Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
- Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
- Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
- Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
- Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
- Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
- Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
- Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
- Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
- Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
- Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
- Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
- Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
- Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
- Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
- Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
- Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
- Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
- Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
This week asks what we owe to the people beside us: the stranger, the enemy, the person who has been wronged. Before we can ask about any of these, we need an answer to an earlier question: what is a human being, and what does that make us owe to one another? Christian traditions answer with a short phrase from the first chapter of the Bible, that human beings are made in the image of God. This lecture asks what that phrase has been taken to mean, how it relates to the modern language of human rights, and where that language is strong and where it is limited.
The lecture does not ask you to defend or attack any political declaration, law or movement. It describes how Christians have understood dignity, how historians disagree about the part Christianity played in the history of rights, and what the language of rights can and cannot do. The principle of the week is this: every person bears God's image; what that requires toward the stranger, the enemy and the one wronged is argued within the traditions, and each should be heard in its strongest form. The course's central claim stays in view: the church is called out of the world and sent for the world, and a theology of public life asks what justice and peace for the neighbour require, with humility and with honesty about where believers differ.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Explain three common ways of reading "the image of God" and say what each protects.
- Describe, in general terms, how Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant traditions speak of human dignity.
- State fairly two views of how Christianity and the history of human rights are related, with the strength and weak point of each.
- Name two strengths and two limits of the language of rights.
- Explain why Scripture's teaching on dignity does not by itself decide any particular law or policy.
God said, “Let us make man in our image, after our likeness: and let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the birds of the sky, and over the livestock, and over all the earth, and over every creeping thing that creeps on the earth.”" — Genesis 1:26
World English Bible
God created man in his own image. In God’s image he created him; male and female he created them." — Genesis 1:27
WEB
When I consider your heavens, the work of your fingers, the moon and the stars, which you have ordained; what is man, that you think of him? What is the son of man, that you care for him? For you have made him a little lower than God, and crowned him with glory and honor. You make him ruler over the works of your hands. You have put all things under his feet:" — Psalm 8:3-6
WEB
There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." — Galatians 3:28
WEB
What the text says. Genesis 1:26-27 says that God made human beings in God's image and likeness, male and female, and gave them a place of rule over the other creatures. Psalm 8 wonders that the maker of the heavens should care for such small creatures, and then says they are crowned with glory and honour. Galatians 3:28 says that, in Christ, the divisions of ethnic group, social standing and sex do not divide those who belong to him.
A tradition's reading. Christians have read these verses as the root of a belief that every human life has a worth that no one gives and no one can take away. Some readers stress the rule over creation in Genesis 1; others stress the relation to God and to one another. For Galatians 3:28, some stress the unity of the church; others hear in it a wider claim about every human being.
Our judgement. The verses say that human beings have a special place before God. They do not tell us which laws a country should pass, how to weigh one person's claim against another's, or what a government must provide. Those further questions need other kinds of reasoning, and honest Christians reason differently. A teacher who says that "Genesis 1 requires" a particular law is saying more than the text says.
1. What "the image of God" has been taken to mean
The Bible does not define the phrase. Genesis 1:26-27 uses it and moves on. Readers have therefore asked what it means, and over the centuries three families of answers have appeared. Most writers combine them.
The first is the substantial reading. (The word means that the image is found in something human beings have.) It says the image lies in a human capacity: reason, conscience, the ability to love, the freedom to choose, or an immortal soul. What it protects: the idea that dignity belongs to a person as a person, whatever that person's strength, age or use to others. Where it is weak: if the image lies in a capacity, what of a baby, a person with a profound disability or a person in the last stage of dementia? Careful writers answer that the image belongs to the human kind and to each member of it, and does not rise and fall with the use of a capacity. The reading still has to say this explicitly, or it can slide toward ranking people by ability.
The second is the functional reading. It stresses the verse's own context: the image is joined to rule over the creatures, so human beings are God's representatives in the world, as a king's statue in a distant province stood for the king. (Ancient kings did set up images of themselves in lands they ruled; many scholars find this a helpful background.) What it protects: the link between dignity and responsibility; we are made to care for the world on God's behalf. Where it is weak: if the image is a job, then a person who cannot do the job might seem to lose it. Writers of this view usually reply that the is given to all, whether or not a person can carry it out.
The third is the relational reading. It notices that the verse says "male and female he created them", and it holds that the image is found in being made for relationship: with God, with one another, with the creation. What it protects: the idea that no one is a human being alone, and that dignity includes belonging. Where it is weak: it can seem to make dignity depend on the relationships a person actually has, which would leave out the isolated and the abandoned. Its defenders reply that the relationship in question is God's gift to the person, not the person's achievement.
