Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
- Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test
- Lecture 1-3: Kinds of Theological Writing
- Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: From Topic to Question
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Scripture Before Reading About It
- Lecture 2-2: Kinds of Sources and How to Weigh Them
- Lecture 2-3: Reading in a Second Language and in Translation
- Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Build a Source List
- Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection
- Lecture 3-2: Using Scripture as Evidence
- Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
- Lecture 3-4: Where Readers Disagree: Authority and Method
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
- Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
- Lecture 4-2: Paragraphs and Plain Style
- Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Summarising and Paraphrasing
- Lecture 4-4: Writing in a Second Language
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Draft Paragraph
- Lecture 5-1: Footnotes and Bibliographies
- Lecture 5-2: Citing Scripture and Ancient Sources
- Lecture 5-3: Plagiarism and Academic Honesty
- Lecture 5-4: Copyright, Permission and the Public Domain
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Check Your Sources
Every serious question in theology has more than one answer. People who read the same Scripture, and love it, have come to different conclusions. A paper that does not notice this is not careful, and a paper that notices it and pictures the other side badly is not honest.
This lecture is about the second half of the week's principle: give other positions their strongest form first. It sets out one simple test, the holders' test: would the people who hold this position say, "Yes, that is what we believe, and that is why"? It describes two common failures, the straw man and the attack on the person. It shows how to describe a tradition in its own terms, and how to apply the same standard to your own tradition. It then gives a three-part way of replying to an objection, and a model of reasoned disagreement from Acts 15.
All of this serves the central claim. To say only as much as you can support, you must know what can be said against you. A writer who has not heard the other side in its best form does not yet know how much the evidence supports.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Apply the holders' test to a description of a position you disagree with.
- Recognise a straw man and an attack on the person, and rewrite each as a fair statement.
- Describe a tradition in its own terms, using its own sources.
- Apply the same standard to a position held by your own tradition.
- Reply to an objection by conceding what is right, showing the evidence again and naming the difference in assumptions.
He who pleads his cause first seems right; until another comes and questions him." — Proverbs 18:17
World English Bible
The apostles and the elders were gathered together to see about this matter." — Acts 15:6
WEB
Iron sharpens iron; so a man sharpens his friend’s countenance." — Proverbs 27:17
WEB
The proverb is a plain observation: the first speaker sounds right until someone else asks questions. It does not say the first speaker is lying. It says that one side of a matter is not the whole matter. The verse from Acts shows leaders gathering "to see about this matter", which is what a fair writer does with a disagreement: gather and look. The last proverb describes a gain from meeting a hard edge, which fits an argument that is tested by a strong objection.
1. Why hear the other side first
Proverbs 18:17 describes what happens in any argument written by one person. When you write only your own side, it sounds right. Nothing in the page tests it. The reader may feel convinced, or may feel that something is left out without knowing what.
The remedy is to do the questioning yourself, before the reader does. State the strongest case against your claim. Then see whether your claim stands.
This takes effort, because the other position is often one you have never studied from the inside. You may have heard it only in the words of people who disagree with it. That is the usual cause of unfair description. The writer is not lying. The writer is repeating what was heard, and what was heard was already a weak version.
2. The holders' test
One check covers most of this lecture. After you describe a position, ask: Would the people who hold it recognise this as their view, and as their reasons?
If you can, show the description to such a person. If you cannot, read how the position is stated in its own writings: a creed or confession, an official teaching, a respected book by someone who holds it. Use what they say about themselves, not what others say about them.
The test does not ask you to agree. You can describe a position perfectly and still think it is wrong. It asks only that a holder would say, "Yes, that is what I mean."
A second check is the order. Give the position in its strongest honest form before you answer it. Do not give it in a form that is easy to answer and then say you have answered it.
3. The straw man
A straw man is a weak copy of a position, built so that it is easy to knock down. A writer does this by taking one crude version of the view, or the worst argument made for it, and treating it as the whole view.
Two short invented examples show how it looks. (an invented example)
Those who baptise babies do not care whether anyone believes.
