Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
- Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
- Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
- Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
- Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
- Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
- Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
- Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
- Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
- Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
- Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
- Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
- Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
- Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
- Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
- Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
- Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
- Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
- Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
A plural society is one where people of many faiths, and of none, live side by side and share streets, schools, markets and laws. Most readers of this course live in one. Some are part of a large Christian majority, some of a small minority, some in a place where the balance has changed within their own lifetime. In each case a hard question stands: how can Christians speak and live what they believe in public, honestly and with conviction, while treating every neighbour as a person who is free to believe otherwise?
This lecture asks that question in three steps. It looks at the language Christians use in public and how they explain themselves to people who do not share it. It asks why freedom of religion, the freedom to hold, practise, change or leave a faith, belongs to every person and not only to Christians. And it remembers, honestly, that Christians have sometimes used faith to exclude and harm, as well as being excluded and harmed themselves. It ends with a point on which readers will not agree: how far religious freedom reaches in public life.
The lecture describes positions and does not judge any country's law or any government. Laws differ widely. Follow local law and your community's written rules.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Say what Matthew 5:44-45, Romans 12:18 and 1 Peter 3:15-16 ask of a Christian in a plural society.
- Explain why Christians in several traditions have held that freedom of religion belongs to every person, including people of other faiths and of none.
- Describe honestly, in general terms, how faith has been used both to exclude and to protect, without ranking any community.
- State the main positions on how far religious freedom reaches in public life, each with its strength and its weak point.
- Describe the difference between witness and domination in a plural setting.
But I tell you, love your enemies, bless those who curse you, do good to those who hate you, and pray for those who mistreat you and persecute you, that you may be children of your Father who is in heaven. For he makes his sun to rise on the evil and the good, and sends rain on the just and the unjust." — Matthew 5:44-45
World English Bible
If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men." — Romans 12:18
WEB
But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts; and always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear: having a good conscience; that, while you are spoken against as evildoers, they may be disappointed who curse your good way of life in Christ." — 1 Peter 3:15-16
WEB
What the text says. In Matthew 5:44-45 Jesus tells his hearers to love their enemies and to pray for those who mistreat them, so that they may be children of their Father, who gives sun and rain to the evil and the good alike. In Romans 12:18 Paul says that, as far as it depends on the believer, they should be at peace with everyone. In 1 Peter 3:15-16 believers are told to be ready to give an answer to anyone who asks about their hope, with humility and fear, keeping a good conscience, even when they are spoken against.
A tradition's reading. Many Christians hear in Matthew 5 a limit on how they treat those who differ from them: God's kindness reaches people who do not believe, so the believer's kindness should too. Some read Romans 12:18 as a call to seek peace actively; others stress the words "if it is possible" as a reminder that peace sometimes depends on others. 1 Peter 3:15 is often read as a description of a way of speaking, ready, humble and gentle, and not as a plan for winning arguments. Readers differ about how much these passages say about public law and the state, and how much only about personal conduct.
Our judgement. The three passages describe a way of living with others who may be hostile or simply different. They do not give a theory of religious freedom and do not mention a state. When a theory is built on them, the building is ours, and we should say so.
1. Speaking in a plural square
Lecture 1-4 asked whether believers should speak in the shared language of the public square or in the language of faith. Week 5 takes that question into daily life. A Christian in a plural society speaks to neighbours who use other words for what matters most. Some say "God" and mean something quite different from what a Christian means. Some use other names. Some do not speak of God at all. A Christian may use the language of faith inside the church, the shared language of citizens in a public meeting, and ordinary human words at a kitchen table. All three can be honest.
1 Peter 3:15-16 describes a tone more than a vocabulary. The word translated "answer" is the word for a reasoned defence, and the verse says that it is given when someone asks. The believer is not told to push a message on people who have not asked. The believer is told to be ready, so that the hope is not hidden, and to answer with humility and a good conscience. The final phrase of the passage is worth noticing. It expects that believers may be spoken against, and it asks that they live so that the criticism has no basis. It does not ask them to answer in kind.
(An invented example.) A woman at a workplace is asked by a colleague of another faith why she does not join a certain celebration. She does not give a speech and does not pretend to have no reason. She says that her faith shapes how she keeps the year, tells him a little of what she does keep, and asks about his own tradition. He is surprised to be asked. They continue to eat lunch together. This is neither a victory nor a defeat. It is a small act of the kind that 1 Peter has in mind.
