Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
- Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
- Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
- Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
- Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
- Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
- Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
- Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
- Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
- Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
- Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
- Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
- Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
- Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
- Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
- Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
- Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
- Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
- Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
Almost every public argument is partly an argument about justice. People say that a decision is just or unjust, that a share is fair or unfair, that a freedom is protected or lost. Christians use the same words as everyone else, and the Bible uses them often. But the word does not carry one meaning. This lecture looks at what Scripture and some Christian traditions have meant by justice and the common good, and at the tensions between freedom, equality and the common good.
This is a lecture about concepts. It does not say which party, law or policy is just. Its aim is to give you words that make your own thinking, and your conversations with people who think differently, more exact. A hard passage here may be skipped on a first reading without losing the rest.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Explain in plain terms two Hebrew words for justice and righteousness, *mishpat* and *tsedaqah*, and how Scripture uses them together.
- Define the common good and say how it differs from the total of private goods.
- Describe, in general outline, how Augustine, Aquinas, the Reformed tradition and the Orthodox tradition have spoken about justice, each as it speaks of itself.
- Explain how freedom, equality and the common good can pull in different directions, using an invented example.
- State fairly the disagreement about the proper task of government, without naming a party or policy.
He has shown you, O man, what is good. What does Yahweh require of you, but to act justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God?" — Micah 6:8
World English Bible
But let justice roll on like rivers, and righteousness like a mighty stream." — Amos 5:24
WEB
Owe no one anything, except to love one another; for he who loves his neighbor has fulfilled the law. For the commandments, “You shall not commit adultery,” “You shall not murder,” “You shall not steal,” “You shall not covet,” and whatever other commandments there are, are all summed up in this saying, namely, “You shall love your neighbor as yourself.” Love doesn’t harm a neighbor. Love therefore is the fulfillment of the law." — Romans 13:8-10
WEB
What the text says. Micah 6:8 says that what the Lord requires is to act justly, to love mercy and to walk humbly with God. Amos 5:24 asks that justice roll on like rivers and righteousness like a mighty stream; the prophet says it in the middle of a rebuke of worship that has lost its connection with how people treat each other. Romans 13:8-10 says that the one who loves a neighbour has fulfilled the law, because love does not harm a neighbour.
A tradition's reading. Many Christians read the three together and hear a call in which public justice, personal mercy and humble worship belong together. Some stress the first part of Micah, justice, and read the verse as a public demand. Others stress the third, humility before God, and warn that a demand for justice can become pride. In Romans, some read love as the whole of what the law is for, so that justice is love taking a public form. Others say that love goes beyond what justice can enforce, and the two are related but not the same.
Our judgement. These verses do not give a theory of justice or a list of just laws. They tell us what kind of people are asked for: those who act fairly, love mercy and walk humbly, and who do their neighbour no harm. What follows from this for the shape of a society is a matter for careful argument, and the traditions have argued it in different ways.
1. Two Hebrew words
The Old Testament uses two words very often when it speaks about how a community ought to live. They are usually translated "justice" and "righteousness", and they often appear together, as in Amos 5:24.
Mishpat is a word connected with judging. It can mean a decision in a case, a rule, or the right ordering of things. It also describes the work of putting a wrong right, especially for those who have no strength to do it for themselves. Tsedaqah is often translated "righteousness". It means being in the right relationship, behaving as one should toward someone to whom one is bound: a king to his people, a neighbour to a neighbour, a person to God. Many scholars note that the two words, together, describe both the standard and the practice: what is right, and doing what is right in a way that reaches those who are most easily overlooked.
This helps with a common misunderstanding. When English readers hear "justice" they often think first of courts and punishments. In the Bible the word reaches further. It includes judges who are fair, and it includes widows, orphans and strangers who are not abused or forgotten.
"Learn to do well. Seek justice. Relieve the oppressed. Judge the fatherless. Plead for the widow.”" — Isaiah 1:17 (WEB)
The same pairing is in Psalm 72, a prayer for the king: that he will judge the people with righteousness and the poor with justice. The prayer gives the king's task a moral shape. Authority exists to do justice, especially for those with least power, and the prayer asks God to give the king what he needs for it.
2. Justice that does not take sides
Here is something that surprises readers. The same law that speaks so much about the poor also warns against bias in a lawsuit. Exodus 23 contains two sentences that sit close together.
"neither shall you favor a poor man in his cause." — Exodus 23:3 (WEB)
"“You shall not deny justice to your poor people in their lawsuits." — Exodus 23:6 (WEB)
The first says not to favour the poor person in his case, and the second says not to deny justice to the poor in their lawsuits. They are not in conflict. The first says that a judge must not bend a verdict out of pity or out of a wish to be on the side of the weak. The second says that a judge must not bend it against the poor because they are weak. Both ask that the case be judged on what is true and what is owed. Leviticus 19:15 puts it more briefly: no injustice in judgment, no partiality to the poor, no favouritism to the great. We will meet this verse again in lecture 2-4.
