FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL11E Public Theology: The Church, Politics, Economy and Society

Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice

Contents 31
STEL11E Public Theology: The Church, Politics, Economy and Society
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Public Life?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Public Life?
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Faith in the Public Square
  1. Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
  2. Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
  3. Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
  4. Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Politics and Authority
  1. Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
  2. Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
  3. Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
  4. Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Economy and Work
  1. Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
  2. Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
  3. Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
  4. Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
Chapter 4 · Week 4: People and Neighbours
  1. Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
  3. Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
  4. Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Creation, Culture and Civil Society
  1. Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
  2. Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
  3. Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
  4. Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
Chapter 6 · Week 6: The Church's Public Witness
  1. Lecture 6-1: Service, Advocacy and Witness
  2. Lecture 6-2: Public Witness in Different Settings
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Virtues of Public Witness
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Map of Where Believers Disagree: Course Synthesis
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Next Step in Public Witness

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

Of all the things authority does, punishing wrong is the one that touches people most painfully. Some readers have been harmed by crime. Some have been through the justice system as accused persons or as relatives of the accused. Some work in it. This lecture is written with all of them in mind. It does not say what any law should be, and it does not name any country. It asks what punishment is for, in the Christian traditions' own words, what restorative justice is and what is said for and against it, how Christians have disagreed about the death penalty, and how mercy and justice can be held together.

If a part of this lecture comes close to your own experience, you may skip it, and you may speak to a trusted pastor, priest or counsellor. If you are in danger now, call your local emergency number.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Name four or five purposes that punishment is said to serve, and state a strength and a risk of each.
  • Explain how Romans 12:17-21 and Romans 13:4 have been held together in the traditions.
  • Describe restorative justice and give one argument for it and one question asked about it.
  • State fairly the positions Christians take on capital punishment, each in its strongest form and with its weak point.
  • Explain why mercy and justice need each other, using Zacchaeus in Luke 19.

‘You shall do no injustice in judgment. You shall not be partial to the poor, nor show favoritism to the great; but you shall judge your neighbor in righteousness." — Leviticus 19:15

World English Bible

He entered and was passing through Jericho. There was a man named Zacchaeus. He was a chief tax collector, and he was rich. He was trying to see who Jesus was, and couldn’t because of the crowd, because he was short. He ran on ahead, and climbed up into a sycamore tree to see him, for he was to pass that way. When Jesus came to the place, he looked up and saw him, and said to him, “Zacchaeus, hurry and come down, for today I must stay at your house.” He hurried, came down, and received him joyfully. When they saw it, they all murmured, saying, “He has gone in to lodge with a man who is a sinner.” Zacchaeus stood and said to the Lord, “Behold, Lord, half of my goods I give to the poor. If I have wrongfully exacted anything of anyone, I restore four times as much.” Jesus said to him, “Today, salvation has come to this house, because he also is a son of Abraham. For the Son of Man came to seek and to save that which was lost.”" — Luke 19:1-10

WEB

Repay no one evil for evil. Respect what is honorable in the sight of all men. If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men. Don’t seek revenge yourselves, beloved, but give place to God’s wrath. For it is written, “Vengeance belongs to me; I will repay, says the Lord.” Therefore “If your enemy is hungry, feed him. If he is thirsty, give him a drink; for in doing so, you will heap coals of fire on his head.” Don’t be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good." — Romans 12:17-21

WEB

What the text says. Leviticus 19:15 forbids injustice in judgment and says not to be partial to the poor or to favour the great, but to judge a neighbour in righteousness. Luke 19 tells of Zacchaeus, a rich chief tax collector whom the crowd called a sinner. Jesus stays at his house. Zacchaeus says that he gives half of his goods to the poor and restores four times what he wrongfully took, and Jesus says that salvation has come to the house. Romans 12:17-21 tells believers not to repay evil for evil, to be at peace with all so far as it depends on them, not to take revenge but to leave room for God's wrath, and to overcome evil with good.