A fourth voice should be added, because it is common in the New Testament and in the . Christ is called the true , and the church is being renewed into that image. On this view, the Genesis phrase points forward: we are made for a likeness to Christ that we have not yet fully reached. This can sit beside any of the first three.
Some Christian writers also stress that sin has damaged the image without destroying it. Other writers stress that the image remains whole, and what has been damaged is its use. Traditions weigh this differently, but all of them keep a short list of things that follow from the verse: a person is not a thing, no person is without worth, and the worth is received from God and not conferred by any human power.
2. How the traditions speak of dignity
(We describe each tradition as it describes itself; this is a general outline and no tradition is reduced to one paragraph.)
The Catholic tradition has a rich vocabulary on this point. It speaks of the dignity of the human person, grounded in the creation of every person in God's image, and it places the principle at the base of its social teaching. In the twentieth century, papal and conciliar documents, among them one by Pope John XXIII in the early 1960s that spoke at length of rights and duties, and the Second Vatican Council's statements in the 1960s on the church in the modern world and on religious freedom, set out dignity and rights together. Catholic teaching typically joins rights with duties: a person has a claim on others and also owes something to others and to the common good. It also grounds the argument for rights in , the old idea that human reason can see some moral truths because of what human beings are.
The Orthodox tradition speaks of the human being as made for communion with God and called to grow into God's likeness, a path often called (the Greek word usually translated "deification", meaning a sharing in the life of God by grace). Many Eastern writers distinguish "image", which every person has, from "likeness", toward which a person grows. The dignity of the person is therefore very high, and it is bound up with the calling to holiness. Some Orthodox writers have been cautious about the language of individual rights, fearing that it can set persons against one another and cut them off from the community and from God. Others use the language of rights readily, as a way to protect the person's freedom to worship and live. Both positions exist within the tradition.
Protestant traditions vary. Writers in the Reformed tradition have often linked human dignity to creation in God's image, to the calling of every person to serve God in daily life, and to the idea that every ruler is under God's law. Lutheran writers stress that a person is received by God by grace and not by achievement, which can be read as a deep ground for dignity that no can raise and no failure can remove. Anabaptist writers stress the dignity of each believer's conscience before God and the unity of the community. Evangelical and Pentecostal writers describe dignity in many ways, but common ground is the worth of each person for whom Christ died. Many Protestants have also spoken of conscience as a place where no earthly power may enter.
These descriptions overlap more than they conflict. All of them hold that dignity is given by God, and none holds that it is earned. They differ about the reach of the language of rights, about the place of the community and about how best to protect the person in the public square.
3. Christianity and the history of rights
(Here we state only what historians broadly agree on and where they disagree.)
In 1948 the United Nations adopted a declaration of human rights whose opening speaks of the inherent dignity of all members of the human family. Earlier statements of rights are well known: declarations made in the late eighteenth century at the time of the American and French revolutions, and older documents that limited rulers' power. Historians ask how these developed, and what part the Christian tradition played.
This is a point where readers will not agree. One group of scholars stresses Christian roots. They point to the old belief that every person is made in God's image; to the medieval writers on natural law and on the claims of persons that were rooted in it; to the early modern writers who argued from conscience and religious freedom; to the Christians, in many places, who led the campaigns against the slave trade and slavery; and to the church's long practice of caring for the sick, the poor and the stranger. The strength of this view is that it can account for why ideas of equal dignity grew in places shaped by a Christian vocabulary. Its weak point is that these same societies also tolerated slavery, torture and persecution for centuries, and that the Christian authorities of several periods opposed rights claims, so the story of a straight line from the Bible to human rights is too simple.
Another group of scholars stresses the Enlightenment and other streams. They point to the philosophers of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries who argued that rights belong to individuals by nature and not by grace, to the political revolutions that turned the argument into law, to older traditions of law and justice in other civilisations, and to the fact that in the nineteenth century some church authorities were wary of rights language because it came with revolutions that attacked the church. The strength of this view is that it takes seriously the actual history of the declarations and of their critics, and it makes room for the contributions of people of other faiths and none. Its weak point is that it can overlook how much its own vocabulary was shaped by Christian ideas, and it can forget that many of those who argued for rights were themselves Christians.
A third view says the question is too large. Each stream influenced the others; the debate is partly about definitions (what counts as "rights language"?) and partly about what the story is for. A person may use history to defend a theory of rights or to criticise one, and the temptation is to choose the history that serves the purpose.
This course does not require a student to choose among these. It requires that the student state each fairly, name its strength and its weak point, and avoid claiming that history proves either that Christianity "invented" rights or that it had nothing to do with them. The Catholic Church, for its part, came to embrace the language of rights in the twentieth century after a period of caution; many Protestant and Orthodox communities have come to it by their own roads. The churches are therefore participants in this history, with both credit and debts, and not only judges of it.
