FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH202E The Church in the Modern World

Lecture 8-1: Edinburgh 1910 and the Making of the World Council of Churches

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 33
CH202E The Church in the Modern World
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Modern Church History Is, and Why It Is Worth Studying
  1. Introduction: What Modern Church History Is, and Why It Is Worth Studying
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Protestant Orthodoxy and the Puritan Movement
  1. Lecture 1-1: Building the System: Lutheran and Reformed Orthodoxy
  2. Lecture 1-2: Arminius, Dort, and the Doctrine of Grace
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Puritans: Holiness, Conscience, and the Crown
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Westminster Assembly and its Catechisms
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Thirty Years War and the Making of Denominations
  1. Lecture 2-1: The War That Discredited Holy War
  2. Lecture 2-2: Westphalia — A Peace Nobody Loved
  3. Lecture 2-3: Denominations — A Word for People You Cannot Destroy
  4. Lecture 2-4: An Errand into the Wilderness
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Pietism and the Great Awakening
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Revolt Against Cold Orthodoxy: Spener and Francke
  2. Lecture 3-2: Zinzendorf, Herrnhut and the Moravian Missions
  3. Lecture 3-3: John Wesley and the Methodists: Grace and Holiness
  4. Lecture 3-4: The First Great Awakening in North America
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Enlightenment and the Challenge of Liberal Theology
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Age of Reason and the Scientific Revolution
  2. Lecture 4-2: Deism and the Search for a God Nobody Has to Fight About
  3. Lecture 4-3: Biblical Criticism and the Quest for the Historical Jesus
  4. Lecture 4-4: Schleiermacher and the Liberal Century
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Missionary Century
  1. Lecture 5-1: William Carey and the Invention of the Missionary Society
  2. Lecture 5-2: Hudson Taylor, the China Inland Mission and the Cost of Going Inland
  3. Lecture 5-3: David Livingstone — Explorer, Abolitionist, Failed Pastor
  4. Lecture 5-4: Missions and Empire — The Argument That Will Not Settle
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Two World Wars and Neo-Orthodoxy
  1. Lecture 6-1: 1914 — The Year the Future Stopped Working
  2. Lecture 6-2: Barth's Romans and the Theology of the Word
  3. Lecture 6-3: The German Christians, the Confessing Church, and Barmen
  4. Lecture 6-4: Bonhoeffer — Costly Grace and Guilty Hands
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Pentecostalism and the Charismatic Renewal
  1. Lecture 7-1: Azusa Street, 1906
  2. Lecture 7-2: Spirit Baptism and Tongues: An Experience Becomes a Doctrine
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Second Wave: Renewal Inside the Old Churches
  4. Lecture 7-4: Why the South Grew
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Ecumenism and Global Christianity
  1. Lecture 8-1: Edinburgh 1910 and the Making of the World Council of Churches
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Second Vatican Council, 1962–1965
  3. Lecture 8-3: Lausanne 1974 — Evangelism, Justice, and What the Covenant Settled
  4. Lecture 8-4: Where the Church Is Now — and How Four Centuries Got Us Here

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

By 1900 the mission field had a problem that was visible to everyone working on it and embarrassing to admit at home. In a single African district you might find four Protestant societies, from four countries, running four schools with four catechisms, teaching converts to distrust each other's version of a faith none of them had held five years earlier. The societies were not enemies. They were simply not talking, and the people paying the price for that were not in Europe.

Edinburgh 1910 was the meeting that began to fix it. It is regularly called the beginning of the modern ecumenical movement, and that is fair — but only if you also say what it was not. It was a conference of Protestant mission agencies, overwhelmingly Western, with almost nobody from the churches those agencies had founded, no Catholic delegation, and a deal on the agenda that kept Latin America off the table altogether.