A tradition's reading. Many Christians have read Leviticus 19:15 as a standard for courts: fair to rich and poor alike. Luke 19 has been read as a picture of repentance that includes repair, so that forgiveness and restitution belong together. Romans 12 has been read in two ways: as a rule for private persons, leaving public punishment to those whose office it is (Romans 13:4), or as the pattern for all Christian responses to wrong, including those of public life. The traditions that read it the second way tend to be wary of the state's use of force; those that read it the first way tend to accept it as a God-given duty.

Our judgement. The three passages do not give a penal code. They give a standard for judging (fair, with no favourites), a picture of repentance that reaches to repair, and a call to a way of living in which revenge is given up. They ask the reader to hold fairness, repair and the refusal of revenge together. The rest of the lecture shows how hard this is, and how differently people have done it.

1. What is punishment for?

People who agree that a wrong should be answered may still give different reasons. Christian writers have used the same list as everyone else, with their own accents. Here are five purposes that are often named.

Retribution says that a wrong deserves an answer, and that the answer should fit the wrong. It treats the offender as a responsible person, who can be held to account, and it takes the victim's wrong seriously. Many readers see in "an eye for an eye" in the law of Moses a limit as well as a demand: no more than the wrong that was done. The strength of this view is its moral seriousness and its demand for proportion. The risk is that it can slide into revenge, which Romans 12:19 forbids to private persons and gives to God.

Protection (sometimes called incapacitation) says that society and neighbours must be kept safe from those who have done grave harm. The strength is plain: the weak need protecting, and this is part of the purpose of authority in Romans 13. The risk is that it can be stretched too far, so that a person is seen only as a danger and never as someone who can change.

Deterrence says that punishment should discourage others from doing the same wrong. The strength is that it looks to the safety of all. The risk is that a person may be punished more heavily for the sake of an example, which many Christians find hard to accept, since a person is not a means to an end.

Correction (or rehabilitation) says that punishment should aim at the offender's change, so that he or she may return to the community as a better person. The strength is hope: Christians believe that people can be changed. The risk is that "correction" can become control, can ignore the victim, and can become a name for something that does not actually help the person.

Restoration or repair says that the aim is to put right, as far as possible, what was broken: the harm to the victim and to the community, and the offender's relationship to both. We shall look at this separately below.

Most justice systems use several of these in some mixture, and Christians hold them in different proportions. Notice that Scripture touches all of them. The sword of Romans 13:4 speaks of protection and answer. Leviticus 19:15 speaks of fairness. The law of Moses also contains restitution, the making good of loss. And the prophets speak of turning back to God and living.

2. Holding Romans 12 and 13 together

The same letter says, in chapter 12, that believers should not repay evil for evil and should leave vengeance to God. In chapter 13 it describes the ruler.

"for he is a servant of God to you for good. But if you do that which is evil, be afraid, for he doesn’t bear the sword in vain; for he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil." — Romans 13:4 (WEB)

How do these fit? The older traditions mostly said this. The believer, as a private person, does not take revenge; God is the judge of all, and he has given the ruler a duty to restrain wrong and to protect the neighbour. A Christian who holds public office may therefore do, in that office, what he or she may not do privately. Augustine, Luther and Calvin all spoke in this way in their own terms. Augustine also pleaded, in letters to officials, for mercy toward convicted persons, while accepting that the state had a duty to punish, and he warned that those who judge must watch their own hearts.

Other traditions, especially the Anabaptist, have said that Romans 12 sets the pattern for all of Christian life, and that Christians should not take part in the use of force even in office. They do not deny that rulers have a task; they ask whether a disciple of Jesus is called to it. The disagreement is real, and the strongest form of each is not a caricature of the other. The first protects the neighbour who needs protection and takes the ruler's role as a gift of God. The second protects the integrity of the way of Jesus, and asks whether Christians are too ready to see the sword as a necessity. Neither gets rid of the weak point in the other: the first can bless force too readily, and the second can seem to leave the work of restraint to others.

3. Prisons and the church

Christians have been involved in the history of punishment in other ways. In the early centuries, the church had its own practice of penance for serious sin, aimed at healing and return, and not simply at pain. Later, Christian reformers, among them some Quakers in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, argued for prisons as places where a person might reflect and repent, as an alternative to cruel physical punishments. The word penitentiary comes from this idea. Historians also note that some of the methods they promoted, such as long isolation, were later seen by many as harmful. The lesson is not that Christian reform was foolish but that good intentions need to be tested against what actually happens to people. Hebrews 13:3 asks believers to remember those in prison as if they were bound with them, and many Christians in many places have visited prisoners and cared for their families.

