FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT602E The Synoptic Gospels

Lecture 11-3: The Empty Tomb and the Resurrection Accounts

Contents 37
BT602E The Synoptic Gospels
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Three Gospels, One Subject
  1. Introduction: Three Gospels, One Subject
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: What the Synoptic Gospels Are
  1. Lecture 1-1: Gospel as a Genre: Biography, History, or Something Else
  2. Lecture 1-2: Oral Tradition, Written Sources, and How the Gospels Reached Us
  3. Lecture 1-3: Why Three, and Why They Are Called Synoptic
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Synoptic Problem
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Data: Agreements, Disagreements, and Order
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Two-Source Theory and the Case for Q
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Alternatives: Griesbach, Farrer, and the Present State of the Question
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The World in Which Jesus Taught
  1. Lecture 3-1: Galilee and Judea under Rome
  2. Lecture 3-2: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and the Rest of Second Temple Judaism
  3. Lecture 3-3: Synagogue, Temple, Household: Where the Gospel Scenes Take Place
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Gospel of Mark
  1. Lecture 4-1: Structure, Pace, and the Shape of Mark's Story
  2. Lecture 4-2: Mark's Christology and the Question of the Messianic Secret
  3. Lecture 4-3: Discipleship, Failure, and the Ending at 16:8
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Gospel of Matthew
  1. Lecture 5-1: Structure, the Five Discourses, and Matthew's Jewish Frame
  2. Lecture 5-2: Fulfilment, Scripture, and the Law in Matthew
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Community Addressed: Church, Mission, and Judgment
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Gospel of Luke
  1. Lecture 6-1: Luke's Preface, Sources, and Claim to Orderly Account
  2. Lecture 6-2: Reversal: The Poor, Women, Samaritans, and Outsiders
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Spirit, Prayer, and the Journey to Jerusalem
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: The Kingdom of God
  1. Lecture 7-1: What Jesus Announced, and What His Hearers Would Have Heard
  2. Lecture 7-2: Present, Future, or Both: The Eschatology Debate
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Sermon on the Mount and the Demands of the Kingdom
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: The Parables
  1. Lecture 8-1: How Parables Work, and How They Have Been Misread
  2. Lecture 8-2: Parables of the Kingdom
  3. Lecture 8-3: Parables of Mercy, Warning, and Reversal
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Miracles, Exorcisms, and Healing
  1. Lecture 9-1: Healings and Nature Miracles in the Synoptic Accounts
  2. Lecture 9-2: Exorcism and the Conflict with Evil
  3. Lecture 9-3: How Historians and Theologians Have Handled the Miracle Accounts
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Jesus, the Law, the Temple, and Israel
  1. Lecture 10-1: The Sabbath and Purity Controversies
  2. Lecture 10-2: The Temple Action and What It Meant
  3. Lecture 10-3: Jesus and the Restoration of Israel: The Twelve and the Nations
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: Passion, Death, and Resurrection
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Last Supper and the Arrest
  2. Lecture 11-2: Trial, Crucifixion, and the Three Passion Narratives Compared
  3. Lecture 11-3: The Empty Tomb and the Resurrection Accounts
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: The Historical Jesus and the Gospels Today
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Quests for the Historical Jesus, from Reimarus to the Present
  2. Lecture 12-2: Criteria, Method, and What History Can and Cannot Establish
  3. Lecture 12-3: Preaching and Teaching the Synoptic Gospels

Jump to the key points ↓

37 min

The three Synoptic accounts of the first day of the week are shorter than the passion narratives that precede them and disagree with one another far more. They differ about who went to the tomb, what was seen there, what was said, what the women did afterwards, and where the risen Jesus was subsequently encountered. Mark, in the text of the earliest manuscripts, has no encounter at all: the women flee and say nothing, and the book stops. Matthew has an appearance in Jerusalem and a commissioning on a mountain in Galilee. Luke has everything in and around Jerusalem, and explicitly instructs the disciples to remain in the city.

