Lecture 7-1: Azusa Street, 1906
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: Building the System: Lutheran and Reformed Orthodoxy
- Lecture 1-2: Arminius, Dort, and the Doctrine of Grace
- Lecture 1-3: The Puritans: Holiness, Conscience, and the Crown
- Lecture 1-4: The Westminster Assembly and its Catechisms
- Lecture 2-1: The War That Discredited Holy War
- Lecture 2-2: Westphalia — A Peace Nobody Loved
- Lecture 2-3: Denominations — A Word for People You Cannot Destroy
- Lecture 2-4: An Errand into the Wilderness
- Lecture 3-1: The Revolt Against Cold Orthodoxy: Spener and Francke
- Lecture 3-2: Zinzendorf, Herrnhut and the Moravian Missions
- Lecture 3-3: John Wesley and the Methodists: Grace and Holiness
- Lecture 3-4: The First Great Awakening in North America
- Lecture 4-1: The Age of Reason and the Scientific Revolution
- Lecture 4-2: Deism and the Search for a God Nobody Has to Fight About
- Lecture 4-3: Biblical Criticism and the Quest for the Historical Jesus
- Lecture 4-4: Schleiermacher and the Liberal Century
- Lecture 5-1: William Carey and the Invention of the Missionary Society
- Lecture 5-2: Hudson Taylor, the China Inland Mission and the Cost of Going Inland
- Lecture 5-3: David Livingstone — Explorer, Abolitionist, Failed Pastor
- Lecture 5-4: Missions and Empire — The Argument That Will Not Settle
- Lecture 6-1: 1914 — The Year the Future Stopped Working
- Lecture 6-2: Barth's Romans and the Theology of the Word
- Lecture 6-3: The German Christians, the Confessing Church, and Barmen
- Lecture 6-4: Bonhoeffer — Costly Grace and Guilty Hands
- Lecture 7-1: Azusa Street, 1906
- Lecture 7-2: Spirit Baptism and Tongues: An Experience Becomes a Doctrine
- Lecture 7-3: The Second Wave: Renewal Inside the Old Churches
- Lecture 7-4: Why the South Grew
The most consequential Christian meeting of the twentieth century took place in a building that had been a stable. There were plank benches, nail kegs to sit on, and a shoebox on the wall for offerings. There was no announced order of service and no raised pulpit; the preacher often sat behind a pair of stacked wooden crates with his head inside the top one, praying, while the meeting went on around him.
This lecture asks why anybody was there, and why what happened there travelled. Both questions have ordinary historical answers. People were there because a whole strand of nineteenth-century Protestantism had spent fifty years teaching them to expect a second, decisive encounter with God after conversion, and had not told them what it would look like when it came. It travelled because a poor congregation with a mailing list and a print shop happened to be sitting on the American railway network at the moment the transatlantic missionary movement was at its height.
The lecture also has an uncomfortable second half. Azusa Street was interracial at a moment when almost nothing in American public life was. Within twenty years the movement it started was as segregated as everything around it. Both of those sentences are true, and a course that prints only one of them is not teaching history.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Explain how the Holiness movement's teaching of a "second blessing" created both the appetite and the vocabulary that Pentecostalism would use, and note the difference between its Wesleyan and Keswick wings.
- Describe what happened at Charles Parham's school in Topeka in 1901, and explain why Parham's own theory of tongues mattered for what came next.
- Describe how the Azusa meetings crossed the colour line under William J. Seymour, what that cost, and what happened to it within twenty years.
- Trace how the revival spread through print, rail and missionary networks — and state why "everything came from Azusa" is too simple.
But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you. You will be witnesses to me in Jerusalem, in all Judea and Samaria, and to the uttermost parts of the earth.”" — Acts 1:8
World English Bible
This was the movement's founding text, and it is worth noticing what it actually promises. The promise is power for a purpose: the sentence does not stop at the receiving. Almost every argument in this chapter — including the arguments Pentecostals had with each other — turns on how tightly the first half of that verse is tied to the second.
1. The appetite came first
Nothing in 1906 would have made sense to the people in that room without the fifty years behind it.
Through the nineteenth century, a large part of English-speaking Protestantism had come to expect that conversion was not the end of the story. In Methodism this was Wesley's own teaching of entire : a second definite work of grace in which the disposition to sin is dealt with, not merely resisted. Camp meetings, the National Camp Meeting Association for the Promotion of Holiness founded in 1867, and a vast periodical literature kept the expectation alive and gave it a name: the second blessing.
