FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL11E Public Theology: The Church, Politics, Economy and Society

Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns

Contents 31
STEL11E Public Theology: The Church, Politics, Economy and Society
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Public Life?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Public Life?
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Faith in the Public Square
  1. Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
  2. Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
  3. Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
  4. Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Politics and Authority
  1. Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
  2. Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
  3. Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
  4. Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Economy and Work
  1. Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
  2. Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
  3. Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
  4. Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
Chapter 4 · Week 4: People and Neighbours
  1. Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
  3. Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
  4. Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Creation, Culture and Civil Society
  1. Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
  2. Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
  3. Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
  4. Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
Chapter 6 · Week 6: The Church's Public Witness
  1. Lecture 6-1: Service, Advocacy and Witness
  2. Lecture 6-2: Public Witness in Different Settings
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Virtues of Public Witness
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Map of Where Believers Disagree: Course Synthesis
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Next Step in Public Witness

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

Whenever a church lives in a country, it lives beside a government. The two have been arranged in many ways, in many centuries, and Christians have defended nearly every arrangement from Scripture and from experience. This lecture sets out some patterns of church and state that scholars have described, with a strength and a risk for each. It then looks at three passages that Christians have used in thinking about the question, and it ends with a point where readers will not agree.

By state we mean the government and the machinery of law, courts, taxes and force by which a country is ruled. By church we mean the community of believers and its organised forms. The two words cover many kinds of things, and they are not always as separate in real life as they are on paper.

This lecture does not name any government, judge any country or say which arrangement is best. It describes types, and it uses invented cases to show them. Rules about church and state are set by the law of each country, and they change. Always follow the law of your own place and the written rules of your own community.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Describe four patterns of church and state (union or establishment, separation, cooperation, critical distance) and say what each protects and where each is weak.
  • Explain why a typology is a tool for thinking and not a map of any real country.
  • Say how Matthew 22:15-22, Acts 5:27-29 and Romans 13:1 have each been used in the discussion of church and state.
  • State the contested question about law and faith fairly from at least two sides.
  • Explain why the same pattern can look different from the point of view of a majority church and a minority church.

Tell us therefore, what do you think? Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar, or not?” But Jesus perceived their wickedness, and said, “Why do you test me, you hypocrites? Show me the tax money.” They brought to him a denarius. He asked them, “Whose is this image and inscription?” They said to him, “Caesar’s.” Then he said to them, “Give therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”" — Matthew 22:17-21

World English Bible

When they had brought them, they set them before the council. The high priest questioned them, saying, “Didn’t we strictly command you not to teach in this name? Behold, you have filled Jerusalem with your teaching, and intend to bring this man’s blood on us.” But Peter and the apostles answered, “We must obey God rather than men." — Acts 5:27-29

WEB

Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those who exist are ordained by God." — Romans 13:1

WEB

What the text says. In Matthew 22, people who hoped to trap Jesus ask whether it is lawful to pay tax to the emperor. Jesus asks whose image is on the coin and tells them to give to Caesar what is Caesar's and to God what is God's. In Acts 5, the council has ordered the apostles not to teach in Jesus' name, and Peter and the apostles answer that they must obey God rather than people. Romans 13:1 tells everyone to be in subjection to the higher authorities, and gives as a reason that no authority exists except from God.

A tradition's reading. Christians have heard in these passages three different things. Some hear a limited claim by the state: the emperor's claim is real, but it is not the whole claim, and the coin belongs to him while the person belongs to God. Some hear a boundary: when the state demands what belongs to God, the believer refuses. Some hear a duty of obedience that is rooted in God's own will for order. These readings are not always set against each other, and many traditions combine them. We return to the passages at greater length in lectures 2-1 and 2-3.

Our judgement. None of the three passages describes a whole arrangement of church and state. Matthew 22 is an answer to a trap, given to a particular question. Acts 5 is the case of a refusal by people ordered to stop proclaiming the gospel. Romans 13 is a short paragraph in a letter to Christians in a city under imperial rule. A student should be careful about turning any of them into a constitution.

1. Before there were patterns

The first Christians were a small group inside an empire that was not Christian. Sometimes they were left alone, sometimes they were suspected and sometimes they were persecuted. They had no way to arrange the state, and their questions were smaller and sharper: may we pay the tax, may we say the words of loyalty that others say, may we serve in some offices? In the fourth century that changed. The emperor Constantine ended the legal pressure on Christians (the usual date given for the first step is 313), and later in the same century Christianity became the favoured faith of the empire. From then on, in much of Europe and the lands around the Mediterranean, the church was bound up with the power of the state for a very long time. The questions changed from "may we pay?" to "how do the two powers share the work, and what happens when they disagree?"

Not every part of the Christian world followed the same path. Some churches lived for centuries under rulers of another faith. Others grew up where there was no single dominant church at all. The patterns below are shaped by all of these histories.