This lecture does two things, and keeps them separate. The first is descriptive: to set out precisely what each Gospel says, without merging the accounts and without minimising the differences. That task is more demanding than it sounds, because most readers carry a composite version assembled from all four Gospels and from Christian art, and cannot easily say which element comes from which book. The second task is analytical: to examine the historical arguments that have been built on this material and the methodological dispute about whether historical argument can reach a verdict here at all.

The lecture will not decide whether the resurrection happened. That is not modesty for its own sake. It reflects a genuine feature of the debate, which is that the disagreement is not primarily about the evidence — the participants largely agree about what the texts say and when they were written — but about what a historian is entitled to conclude, and about whether the question is of a kind that historical method can settle. Students from Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant traditions all confess the resurrection; they do not all hold the same view of its relation to historical argument, and neither do the scholars named below. What this lecture can do is set out the positions in the form their own advocates would recognise.

What these 37 minutes give you

  • State, for each Synoptic Gospel, who came to the tomb, what they encountered, what they were told, and what they did next, without conflating the three.
  • Explain the geographical disagreement about where the risen Jesus appeared, and describe two proposals for accounting for it.
  • Set out the tradition in 1 Corinthians 15:3-8, say why it is dated earlier than the Gospels, and identify what it contains that the tomb narratives lack and what it omits that they contain.
  • Present the argument from the women as first witnesses at full strength and state at least two substantial objections to it.
  • Describe the positions of N. T. Wright, Dale Allison, and Bart Ehrman on whether historical method can adjudicate the resurrection, and identify the assumption each one is making about the nature of historical judgement.

When the Sabbath was past, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Salome, bought spices, that they might come and anoint him. Very early on the first day of the week, they came to the tomb when the sun had risen. They were saying among themselves, “Who will roll away the stone from the door of the tomb for us?” for it was very big. Looking up, they saw that the stone was rolled back. Entering into the tomb, they saw a young man sitting on the right side, dressed in a white robe, and they were amazed. He said to them, “Don’t be amazed. You seek Jesus, the Nazarene, who has been crucified. He has risen. He is not here. Behold, the place where they laid him! — Mark 16:1-6

World English Bible

They went out, and fled from the tomb, for trembling and astonishment had come on them. They said nothing to anyone; for they were afraid. — Mark 16:8

WEB

Now after the Sabbath, as it began to dawn on the first day of the week, Mary Magdalene and the other Mary came to see the tomb. Behold, there was a great earthquake, for an angel of the Lord descended from the sky, and came and rolled away the stone from the door, and sat on it. — Matthew 28:1-2

WEB

But on the first day of the week, at early dawn, they and some others came to the tomb, bringing the spices which they had prepared. They found the stone rolled away from the tomb. They entered in, and didn’t find the Lord Jesus’ body. While they were greatly perplexed about this, behold, two men stood by them in dazzling clothing. — Luke 24:1-4

WEB

For I delivered to you first of all that which I also received: that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures, and that he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve. — 1 Corinthians 15:3-5

WEB

Read the three tomb openings in sequence and the differences appear at once, before any commentary. Three named women in Mark; two in Matthew; an unnumbered group in Luke, named only afterwards in 24:10. In Mark the stone is already moved when they arrive; in Matthew it is moved in front of them by a descending angel accompanied by an earthquake; in Luke it is simply found moved. One young man in a white robe in Mark, sitting inside; one angel in Matthew, sitting outside on the stone; two men in dazzling clothing in Luke, standing. The passage from 1 Corinthians is placed here because it is the earliest written statement of the claim and mentions no tomb, no women, and no stone.