A second wing developed alongside it, associated with the Keswick Convention in England from 1875 and with figures such as Reuben A. Torrey and A. B. Simpson in America. Keswick was more Reformed in instinct and less confident that sin could be eradicated in this life. It therefore shifted the emphasis: the second work is not chiefly cleansing but enduement with power for service, and the phrase it liked was "baptism with the Holy Spirit."
Hold those two together and you have the raw material. From the Wesleyan wing, the conviction that a second crisis is normal Christian experience. From the Keswick wing, the specific language of and power. What neither wing supplied was a test. If a second blessing is available and you are meant to seek it, how do you know when you have received it? Thousands of serious people were praying for something they could not identify.
That is the gap Pentecostalism filled, and it explains a great deal about why the answer it gave took the form of a visible sign.
2. Topeka, 1901: the answer arrives, with a theory attached
Charles Fox Parham was a former Methodist minister running a short-lived school called Bethel Bible College in a rented house in Topeka, Kansas. In late 1900 he set his students a study assignment: work through the book of Acts and identify the biblical evidence of the baptism of the Holy Spirit. The students reported back that in Acts the sign was tongues. Parham agreed. On or about 1 January 1901, a student named Agnes Ozman spoke in what those present took to be a language she had not learned. Within days others had done the same, Parham included.
Two things about Parham shaped everything that followed, and they pull in opposite directions.
The first is his theory of what tongues were. Parham believed they were xenolalia — real, identifiable human languages, given supernaturally so that missionaries could preach abroad without spending years on grammar. This was not an eccentric fantasy; it was an entirely reasonable reading of Acts 2, where the crowd hears its own languages. It also made the doctrine testable, and within a few years it failed the test. Pentecostal missionaries went to India, China, Japan and West Africa expecting to be understood, and were not. The movement had to revise. Lecture 7-2 follows that revision, which is one of the more honest episodes in its history.
The second is Parham's racism, which is not a detail. When William Seymour came to his short-term Bible school in Houston in late 1905, Parham had him listen to lectures from outside the room or from a chair in the hallway, in keeping with Texas segregation and with Parham's own convictions. Parham travelled to Los Angeles in the autumn of 1906 expecting to take charge of the revival his teaching had helped produce, was appalled by the sight of black and white worshippers together, denounced the meetings in explicitly racial terms, and was shown the door. In the 1920s he spoke publicly in favour of the Ku Klux Klan.
So the doctrine and the practice came into the world already at odds. The man who formulated Pentecostalism's distinctive teaching rejected the meeting that made it famous, and rejected it on grounds of race.
3. Bonnie Brae Street and 312 Azusa
William Joseph Seymour was born in Centerville, Louisiana, in 1870, to parents who had been enslaved. He lost the sight of one eye to smallpox. He was largely self-educated, had moved north and worked as a waiter, had been shaped by the Holiness movement in Cincinnati, and by 1905 was preaching where he could.
Early in 1906 a woman named Neely Terry, who had heard him in Houston, recommended him to a small Holiness mission in Los Angeles led by Julia Hutchins. He arrived in February. He preached that tongues is the evidence of Spirit baptism — a doctrine he had not yet experienced himself. Hutchins padlocked the door of the mission against him.
He was taken in by the Asberry family at 214 North Bonnie Brae Street, where a prayer meeting formed in the front room. On 9 April 1906, several of those present spoke in tongues; Seymour himself did so a few days later. The crowds outgrew the house — the porch reportedly gave way — and the group rented a dilapidated two-storey building at 312 Azusa Street, a former African Methodist Episcopal chapel that had since served as a stable and warehouse.
The meetings ran, more or less daily and often for most of the day and night, for about three years. On 18 April, nine days after the Bonnie Brae outbreak, the San Francisco earthquake killed thousands four hundred miles up the coast, and Los Angeles read the newspapers with the meetings in mind. Whatever one makes of that, it is a fact about how the revival was received: it began in a city that had just been given a reason to think the end was near.