4. Restorative justice

Restorative justice is a way of thinking, and a set of practices, that starts from a different question. Instead of asking only which rule was broken and how should the offender be punished, it asks: who was harmed, what do they need, and who is responsible for putting it right? The word for the harm is wide. It includes the victim, the victim's family, the community and the offender's own relationships.

In practice, this may include a meeting, if all freely agree and are safe, between a victim and the person who caused the harm, with a trained person to guide it. It may include a circle in which family, neighbours and others speak. It may include an apology, repayment, work to repair damage, and a plan for the offender's return. Many traditional communities in several parts of the world have long used forms of this, and in the twentieth century the modern movement grew. Some Mennonite practitioners were among the early developers, drawing on their tradition's emphasis on reconciliation, and a well-known book by Howard Zehr, Changing Lenses, set out the approach for many readers.

The biblical echoes that supporters point to include the Hebrew idea of shalom (a wholeness of right relationships), the law's call for restitution, and the story of Zacchaeus, where repentance includes giving back. Notice that Zacchaeus is not simply forgiven and let go. He is received, and he repairs.

Restorative approaches are discussed with care by those who work in them, and the questions asked of them are fair ones.

  • Is it too soft? Supporters say that facing the person you harmed is often harder than a sentence, and that restorative work can sit beside a penalty and need not replace it. Critics say that it can seem to put the offender's needs above the victim's wrong.
  • Does it pressure victims? This matters a great deal. Supporters say that taking part must be free, that a victim may refuse, and that no victim should ever be told that forgiveness or a meeting is required. Critics say that, in practice, social pressure can make "voluntary" less than free.
  • Is it suitable for all harms? Many people who work in this field say that it must be used with great care, or not at all, in cases of ongoing abuse or grave violence, where a meeting might put someone in danger. This is one reason that no one should present it as the answer to every case.

The honest summary is that restorative justice is an approach with real appeal in Christian thought, with real limits, and that claims about how well it works should be tested and not taken on trust.

5. Forgiveness, repair and what the text does not say

Many readers who have been wronged have been told that Christians must forgive, and told it too quickly. Romans 12 does not say that you must feel safe, or pretend that nothing happened, or return to a person who has hurt you. It does not say that a wrong has no consequences. Christian traditions have long distinguished between forgiveness, which gives up revenge and the wish to see the other harmed, and reconciliation, which needs two people and trust. Justice may still ask for accountability, and safety may still ask for distance. Anyone who speaks to a person who has been hurt should be slow to tell them what they must do.

6. Where readers will not agree: the death penalty

This is a point where readers will not agree: whether the state may take the life of a person convicted of a grave crime. Christians in the same church, and in different churches, hold different views. We state three, not as the whole of any tradition.

The first view holds that the state may do so, in grave cases and with careful procedure. Its supporters point to Genesis 9:6, which speaks of the shedding of a person's blood and links it to the , to the sword in Romans 13:4, and to the fact that most Christian churches for most of their history accepted the practice, including Aquinas and Calvin. The strongest form of the argument is that the gravest penalty shows how great the value of a human life is, and that justice for a murder is a moral duty. Its weak point is that Genesis 9:6 may also be read as a statement of what follows from violence, rather than as a command to a court; that an execution cannot be undone if a mistake is found; and that, in practice, the penalty may fall unequally on people who have less power to defend themselves.

The second view holds that the state should not do so. Its supporters point to the image of God, which the offender also bears, to the possibility of repentance, which an execution ends, to the way of Jesus toward those who did wrong, and to the risk of irreversible error. The Catholic Church, whose teaching in earlier centuries allowed the penalty in rare cases, revised its in 2018 to call it inadmissible, on grounds of the dignity of the person and the ability of society to protect itself by other means; Catholic thinkers still discuss how this relates to earlier teaching. Many in the Anabaptist tradition also oppose it. The strongest form of the argument is that a society may protect itself without taking a life and that to take a life gives up on the possibility of repentance. Its weak point is that the law of Moses and much of the later tradition accepted the penalty, and some victims and their families feel that nothing else can answer the wrong done.

