Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
- Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
- Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
- Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
- Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
- Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
- Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
- Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
- Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
- Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
- Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
- Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
- Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
- Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
- Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
- Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
- Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
- Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
- Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
Last week asked whether faith can stay private and how traditions have understood the church's place in public life. This week turns to politics and authority. We begin where every Christian tradition begins, with Scripture. The Bible speaks about rulers, governors, kings and councils in more than one voice. One passage tells believers to be in subjection. Another shows believers who refuse a command. Another pictures a ruling power that demands worship and makes war on the saints.
This lecture reads those passages side by side. It does not choose the passage that fits a political mood. It asks what each text says, in its own setting, what traditions have drawn from it, and where our own judgement comes in. It then states plainly the one disagreement about Romans 13 that has run through the church's history, without settling it. The aim is a habit of reading: slow, honest, and fair to the people who read the same verses differently.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Describe, in your own words, what Romans 13:1-7 and 1 Peter 2:13-17 say about authority, and in what setting each was written.
- Describe at least three passages in which Scripture shows refusal of a human command, and what each refusal was about.
- Explain why one verse alone cannot serve as decisive proof for obedience or for resistance.
- State fairly the main ways Romans 13 has been read, with the strength and weak point of each.
- Separate "what the text says", "what a tradition has drawn from it" and "our judgement" for one passage.
Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those who exist are ordained by God." — Romans 13:1
World English Bible
Honor all men. Love the brotherhood. Fear God. Honor the king." — 1 Peter 2:17
WEB
But Peter and the apostles answered, “We must obey God rather than men." — Acts 5:29
WEB
What the text says. Romans 13:1 tells every person to be in subjection to the higher authorities, and says that no authority exists except from God. 1 Peter 2:17 gives four short commands in a row: honour everyone, love the community of believers, fear God, honour the king. In Acts 5:29, Peter and the apostles, ordered by the council not to teach in the name of Jesus, answer that they must obey God rather than men.
A tradition's reading. Many Christians have heard in the first two a general duty of respect and order toward governments, and in the third a limit on that duty. Some have put the weight on the first two, so that refusal is a last and rare step. Some have put the weight on the third, so that every claim of a ruler is tested against what God commands. Others say the three do not need to be balanced in this way, because they were written to different people in different situations.
Our judgement. The three verses do not give one rule. They give three truths held together: authority is not an accident, God alone is Lord of conscience, and the honour we give a ruler is different from the worship we give God. How to hold them in a given situation is a matter of judgement, and the rest of this lecture and the next two lectures try to make that judgement more careful.
1. One Bible, more than one voice
Suppose you wanted to find out, from the Bible alone, whether a believer should obey the government. You might begin with Romans 13 and conclude: yes, always. You might begin with Acts 5 and conclude: yes, unless it contradicts God. You might begin with the book of Daniel and conclude: refuse the order, accept the penalty, and speak politely. You might begin with Revelation 13 and conclude: some powers are beyond being honoured at all.
All of these are things Scripture contains. A reader who stops at one of them has not misread a verse, but may have misread the Bible, because the Bible does not speak about authority in one voice. This is not a defect. The books were written over many centuries, to people in very different positions: a nation with its own king, exiles under a foreign empire, a small church inside the Roman world, a community in danger. Advice for one of these is not automatically advice for another. The honest course is to hear each voice in its place, and then ask how they fit together.
2. Romans 13:1-7 in its setting
Paul wrote to the Christians in the city of Rome, a mixed community of Jewish and non-Jewish believers who lived in the capital of an empire. Some had lived through a time when Jews, among them Jewish Christians, had been ordered out of the city (Acts 18:2 mentions this); they knew how fragile their position was.
Paul begins by saying that everyone should be in subjection to the higher authorities, and gives a reason: there is no authority except from God. He says that anyone who resists the authority resists what God has appointed (verse 2). He describes the ruler as God's servant for the good of the people, who bears the sword for a reason (verses 3-4), and says that this is why one should be subject not only out of fear of punishment but for conscience' sake (verse 5). He then speaks of taxes, customs, respect and honour, and says to give to each what is owed (verses 6-7).
Several things are worth noticing before anyone draws a conclusion.
It sits inside a larger argument. The paragraph just before it (Romans 12:17-21) tells believers not to repay evil for evil, not to take revenge, and to overcome evil with good. The paragraph just after it (Romans 13:8-10) says that love is the fulfilment of the law. Paul did not write "chapter 13" as a separate essay. The chapter divisions were added much later.
It speaks in the language of a ruler's task. The ruler is described as a servant of God to punish wrong and to praise what is good. Readers ask: what if a ruler does the reverse? Paul does not discuss that case in these verses. Some say this means the text does not allow resistance at all. Others say the text defines what authority is for, and that a ruler who rewards evil and punishes good is not doing the work described. Both readings are held by serious people.
