Lecture 6-1: Forgiveness, Reconciliation and Trust
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
- Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
- Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
- Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
- Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
- Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
- Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
- Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
- Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
- Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
- Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
- Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
- Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
- Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
- Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
- Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
- Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
- Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
- Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
After a conflict has been named, argued over and, in some way, brought to an end, a quiet question remains in the room: "Are we all right now?" People answer that question with one word. "Yes, we have forgiven each other." Or "No, I cannot forgive." Or "We are reconciled." Or "I just don't trust them any more."
Those four sentences use three different words as if they were one. Forgiveness, reconciliation and trust are three different things. They do not arrive together, they do not need the same people, and they do not have the same price. A community that does not separate them will do harm in two ways. It will press people to feel something that cannot be commanded, and it will tell people they have "forgiven" when they have only gone quiet.
This lecture sets the three side by side. It says what each one is, what each one is not, and how each is related to accountability. It also says plainly, at the point where it matters most, that no one who has been harmed is pressed to reconcile.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Define forgiveness, reconciliation and trust, and say who is needed for each.
- Explain why forgiveness and accountability are not opposed.
- State what forgiveness does not mean, including silence, forgetting and staying.
- State the disagreement among Christians about what forgiveness requires, fairly and in the strongest form of each view.
- Explain why a leader never presses a person who was harmed to forgive, apologise or meet.
If therefore you are offering your gift at the altar, and there remember that your brother has anything against you, leave your gift there before the altar, and go your way. First be reconciled to your brother, and then come and offer your gift." — Matthew 5:23-24
World English Bible
If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men." — Romans 12:18
WEB
bearing with one another, and forgiving each other, if any man has a complaint against any; even as Christ forgave you, so you also do." — Colossians 3:13
WEB
Be careful. If your brother sins against you, rebuke him. If he repents, forgive him." — Luke 17:3
WEB
Notice who is spoken to in each text. In Matthew 5:23-24 the person who must "go" is the one who remembers that someone else has something against him. Notice, too, the small words in Romans 12:18: "if it is possible" and "as much as it is up to you." Paul knew that peace takes two people, and that sometimes it is not possible.
1. Three words that are not one word
Begin with plain definitions. They are not the only possible ones, but they are enough to work with.
Forgiveness is a release. The person who was wronged lets go of the claim to repay. They stop keeping the debt as a weapon, and they stop wishing the other person harm. Forgiveness happens first in the one who was wronged. It can be done without the other person knowing, and it can be done when the other person has died or is far away. It takes time. It does not need a meeting.
Reconciliation is a restored relationship. People who were apart walk together again. By its nature it needs two people. One person cannot reconcile alone, any more than one person can shake hands alone. It needs truth about what happened, an honest naming of the wrong by the one who did it, and a real change. Where there is still a danger, it also needs safety.
Trust is confidence about the future. It is the belief that this person will do what they say and will not hurt me. Trust is not given by a decision. It is built by behaviour, repeated over time. It can be rebuilt slowly, or only in part, or not at all.
Put them in a table.
| Forgiveness | Reconciliation | Trust | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Letting go of the claim to repay | A restored relationship | Confidence about what the person will do |
| Who is needed | One person | Both persons | The one who trusts, and a record of behaviour |
| How fast | Often slowly; may come in stages | Slower still | The slowest |
| Can it be decided? | It can be chosen, and then lived | Only if both choose | No: it is earned |
| Needs the other to repent? | Debated (see below) | Yes | Behaviour must change |
2. An invented example of the three coming apart (an invented example)
A parish council quarrelled for months over the date and cost of a hall repair. In one meeting a member, Tomas, said that another member, Ilse, "has never kept a promise in her life." Many people heard it.
Later Ilse said that Tomas's words had hurt her badly. A year on she had forgiven him. She no longer wished him ill, and she no longer rehearsed the sentence in her mind. Forgiveness had happened.
Tomas, for his part, had said sorry in front of the council and had not repeated the words. Over the following year the two of them worked together on the hall roof, at first with care and then with ease. Reconciliation had happened.
But Ilse still did not hand Tomas the parish account book. That was not unforgiveness. She had seen how he spoke when he was frightened, and she wanted to see a longer record before she gave him anything that mattered. Trust was still being rebuilt, and it was right that it was.