1. What each Gospel actually says

Mark. Three women — Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James, Salome — come after sunrise with spices, worrying about the stone. It is already rolled back. Inside is a young man in a white robe, described as such and not called an angel. He announces that Jesus has risen, shows them the empty place, and gives an instruction: tell the disciples and Peter that he goes ahead of them into Galilee, where they will see him, as he told them. That instruction points back to Mark 14:28, spoken on the night of the arrest. The women flee, and tell no one, because they were afraid. The Gospel ends there in the earliest manuscripts, at 16:8.

The endings printed after that verse in most Bibles — the twelve-verse "longer ending" and a shorter alternative — are absent from Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Vaticanus, and their vocabulary and style differ markedly from the rest of Mark. The relevant point for this lecture is only that the earliest recoverable text of Mark contains no appearance of the risen Jesus, and that the endings we do have were composed to supply one. Whether 16:8 is a deliberate conclusion or the result of a lost leaf is discussed in lecture 4-3 and is not reopened here; the canonical status of the longer ending in the Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant traditions is also treated there.

Matthew. Two women, no spices — they come "to see the tomb," which fits Matthew's earlier addition of a guard and a sealed stone (27:62-66). An earthquake occurs; an angel descends and rolls the stone away and sits on it; the guards become like dead men. The angel gives the message, including the direction to Galilee. The women leave with fear and great joy and run to tell the disciples. On the way, Jesus meets them; they take hold of his feet and worship. He repeats the instruction about Galilee. Matthew then has the guards report to the chief priests, who pay them to say the body was stolen (28:11-15) — a passage that is evidence that the claim of theft was circulating when Matthew wrote, since one does not refute an argument nobody is making. The Gospel ends on a mountain in Galilee, where the eleven see him, worship, and are commissioned; Matthew adds, without explanation, that some doubted.

Luke. A group of women, named in 24:10 as Mary Magdalene, Joanna, and Mary the mother of James, with others. Spices; the stone already moved; no body. Two men in dazzling clothing appear beside them and ask why they seek the living among the dead. The message is different in an important respect: instead of directing them to Galilee, the two men tell the women to remember what Jesus said while he was still in Galilee. The women report to the eleven, who regard it as nonsense and do not believe them; Peter runs to the tomb and sees the linen wrappings. Luke then narrates the Emmaus road, an appearance to the eleven in Jerusalem in which Jesus shows his hands and feet and eats a piece of fish, and a departure at Bethany. Luke's disciples are told to stay in the city until they are clothed with power (24:49). There is no Galilean appearance in Luke and no room in his narrative for one.

2. The disagreements, stated without softening

Four are substantial.

Who went. Three named women in Mark, two in Matthew, a larger group in Luke including Joanna, who is not in the other lists. This is the least significant difference; lists of witnesses vary in ancient narrative for many reasons, and none of the three claims to be exhaustive.

What they saw. A young man, an angel, or two men. The descriptions are not simply variant labels for the same thing: Mark's figure is inside and sitting; Matthew's descends visibly, moves the stone, and sits outside on it; Luke's two stand. Matthew has an earthquake and a guard which the other two lack entirely.

What they did. Mark's women say nothing to anyone. Matthew's run to tell the disciples. Luke's report and are disbelieved. Mark's ending has generated a great deal of comment for this reason: if the women told no one, the existence of the story requires an explanation, and Mark supplies none. Readings that treat the silence as temporary, or as directed at the reader rather than at other characters, are attempts to soften a sentence that Mark seems to have meant to leave hard.

Where the appearances happened. This is the difference that cannot be dissolved. Mark and Matthew both direct the disciples to Galilee, and Matthew narrates the Galilean meeting. Luke has the risen Jesus appear only in and around Jerusalem, on the same day, and instructs the disciples not to leave the city. A harmonisation is available — appearances in both places over a period of weeks, with Luke compressing — and it is not impossible, but it has to be supplied by the reader, since neither Luke nor Matthew leaves space for the other's account. The candid description is that we have two traditions of appearance locations, one Galilean and one Jerusalemite, and that the Gospels preserve them differently.