A third view holds that the penalty may be just in principle but should not be used in practice, because courts make errors and apply it unfairly. Its strength is that it takes both the weight of the crime and the weakness of human judgement seriously. Its weak point is that it can be hard to say, in a given place, what would count as safe enough.

What this course requires is that you can state each position as its holders would, with its strength and its weak point, and name the texts and arguments each uses. It does not ask you to take a side, and it says nothing about the law of any country. Remember that in any group there may be a person whose family member was killed, and another whose family member has been executed or imprisoned. Speak with care.

7. Mercy and justice together

Return to Zacchaeus. The crowd murmured when Jesus went to the house of a man known as a cheat. Jesus did not deny the wrong. He did not say that it did not matter. He went to the house, he was received joyfully, and Zacchaeus repaired what he had taken. Jesus then said that salvation had come. Mercy came first; repair followed; neither was a substitute for the other.

Justice without mercy tends toward cruelty, and mercy without justice tends to leave the victim alone. Micah 6:8 asks for both: to act justly, and to love mercy. Many Christian traditions, in their own words, say that a just society will have both its courts and its pardons, its penalties and its repair, and that no human system gets them in perfect balance. They also say that the final judge is God, who sees what no court sees. That is not a reason to give up trying to be just. It is a reason to do the work with humility.


Diagram 1. What punishment is for

What is punishment for? Several purposes, usually mixed; each protects something and risks something Retribution Protects: proportion; the wrong is taken seriously. Risk: it can slide into revenge. Protection Protects: neighbours from grave harm. Risk: a person seen only as a danger. Deterrence Protects: the safety of many. Risk: a person used as an example. Correction Protects: hope that a person can change. Risk: control under another name; the victim forgotten. Restoration Protects: the repair of harm and relationships. Risk: pressure on victims; not fit for every harm. Restorative justice asks three questions Who was harmed? What do they need? Who is responsible for putting it right? Taking part must be free, and safe. No victim is ever told to forgive or to meet. It may sit beside a penalty. It is used with great care, or not at all, where danger remains.

In short

  • Punishment is said to serve retribution, protection, deterrence, correction and restoration; each has a strength and a risk.
  • Older traditions held Romans 12 (no private revenge) and Romans 13:4 (the ruler's duty) together; Anabaptist traditions read Romans 12 as the pattern for all.
  • Restorative justice asks who was harmed, what they need and who must put it right; taking part must be free and safe.
  • Forgiveness, which gives up revenge, is not the same as reconciliation, and neither cancels accountability or safety.
  • Christians take three main positions on capital punishment; each has a strong form and a weak point.
  • Zacchaeus shows mercy that is received and repair that follows; mercy and justice need each other.
Front Back
Five purposes Retribution, protection, deterrence, correction, restoration.
Restorative justice A way of answering harm that asks who was harmed, what they need and who must put it right; free, safe, never forced.
Forgiveness and reconciliation Forgiveness gives up revenge; reconciliation needs two people and trust; neither cancels accountability.
Capital punishment Christians hold at least three positions: it may be just; it should not be used; it may be just in principle but not in practice.

One sentence to remember Justice that forgets mercy turns cruel and mercy that forgets repair abandons the victim, so hold both and speak with care.

This week's action Read Luke 19:1-10 again, and write what each person in the story gives up, receives or repairs.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the five purposes of punishment do you find easiest to understand, and which hardest? What does each protect and what does each risk?
  • How have older traditions held Romans 12:17-21 and Romans 13:4 together? How does the Anabaptist reading differ?
  • What question does restorative justice ask that a penalty alone may not? What question do its critics raise?
  • State two of the positions on the death penalty as their holders would, each with strength and weak point. Why might a group member need you to speak with care?
  • In the story of Zacchaeus, what comes first, and what follows? What does this suggest about mercy and justice?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.