4. The colour line, and what happened to it
Frank Bartleman, a white Holiness writer who attended, left the sentence the movement has quoted ever since: "The color line was washed away in the blood." It is a witness's phrase, not a statistic, and it should be read as one. But the substance behind it is well attested, including by people who disliked it. Black, white, Mexican and some Asian worshippers were in the same room. Women prayed over men and men over women. Nobody had assigned seating. In Los Angeles in 1906, with segregation law and custom hardening across the country, that was the most conspicuous thing about the meetings — which is why hostile reports kept mentioning it.
The leadership matters too. Seymour did not preside in the ordinary sense. Testimony, song, prayer and preaching arose from the floor; his authority was moral rather than procedural. That has been described as chaos, and sometimes it was. It was also the mechanism by which a poor black congregation could host white visitors without the usual hierarchy reasserting itself the moment anyone stood up.
Now the second half of the sentence.
Within a decade the American movement had sorted itself by race, and it did so along the ordinary fault lines of American life rather than any theological one. Charles Harrison Mason, a black Holiness preacher, came to Azusa in 1907 and took the experience back to Memphis, where his Church of God in Christ became the largest black Pentecostal body in the United States. Because COGIC was legally incorporated and could ordain, hundreds of white ministers took credentials from Mason's hand between 1907 and 1914. In April 1914 a group of white ministers met at Hot Springs, Arkansas, and formed the Assemblies of God. The new fellowship had real organisational reasons for existing — missionary finance, doctrinal definition, legal standing. It was also, in practice, white, and it drew white ministers out of a black-led body. In the Oneness wing the same thing happened slightly later: the Pentecostal Assemblies of the World remained interracial for longer, and in 1924 most of its white ministers withdrew.
By the middle of the century the separation was institutional. The Pentecostal Fellowship of North America, founded in 1948 as the movement's umbrella body, was entirely white for forty-six years.
And then, in October 1994, at a meeting in Memphis, the PFNA dissolved itself and reconstituted as a body including the black denominations, adopted a "Racial Reconciliation Manifesto," and staged an act of foot-washing between white and black leaders — an event immediately named "the Memphis Miracle," and just as immediately questioned by those who noted that repentance in a ceremony is cheaper than repentance in a budget.
Draw the line and look at it: 1906 integrated, 1914 and 1924 separated, 1994 formally repented. That is eighty-eight years. The movement did not simply fail here; it also did something most of American Protestantism has not done at all. Both halves of that are the record.
5. How it travelled — and why "it all came from Azusa" is too simple
Seymour published a paper, The Apostolic Faith, from the mission. It was free, and at its height it went to somewhere in the region of fifty thousand addresses. It carried testimonies, sermon notes, and instructions on seeking the baptism. That mailing list was the movement's real infrastructure — a fact underlined in 1908, when Clara Lum, who managed the paper, moved to Portland and took the subscription lists with her. Seymour never recovered the reach.
Around the paper ran two other networks that already existed. The American rail system meant a Holiness preacher in Indiana could be in Los Angeles in four days and home again with a story. And the Anglo-American missionary movement, at its peak in exactly these years, had thousands of people in transit who stopped in Los Angeles, went into the meetings, and carried what they found to Liverpool, Oslo, Valparaíso, Calcutta and Shanghai. Thomas Ball Barratt, a Methodist in Norway, received the experience in New York in 1906 and became the channel into Scandinavia and, through it, much of northern Europe. Willis Hoover, a Methodist missionary in Chile, read the reports and by 1909 was leading a revival in Valparaíso that produced the Iglesia Metodista Pentecostal.
Many starting points
Here is where to be careful. It is very tempting to draw one arrow out of a stable on Azusa Street and let it fan out across the world, and the tidiness of that picture should make you suspicious — it is our diagram, not history's.
Pandita Ramabai's Mukti Mission at Kedgaon in western India saw a revival with weeping, confession and tongues beginning in 1905, before Azusa, with no dependence on it. The great Korean revival centred on Pyongyang came in 1907 out of its own history. In West Africa, the Liberian prophet William Wadé Harris walked through the Ivory Coast and the Gold Coast in 1913–15 and baptised converts by the tens of thousands with no Pentecostal denominational connection whatever; the Aladura churches of Nigeria and the prophet-healing churches of southern Africa grew from local soil. Historians of the movement now generally describe its origins as polycentric: several places, at roughly the same time, reaching for similar things out of similar conditions.