2. Witness in many settings
Christians in a plural society occupy very different positions. Some belong to a majority whose faith has shaped the public calendar and law for centuries. Some are a minority whose neighbours hold the public power, and whose worship may be tolerated, restricted or at risk. Some are immigrants who keep their faith in a new language in a new place. Some are the second or third generation of a community that no longer feels like a stranger and not wholly at home either. The temptation differs with the position. A majority can be tempted to expect that its faith will be favoured and to treat other faiths as guests. A minority can be tempted to withdraw, or to see every neighbour as a danger. Each should ask honestly what its own position tempts it to do.
The central claim of the course, that the church is called out of the world and sent for the world, applies in all of them. Witness is possible from any position. It does not depend on having power, and where there is power it should not rely on it.
3. Why religious freedom belongs to every person
Freedom of religion means that a person may hold a faith, change it, practise it in worship and daily life, teach it to their children, or hold none, without being forced by threat or penalty. Many Christians have come to hold that this freedom belongs to every human being and not only to Christians. Their reasons differ, and it is worth setting out three.
The first reason is theological. Faith, on this view, cannot be forced. A confession made under threat is not a confession. Writers in the early church, such as Tertullian around the year 200, argued that worship has to be given freely to be worship. The claim is that God asks for the heart, and a heart cannot be commanded.
The second reason is about the dignity of the person. Because every human being bears the , a person's conscience deserves respect even when it is mistaken. Catholic teaching took this up in a declaration on religious freedom adopted at the Second Vatican Council in the 1960s, which says that each person has a right not to be forced to act against conscience in religious matters and not to be prevented from acting on it within due limits. Several Protestant traditions, including some Baptist and Anabaptist communities, had long argued for liberty of conscience, and in the seventeenth century Roger Williams, a Protestant minister, founded a colony in North America on the principle that a person's conscience should not be coerced by the civil power. Orthodox thinkers have also written about freedom of conscience, and the way the question is put differs among Orthodox churches. These are different roads that lead to related conclusions, and they are not identical.
The third reason is practical, and is often put as a Golden Rule. Christians who are a minority somewhere want freedom for their own worship. It is hard to ask for it in one place and to deny it in another. The same freedom that protects a Christian under pressure must protect a person of another faith, or of none, in a place where Christians are many.
A statement after the Second World War, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 1948, includes freedom of thought, conscience and religion, and it includes the freedom to change one's religion. Christians have appealed to that statement in many places. It is also true that nations that have signed such statements have kept them in different degrees. This lecture mentions it because it is part of the world in which Christians speak, and not to judge any country.
The lecture does not claim that these reasons are the only Christian ones or that all Christians have held them. Some have not, and the history that follows shows why we must say so.
4. Honest remembering
An honest account of the Christian past in a plural world has two sides. Both are true.
On one side, Christians have been persecuted, in the first centuries by various rulers, and in many later times and places by other powers. Some are in danger today, and many readers know this in their own families. Nobody should treat that suffering as a debating point or as less than real.
On the other side, Christians have also been among those who excluded and harmed. After the fourth century, when the Roman state came to favour the Christian faith (the Edict of Milan of the year 313 is the usual starting point), it became possible for Christians to use the power of the state against people who did not agree. Over the following centuries, in many places, people were pressed to convert, forced to leave, denied rights or harmed because of their religion. Jews were often the targets of such treatment, and so were Christians of other traditions, and later people of many other faiths. At times, Christians in one tradition used the state against Christians in another. We will not give particular cases here, and we describe none in detail. The point for a student is to know that the record exists and that most traditions today have said so in some form, with repentance, and not to treat the record as only an attack from outside.
Why say this in a course on public life? There are three reasons. First, truthfulness. A church that remembers only the harm done to it is not telling the whole truth. Second, humility. A person who knows that their own community has misused power will be slower to ask for power. Third, trust. Neighbours of other faiths remember, and they listen differently to a church that can say that it remembers too. This is not a reason to hate one's own tradition. It is a reason to say, as Christians often do in confession, that what has been done in the church's name is the church's to answer for.
5. Where witness shades into domination
Take the line between witness and domination in a plural setting. Witness means telling what we hold, living by it, inviting and being ready to answer. Domination means making others conform: by law that forces belief, by social pressure that makes a minority afraid, by contempt, by threats, by buying loyalty with help, or by misrepresenting another faith to win an argument.
Some forms are plain. Some are subtle, and some depend on place. In a school or hospital or workplace, a person with power over others (a teacher, a manager, a carer) has to be careful that an invitation to faith is not heard as a requirement. The person on the other side of the desk may feel unable to say no. A church that offers food or help to people in need must be clear that the help does not depend on attending or believing, since a person in need is not free to refuse. These are questions about power, and the same words that are witness in one setting can be pressure in another. The rule of thumb is: Can the other person say no, and keep their dignity and their help? If not, something has gone wrong.
