Lecture 5-3: David Livingstone — Explorer, Abolitionist, Failed Pastor
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: Building the System: Lutheran and Reformed Orthodoxy
- Lecture 1-2: Arminius, Dort, and the Doctrine of Grace
- Lecture 1-3: The Puritans: Holiness, Conscience, and the Crown
- Lecture 1-4: The Westminster Assembly and its Catechisms
- Lecture 2-1: The War That Discredited Holy War
- Lecture 2-2: Westphalia — A Peace Nobody Loved
- Lecture 2-3: Denominations — A Word for People You Cannot Destroy
- Lecture 2-4: An Errand into the Wilderness
- Lecture 3-1: The Revolt Against Cold Orthodoxy: Spener and Francke
- Lecture 3-2: Zinzendorf, Herrnhut and the Moravian Missions
- Lecture 3-3: John Wesley and the Methodists: Grace and Holiness
- Lecture 3-4: The First Great Awakening in North America
- Lecture 4-1: The Age of Reason and the Scientific Revolution
- Lecture 4-2: Deism and the Search for a God Nobody Has to Fight About
- Lecture 4-3: Biblical Criticism and the Quest for the Historical Jesus
- Lecture 4-4: Schleiermacher and the Liberal Century
- Lecture 5-1: William Carey and the Invention of the Missionary Society
- Lecture 5-2: Hudson Taylor, the China Inland Mission and the Cost of Going Inland
- Lecture 5-3: David Livingstone — Explorer, Abolitionist, Failed Pastor
- Lecture 5-4: Missions and Empire — The Argument That Will Not Settle
- Lecture 6-1: 1914 — The Year the Future Stopped Working
- Lecture 6-2: Barth's Romans and the Theology of the Word
- Lecture 6-3: The German Christians, the Confessing Church, and Barmen
- Lecture 6-4: Bonhoeffer — Costly Grace and Guilty Hands
- Lecture 7-1: Azusa Street, 1906
- Lecture 7-2: Spirit Baptism and Tongues: An Experience Becomes a Doctrine
- Lecture 7-3: The Second Wave: Renewal Inside the Old Churches
- Lecture 7-4: Why the South Grew
David Livingstone is the hardest person in this chapter to write about, because three true descriptions of him will not sit comfortably in one paragraph.
He was the most determined European opponent of the East African slave trade in his generation, and his reporting of it did more than anyone's to close the Zanzibar market. He was, by the ordinary measure of his own profession, a failure: in more than thirty years in Africa he baptised one convert, and that convert was suspended from communion within months. And after his death he became the most useful symbol the British Empire had for the proposition that Africa needed opening — a proposition that supplied moral cover for a partition of the continent he would probably have hated.
There is a version of this lecture that keeps only the first description. There is another that keeps only the third. Both are shorter and both are wrong. The point of studying Livingstone is that he is where the whole argument of this chapter becomes personal: a man who genuinely hated what empire did to Africans, who genuinely believed that European commerce and European civilisation were the cure, and whose life was then used to justify what he had opposed.
This lecture also puts names to the Africans in the story, beginning with the man usually described as Livingstone's failure — Sechele, chief of the Bakwena — and ending with Chuma and Susi, who carried his body a thousand miles.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Explain why Livingstone abandoned station-based mission for continuous travel, and what he thought exploration was for.
- Set out the 3C strategy — Christianity, commerce, civilisation — as its author meant it, and identify the assumption inside it that later events falsified.
- Explain the structure of the nineteenth-century East African slave trade, why Livingstone treated its abolition as a Christian obligation, and how he argued the case.
- Describe what happened to Livingstone's reputation and his maps after 1873, and assess his legacy for African Christianity in both its columns.
He said to them, "Go into all the world, and preach the Good News to the whole creation." — Mark 16:15
World English Bible
A note you should have. This verse sits in the "longer ending" of Mark, verses 9 to 20, which is absent from the two oldest complete Greek manuscripts and is printed with a marginal note in nearly every modern edition, Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant alike. Livingstone's generation had no such doubts about it and preached from it constantly. It is worth knowing, when you meet a text used as the charter of an entire movement, how the text itself stands.
The command it carries is not in doubt; it appears in Matthew, in Luke and in Acts on firmer ground. What this course asks you to notice is a different thing: what "all the world" meant to the people who quoted it in 1850, and how much geography, commerce and empire had already been packed into the phrase before anyone opened the Bible.