Two further observations belong here, one about method and one about content.

The methodological one: the differences among these accounts are of a different order from the differences among the passion narratives. In the passion the sequence is fixed and the variation is in emphasis. Here the variation is in the events themselves. Whatever else that indicates, it suggests that the tomb material was not part of the same connected, early-fixed narrative that the passion evidently was.

The content one: for all their divergence, the accounts agree on a small set of items — the first day of the week, a tomb found empty, women as the first at the tomb, and a claim that Jesus was raised. Whether that convergence establishes anything is exactly what is disputed below.

3. The earlier tradition in 1 Corinthians 15

Paul's letter to Corinth is normally dated to the mid-50s, and in chapter 15 he quotes something he says he received and passed on, using the standard vocabulary for transmitting a fixed tradition. Most scholars, across a wide range of positions, judge the formula itself to be considerably older than the letter — dates within a few years of the crucifixion are commonly proposed, though the precise dating is an inference from the language and from Paul's account of his visits to Jerusalem, not a fact.

What it contains: died, buried, raised on the third day, appeared. Then a list — Cephas, the twelve, more than five hundred at once, James, all the apostles, and last Paul himself.

What it does not contain: any mention of a tomb being found empty, any mention of women, and any mention of a location. It does contain "that he was buried," which implies a burial, and the sequence buried-raised may imply an emptied grave, but the text does not say so.

Two opposite conclusions have been drawn from that silence, and both overreach. Some have argued that the empty tomb story is a later development unknown to Paul. Against this: a list of appearances is not a narrative and would not naturally include the discovery of the tomb; and in the legal and rhetorical conventions of the time, women's testimony was not what one would cite to persuade. Others have argued that Paul obviously presupposes an empty tomb, since a Jew speaking of resurrection meant bodily resurrection. Against this: what a term implies in general usage is not the same as what a particular author says, and Paul's own discussion later in the chapter of the transformed body complicates any simple inference.

The most that can be said carefully is that 1 Corinthians 15 is an early, formal statement of appearances that does not mention the tomb, and that the tomb narratives are later in written form and differ from one another. Both those statements are compatible with several conclusions.

4. The argument from the women

A frequently repeated argument runs: in the first century the testimony of women was not valued; a community inventing a foundation story would not have made women the first and only witnesses of the empty tomb; therefore the detail is likely to be historical. The argument appears in Wright, in William Lane Craig, and in many popular treatments, and it appeals to the criterion of embarrassment discussed in chapter 12.

State it at full strength first. Josephus does say, in Antiquities 4, that the testimony of women is not to be accepted because of their lightness and boldness — a text often cited here. The Gospels themselves record that the women were disbelieved (Luke 24:11), which suggests the tradition was aware of the difficulty. And the detail is present in all four Gospels despite the fact that it was, from an apologetic point of view, inconvenient.

Now the objections, which are serious.

First, the generalisation is too broad. Women could and did give testimony in various legal and social settings in the ancient Mediterranean world, and the situation varied by jurisdiction and by kind of case. Josephus's statement is one source with its own rhetorical purpose, not a code of evidence.

Second, the argument proves less than it appears to. Even granting that the detail is unlikely to have been invented, that establishes at most that women were remembered as having found the tomb, not what they found or how to explain it.

Third, and most sharply: the argument assumes we know how first-century storytellers optimise. Dale Allison has pressed this point. Narratives regularly include features that a modern strategist would remove, and reasoning from what a hypothetical inventor would have done is reasoning about a person we have invented ourselves. Allison accepts that the detail is probably historical, and still regards the argument as weaker than its users suppose — which is the right shape for a criticism: it targets the inference, not the conclusion.

5. Alternative explanations, and their difficulties

Several non-miraculous accounts have been offered, and a student should know them in their real form rather than as caricatures.