Azusa Street's real distinction is not that it was first. It is that it was the best-connected — a poor congregation that happened to hold a printing press, a mailing list and a railway junction, at a moment when a great many people were already looking for exactly what it claimed to have.
6. What the lecture is claiming
The respectable churches of 1906 did not fail to notice the Azusa meetings. They noticed and declined. The Los Angeles Times mocked them; established Holiness leaders repudiated them; Parham, who had supplied the doctrine, walked out over the sight of the congregation. The reasons given were about theology and order. The reasons operating were also about class, education and colour, and everyone involved knew it.
Whatever else it is, this is a chapter about who gets to be taken seriously. The judgment made in 1906 was that these people did not matter. It was wrong on a scale that is now difficult to overstate.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Stage | What happened | Why it mattered |
|---|---|---|
| Background | Holiness teaching of a second blessing; Keswick language of Spirit baptism and power | Created a large public expecting a second experience, with no agreed way to identify it |
| Trigger | Topeka, January 1901: Parham's students conclude tongues is the evidence; Agnes Ozman speaks | Supplied the missing test — and attached a theory of tongues as foreign languages that would fail |
| Ignition | Bonnie Brae Street and 312 Azusa, April 1906, under William J. Seymour | Interracial worship in a segregated city; three years of daily meetings; a movement with a centre |
| Transmission | The Apostolic Faith, the rail network, missionaries in transit | Reached Norway, Chile, India and West Africa within three years without any mission board |
| Correction | Mukti (1905), Pyongyang (1907), Harris (1913–15), the Aladura churches | Origins were polycentric; Azusa was the best-connected node, not the only source |
5. Going to the Sources
- The Apostolic Faith, Los Angeles, September 1906 – 1908. The complete run is available in digitised form from several Pentecostal archives. Read the first issue and notice what is and is not there: testimonies from named individuals, no denominational apparatus, and repeated insistence that the meetings are for everyone.
- "Weird Babel of Tongues," Los Angeles Times, 18 April 1906. One page. The best short document on what respectable opinion thought it was looking at, and how much of the objection was about race and class.
- Frank Bartleman, How Pentecost Came to Los Angeles (1925). An eyewitness, a partisan, and an unusually candid one — he also records the movement's early quarrels. Read it as testimony, not as a chronicle.
- The Racial Reconciliation Manifesto (Memphis, October 1994). Short, public, and worth reading beside the 1914 and 1924 minutes it is answering.
In short
- Holiness teaching expected a second blessing after conversion. The Wesleyan wing stressed cleansing, and the Keswick wing stressed power for service. Neither gave a test for recognising it.
- At Parham's school in Topeka in 1901, students concluded that tongues is the sign of Spirit baptism. Parham thought tongues were real foreign languages for missionaries, a theory that failed, and he was also a racist.
- Under William Seymour, the Azusa meetings from 1906 joined black, white, Mexican and some Asian worshippers. Within two decades the American movement had divided by race, and in 1994 the Memphis meeting repented formally.
- The Apostolic Faith paper, the rail network and missionaries in transit carried the revival abroad, to Norway and Chile among other places.
- Origins were polycentric. Mukti, Pyongyang, William Wadé Harris and the Aladura churches arose on their own, so Azusa was the best-connected node, not the only source.
Topic: This lecture explains why Pentecostalism arose at Azusa Street in 1906, how it spread, and what happened to its interracial worship.
Remember: Azusa was interracial in 1906, separated by 1914 and 1924, and formally repented in 1994. The lecture insists on printing the whole record, not half of it.
Caution: Do not say everything came from Azusa. The lecture calls that too simple and says the movement began in several places at about the same time.
One line to carry into ministry: Tell the whole story of your tradition, including where it failed, and ask who today has no access to the networks that carry a movement.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- The Holiness movement taught people to expect a second decisive experience but gave them no way to recognise it. How much of Pentecostalism's distinctive doctrine is explained by that gap, and what does that suggest about how doctrines get formed?
- Parham formulated the teaching and rejected the revival on grounds of race. What should a movement do with a founder like that — and what have you seen your own tradition do with an equivalent figure?
- The lecture insists on printing both 1906 and 1924. Which of the two is your tradition more likely to quote, and why?
- If Azusa's real advantage was a mailing list, a railway and a moment, what is the equivalent infrastructure today — and who currently has no access to it?