1. From the mill floor
Livingstone was born in 1813 in Blantyre, near Glasgow, into a family of seven living in a single room in a tenement built for cotton-mill workers. He went into the mill at ten as a piecer, tying broken threads, on a shift that ran from six in the morning to eight at night. He propped a book on the spinning jenny and read it in fragments as he worked, then went to the company school afterwards. He later paid his own way through medical and theological study in Glasgow and London.
This background matters for two reasons. It explains his physical durability, which was extraordinary. And it explains something about his politics: he had been industrial labour, and he never developed the confident contempt for working people that came easily to many of his contemporaries. He extended that, incompletely but genuinely, to Africans. His journals argue repeatedly that African communities are intelligent, governed, and capable — an unremarkable claim now, a contested one then.
He was accepted by the London Missionary Society, arrived at the Cape in 1841, and travelled north to Kuruman, the station of Robert Moffat, whose daughter Mary he married in 1845. Moffat's model was the settled station: a mission compound, a school, a church, a slow gathering of a congregation. Livingstone tried it and could not stand it.
His stated reason is the famous one. From a ridge in the north he reported seeing "the smoke of a thousand villages where no missionary had ever been." Whether he ever wrote that sentence in that form is uncertain — versions of it circulate that are probably compressions by his publicists — but the impulse is documented all through the journals. He believed that a missionary who spent thirty years building one congregation while a continent went unvisited had made an arithmetical error.
There is a less flattering reason too, and the sources support it: Livingstone was a difficult colleague, impatient with committees, poor at sustained cooperation, and happier alone or with African companions than with other Europeans. Both reasons are true at once. and temperament are rarely separable.
2. The 3C strategy, and the assumption inside it
Livingstone's programme is usually summarised as three words: Christianity, commerce and civilisation. He set it out most publicly in December 1857 at the Senate House in Cambridge, at the end of a speech that ended by asking his hearers to carry on the work he had begun of opening a path for commerce and Christianity. The lecture produced, within a year, the Universities' Mission to Central Africa.
The logic runs like this, and it is worth reconstructing carefully rather than dismissing.
Central Africa's most destructive economic fact, Livingstone argued, was the slave trade. It was not a marginal abuse; it was the region's main export industry, and it worked by making raiding profitable, which made war profitable, which made settled agriculture and settled anything else impossible. Preaching into that, he thought, was pouring water into a broken jar. You cannot ask a village to receive the gospel while its ordinary expectation is that it will be raided within the decade.
So: replace the trade. Find the rivers, map the routes, and give the interior a legitimate export — ivory, cotton, sugar — with a route to the coast that did not run through a slave caravan. Legitimate commerce would then make slaving unprofitable, stable communities would follow, and the missionary would have somewhere to work. "Civilisation," in this sequence, meant literacy, medicine, agriculture and the rule of law.
Two things about this.
The first is that it was not naive about self-interest. Livingstone deliberately addressed British commercial appetite, because he judged that Britain would act against slavery for profit when it would not act for conscience. He was, in effect, trying to steer greed. Anyone who has ever written a funding proposal in language the funder wants to hear knows the manoeuvre.
The second is that the assumption underneath it was wrong, and events proved it wrong within his own lifetime and after. Livingstone assumed European commerce would displace slaving and stop there. What European commerce actually did, once the rivers were mapped, was arrive with claims. The Zambezi expedition he led from 1858 to 1864 — government-funded, government-recalled — is the small-scale version of the failure: the Zambezi turned out to be unnavigable at the Cabora Bassa rapids, the venture achieved nothing it set out to do, his colleagues resigned in sequence, and his wife Mary died of fever at Shupanga in 1862. The large-scale version came after 1884, when the same maps served the partition of Africa.
The step from "commerce will end slaving" to "commerce and conquest will arrive together" is the one Livingstone did not see. It is fair to say he was wrong about it. It is not fair to say he wanted what came.
3. The open sore
Livingstone's attack on slavery is the part of his record that stands without qualification, and it is the part most likely to be unfamiliar to readers who know only the explorer.
The trade he encountered was not the Atlantic system. It was the East African trade, run largely by Swahili and Arab merchants under the Sultanate of Zanzibar, with Portuguese participation in the south, exporting captives north and east to Arabia, Persia and the Indian Ocean islands, and using enslaved labour on the clove plantations of Zanzibar and Pemba itself. It expanded through the nineteenth century even as the Atlantic trade was being suppressed.