Those who baptise only people who profess faith think that children are outside God's care.
Neither sentence would be accepted by the people it describes. Communities that baptise infants say they care a great deal about faith, and that they teach and nurture it after baptism. Communities that baptise those who profess faith, for their part, say that children are in God's care and are often blessed or dedicated in a church. The straw man takes a difference in practice and turns it into a charge about the heart.
Now a fair version of each position, in a few sentences. These are short and general, and each tradition has its own fuller statements. (an invented example of how to write it)
Many Catholic, Orthodox, Lutheran, Anglican, Reformed and Methodist communities baptise infants. They differ among themselves about what baptism does. They hold in common that God gives grace to a child within the believing community, and that faith is then nourished through teaching and life in the church. They point to passages that tell of whole households baptised, for example Acts 16:15 and 16:33, and to the long practice of the church.
Baptist communities, many Pentecostal communities and others baptise those who profess faith. They hold that baptism is a believer's public answer to Christ, and they point to passages in which people hear the message, believe and are then baptised, for example Acts 2:38 and 8:12.
A holder of either view might want to add something, and that is the point of the test. But neither sentence accuses the other of not caring. Each states what the group does, why it does it and where its texts are. A writer who has written both can now say honestly where the disagreement lies, which is a question about what the texts are describing and what they require.
4. The attack on the person
The second failure answers the speaker and not the argument. It says that a view is wrong because of who holds it, or why they might hold it. (an invented example)
Of course a minister paid by that denomination would defend this teaching.
This sentence says nothing about whether the teaching is right. It speaks about a supposed motive. Even if the motive were real, a view may be true while its holder has a poor motive, and false while the holder is sincere. The argument must be met on the evidence.
A related fault answers a position by naming a bad example of those who hold it. Every tradition has members who have done wrong. The existence of such a member is not an argument against the tradition's teaching, and we do not accept it when it is said about our own.
5. Describing a tradition in its own terms
Each tradition has words it uses for itself. Use them. If a community says "the Eucharist", "the Lord's Supper" or "communion", do not replace its word with your own. If a community says it holds Scripture and a body of teaching together, do not describe it as "adding to the Bible" unless you also say, in the community's own words, why it does not see it so.
Then check the sources the tradition itself stands on. A claim that "this tradition teaches X" should be supported by that tradition's own document, in a named translation or edition. Lecture 2-2 explained how to name a creed, confession or official text. The same rule applies here: do not report what a group believes from a hostile or distant source when its own statement is available.
When a tradition is not your own, expect differences inside it. Words like "Protestants believe", "Catholics hold" or "Orthodox say" describe millions of people, and no sentence is true of all of them. Use words such as "many", "most" or "the official teaching of" only as far as your sources allow, and name the document when you can.
6. The same standard for your own tradition
It is easy to be fair to a view you almost share, and harder to be fair to your own side's weak points. Apply the same test.
- State your own tradition's position in the form its best representatives would use. Do not defend a popular version that its teachers would not defend.
- Say honestly where your tradition's reading of a text is contested within the tradition itself.
- If another tradition's strongest objection to yours is one you cannot answer fully, say so. A paper that admits where it stops is more trustworthy than one that claims to have answered everything.
This is not a call to doubt your own convictions. A person may hold a position firmly and still describe the alternatives fairly. Lecture 1-3 mentioned that some schools want convictions kept out of the argument and others want them visible. Whichever your assignment expects, fairness to the other side is expected in both.
7. Replying to an objection
An objection is not an insult. It is a reader's strongest question. A reply has three moves, and you may need only one or two.
1. Concede what is right. If the objection has a true point, say so plainly. This shows the reader that you have understood it, and it often lets you make your claim smaller and stronger.
2. Show the evidence again. Return to the text or source and say what it supports and does not support. Do not simply repeat your claim.
3. Name the difference in assumptions. Often two readers who disagree about a conclusion disagree earlier, about what kind of evidence counts, how to read a kind of text or whom to trust. Say so. That is an honest reply even when you cannot close the gap.