This lecture follows the line from that room to Amsterdam in 1948, where the World Council of Churches was constituted — and then to the theological idea, missio Dei, that the ecumenical movement reached for once it had an institution to think with.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Explain why Edinburgh 1910 is called the opening of the ecumenical movement, and state clearly who was not in the room and what was kept off its agenda.
  • Distinguish the Life and Work stream from the Faith and Order stream, explain why each thought the other had the priority wrong, and describe how they were brought together.
  • State what the World Council of Churches committed its member churches to in 1948, how the basis was enlarged in 1961, and what the Council expressly declined to be.
  • Explain the concept of *missio Dei*, what it opened up, and why it became the hinge of the dispute that lecture 8-3 takes up.

There is one body, and one Spirit, even as you also were called in one hope of your calling; one Lord, one faith, one baptism," — Ephesians 4:4–5

World English Bible

Read the tense carefully. Paul is not urging his readers to construct unity; he is telling them that unity is already a fact about the body they are in, and that their job is to stop contradicting it. That grammar is what makes division awkward rather than merely regrettable. It also explains why the kept insisting it was not building something new — a claim its critics have never accepted at face value.

1. The room, and the rooms nobody was in

The World Missionary Conference opened in Edinburgh on 14 June 1910. Around 1,200 delegates attended, sent by mission societies rather than by churches, and the atmosphere was one of enormous confidence — this was the generation of the Student Volunteer Movement and its watchword, "the evangelisation of the world in this generation."

Two men made it work. John R. Mott, an American Methodist layman from the YMCA and the Student Volunteer Movement, chaired it; he had a genius for getting rival organisations into one room and keeping them there. J. H. Oldham, a Scot, was the secretary, and did the harder, quieter work — the eight commissions of preparatory research, the questionnaires sent to missionaries across the world, and afterwards the Continuation Committee and the International Review of Missions. Edinburgh's real innovation was not the speeches. It was that it did not disband.

Now the parts of the story that a triumphal telling leaves out.

Almost no delegates came from the churches the conference was discussing. Of roughly 1,200 delegates, something like seventeen or eighteen were from Asia and Africa; the exact figure varies with how you count, and every version of the count is small. The most quoted moment of the conference came from one of them: V. S. Azariah, an Indian who would become the first Indian Anglican bishop, told the delegates that missionaries had given money and labour without limit, and asked them for something else. His closing sentence — asking, in effect, to be given friends — was heard by some in the hall as ingratitude. It was reported home as the most uncomfortable speech of the week.

Latin America was excluded from the agenda. This was not an oversight but the price of a coalition. Anglo-Catholic participation in the conference was secured on the understanding that Edinburgh would treat only missions to the non-Christian world, and that Latin America, being Catholic, did not qualify. North American evangelicals who thought Latin America very much a mission field went away angry, and held their own Congress on Christian Work in Latin America at Panama in 1916. Keep this in view: the first great act of Protestant cooperation was purchased by agreeing not to mention a continent.

Rome was not there, although the Bishop of Rome was not silent about it: a letter from Cardinal Bourne conveyed Catholic good wishes without participation. The Orthodox presence was minimal. So a conference of Western Protestants was, in 1910, capable of itself a world missionary conference — and that fact is itself part of what this chapter is about.

None of this makes Edinburgh a fraud. It makes it a beginning, with the limits of the people who began it.

2. Two convictions, two movements

Edinburgh's energy did not run in one channel. Within fifteen years it had split into two movements that were, in a real sense, arguing with each other about what unity is for.

Life and Work came out of the First World War, and its shape is unintelligible without it. Nathan Söderblom, Lutheran Archbishop of Uppsala, had watched national churches on both sides bless the killing of each other's congregations, and drew the conclusion that waiting for doctrinal agreement before acting together was a luxury Europe could no longer afford. His conference at Stockholm in 1925 worked from a slogan that later became a stick to beat the movement with: doctrine divides, service unites. Life and Work met again at Oxford in 1937, where the mood had darkened considerably — the Oxford conference, meeting under the shadow of the German church struggle, produced the line "let the church be the church," which is not the language of a body indifferent to doctrine.