Livingstone's method was documentation. He travelled with the caravans, counted, described, named the merchants, and wrote it down in unbearable detail. The single most consequential passage in his journals is his account of the massacre at Nyangwe on the Lualaba in July 1871, where he watched armed slavers open fire on a crowded riverside market and estimated hundreds of people, mostly women, shot or drowned. He could do nothing. The dispatch describing it reached Britain and did more political damage to the Zanzibar trade than a decade of parliamentary speeches.
He called the trade the open sore of the world and said he would not be satisfied until it was healed. The theological argument he attached to it is simple and he made it repeatedly: human beings bear the , and an economy built on selling them is not a regrettable custom but a standing blasphemy. He drew no line between preaching that and preaching the gospel; to him they were one message.
In 1873 the Sultan of Zanzibar, under British naval pressure, closed the slave market and banned the seaborne trade. Livingstone died in the same year, and the Anglican cathedral in Zanzibar was subsequently built on the market site, with the altar reportedly where the whipping post had stood. Cause and effect here are genuinely tangled — British anti-slavery policy had many drivers, and naval and diplomatic pressure had been building for decades — but no serious account of the closure leaves Livingstone's reporting out of it.
Note also who is not simply a victim in this story. The suppression of the East African trade involved African rulers and communities who resisted the raiders, converts who left the caravans, and freed captives who became the first generation of Christians in several regions. The Universities' Mission's first African clergy included men freed from slave ships. The history is not Europeans acting upon Africans; it is a fight with African participants on both sides of it.
4. One convert: Sechele of the Bakwena
Now the failure, and it deserves more than a sentence, because the usual telling of it is condescending.
Sechele I (c. 1812–1892) was kgosi — chief — of the Bakwena, in what is now Botswana. Livingstone settled near him in 1845. Sechele learned to read in a matter of weeks, read the Bible for himself, was baptised in 1848, and preached to his own people.
Then the difficulty. Sechele had five wives, from families whose alliances held his chiefdom together. Livingstone required him to dismiss four of them, which he did — an act with real political and human costs to the women and their families that the mission's arithmetic did not register. Within a few months Sechele resumed relations with one of the dismissed wives, Makhari, and she became pregnant. Livingstone suspended him from communion and, not long afterwards, left.
That is where the standard account stops: the great missionary's single convert, lapsed. What follows is more interesting.
Sechele did not stop being a Christian. He continued to read the Bible, to hold services, and to preach — and over the following forty years he presided over the conversion of a large part of the Bakwena and used his position to spread Christianity across neighbouring peoples, on terms he set, in a form that did not require any of them to become European. The historian Neil Parsons has argued that Sechele did more to evangelise that region than Livingstone ever did, and the demographic record is hard to read any other way.
So who failed? By the mission's rules, Sechele failed a test of monogamy. By the outcome the mission said it wanted — a self-governing, self-propagating African church — Sechele succeeded and the mission's rules were the obstacle. This is not an argument that the missionaries were wrong about marriage; the question of polygamy and baptism was genuinely hard and African Christians themselves have disagreed about it ever since, and still do. It is an argument that the missionary's ledger and God's are not obviously the same ledger, and that the story told as "one convert who lapsed" was written by people who were not counting what was actually happening.
5. Ilala, and the uses of a dead man
Livingstone spent his last years searching for the source of the Nile, in poor health, largely out of contact, and dependent on the very slave caravans he denounced for supplies — a compromise he recorded in his journal with disgust at himself. In May 1873 he died at Chitambo's village in Ilala, in present-day Zambia, apparently while kneeling by his bed.
What his African companions then did is the most remarkable event in this lecture. James Chuma and Abdullah Susi, who had been with him for years, together with about sixty others, buried his heart and viscera under a tree, dried and preserved the body, wrapped it, and carried it overland for roughly nine months and a thousand miles to Bagamoyo on the coast, through territory where carrying a corpse invited both disease and hostility. They also carried his papers and instruments, intact.
They did this without supervision, without pay in advance, and with no obligation anyone could have enforced. The body reached London and was buried in Westminster Abbey in April 1874. Chuma and Susi attended. Then they largely disappeared from the story that the abbey's floor tells.
Hold the two halves of what happened next.
What his death did for African Christianity was real. The publicity produced a wave of missionary recruitment — the Scottish missions in Nyasaland, named Livingstonia and Blantyre after him, the expansion of the UMCA, and the arrival of missions in Uganda and around Lake Tanganyika. Those missions trained the men and women who became the first African clergy, teachers and, eventually, nationalists across a wide belt of the continent. John Chilembwe, whom we meet again in 5-4, came out of that Nyasaland mission world.