Notice that the three arrived at different times. Notice also that nobody made the mistake of saying "if you had really forgiven him, you would trust him." Forgiveness does not cancel the need for a record.
3. Forgiveness and accountability are not opposed
Many people feel that to hold someone accountable is to refuse forgiveness, and that to forgive is to let the matter drop. Scripture does not set them against each other.
Luke 17:3 puts them in one sentence. "If your brother sins against you, rebuke him. If he repents, forgive him." The rebuke is not an insult to forgiveness. It is part of the path. A wrong that is named and answered is a wrong that can be forgiven honestly. A wrong that is quietly ignored is not forgiven; it is buried.
In the same way, Colossians 3:13 says "bearing with one another, and forgiving each other." Bearing with one another does not mean pretending nothing happened. It means carrying one another's weakness without turning it into a weapon.
So forgiveness is compatible with:
- a clear statement of what was done;
- a consequence that is fair and fixed beforehand (an apology, a repayment of what was lost, a change of duty, a pause in an office);
- a limit on contact or on what the person may be trusted with;
- a continuing watch.
None of these is a failure to forgive. Each may be a way of caring for the community and, in an honest way, for the one who did wrong.
4. What forgiveness is not
Because the word is used so often, it is also misused. Forgiveness is not:
- Forgetting. A person who has forgiven may remember exactly what was done. Memory is how they protect themselves, and how a community learns.
- the wrong small. "It was nothing" is a lie when it was something. Forgiveness needs the wrong to be called what it was.
- Silence. A person is not made to stay quiet about what happened, or told that talking about it shows they have not forgiven.
- Staying. Forgiving a person does not require sitting in the same room, serving on the same committee, or remaining in the same congregation. A person may forgive and leave. A person may forgive and refuse any further contact.
- Removing consequences. Forgiveness is a gift of the heart. Consequences are a matter of justice and safety, and they stand beside it.
- A deadline. No one is told that after three months they ought to have forgiven.
- A performance. A public handshake does not show that forgiveness has taken place, and it can hide that it has not.
5. Reconciliation is not owed
Now we come to the sentence on which the whole lecture turns.
Reconciliation can never be demanded of a person who was harmed.
It is true that Christians are told to "be at peace with all men" (Romans 12:18). But read the sentence. "If it is possible, as much as it is up to you." Paul does not say "at any cost." He does not say "whatever the other person does." He admits that there are cases where peace is not possible, and that a person's responsibility reaches only as far as what is "up to you."
Matthew 5:23-24 is often used to press the wounded. Read it again. The person in the story is at the altar, with a gift in his hand, and he remembers that his brother has something against him. In the story, he is the one who has to go. The story begins from the possibility that I may have wronged someone, and sends the person who might be at fault to put it right. It does not tell the person who was wronged to walk back toward the one who did it.
This matters because it shows the direction of the movement in this text. The weight falls on the one who did the wrong, to seek, to confess and to repair. It is not a text for pushing a harmed person toward a table.
Here the course draws a line it will draw again in lectures 6-3 and 6-5. Where there has been harm (abuse, violence, sexual misconduct, intimidation, danger to a child or vulnerable adult, theft of funds), the road is protection, reporting and the community's written procedure. It is not reconciliation. A leader does not arrange a meeting between a person who was harmed and the person accused, does not ask the person harmed to forgive in front of others, and does not suggest that their healing depends on meeting. If the person harmed, in their own time and by their own free choice, with support and with safeguards, ever wishes to speak to the one who harmed them, that is theirs to decide. It is never the leader's to ask for. Lectures 4-4 and 5-4 give the procedure when harm is suspected.
6. What the person who did the wrong can do
Most of the lecture so far has been about the one who was wronged. A word is owed to the other side too, because many conflicts in a congregation are ordinary ones where both people did some wrong.
A person who has wronged another can:
- Name the wrong plainly, without "if I offended anyone" and without "but you also...".
- Not ask for forgiveness as though it were a debt. To say "I hope in time you may be able to forgive me, and I will understand if you cannot" is different from "I have said sorry, so now it is your turn."
- Make amends where something can be put right: return what was taken, correct what was said, step back from what was misused.
- Accept a consequence, and not argue about its size.
- Leave the other person free to refuse contact, to refuse a meeting, or to say nothing.
- Change, and be patient while the change is watched.
