exercise.
  • Richard Sibbes, The Bruised Reed (1630). Thirty pages will correct the caricature of Puritanism faster than any argument. This is a pastor writing to people who cannot believe they are forgiven.
  • John Milton, Areopagitica (1644). A Puritan arguing against Puritan censorship, in the middle of the Puritan ascendancy. Evidence that the movement contained its own critics.
  • The Act of Uniformity (1662) and accounts of St Bartholomew's Day that year, when the ejected ministers preached their farewell sermons.

In short

  • Puritanism began as a demand for a fuller experience of God. William Perkins and others built a "psychology of piety," a stage-by-stage account of Christian experience, to help believers test whether their faith was real.
  • That method had a shadow: self-examination never finishes, so for scrupulous people, such as Nehemiah Wallington, a doctrine meant to give assurance could withhold it.
  • Covenant thought made the household a small church, made work a calling, and made the nation a party to covenant. It also fed disputes over vestments, the Prayer Book and church government.
  • Divine right of kings (James I) met the covenant case for resistance by lesser magistrates (Rutherford). The result was war and the execution of Charles I in 1649.
  • The godly, once in power, banned the Prayer Book, and about 2,000 Puritan ministers were ejected in 1662. The claim that Puritanism produced modern liberty is too tidy; it was one strand among several.

Topic: This lecture follows the Puritans from a search for assurance and holiness through conflict with the Church of England and the crown, to their legacy.

Remember: Puritanism was an inward demand for a fuller experience of God that grew into a political conflict, and its lasting gifts are mainly devotional, not political.

Caution: Do not accept the caricature of joyless Puritans, nor the confident line from Puritanism to modern democracy. The evidence supports only a limited claim.

One line to carry into ministry: Teach self-examination gently, as Sibbes did, and remember that a church holding power can wrong others as it was once wronged.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • The lecture argues that the surplice became a sign of which side you were on, and that once an object means that, no argument about the object can settle it. Identify something in your own church's life that now functions this way. What would it take to give it back its ordinary meaning?
  • Perkins's method was designed to give believers assurance and, in some temperaments, withheld it. Is there a way to teach self-examination that does not carry this risk, or is the risk built into the doctrine?
  • Read the 1645 abolition of the Prayer Book alongside the 1662 ejection. What, if anything, distinguishes the two acts morally? If you cannot find a distinction, what follows for how a church should use state power when it has it?
  • Which parts of the claim "Puritanism produced modern liberty" do you think the evidence supports, and which parts are a present-day argument borrowing a costume?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.