Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
- Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
- Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
- Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
- Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
- Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
- Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
- Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
- Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
- Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
- Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
- Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
- Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
- Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
- Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
- Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
- Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
- Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
- Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
- Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
A small-group leader notices that a member who used to talk a great deal has gone quiet. She has stopped coming to the meal after the meeting. A deacon hears that a family's grown son has not left his room for weeks, and that the family "is praying about it". A pastor is asked by a young mother, after a service, whether it is a sin to feel nothing when she tries to pray. Each of these leaders wants to help, and each has been taught, openly or without anyone saying it, one of two ways to answer.
This lecture begins the course by looking at those two ways. The first treats a struggle of mind or mood as only spiritual: a matter of faith, sin or prayer, and nothing else. The second treats it as only a medical or psychological matter, and so leaves the spiritual side out, or leaves the person with someone else. This lecture calls them the two mistakes. It says plainly that both usually come from love, and that no one in this lecture is the villain. It then goes to Scripture, which is more honest about the troubled mind than many of us have been.
The central claim to which every week of this course returns is this: a church leader is not a diagnostician but someone who notices, stays beside, and connects. Prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith. The leader has a mind and limits too, and receives help.
This course is not medical or psychological advice, not diagnosis and not treatment, and it does not replace professional care. It names no test, no programme and no medicine. Lecture 1-3 and lecture 1-4 say plainly where a leader's work stops.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Describe the first mistake, treating everything as only spiritual, and the second, leaving out the spiritual, without blaming the people who make them.
- Say why both mistakes often come from love or from fear.
- Name three places in Scripture where a troubled person is shown honestly, and say what each shows.
- Explain why this course does not diagnose Elijah, Job or the writers of the Psalms.
- State the central claim of the course in your own words.
When he saw that, he arose, and went for his life, and came to Beersheba, which belongs to Judah, and left his servant there." — 1 Kings 19:3
World English Bible
He lay down and slept under a juniper tree; and behold, an angel touched him, and said to him, “Arise and eat!”" — 1 Kings 19:5
WEB
Yahweh’s angel came again the second time, and touched him, and said, “Arise and eat, because the journey is too great for you.”" — 1 Kings 19:7
WEB
After the earthquake a fire passed; but Yahweh was not in the fire: and after the fire a still small voice." — 1 Kings 19:12
WEB
My tears have been my food day and night, while they continually ask me, “Where is your God?”" — Psalm 42:3
WEB
Why are you in despair, my soul? Why are you disturbed within me? Hope in God! For I shall still praise him for the saving help of his presence." — Psalm 42:5
WEB
I am weary with my groaning. Every night I flood my bed. I drench my couch with my tears." — Psalm 6:6
WEB
Therefore I will not keep silent. I will speak in the anguish of my spirit. I will complain in the bitterness of my soul." — Job 7:11
WEB
To him who is ready to faint, kindness should be shown from his friend; even to him who forsakes the fear of the Almighty." — Job 6:14
WEB
I have heard many such things. You are all miserable comforters!" — Job 16:2
WEB
Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalm 34:18
WEB
The Bible does not hide the troubled mind. Elijah runs for his life, falls asleep, and is woken and fed before anyone asks him a question. The writer of Psalm 42 has tears for food and talks to his own soul. Another psalmist is weary with groaning. Job refuses to keep silent and complains in the bitterness of his soul, and his friend Eliphaz and the others fail him when they talk and not when they sit. None of these passages is a method of treatment, and none gives a label to anyone. Together they show that honest speech about a heavy heart has always been part of the life of God's people.
1. Why begin with the church's story
Before this course teaches anything about noticing or helping, it asks a leader to look at what the church has done in the past and still does. A leader who does not know the two mistakes will make one of them without meaning to. The mistakes are old, and they appear in every tradition and in every size of community, from a house church to a large parish. They also appear outside the church. Many families, schools and workplaces make the same two mistakes with different words.
This lecture does not tell the history of any church, country or period, and it names no event. Knowledge about the mind has changed a great deal over time, and it differs between places. In many times and places, churches have given shelter and patient care to people in mental distress. In many times and places, churches have also feared, hidden, blamed or silenced them. Both are true, and a leader who wants to serve today can be grateful for the first and honest about the second.
2. The first mistake: only spiritual
The first mistake treats every struggle of mind or mood as a spiritual problem and nothing else. The person is told, or learns to think, that the trouble comes from weak faith, hidden sin, too little prayer, too little thanks, or an unsettled relationship with God. The remedy is then prayer, repentance, Bible reading, more attendance, or a stronger will.