7. This is a point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: what forgiveness requires, and whether reconciliation should be public.
Some Christians hold that forgiveness is conditional. Luke 17:3 says "If he repents, forgive him", and they read this as meaning that full forgiveness waits for repentance. They argue that a forgiveness given where there is no repentance is cheap, that it lets a wrongdoer off without ever facing what they did, and that God himself forgives those who turn to him. For them, to forgive without repentance is to make light of the wrong.
Others hold that forgiveness is to be given freely, without waiting for the other person to ask, because Christ forgave while people were still wronging him, and because Colossians 3:13 says "even as Christ forgave you, so you also do." They argue that a forgiveness that waits on the other person leaves the wounded tied to the one who hurt them, with their peace held in someone else's hand. But many in this group add that reconciliation does wait on repentance and on change.
A third view, found especially in traditions with a of confession, holds that the whole matter is carried by the church: confession is made, absolution is given by an ordained minister, and a penance is set. The wronged person's own forgiveness belongs in prayer and is not tied to that act.
On the public side, some communities call for open confession before the whole body, and some hold that confession is made to the pastor or priest in private, or to the one who was wronged alone. Each side has reasons. The public view stresses that wrongs done in public damage a body and need public repair. The private view stresses that exposure can itself become harm.
What this course requires is less than any of these requires. It requires three things only. First, that forgiveness, reconciliation and trust are not mixed up. Second, that no one who was harmed is pressed to forgive, apologise or reconcile, whichever of the above views the community holds. Third, that no confession is staged in public in a way that puts the person who was wronged on display or obliges them to answer.
8. The leader's part
A leader is not the one who forgives, and is not the judge of whether forgiveness has happened. The leader's part is smaller and more careful.
- Do not announce that it is over. "Let us all forgive and move on" is a sentence that sounds kind and often does damage. It tells those who are not ready that they are failing.
- Keep the three words apart when you speak, and teach others to do so.
- Make room for consequence. Say that accountability is not a lack of love.
- Protect the person who was wronged from being hurried, and protect the person who did wrong from being treated as beyond repair.
- Watch for the cases that are not ordinary. If there is any sign of the kinds of harm named above, stop, protect, and follow the procedure in lecture 5-4.
- Pray, and let the time it takes be the time it takes.
Diagram 1. Three things that are not one thing
Diagram 2. Who is asked to move in Matthew 5:23-24
| Person in the story | What the text says |
|---|---|
| The one at the altar with a gift | Remembers that another person has something against him |
| What he is told to do | Leave the gift, go, and be reconciled |
| The person who has "something against" him | Is not told to do anything in this text |
In short
- Forgiveness is a release of the claim to repay; reconciliation is a restored relationship; trust is confidence built by behaviour over time.
- Forgiveness needs one person; reconciliation needs two; trust needs a record. They can arrive in any order.
- Forgiveness and accountability are not opposed: Luke 17:3 joins rebuke and forgiveness in one sentence.
- Forgiveness is not forgetting, silence, staying, a deadline, or the removal of consequences.
- Matthew 5:23-24 sends the person who may have done wrong; it does not send the person who was wronged.
- No one who was harmed is pressed to forgive, apologise or reconcile, and where there is harm the road is protection.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Forgiveness | A release of the claim to repay. It begins in one person and needs no meeting. |
| Reconciliation | A restored relationship. It needs two people, truth and change, and safety where there was danger. |
| Trust | Confidence built by behaviour over time. It is earned, not decided. |
| Matthew 5:23-24 | The person who may have wronged another is the one who goes. |
One sentence to remember Forgiveness, reconciliation and trust are three things, and no one who was harmed is pressed to reconcile.
This week's action Write the three words on a card, and the next time you hear one of them used in your community, ask quietly which of the three is meant.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a time (without naming anyone) when you saw forgiveness, reconciliation and trust arrive at different times. Which came first, and which last?
- Why might "let us forgive and move on" harm a person who was not ready?
- Luke 17:3 puts "rebuke" and "forgive" in one sentence. How can a community do both?
- Which of the three positions on what forgiveness requires seems strongest to you? State the best argument of a position you do not hold.
- Why does Matthew 5:23-24 send the person who may have done wrong, and not the person who was wronged?
- What would a leader say to a person who says "I cannot forgive, and I do not want to be in the same room"?