Evangelism and conversion are an honest part of many Christian traditions, and this lecture does not say that sharing one's faith is domination. It says that sharing differs from forcing. A person is free to say yes, free to say no, and free to say "not now". The same freedom applies to Christians who are asked to speak or act against their conscience.
6. A point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is how far religious freedom reaches in public life.
One view holds that it reaches far. On this view freedom of religion covers not only private belief and worship but also public expression and the right of religious communities to run their own affairs: to teach, to gather, to run schools and charities according to their convictions, and in some cases to be excused from a requirement that conflicts with conscience. Its strongest argument is that faith is a whole way of life, so a freedom that stops at the church door is hollow. It also notes that majorities can burden minorities by laws that seem neutral. Its weak point is that a wide claim can conflict with the rights and needs of others, such as those who work for or are served by a religious body, and that it is hard to say where a claim of conscience ends and a claim of convenience begins.
A second view holds that freedom of belief and worship must be fully protected, but that public life, and especially the law and public services, must apply equally to all, with any exceptions few, clear and carefully limited. Its strongest argument is that equal treatment protects everyone, including religious minorities, and that a public order in which each group has its own rules for public matters would be unfair to those who belong to none. Its weak point is that equal rules can fall unevenly on those whose practice differs from the common pattern, and that it can leave a believer to choose between conscience and participation.
A third view holds that the public space should be strictly neutral, with religious symbols and speech kept to private and congregational life, so that no faith appears to be favoured by the state. Its strongest argument is that neutrality protects those who believe differently and prevents a majority from using public space to press its own faith. Its weak point is that neutrality may not be possible, since every public space rests on some view of what matters, and that believers may feel asked to be a different person in public than at home.
Christians are found on every one of these sides, and they apply them differently in different countries because the facts and the laws differ. They also differ on a further point on which the state's powers touch: what weight religious freedom should have when it meets other rights. This course does not ask you to choose. It asks that you can state each position fairly, say what each protects and where it is weak, and notice that the position a Christian finds natural may depend on whether their community is large or small. It also asks that you hold one thing in common with all three: the freedom you ask for yourself must also be given to a neighbour who believes differently.
7. What the course asks
To keep the line between witness and domination in a plural society, the course asks for four habits.
- Say it plainly and kindly. Explain what you believe and why, when asked, in words a neighbour can follow.
- Ask before you assume. Learn what a neighbour's faith or lack of faith actually says, in the words that neighbour would use.
- Give what you ask. If you want freedom to worship, argue for the freedom of others to do the same.
- Remember honestly. Name the times when Christians have harmed others, and do not use the harm done to Christians as an excuse for contempt.
None of these requires you to hide your faith, to say that all faiths are the same, or to give up the claim that Christ is Lord. Whether and how to say so is a question for the next lecture and for your own tradition.
Diagram 1. Three views of how far religious freedom reaches, and the habits that hold in all
In short
- Matthew 5:44-45, Romans 12:18 and 1 Peter 3:15-16 describe a way of living with those who differ: love, peace as far as possible, and a ready, humble answer.
- Many Christian traditions hold that religious freedom belongs to every person, for theological, dignity-based and practical reasons that differ.
- An honest history names both the persecution of Christians and the use of faith to exclude and harm others.
- Readers disagree on how far religious freedom reaches in public life; each view has a strength and a weak point.
- Witness lets the other person say no and keep their dignity and help; domination does not.
- The freedom we ask for ourselves must be given to a neighbour who believes differently.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| 1 Peter 3:15-16 | Be ready to answer anyone who asks, with humility and a good conscience, even when spoken against. |
| Why freedom belongs to everyone | Faith cannot be forced; every person bears God's image; the freedom that protects us must protect others. |
| Honest remembering | Christians have been persecuted and have also used faith to exclude and harm; truthfulness, humility and trust all call for both to be said. |
| Test of witness | Can the other person say no, keep their dignity and keep their help? |
One sentence to remember Give an honest answer when asked, and give your neighbour the same freedom you ask for yourself.
This week's action Ask one neighbour of another faith, or of none, what matters most to them, and listen without replying with your own view.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What does 1 Peter 3:15-16 describe: a vocabulary, a tone, or a plan? Where in the passage do you see this?
- Give two of the reasons Christians have given for holding that religious freedom belongs to every person. Which seems strongest to you, and where would a critic push back?
- Why does an honest account of the past include harm done by Christians as well as harm done to them? What does this do for trust with neighbours?
- State two of the three views of how far religious freedom reaches in public life, each with its strength and its weak point.
- Where does help given by a church risk becoming pressure? What question tests it?