The wrong tomb. Kirsopp Lake proposed in 1907 that the women, unfamiliar with the burial place, went to the wrong tomb and found it empty. This explains the emptiness without theft and without a body. Its weakness is that it requires that no one subsequently corrected the mistake, in a city where the correction would have been easy and where, on Matthew's evidence, opponents were arguing about the body.

Theft or removal. Attested as a claim in Matthew 28:13-15, which is the earliest evidence that this explanation was in circulation. It accounts for the empty tomb but not for the appearances, and it requires a deception maintained by people who subsequently suffered for the claim.

No burial in a tomb at all. If crucified bodies were normally left unburied or placed in a common grave, as Crossan has argued, the empty-tomb story would have nothing to be empty. This is the strongest challenge in one respect, since it attacks a premise rather than a step. Against it stands the archaeological evidence of the Yehohanan burial discussed in lecture 11-2, the Deuteronomic requirement of same-day burial, Josephus's statement about Jewish practice, and the awkwardness for the tradition of the figure of Joseph of Arimathea, a member of the council who is credited with the burial in all three Synoptics — an inconvenient hero for a narrative otherwise hostile to that body.

Visionary or bereavement experiences. Gerd Lüdemann argued that the appearances are best explained as visions arising from grief and guilt, particularly in Peter, with a subsequent chain reaction. Dale Allison has developed a more careful version, drawing on the extensive modern literature documenting apparitions of the recently dead reported by bereaved people, which he takes seriously as a parallel without claiming that it disposes of the matter. Objections: the reported group appearances do not fit the usual pattern of such experiences; the earliest tradition presents an event that changed the disciples' expectations rather than confirming them, since a resurrection of one individual in the middle of history was not what Jewish eschatological hope generally expected; and the empty tomb, if historical, remains unexplained on this account. Allison, notably, states the objections to his own parallel as fully as he states the parallel.

6. Where readers divide on method

This is a point where readers will not agree. The disagreement here is not chiefly about the evidence. It is about what history is for and what it can do.

N. T. Wright, in The Resurrection of the Son of God, argues as a historian working from a large base: he surveys ancient views of life after death, argues that neither pagan nor Jewish expectation supplies a category for what the early Christians claimed, notes the sudden and uniform reshaping of Christian language about resurrection, and concludes that the bodily resurrection of Jesus is the best available explanation of the rise of Christianity — that any other proposal leaves the historical data less well explained. He is explicit that this is a historical argument and that historical arguments are probabilistic, and he acknowledges that the final step, from "best explanation" to belief, involves more than history.

Dale Allison, in Resurrecting Jesus and more fully in The Resurrection of Jesus: Apologetics, Polemics, History, works through the same evidence and declines to reach a verdict. He argues that the apologetic arguments are weaker than their proponents claim and the sceptical arguments weaker than theirs, that the parallels from apparition literature are genuinely instructive and genuinely insufficient, and that a careful historian ends in a state that is neither proof nor refutation. His position is not a covert scepticism; he writes explicitly as a Christian who finds the historical question undecided, which is a possibility students often do not know is available.

Bart Ehrman argues that the question is outside the historian's competence in principle. History, on this view, establishes what probably happened, and a miracle is by definition the least probable of the available explanations, since it is a violation of the ordinary course of events; therefore a historian, qua historian, can never conclude that a miracle is the most probable explanation. Note carefully what this does and does not assert. It is not the claim that the resurrection did not happen; Ehrman is explicit that a believer may hold it on other grounds. It is a claim about method.

Two further positions should be named because they change the shape of the argument rather than taking a side within it.

Michael Licona, in The Resurrection of Jesus: A New Historiographical Approach, engages Ehrman's methodological claim directly, arguing that the exclusion of miracle from the historian's range of explanations is a philosophical commitment brought to the evidence rather than a result derived from it, and that a historian may weigh a supernatural explanation if the alternative explanations fail.