2. A typology, with a warning

There is an analysis that sorts the relations of church and state into a few types. Writers use different lists, and this is only one useful list. A is a set of categories made to help thinking. It always leaves things out. Real countries are mixtures and change over time, and a type is never a verdict on a government or a people. Please read the four types below as tools to sharpen questions, not as labels to stick on a real place.

3. Union or establishment

In this pattern, one church (or a small group of churches) is recognised by the state in a special way. The recognition can be strong or weak: in a strong form, the state helps to choose church leaders, the church has seats or duties in public bodies, and public life follows its calendar; in a weak form, the recognition is mostly a matter of history, ceremony or title.

What it protects: the idea that a nation as a whole may acknowledge God; chaplains in hospitals, schools and the armed forces; a church that is present in every village and open to all, not only to members; and a settled voice that can speak to the nation. Where it is weak: the church may become the servant of the state or may be tempted to speak in the state's voice; its critical voice may be dulled by privilege; people of other faiths or of none may be treated as lesser citizens; and membership may become a matter of national belonging rather than of faith. Some Christians inside such churches share these worries and work to keep the church free. Others hold that the benefits are real and that the dangers can be managed.

4. Separation

In this pattern, the state does not favour or fund any church and does not interfere in its internal life, and the churches do not govern. There are at least two quite different forms, and people often confuse them. In one, the state keeps out of religion but is friendly to it: religious groups are free to speak, to teach, to run schools and charities, and to take a full part in public debate. In another, the state also tries to keep religion out of public institutions, such as schools and offices, treating it as a private affair.

What it protects: freedom of conscience; the independence of the church, which can criticise the government without fear of losing a privileged place; and the equal standing of people of every faith or none. Many Christians, including those descended from groups that were once persecuted, are strong defenders of separation. Where it is weak: in its stricter forms, it may suggest that faith has no place in public reasoning, which many believers feel as an exclusion; and some ask whether a state can really be neutral about what a good life is. Defenders reply that neutrality in this sense means fairness to all, not hostility to any.

5. Cooperation

In this pattern, there is no single established church, but the state and the churches work together on shared tasks. They may share the work of running schools, hospitals, care for the elderly or for refugees. Public money may flow to religious bodies, often to many kinds, and the state may give religious groups a role in consultation.

What it protects: it makes use of the energy and the reach of the churches for the common good, and it can respect religious communities as part of civil society (we come to this in lecture 5-4). Where it is weak: a church that depends on public money can become shy of speaking against the funder; smaller or newer groups may be treated less well than the large ones; and the line between serving and being used can blur.

6. Critical distance

This one differs from the others, because it names an attitude more than a legal arrangement. It holds that, whatever the legal pattern, the church should keep a distance from the state's power, so that it can speak, when it must, to rulers and to the people as an independent voice. It is often linked with the prophets of Israel, who spoke to kings, and with believers who have lived under governments that were not friendly. It can be found inside an established church, inside a separated church and inside a cooperating one.

What it protects: the freedom to criticise and to refuse, and the sense that the church's first loyalty is to God. Where it is weak: distance can turn into disdain for ordinary public work, or into a habit of complaint that does not help anyone; it also has trouble saying when the church should work with the state; and a church that stands apart may find it hard to contribute to common tasks.

7. Three invented settings

Here are three invented cases (an invented example), set by type of setting. They are not about any real country.

A country with an established church. In a mountain country, the oldest church of the land has a formal place in public ceremony, and its priests are present at many state occasions. Most citizens are baptised in it, though many seldom attend. A priest in a village says that his congregation is the whole village, which is a joy to him: he buries the unbelieving and the believing, and everyone knows where to turn at a time of grief. A young member of a small Christian group in the same village says that she is always treated as a guest in her own country. They both love the village. Each sees a different thing.

A country with strict separation. In a large city, the law keeps religious symbols out of public schools and offices. A teacher who is a member of a church says that this protects her pupils, who come from many faiths, from being pressed. A parent in the same city says that his children never hear any adult say that faith matters, and he fears they will conclude that it does not. Both want the same pupils to be treated fairly.

A country with cooperation. On a wide plain, the government pays the churches and other religious groups to run clinics and schools, under shared rules. A clinic director says that without the arrangement, many poor patients would have no care. A pastor from a newer church says that his small group is left out of the arrangement because it does not meet the size the rules require, and that the larger churches have grown used to speaking softly.

In each case the type shows both a gift and a cost. A fair student keeps both in view and does not take a short route to a verdict.

8. Settings from the other side

The same pattern feels different from different positions. A member of a majority church may feel at home under a pattern of establishment, and a member of a minority church may feel like a guest there. A member of a church that has been persecuted may prize separation above everything. A member of a church that was pushed out of public life by hostility may prize cooperation as a way back. When someone defends a pattern with strong feeling, it may help to ask what that person's community has lived through. This is not to say that history decides what is right, but it explains why the argument is so warm.