This answer often comes from love. A pastor who believes that God is the Lord of the whole person, and that prayer matters, will naturally begin there. Sometimes it comes from fear: it is frightening to think that a faithful person's mind can be unwell, and a spiritual explanation feels safer. Sometimes it comes from loyalty to a tradition that has taught for generations that the church has everything its people need. None of these is a wicked motive.
But the answer has a cost. A person who is told that the trouble is a lack of faith may start to feel guilty on top of everything else. A person who prays hard and does not feel better may decide that God is angry, or that they are beyond help. A family may wait, praying, for a long time before anyone suggests another kind of help. And the person may learn to hide. The cost of the first mistake is often silence.
This is only half the picture. Prayer, the Scriptures, the sacraments and the fellowship of the church do matter to a struggling person. The first mistake is not "too much spirituality". It is only spiritual: a single answer where there may be several things at once.
3. The second mistake: ignoring the spiritual
The second mistake runs the other way. It treats a struggle as a purely medical or psychological matter, and the church's part as nothing. The leader says, "That is for the doctors," and steps back. Or the leader says, "I am not trained for this," and then says no more, and the person is left without a visit, a prayer or a place at the table.
This answer, too, often comes from love. A leader who respects the work of doctors and counsellors, and who does not want to give bad advice, is behaving responsibly. Sometimes it comes from a reaction to the first mistake: someone who saw a friend hurt by it may promise never to be "that kind of church". Sometimes it comes from fear of saying the wrong thing.
But this answer too has a cost. A person who is seeing a professional still has a faith, a community and questions that a professional may not be able to answer: Does God see me? Is this my fault? Will my church still want me? A church that goes silent at the first mention of a doctor tells the person that their spiritual life is no longer wanted. The cost of the second mistake is often loneliness.
4. Both mistakes in one picture
The two mistakes are easier to see side by side. The first says, "It is only spiritual, so only we can help." The second says, "It is only medical, so only they can help." The truth this course holds is plainer: a person is one person. A struggle in mind or mood touches body, thoughts, feelings, relationships and faith together, and a good response can have more than one part. A leader's part is to notice, to stay beside, and to connect the person to the kind of help the leader cannot give. Prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith.
(an invented example) Corran Street Chapel is a house church of about twelve adults. When a member, Ayesha, stops coming, the leader, Tomas, decides that the matter is one of faith. He calls the group to pray for her sin to be revealed. Ayesha hears about it through a friend and does not come back for a long time. Tomas was acting in love. He did not know that there was another way to act. Later he learns to make a different first move: he calls, asks if he may visit, and brings bread.
(an invented example) Westmere Community Church is a large congregation of several hundred people with a paid staff. When a young man named Elias tells a staff member that he has been struggling, the staff member listens kindly, says, "That is a matter for a professional," writes down the name of a clinic, and says goodbye. Nothing was said that was untrue. But Elias felt that he had been handed on, and he did not mention the matter again. The staff member was acting with care and respect for professionals. She did not know that she could do both: send him to the right help and still stay beside him.
The two churches are very different in size and structure. The mistakes are the same, and so is the way out.
5. What Scripture shows us about a troubled mind
Scripture does not give us a medical account, and this course does not diagnose anyone in it. Elijah, Job and the Psalm writers are not cases. We cannot know what a modern professional would say about any of them, and it would be wrong to guess. But the Bible shows plainly how heavy and honest life with God can be. Three pictures help.
Elijah (1 Kings 19). Elijah has been through a great strain, and now he is afraid. He runs for his life and travels a long way (1 Kings 19:3). Then something quiet happens. He lies down and sleeps, and an angel touches him and says, "Arise and eat" (1 Kings 19:5). There is a cake and a jar of water. He eats, he drinks, and he lies down again. The angel comes a second time and says, "Arise and eat, because the journey is too great for you" (1 Kings 19:7). Before any question is put to him, before any word of correction, God gives him food and sleep.
The lesson is not that every weary person needs a nap, and it is not an argument for or against any medical care. It is that the God of Scripture meets a worn-out, frightened person with care for the body as well as the soul. Later in the same chapter God comes to Elijah not in the earthquake or the fire but in a still small voice (1 Kings 19:12). A leader may learn from this to be gentle, to feed before questioning, and to be unhurried. Nothing here says that Elijah's trouble was only spiritual, or only physical. It says that God cares for the whole of him.
A word of caution. The same chapter shows Elijah saying things in his weariness that a leader must take seriously if a person ever says something like them today. This course does not dwell on those words. If anyone you are caring for speaks about ending their life, the course on crisis, suicide and trauma response is the place to turn, and the lecture on your own limits (1-4) says briefly how a leader acts.