Faith and Order came from the opposite instinct. Charles Brent, an American Episcopal bishop who had been at Edinburgh, thought cooperation that dodged the doctrinal questions was a truce, not a peace: churches divided over baptism, ministry and the Eucharist would keep re-dividing until they dealt with baptism, ministry and the Eucharist. Faith and Order met at Lausanne in 1927 and Edinburgh in 1937, and, unlike Life and Work, it managed to bring Orthodox delegates into serious conversation.

The two movements each thought the other had the order wrong. Life and Work suspected Faith and Order of theological delay while the world burned. Faith and Order suspected Life and Work of building a coalition on a foundation nobody had inspected. Both suspicions were reasonable, and both movements voted in 1937–38 to merge anyway. A constitution was drafted at Utrecht in 1938 for a World Council of Churches "in process of formation".

Then the war came, and the Council spent seven years existing on paper, run from Geneva by a young Dutchman, W. A. Visser 't Hooft, whose office during those years was also a node in the Dutch resistance's communications.

3. Amsterdam 1948, and what the Council refused to be

The World Council of Churches was constituted at Amsterdam on 23 August 1948, with delegates from 147 churches. Karl Barth preached. The assembly's message contained the sentence the Council has quoted ever since: "We intend to stay together."

Three things about its founding matter more than the date.

First, the basis was deliberately minimal. Member churches were those which "accept our Lord Jesus Christ as God and Saviour". That is a short sentence, and it was short on purpose: broad enough to include churches with irreconcilable views of ministry, narrow enough to exclude bodies that did not confess Christ as God. It was enlarged at New Delhi in 1961 into its present trinitarian form — churches which confess Jesus Christ as God and Saviour "according to the Scriptures" and seek to fulfil their common calling "to the glory of the one God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit." Both the original brevity and the later enlargement were contested at the time.

Second, the Council said what it was not. The Toronto Statement of 1950 is the document to read if you want to be fair to the WCC, and it is routinely ignored by both its defenders and its critics. It states that the Council is not and must not become a super-church; that membership does not imply that a church must regard the other member churches as churches in the full sense of its own doctrine; and that no church is required to change its ecclesiology by joining. That was written largely to make membership possible for Orthodox and high-Anglican bodies, who could not have joined a Council that required them to concede the point at issue. It is also the standing answer to the charge that the WCC was a merger scheme.

Third, the membership did not stay Protestant. The Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople was involved from the start. At New Delhi in 1961 the Russian Orthodox Church and several other Eastern European Orthodox churches joined — a decision inseparable from Cold War politics, and read by critics as Moscow acquiring a platform. At the same assembly the International Missionary Council, Edinburgh's own institutional descendant, was integrated into the WCC as its Commission on World Mission and Evangelism. The three streams of Edinburgh were finally in one channel.

The Roman Catholic Church has never joined and has never applied. It has sent observers since Vatican II, is a full member of the Faith and Order Commission, and works with the WCC in a Joint Working Group. Lecture 8-2 explains why full membership is, from Rome's side, a question about what the Council is rather than about goodwill.

4. Missio Dei: the idea that changed the subject

Now the theology. Once mission had an ecumenical institution, it acquired an ecumenical concept, and the concept turned out to be more disruptive than the institution.

God sends the church

At the International Missionary Council's conference at Willingen in 1952 — convened, not incidentally, in the wake of the expulsion of missionaries from China, which had just demolished a century of assumptions — the German missiologist Karl Hartenstein used the phrase , drawing on a line of thought Karl Barth had opened in 1932. The claim is this: mission is not first an activity of the church. It is an attribute of God. The Father sends the Son; the Father and the Son send the Spirit; and that same sending includes the church, which is therefore not the origin of mission but one of its results.

Two things followed, and they pull in opposite directions.

The constructive consequence is large and, in this course, hard to overstate. If mission is God's and not the church's property, then no denomination owns a mission field, no sending church holds a permanent seniority over a receiving one, and the map of "Christian countries" sending to "heathen countries" loses its theological basis. Much of what the rest of this chapter describes — the dismantling of missionary paternalism, the recognition of the younger churches as churches — was argued through this door.