9. A sober memory

It should be said plainly that Christian states and churches have, at various times, used the power of the state against Christians of other kinds, against Jews and against people of other faiths. After the Reformation of the sixteenth century, many territories in Europe followed the faith of their rulers, and those who differed were sometimes harassed or worse. Out of that memory came some of the strongest arguments for religious freedom. In the seventeenth century some Christians, such as the Baptist Roger Williams, argued that the state ought not to enforce faith, because faith that is forced is not faith. We take up religious freedom again in lecture 5-3. This history does not settle the question for every pattern, but it should keep us humble: arrangements that have seemed natural and holy to one generation have caused pain to others.

10. Where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree: whether the laws of a country should be shaped by the Christian faith, or whether the state should be separate from it, and in what way. One position holds that a nation should acknowledge God, that its laws will inevitably rest on some beliefs about what is good, and that those beliefs are better drawn openly from the Christian tradition than from sources hidden from view. This has the strength of honesty about the fact that every legal system assumes something, and its weak point is that those who do not share the faith may feel pressed, and that it is hard to find a form which does not give the state a hand in religion. A second position holds that the state should be strictly separate from religion, so that the church can be free and every citizen equal. This has the strength of protecting conscience and the church's independence; its weak point is that a strict form can seem to say that faith has no place in the reasoning of citizens, and it may be difficult to define where religion ends and ordinary moral conviction begins. A third position holds that the state should not endorse any faith but should welcome all of them into public life, as groups with a right to speak and serve. This has the strength of fairness and openness; its weak point is that it can be hard to apply when the beliefs of different groups clash. The course asks you to state each of these fairly, to say what each protects and what it risks, and to follow the law of your own country and the written rules of your own community; it does not ask you to say which is best.

11. What the passages do and do not give

Return to the three passages. Matthew 22:17-21 is a reply that refuses a trap: it neither says that the tax is wrong nor that Caesar owns everything. Acts 5:27-29 is a limit: whatever else the believers owe, they may not stop proclaiming what they have seen. Romans 13:1 is a call to respect authority as part of God's ordering of the world, which we take up with care in Week 2. Taken together, they suggest that a Christian can say two things at once: authority is real and deserves respect, and authority is not God. How far apart those two sentences are in any real situation is what Christians in every pattern of church and state have argued about. The three passages tell us what must be held together. They do not tell us which legal pattern keeps them together best.


Diagram 1. Four patterns and the question each answers

CHURCH AND STATE: FOUR PATTERNS Tools for thinking, not labels for real countries Union or establishment Protects: the nation may acknowledge God; a church open to all Risk: church serves the state; others treated as lesser; belonging replaces faith Separation Protects: conscience, church independence, equal standing of all Risk: stricter forms may seem to push faith out of public reasoning Cooperation Protects: shared service for the common good; respect for religious communities Risk: dependence on funding; smaller groups left out; serving blurs into being used Critical distance Protects: freedom to criticise and refuse; first loyalty to God Risk: disdain or constant complaint; hard to work with the state when needed Critical distance is an attitude: it can live inside any of the other three.

In short

  • Four patterns are union or establishment, separation, cooperation and critical distance; each protects something and risks something.
  • A typology is a tool for thinking; it is not a verdict on any real country.
  • Separation has a friendly form and a stricter form; critical distance is an attitude that can live inside any pattern.
  • Matthew 22, Acts 5 and Romans 13 together suggest that authority is real and that authority is not God, but they do not give a constitution.
  • Whether laws should be shaped by Christian faith or kept separate is a point where readers will not agree.
Front Back
Union or establishment A church is recognised by the state in a special way; it can serve all, but may serve the state or lessen others.
Separation The state favours no church; it protects conscience, but a strict form may seem to push faith out of public reasoning.
Cooperation State and churches share tasks without one established church; risks are dependence and unequal treatment.
Critical distance An attitude, not a legal form: the church keeps a freedom to criticise, whatever the pattern.

One sentence to remember No pattern of church and state is free of cost, and a fair student names both the gift and the cost of each.

This week's action Write one paragraph describing the arrangement of church and state in your own setting, using the four types as questions rather than labels.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • What does a typology help you to see, and what does it leave out? Why is it not a map of any real country?
  • Which of the four patterns is closest to the way church and state are arranged in your own setting? What does your tradition gain from it, and what does it risk?
  • In the three invented settings, what would each person have to hear from the other?
  • How might a member of a majority church and a member of a minority church each read Matthew 22:17-21? Does the difference say anything about the verse, or about the readers?
  • Why do you think the Christians who argued for religious freedom after the Reformation often came from groups that had suffered? Does that weaken or strengthen their argument?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.