So justice in Scripture has at least two sides. It is impartial in the courtroom, and it is attentive to the weak in the community. Christian traditions have sometimes stressed one side and sometimes the other. A careful reader holds both.
3. Giving each what is due
Long before the Christian era, thinkers in Greece and Rome described justice as a steady will to give to each person what is due. Christian writers took this up, and Thomas Aquinas, a thirteenth-century Catholic theologian, worked it out with great care. Three kinds of "what is due" are often distinguished, following Aristotle and Aquinas.
- Commutative justice concerns fair dealing between persons: an honest price, a promise kept, a debt paid.
- Distributive justice concerns how common things or burdens are shared among the members of a community. What counts as a fair share is exactly what people argue about.
- Legal justice (sometimes called general justice) concerns what each person owes to the common good, such as obeying fair laws and bearing a share of public tasks.
Notice that these are categories, not answers. Two people may agree that "distributive justice" is a real thing and still disagree about what a fair distribution is. In the Catholic tradition a fourth phrase, social justice, came into use from the nineteenth and twentieth centuries to name the justice of the way a society's institutions are arranged. Writers within and outside that tradition use the phrase in different ways, and it is worth asking in each case what the speaker means.
4. The common good
The common good is an old phrase, and a frequently misunderstood one. It does not mean the total of what each person wants, nor the wishes of a majority. In the Catholic tradition, which has given the phrase most attention, it refers to the conditions of social life that allow persons and groups to flourish: peace, order, a shared life in which each can reach what is good for a human being. The key idea is that some goods are shared and cannot be had alone: a trusted language, safe streets, honest dealing, a community that remembers its dead and teaches its young. Each person benefits, but no one owns these goods.
Augustine, a bishop in North Africa in the fourth and fifth centuries, wrote about two communities that live mixed together in this age. One is gathered by the love of God; the other by love of self. Both use the earthly peace: the ordinary order of villages, markets and courts. He taught that Christians, as pilgrims in this world, should use and seek that peace, and that a state without justice is hardly different from a band of robbers. He did not think any human city could be the city of God, and he was cautious about any claim that a political order is itself saved. Readers still argue about how much hope he left for public life: some hear a strong realism and a call to modest service, others hear a real support for public justice.
Aquinas took a more confident view of human political life as part of the order God made. For him a law is an of reason, for the common good, made by one who has care of the community. A rule that serves only a ruler's advantage is not truly a law in the full sense. His account of , the idea that human reason can know basic goods and wrongs, has shaped Catholic reflection on public life and has been both admired and criticised by Protestant and Orthodox thinkers.
5. How other traditions speak
The traditions are not simply variations on Augustine and Aquinas.
Reformed writers, following John Calvin in the sixteenth century, held that civil government is a gift of God for the outward order of society, and that God's law has a place in guiding it. Calvin himself gave magistrates duties for both the care of neighbours and the protection of true worship; many Reformed churches later revised the second duty. Abraham Kuyper, a Dutch theologian and statesman of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, spoke of sphere sovereignty (we met the term in lecture 1-2): family, school, church, business and state each have their own proper authority under God, and justice includes not letting one sphere swallow another. Notice that this is an idea about the limits of power as much as about its use.
The Orthodox tradition is rich in its teaching on mercy and care for the poor, in the writings of early bishops such as Basil of Caesarea and John Chrysostom, who both gave a great deal of attention to the care of the poor and the sick. Basil, in the fourth century, is known for founding a large complex for the poor and the sick. In the Byzantine world, Orthodox Christians spoke of an ideal of symphony, a harmony between church and ruler, each with its own task. Orthodox writers today differ about what the ideal teaches and about how far it can be used outside the setting where it grew; critics ask whether such an ideal can end by blessing power. We state this as a description, not a verdict.
The Anabaptist tradition, which grew in the sixteenth century, tends to place justice first in the common life of the church: forgiveness, the sharing of goods and refusing to use force. Many in this tradition are wary of expecting the state to produce what the church is for, while many also work for the good of their neighbours. This will matter in the next lecture.
Each of these voices has a strength and a risk. The Catholic account is wide-ranging and gives a place for public reason, and it can seem to trust the state or human reason too much. The Reformed account protects both the order of law and the limits of power, and it can be tempted to make the law do the work of grace. The Orthodox account roots justice in worship and mercy, and it can be tempted to trust a harmony that hides injustice. The Anabaptist account protects the integrity of the church's witness, and it can seem to leave public life to others.
6. Freedom, equality and the common good
Three ideas pull on every discussion of public life, and each is good.