The confessional caution. In much Catholic and Orthodox theology, and in a strand of Protestant thought going back to Martin Kähler, the resurrection is not primarily an object of historical demonstration at all. Joseph Ratzinger, writing on the resurrection, insists that it is a real event that leaves traces in history while also being something that transcends the historian's categories, since it is not a resuscitation within the ordinary order of events. This is not evasion of the historical question; it is a claim about what kind of event is being asserted.

Note that these five positions do not line up with the confessional divisions of the students reading them. Wright, Allison, Licona, and Ratzinger all confess the resurrection and disagree with one another about method. A reader who converts this debate into a contest between belief and unbelief has misdescribed it.

7. A closing caution about tidiness

Not every detail is design

This chapter's principle has been that the differences among the three Gospels are the theology of each. That principle is productive, and this lecture is where it is most likely to be overworked. It is one thing to observe that Luke keeps his appearances in Jerusalem and that Jerusalem is the pivot of Luke-Acts, as lecture 6-3 argued; that connection is supported by a pattern running through two books. It is another to explain every detail — the number of figures at the tomb, the posture of the young man, which women are named — as a deliberate signal. Some of those variations are probably nothing more than what happens to a story told in different places by different people over forty years. Where this lecture has claimed design, it has tried to give the pattern that supports the claim. Where it has not given one, the reader is entitled to treat the claim as a suggestion.

The tomb and the appearances, side by side Described, not reconciled. The earliest written statement is the column on the right. Mark 16:1-8 Matthew 28 Luke 24 1 Corinthians 15:3-8 three women, with spices stone already rolled back a young man in a white robe, sitting inside go to Galilee, you will see him they flee and say nothing no appearance narrated the book ends at 16:8 in the earliest manuscripts two women, no spices earthquake; an angel descends and rolls the stone away guards present, then bribed go to Galilee Jesus meets the women commissioning in Galilee 28:17 says some doubted, and does not explain it a group of women, named later stone found rolled away two men in dazzling clothing, standing remember what he said in Galilee the eleven disbelieve them Emmaus; Jerusalem; Bethany told to stay in the city; no Galilean appearance received and delivered as a fixed formula; letter c. 54 AD died / buried / raised / appeared Cephas, the twelve, over five hundred, James, all the apostles, last of all Paul not mentioned: the tomb, the women, any location a list is not a narrative — the silence bears less than it seems Held in common by all three Gospel accounts the first day of the week & a tomb found empty & women there before anyone else & a figure or figures announcing that he is risen Whether this convergence establishes anything historically is precisely what Wright, Allison and Ehrman disagree about.

The four columns are placed side by side rather than merged, which is the whole method of the lecture. The right-hand column is shaded differently because it is not a fourth version of the same narrative: it is an earlier and formally different kind of text, a list of appearances with no scene attached, and the two things it does not mention are printed in bold because both the apologetic and the sceptical use of that silence run past what the text supports. The panel across the foot lists the convergence, and the italic line under it states honestly that naming a convergence is not the same as drawing a conclusion from it.

6. Further Reading

  • N. T. Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God (Fortress, 2003). The fullest recent historical argument for the bodily resurrection; the survey of ancient views of the afterlife in the opening third is valuable on its own.
  • Dale C. Allison Jr., The Resurrection of Jesus: Apologetics, Polemics, History (T&T Clark, 2021). The most thorough recent treatment by a scholar who declines a verdict; unusually fair to positions he does not hold.
  • Bart D. Ehrman, How Jesus Became God (HarperOne, 2014). Contains the clearest short statement of the methodological argument that historians cannot adjudicate miracle claims.
  • Michael R. Licona, The Resurrection of Jesus: A New Historiographical Approach (IVP Academic, 2010). Engages the methodological question directly rather than assuming an answer to it.
  • Gerd Lüdemann, The Resurrection of Jesus: History, Experience, Theology, trans. John Bowden (Fortress, 1994). The main recent statement of the visionary explanation, argued rather than asserted.
  • Raymond E. Brown, The and Bodily Resurrection of Jesus (Paulist, 1973). A short, careful Catholic treatment of what the differences among the accounts do and do not imply.
  • Kirsopp Lake, The Historical Evidence for the Resurrection of Jesus Christ (Williams and Norgate, 1907). Worth reading for the wrong-tomb proposal in the author's own words rather than in later summaries of it.