The risk arrived quickly. If God is at work in the world, and the church merely joins in, then some ecumenical thinkers of the 1960s concluded that the world sets the agenda and the church's job is to discern where God is already acting — in decolonisation, in revolutions, in the movements of the age. J. C. Hoekendijk pushed the argument furthest. At that point the church becomes optional to mission, and it was precisely this that convinced a large body of evangelicals that the ecumenical movement had begun to say something other than the gospel.

This is a point where readers will not agree. The dispute is over whether the WCC's turn towards social and political action from the late 1960s was the gospel's own implication or a replacement for it, and it is not settled. Take the critics' case at full strength first. At the Uppsala assembly in 1968, and still more at the mission conference in Bangkok in 1973 on the theme "Salvation Today", the language of salvation was applied — freely, and often without an accompanying account of sin, conversion and eternal life — to the liberation of the oppressed. Donald McGavran's essay title from that period, asking whether Uppsala would betray the two billion who had never heard of Christ, is the whole objection in one line. The Frankfurt Declaration of 1970, drafted by Peter Beyerhaus, put it formally: if salvation is redefined as humanisation, then mission has been dissolved into politics and the two billion are simply dropped. When the WCC's Programme to Combat Racism, launched in 1969, began making grants to southern African liberation movements, several churches suspended or ended their membership; the argument had become concrete and expensive. Now the Council's own case, also at full strength. Uppsala and Bangkok did not deny personal conversion — Bangkok's report speaks of salvation reaching the individual person, and the WCC's 1982 statement Mission and Evangelism: An Ecumenical Affirmation is unambiguous that the gospel calls for personal decision and that evangelism belongs to the church's essence. The Council's counter-charge is sharper than its critics usually admit: a church in South Africa that preached personal salvation while declining to say anything about apartheid was not being apolitical; it was taking a side quietly. And the call for a moratorium on Western missionaries — the demand that most offended Northern evangelicals — came not from Geneva but from African church leaders, notably John Gatu of Kenya, who argued in 1971 that dependency was preventing African churches from becoming responsible for themselves. Lecture 8-3 takes up the answer Lausanne tried to give. For now, hold both accounts. A student who can only state one of them has not yet understood the argument.

5. What Edinburgh actually left behind

Take the sentimental reading off the table first. Edinburgh did not end denominational competition, and the century that followed produced more Christian denominations than any century before it. Some of that growth came from the very independence the movement had encouraged.

What Edinburgh did was narrower and more durable. It established, first among Protestants and eventually far beyond them, that division is a problem the church has to explain, rather than a condition it may simply inhabit. Before 1910 a mission society could regard other societies as competitors without embarrassment. After 1910 that position needed defending. That is a change in the burden of proof, and burdens of proof are how institutions actually move.

It also produced, by a route nobody at Edinburgh intended, the thing that most undercut Edinburgh's own composition. The Continuation Committee became the International Missionary Council; the International Missionary Council held the Jerusalem meeting of 1928 and the Tambaram meeting of 1938 — and at Tambaram, near Madras, for the first time, delegates from the younger churches of Asia, Africa and Latin America were the majority. Twenty-eight years after a world missionary conference at which they held perhaps seventeen seats.


Three Streams into One Council, 1910–1961 Edinburgh did not create the WCC. It created a committee that refused to disband. Edinburgh 1910 Mott chairs · Oldham organises Life and Work Söderblom · Stockholm 1925 Oxford 1937 Act now; doctrine later Faith and Order Brent · Lausanne 1927 Edinburgh 1937 Settle doctrine, or nothing holds Missionary Council IMC 1921 · Jerusalem 1928 Tambaram 1938 The younger churches, at last Amsterdam 1948 — WCC constituted 147 churches · “We intend to stay together” New Delhi 1961 IMC integrated · basis made trinitarian · Orthodox churches join Toronto 1950 “not a super-church”