Freedom can mean not being forced: freedom from interference. It can also mean the ability to do what is good: freedom for something. Scripture speaks of both. 1 Peter 2:16 says to live as free people, and not to use freedom as a cover for doing wrong.
Equality can mean that every person has the same dignity as one made in God's image, which most Christians affirm. It can mean equal treatment before the law. It can mean equal opportunity, or equal outcomes. These are different claims, and people who agree on the first may disagree about the last.
The common good, as described above, asks what conditions let a whole community flourish together.
(An invented example.) A village shares one well. A council must decide how to use it in a dry year. One member says that each household should be free to draw what it needs, since people know their own needs. Another says that each household should receive the same amount, since each is of equal worth. A third says that the well must be kept from running empty, so that the whole village, including the children, will have water next year. Each speaks of something real. The first guards freedom, the second equality, the third the common good. A wise council does not decide that two of them are false. It asks how far each can be honoured, and who will bear the cost of the compromise.
The example is deliberately small. It shows that the three ideas are not enemies but that none of them can be pursued without limit. Christians in different places and traditions weigh them differently. The same believer may weigh them differently in different areas of life.
7. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: what the proper task of government is, in the light of Scripture and tradition. One view, strong in the Catholic tradition, holds that government has a real responsibility for the conditions of the common good, and that it may act where smaller communities cannot, while respecting those communities (the principle of subsidiarity, which says that a higher body should not take over what a lower one can do well, but should help when needed). Its strength is that it takes seriously the weak who cannot protect themselves. Its weak point is that a state with a wide task can become too large, and may take over the work of families, churches and neighbours.
A second view, associated with Reformed sphere sovereignty and with many other Protestant writers, holds that government has a limited task, to keep order and administer justice, and that other spheres of life have their own authority under God. Its strength is that it limits the power of any one body and protects the freedom of the church, the family and the school. Its weak point is that the limits are hard to draw, and some ask whether a limited state can protect those who have no strong sphere to protect them.
A third view, found in the Anabaptist and some other traditions, holds that the church's first political act is to be a community that shows another way of living, and that the state's use of force is a different kind of thing from the church's way. Its strength is that it keeps the church's witness clear. Its weak point is that it may seem to give too little guidance to those who must work with the state and for those who suffer within it.
What the course requires is that you can state each of these fairly, name what it protects and what it risks, and say how the three ideas of freedom, equality and the common good enter into each. It does not ask you to say which of them is right, and it applies none of them to a present law or party.
8. Love and justice
Romans 13:8-10 gives a place to begin again. Paul says that the debts we always owe are the debt of love, and that love does no harm to a neighbour. Notice that he does not say that love replaces justice. The commandments he names (not to murder, steal or covet) are the stuff of justice. He says they are summed up in loving one's neighbour as oneself. Many Christians have taken this to mean that justice is the minimum shape of love, and that love always asks for more than a court can require. Others have stressed that love can sometimes forgive what justice might demand, and that this too is part of the Christian pattern. We shall see both in lecture 2-4.
Diagram 1. Three pulls on public life
In short
- Scripture pairs mishpat (justice, right judging and setting wrongs right) with tsedaqah (righteousness, right relationship); together they reach the weak and the overlooked.
- Biblical justice is impartial in the courtroom and attentive to the weak in the community; Exodus 23:3 and 23:6 hold both.
- The common good is the set of shared conditions that allow persons and groups to flourish, not the total of private wishes.
- Augustine, Aquinas, the Reformed, Orthodox and Anabaptist traditions speak about justice differently; each has a strength and a risk.
- Freedom, equality and the common good are each real goods that pull against each other when pursued alone.
- Traditions differ about the proper task of government; the course asks for a fair statement of each, not a choice.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Mishpat and tsedaqah | Justice (right judging, setting wrongs right) and righteousness (right relationship); Scripture often pairs them. |
| Common good | The shared conditions of social life that let persons and groups flourish; not the total of what each wants. |
| Three pulls | Freedom, equality and the common good: each is a real good, and none can be pursued without limit. |
| Subsidiarity | A higher body should not take over what a lower body can do well, but should help when needed. |
One sentence to remember Justice in Scripture is both impartial in judgement and attentive to the weak, and the traditions weigh freedom, equality and the common good in different ways.
This week's action Think of one decision in a group you belong to, and ask which of the three, freedom, equality or the common good, each person speaking was protecting.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- How do *mishpat* and *tsedaqah* together widen the ordinary English idea of "justice"?
- Why do Exodus 23:3 and 23:6 not contradict each other? What does each protect?
- In your own words, what is the common good, and how does it differ from the total of what individuals want?
- In the invented example of the village well, which of the three voices would you find it hardest to take seriously? Why might that be a useful thing to notice?
- Choose two of the three views of the task of government. State each as its holders would, with its strength and its weak point.