What his death did for the empire was also real, and it was not what he intended. Livingstone had made "opening Africa" a moral cause with a martyr attached. Within eleven years of his funeral, the Berlin Conference of 1884–85 had set the rules for the partition of the continent, and the anti-slavery argument was used explicitly in its — by Leopold II of Belgium above all, who founded an association with a humanitarian name and proceeded to run the Congo Free State as a forced-labour regime that killed on a scale historians still argue about. Livingstone's maps, his prestige and his cause were all put to work in that.
He does not get the blame for it. He does get the lesson: a you make in public becomes an instrument in other people's hands, and you do not get to choose whose.
Diagram 1. Three Livingstones, one man
| Description | The evidence for it | What it does not excuse or erase |
|---|---|---|
| Abolitionist | Nyangwe dispatch; years of documentation; the theological case from the image of God; Zanzibar market closed 1873 | Nothing. This part of the record stands. |
| Failed pastor and colleague | One baptism in thirty years, suspended; the Zambezi expedition's collapse; colleagues resigning; Mary Livingstone's death at Shupanga | That his judgement of what mission required was not obviously wrong, only unproven by his own results |
| Imperial symbol | Maps and prestige used after 1884; anti-slavery rhetoric repurposed by Leopold II; Westminster Abbey burial as national myth | That he did not intend it, and that the missions his death produced also trained the men who ended colonial rule |
5. Going to the Sources
- David Livingstone, Missionary Travels and Researches in South Africa (1857) — the book that made him famous, and the one he wrote to persuade. Read a chapter for the argument and then read his descriptions of African communities; they are the evidence for what he actually thought of the people he lived among.
- The Livingstone Online project — his field diaries and letters, digitised with transcriptions, including manuscripts written on scraps of newspaper in berry ink. The 1871 Field Diary containing the Nyangwe account is there, and the difference between the diary and the published version is worth an hour of anyone's time.
- The 1857 Cambridge Senate House address — printed in several collections. This is the 3C argument at its most compressed and its most political.
- The General Act of the Berlin Conference (1885) — read the articles on the suppression of slavery and on the protection of missionaries, and ask what work that language is doing in a treaty partitioning a continent.
In short
- Livingstone left the settled mission station for continuous travel, believing one congregation for thirty years was an arithmetical error. The lecture adds that he was also a difficult colleague, and both reasons are true.
- His 3C plan (Christianity, commerce, civilisation) aimed to replace the slave trade with lawful trade. The wrong assumption was that commerce would displace slaving and stop there. After 1884 the same maps served partition.
- He opposed the East African slave trade by documentation, notably the Nyangwe massacre of 1871. He argued that people bear the image of God, and his reporting helped close Zanzibar's market in 1873.
- Sechele I, his one convert, was suspended over his wives, yet went on to spread Christianity among the Bakwena for forty years. By the mission's rules he failed, but by its stated aim he succeeded.
- Chuma and Susi carried Livingstone's body and papers about a thousand miles to the coast, and then largely vanished from the story.
- His death brought a recruitment wave and missions that trained African leaders. It also gave the empire a moral cause, which Leopold II used. A public argument can be captured, though Livingstone is not blamed.
Topic: This lecture looks at Livingstone as abolitionist, failed pastor and imperial symbol, and names the Africans who shaped his story.
Remember: Livingstone's attack on slavery stands without qualification, but his belief that commerce would end slaving and stop there was wrong, and his cause was later used for partition.
Caution: Do not keep only one of the three descriptions of him. The lecture also does not blame him for the partition, and it says polygamy and baptism are a question on which African Christians disagree.
One line to carry into ministry: Count what is actually happening, and name the people your church's story usually leaves out.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Livingstone deliberately framed his appeal in commercial terms because he judged that Britain would act on profit where it would not act on conscience. Was that wisdom or a category error? What is the equivalent temptation for a mission agency writing a funding case today?
- By the mission's rules Sechele failed. By the outcome the mission said it wanted, he succeeded. What does that gap tell you about how churches count?
- Chuma and Susi carried a body a thousand miles and then left the story. What would have to change about how a church keeps records for people like them to remain in it?
- Livingstone's public argument was taken up by people who used it for ends he opposed. Is there a way to make a moral case in public that cannot be captured this way — or is the risk simply the price of speaking?