In short

  • The three tomb accounts disagree substantially: three named women in Mark find the stone already rolled back and a young man sitting inside; two women in Matthew witness an angel descend visibly amid an earthquake and sit on the stone; Luke's larger group, named only afterward, meets two men standing in dazzling clothing.
  • Mark's earliest manuscripts (Codex Sinaiticus, Codex Vaticanus) end at 16:8 with the women fleeing in fear and telling no one — no resurrection appearance of Jesus is narrated at all in the original text, and the familiar longer ending was composed later to supply one.
  • 1 Corinthians 15:3-8, Paul's formula received and passed on and datable within a few years of the crucifixion, lists appearances to Cephas, the twelve, more than five hundred at once, James, and all the apostles — but mentions no tomb, no women, and no location.
  • The "argument from the women" (their testimony wasn't valued in the period, per Josephus, Antiquities 4, so a community inventing the story wouldn't have made them the sole witnesses) is pressed by N. T. Wright and William Lane Craig, but Dale Allison objects that reasoning about what an ancient storyteller would or would not have invented assumes we know how they optimized, which we do not.
  • Wright, Allison, and Ehrman disagree less about the evidence than about what historical method can establish: Wright argues bodily resurrection is the best explanation of the data; Allison, a professing Christian, declines to reach a verdict at all; Ehrman holds that a miracle is by definition the least probable explanation available to a historian and so cannot be a historian's conclusion.

If you remember nothing else from this lecture: The three Synoptic resurrection accounts diverge sharply — different women, different figures at the tomb, and a flat geographical contradiction between Galilee (Mark, Matthew) and Jerusalem-only (Luke) — while Mark's earliest manuscripts end at 16:8 with the women fleeing in silent fear and no appearance narrated at all. The earliest written witness, Paul's formula in 1 Corinthians 15:3-8 (within a few years of the crucifixion), lists appearances but never mentions a tomb, women, or a location, which cuts against both over-confident apologetic and over-confident skeptical uses of that silence. What divides serious scholars like Wright, Allison, and Ehrman is not chiefly the evidence itself but what a historian, as a historian, is entitled to conclude from it — and remarkably, several of history's most rigorous skeptics on this question, like Allison, remain professing Christians who simply hold the historical question open.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Without looking at the text, write down what happened at the tomb. Then read Mark 16:1-8, Matthew 28:1-10, and Luke 24:1-12 and mark which elements of your account came from which Gospel, and which came from none of them. What does the result suggest about how you have been reading these chapters?
  • Luke's messengers say "remember what he told you when he was still in Galilee"; Mark's and Matthew's say "he goes before you into Galilee." Describe the difference exactly. Then give one explanation that treats it as deliberate and one that does not, and say what evidence would favour each.
  • The tradition in 1 Corinthians 15:3-5 does not mention the tomb. Construct the strongest argument from that silence, and then the strongest reply to it. Which argument depends more heavily on assumptions about what an ancient writer would naturally have included?
  • State the argument from the women as first witnesses in its strongest form, then state Allison's objection to it. Does the objection show the conclusion to be false, or only the argument to be weak? Why does the distinction matter?
  • Wright, Allison, Licona, Ehrman, and Ratzinger disagree about what history can establish here, and four of the five confess the resurrection. What follows from that for the common description of this debate as one between faith and scepticism?
  • This lecture warns against explaining every variation as design. Choose one difference among the three accounts that you think is clearly deliberate and one that you think is probably not, and give your reasons in each case.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.