4. What rights language can do and where it is limited
The language of rights has real strengths, and a thoughtful Christian can name them.
- It protects the weak. A right says to the powerful: there are things you may not do to this person, whoever you are. Many Christians who work with prisoners, refugees, children and the poor find the language useful, because it gives them words that officials and courts understand.
- It is shared. People of many faiths and none can agree that a person should not be tortured, enslaved or silenced for conscience, even when they disagree about why. A common language of rights lets Christians stand with such people without asking them to share a creed.
It also has limits, and many Christians, and others, have named these too.
- It can lose the community. If every claim is stated as an individual's claim against others, the language may leave little room for the family, the church and the neighbourhood, and for duties we owe because we belong. Catholic teaching joins rights to duties for this reason, and some Orthodox and Anabaptist writers raise the point more sharply.
- It does not settle conflicts. When two rights seem to collide (the claim of a person in need and the claim of a person who owns something; the claim of a parent and the claim of a child; the claim of a group to keep its way of life and the claim of a member to leave it), the language of rights does not say which should give way. Other reasoning must do that, and in those places, Christians disagree.
- Its list can grow without limit, or stay too short. Some writers fear that when every desire is called a right, the word weakens; others fear that the word is too often withheld from those who most need it. Both worries are heard from Christians.
- It does not say where dignity comes from. The language of rights can be used by people who think dignity is a gift of God, by people who think it comes from reason or agreement, and by people who say little about its source. A church that wishes to say more than "rights" must say what it believes about the image of God, and it must say it in the public square with humility, as lecture 1-4 suggested.
These are not reasons to abandon the language. They are reasons to use it with care, and to remember that Christian theology has a vocabulary of its own (image, neighbour, love, justice, mercy) that does not reduce to rights.
5. Dignity and the hard cases
The image of God has been used to argue many things, and it is worth admitting how often people use it in several directions. Christians have used it to oppose slavery and to oppose torture; to argue about the beginning and end of life; to argue about punishment; and to argue about the treatment of those who differ from them in belief. Honest readers will see that these arguments do not all come out the same way, and that people who accept the same doctrine of the image of God reach different conclusions about what follows. Some of those questions belong to other courses, and some arise later in this week and the next.
Here is the lesson for a student. When you hear someone say "this is what human dignity requires", ask two questions. First, is the person pointing to something the doctrine itself clearly says, such as that no human being is worthless, or that no person may be treated as a mere tool? Most Christians will agree. Second, is the person going further, to a particular law or policy? If so, other reasoning has entered: about how a society works, what is possible, what costs people bear. That reasoning can be good or bad, and good Christians will disagree about it. Keeping the two questions apart is a mark of honest public theology.
Diagram 1. From the image of God to public questions
In short
- The Bible does not define the image of God; readers have taken it to lie in a capacity, a calling or a relationship, and most combine these.
- The traditions agree that dignity is given by God and not earned; they differ on the reach of rights language and the place of the community.
- Historians disagree on how far Christianity shaped human rights; each view has a strength and a weak point, and the churches took part in this history with credit and debts.
- Rights language protects the weak and is shared with others, but it can lose the community, cannot settle clashes of rights and does not name the source of dignity.
- Dignity does not by itself decide any particular law; that step needs other reasoning, on which Christians differ.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three readings of the image of God | Substantial (a capacity), functional (a calling to represent God) and relational (being made for relation); most writers combine them. |
| Common ground on dignity | No person is a thing, and a person's worth is received from God, not earned or taken away. |
| Rights and history | Some stress Christian roots, some the Enlightenment and other streams; each has a strength and a weak point. |
| A limit of rights language | It can lose the community and duties, and it cannot by itself settle a clash between two claims. |
One sentence to remember Every person bears God's image, and what follows for a particular law is a further question on which honest Christians differ.
This week's action When you next hear the words "human dignity requires", ask whether the speaker is stating what the doctrine says or taking a further step.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which reading of the image of God (substantial, functional or relational) do you find most helpful? What does it protect, and what is its weak point?
- Explain in your own words why the Catholic tradition joins rights with duties. Why might an Orthodox or an Anabaptist writer be careful about the language of individual rights?
- State fairly the view that stresses Christian roots in the history of rights and the view that stresses the Enlightenment and other streams. What is the strength and the weak point of each?
- Give one strength and one limit of rights language. Can you think of a place where two claims seem to collide and the language alone does not decide?
- When someone says "human dignity requires" a particular law, what two questions should you ask?