Here is an invented reply to the objection in lecture 3-1, that the Bereans were a special case because Paul was an apostle. (an invented example)
This objection is right that Paul held an office the Bereans did not. Testing an apostle is not the same as testing an ordinary preacher, and I do not claim that it is. Acts 17:11 records praise for the Bereans' examination of Paul's message and does not say the praise was limited to apostles, but it also does not say it extends to every teacher. I therefore claim only that the habit of testing teaching against Scripture is commended in this passage. Whether it carries over in the same way to ordinary teaching depends on how a reader relates the apostles' office to later teachers, and readers differ on that. I take the narrower claim.
Count the moves: it concedes, it returns to the text and states what the text does and does not say, and it names where readers differ. It also ends with a smaller claim, which is a common and honest result of a good reply.
8. A model from Acts 15
The fifteenth chapter of Acts shows a dispute reasoned through in public. The account is useful here for the pattern of the reasoning, whatever one thinks about councils and their authority. Readers in different traditions understand the meeting differently. Some see in it the model of a council whose decisions bind the church. Others see an example of deliberation. We use only what is plain in the text.
The dispute begins with a disagreement. Some come from Judea teaching a view, and Paul and Barnabas have "no small discord and discussion with them" (Acts 15:2). The opposing view is given in its own words: "But some of the sect of the Pharisees who believed rose up, saying, “It is necessary to circumcise them, and to command them to keep the law of Moses.”" (Acts 15:5, WEB) The account does not shorten the view of those who disagree with Paul. It states what they say.
Then people gather, and the text says there was "much discussion" (15:7). The meeting hears more than one voice. Peter speaks. Then, "All the multitude kept silence, and they listened to Barnabas and Paul reporting what signs and wonders God had done among the nations through them." (Acts 15:12, WEB) The report of what has been seen is placed before the group, and the group listens.
James then appeals to the words of the prophets, saying that "this agrees" with them (15:15). He reasons from Scripture. He gives his judgement in the first person: "“Therefore my judgment is that we don’t trouble those from among the Gentiles who turn to God," (Acts 15:19, WEB)
Finally, the letter that goes out reports the result in these words: "For it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us, to lay no greater burden on you than these necessary things:" (Acts 15:28, WEB)
Notice the stages. The opposing view is stated in its own words. People listen to evidence from experience and to Scripture. The one who gives the judgement says it is a judgement. The decision is explained to those it affects. A writer can follow the same stages in a paper: state the other view, weigh the evidence from text and from lived reports, give your judgement as yours and explain it to the reader.
Diagram 1. From a fair statement to a fair reply
In short
- State another position in its strongest honest form before you answer it; the test is whether its holders would say, "Yes, that is what we mean."
- A straw man is a weak copy of a view; an attack on the person answers the speaker and not the argument.
- Describe a tradition in its own terms and from its own sources, and expect differences inside it.
- Apply the same standard to your own tradition, including where its reading of a text is contested.
- Reply by conceding what is right, showing the evidence again and naming the difference in assumptions.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The holders' test | Would the people who hold this view say, "Yes, that is what we believe, and why"? |
| Straw man | A weak copy of a position, built to be easy to knock down. |
| Attack on the person | Rejecting a view because of who holds it or why, and not on the evidence. |
| Three moves in a reply | Concede what is right; show the evidence again; name the difference in assumptions. |
One sentence to remember Say the other side so well that its holders would thank you, and then say where you differ.
This week's action Write the strongest objection to your own claim in two or three sentences, and ask whether its holders would accept your wording.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a position you disagree with. Write two sentences stating it. Would a person who holds it say, "Yes, that is what I believe"?
- Where have you heard a position described only by people who disagreed with it? What might you have missed?
- What is the strongest objection to the claim in your current piece of writing? Which of the three moves, concede, show again or name the difference, fits your reply?
- Name one point on which your own tradition's reading of a text is contested inside the tradition. How would you say so fairly?
- In Acts 15, which stage of the reasoning is hardest for you to do in a paper, and why?