The Psalms (Psalm 42 and Psalm 6). The writer of Psalm 42 says, "My tears have been my food day and night" (Psalm 42:3), and then speaks to his own soul: "Why are you in despair, my soul? Why are you disturbed within me? Hope in God!" (Psalm 42:5). Notice what he does. He does not pretend that he is well. He names the tears. He asks his soul a hard question. He then points it toward hope, not by forcing the feeling but by speaking to himself and to God. Psalm 6 is plainer: "I am weary with my groaning. Every night I flood my bed. I drench my couch with my tears" (Psalm 6:6).
These psalms were prayed, and they were kept, so the church has always had words for days like these. A leader who has never read them aloud may have given the impression that faithful people are always cheerful. They are not.
Job. Job says, "Therefore I will not keep silent. I will speak in the anguish of my spirit. I will complain in the bitterness of my soul" (Job 7:11). He also says, about the friends who should have stood with him, "To him who is ready to faint, kindness should be shown from his friend" (Job 6:14). When the friends begin to explain his suffering, he calls them "miserable comforters" (Job 16:2).
Job's friends are, in a way, the church's first example of the first mistake. They had one explanation for every trouble, and they held to it. Job answers them. A leader reading this book can see how an explanation, offered too fast to a person in pain, can hurt, even when it is meant as help.
None of these passages offers a cure. They give something else: permission to speak honestly, and a picture of God who comes near. "Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit" (Psalm 34:18).
6. Why we do not diagnose Scripture's people
It is tempting to read Elijah, Job or a psalm writer and decide what was "really wrong" with them, using a modern word. This course does not do that, for three reasons. First, we have only a few verses about them, and a text written for another purpose is not a medical record. Second, a leader who learns to diagnose in the Bible will be tempted to diagnose at the church door, and the course teaches the opposite. Third, it does not matter for the central point. The Bible's pictures are useful because they are pictures of people, and they say nothing about a label.
7. A leader's first step
If a leader takes one thing from this lecture, it is that the first move is not a verdict. It is not "this is only spiritual" and it is not "this is only medical". It is a kind, simple presence, and a willingness to ask. Later lectures show how: lecture 1-4 gives the three verbs, notice, stay and connect, and lecture 4-1 teaches the first conversation.
8. What a leader takes from this lecture
- There are two common mistakes: treating a struggle as only spiritual, and leaving out the spiritual.
- Both usually come from love or fear, and neither makes anyone a villain.
- The cost of the first mistake is often silence; of the second, often loneliness.
- A person is one person, and a good response may have more than one part.
- Scripture speaks honestly of the tired, tearful and complaining, and of a God who comes near.
- We do not diagnose Elijah, Job or the psalm writers, and we do not diagnose anyone else.
Diagram 1. Two mistakes and a third way
Diagram 2. Scripture's honest pictures
In short
- Two common mistakes are treating a struggle of mind or mood as only spiritual, and leaving out the spiritual; both usually come from love or fear.
- The cost of the first mistake is often silence and guilt; the cost of the second is often loneliness.
- A person is one person, so a good response can have more than one part.
- Scripture shows honestly the weary, tearful and complaining, and a God who comes near to the broken-hearted.
- This course does not diagnose Elijah, Job or any psalm writer, and it does not teach a leader to diagnose anyone.
- This course is not medical or psychological advice and does not replace professional care.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| First mistake | Treating a struggle as only spiritual; the cost is often guilt, delay and silence. |
| Second mistake | Leaving out the spiritual and handing the person on; the cost is often loneliness. |
| Elijah in 1 Kings 19 | Food and sleep came before any question; God cares for body and soul together. |
| Why not diagnose the Bible's people | A text is not a medical record, and a leader who diagnoses in Scripture will diagnose at the church door. |
One sentence to remember A person is one person, and the church's first move is a kind presence, not a verdict.
This week's action Read 1 Kings 19:3-12 and Psalm 42 slowly once this week, and write down one sentence your community uses about a troubled mind, only the words, with no names.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the two mistakes does your own community make more easily? Think of words you have heard, not of anyone's name.
- Why might a leader who loves people reach for the first mistake? Why might a leader who respects professionals reach for the second?
- In 1 Kings 19, God gives Elijah food and sleep before any question. What would it mean for your community to "feed before questioning" someone who is worn out?
- Why does this course not decide what was "really wrong" with Elijah, Job or a psalm writer? What would be lost if it did?
- Corran Street Chapel and Westmere Community Church are very different. Which is closer to your setting, and what is the first small change that would help?