Diagram 1. Summary table

Body or moment Date What it settled What it left open
World Missionary Conference, Edinburgh 1910 Cooperation on the field is a duty, not a preference Whose churches count as churches; Latin America off the agenda
Life and Work Stockholm 1925, Oxford 1937 Churches can act together before they agree Whether shared action without shared doctrine holds under pressure
Faith and Order Lausanne 1927, Edinburgh 1937 The doctrinal questions must be worked, not bypassed How long the world is expected to wait
WCC constituted, Amsterdam 1948 A permanent fellowship with a minimal confessional basis What the fellowship may say and do in the world's disputes
Toronto Statement 1950 The Council is not a church and requires no ecclesiology of its members Whether critics would ever accept the disclaimer
New Delhi assembly 1961 Trinitarian basis; IMC integrated; Orthodox membership Whether mission and unity would strengthen or dilute each other

5. Going to the Sources

All of these are short, in English, and available online from the World Council of Churches' own archive.

  • The Toronto Statement, "The Church, the Churches and the World Council of Churches" (1950) — five pages. Read the list of things the Council says it is not, and ask which of the standard criticisms it answers in advance.
  • The Basis of the WCC, in both the 1948 and 1961 forms — set them side by side and ask what the 1961 additions were designed to prevent.
  • The report of Commission I of Edinburgh 1910, "Carrying the Gospel to All the Non-Christian World" — read a few pages of the questionnaire responses from missionaries. The assumptions are visible on the surface, which is what makes it valuable.
  • The Frankfurt Declaration (1970) — two pages. The evangelical objection in its own words, before Lausanne softened its tone.
  • "Mission and Evangelism: An Ecumenical Affirmation" (WCC, 1982) — the Council's own answer to that objection. Read it against Frankfurt and mark the points where they actually agree.

In short

  • Edinburgh 1910 began the modern ecumenical movement, but it was a Western Protestant mission conference. About seventeen of 1,200 delegates came from Asia and Africa, Latin America was off the agenda, and Rome was absent.
  • Life and Work (Söderblom) said doctrine divides and service unites. Faith and Order (Brent) said cooperation without doctrine is only a truce. Each feared the other had the order wrong, and they still merged.
  • The WCC began at Amsterdam in 1948 with a minimal basis, enlarged in 1961. The Toronto Statement of 1950 says it is not a super-church and requires no change of ecclesiology. Rome has never joined.
  • Missio Dei, from Willingen 1952, says mission belongs to God. It undercut paternalism but risked making the church optional. Evangelicals (Frankfurt Declaration) and the WCC (1982 affirmation) disagree over social action and salvation.
  • Edinburgh made division something the church must explain. Tambaram 1938 had a majority from younger churches.

Topic: This lecture traces the line from Edinburgh 1910 to the founding of the World Council of Churches in 1948 and to the idea of missio Dei.

Remember: Edinburgh did not end denominations, but it changed the burden of proof. After 1910, division was a problem the church had to explain, not simply live in.

Caution: Edinburgh was not truly worldwide, and the WCC does not claim to be a church. The dispute over social action and salvation is unsettled, and the lecture asks you to state both sides.

One line to carry into ministry: Treat mission as God's work, not your church's property, while still asking what keeps that claim from making the church unnecessary.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Edinburgh bought its coalition by agreeing to keep Latin America off the agenda. Name a comparable price your own tradition has paid for a partnership, and say whether it was worth it.
  • Life and Work said doctrine divides and service unites; Faith and Order said service without doctrine is a truce, not a peace. Which of these describes your congregation's actual practice, and which describes its official position?
  • State the Frankfurt Declaration's objection so that Peter Beyerhaus would recognise it. Then state the WCC's 1982 answer so that its drafters would recognise it. Which was harder for you?
  • The Toronto Statement insists the WCC is not a church and asks no member to revise its ecclesiology. Is that a real safeguard or a form of words? Give the reason for your answer.
  • If mission belongs first to God and not to the church, what stops that claim from making the church unnecessary? Answer in a sentence you would be willing to defend.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.