The word "subjection" is not the same as "obey in everything". The Greek word Paul uses is built on the idea of ordering oneself under someone. Some scholars and traditions say it describes an attitude and a place in an order, which can include refusing a particular command while accepting the penalty. Others say the word plainly includes obedience. Here, as often, a translation hides a debate.
It was written to a community with little power. Most of the readers were not rulers. Paul does not say what a believer who is a ruler, a judge or a soldier should do. That is also something the later church had to work out.
It names the claim that authority comes from God without naming any particular ruler. The text does not say that every person who holds power is good, or that every decision is right. It says something about the office and its source. Traditions have drawn different conclusions from that.
3. 1 Peter 2:13-17 and the exile's honour
Peter wrote to Christians whom he calls exiles and strangers (1 Peter 1:1 and 2:11). They were a minority, often misunderstood and sometimes slandered. In this setting he tells them to subject themselves to every human institution for the Lord's sake, whether the king as supreme or governors sent to punish evildoers and praise those who do good. He then gives the reason: it is God's will that by doing good they should silence the ignorance of foolish people.
The next verse is the one many readers keep returning to.
"Therefore subject yourselves to every of man for the Lord’s sake: whether to the king, as supreme; or to governors, as sent by him for vengeance on evildoers and for praise to those who do well. For this is the will of God, that by well-doing you should put to silence the ignorance of foolish men: as free, and not using your freedom for a cloak of wickedness, but as bondservants of God." — 1 Peter 2:13-16 (WEB)
Verse 16 says that they are free, and also that they are bondservants of God. It is a short sentence, and it says that the freedom of a believer is not freedom to do whatever one likes, and that a believer's final service is to God. It places a limit on the honour given to authority from the inside, before any conflict has been described. The commands in verse 17 then make a pattern: honour is for everyone, love is for the community, fear belongs to God, and honour is for the king. The verbs are different. Honour is not the same as fear; fear is kept for God alone.
Notice that Peter writes to people who are not in charge. Notice also that the honour he asks for is meant to give the church a good name among its neighbours. Here the obedience is partly a witness.
4. When Scripture shows refusal
The Bible does not only recommend order. It also records people who refuse.
The midwives. In Exodus 1:15-21, the king of Egypt commands two Hebrew midwives, Shiphrah and Puah, to kill the baby boys. The text says that they feared God and did not do what the king commanded. When he asks why, they give an answer. God deals well with them. Two things stand out. First, the refusal is quiet, not a public rebellion. Second, readers have long disagreed about the midwives' answer to the king, which may or may not be a true account. Some early Christian writers argued that the reward was given for their mercy and not for any untruth. Others read the story with less concern for that point. We need not settle this to see what the story says: they would not take part in killing the innocent.
Daniel's friends. In Daniel 3, three young men refuse to bow to a golden image set up by the king. Their answer is polite, firm and open about the cost.
"If it happens, our God whom we serve is able to deliver us from the burning fiery furnace; and he will deliver us out of your hand, O king. But if not, let it be known to you, O king, that we will not serve your gods, nor worship the golden image which you have set up." — Daniel 3:17-18 (WEB)
They do not rebel. They do not say that the king has no power. They say that they will not worship what he asks them to worship, and they leave the outcome to God, "but if not" included. Many readers have been struck that this refusal does not depend on being rescued.
Daniel himself. In Daniel 6 a royal order forbids prayer to anyone but the king for thirty days. Daniel goes home and prays as before, with his window open (verse 10). The text shows no violence, no plan and no insult to the king. It does show a man who will not stop praying.
The apostles. In Acts 4:19-20 and 5:27-29 the council forbids Peter and John, and then the apostles, to teach in the name of Jesus. They answer that they cannot stop speaking about what they have seen and heard, and that they must obey God rather than men. Notice that they are refusing a specific order that touches their , and they remain in the city and accept what follows.
In each of these cases the refusal is narrow. It concerns a particular command (kill the infants, worship the image, stop praying, stop teaching) that falls on the central thing the person owes to God. None of these texts is a general account of how to treat a government, and none says the rulers in question were without any power from God.
5. Revelation 13: a power that asks for worship
The book of Revelation uses pictures. In chapter 13 a beast rises from the sea, receives power, a throne and great authority from the dragon, speaks blasphemy, makes war on the saints and receives authority over every tribe, people, language and nation (13:1-7). The beast is a picture of a ruling power that demands what belongs to God alone.
Readers differ about who or what the beast is. Many ancient and modern readers see in it a picture of the Roman empire, written in coded language for people who knew what was meant. Others see in it a pattern that can appear in any age: a power that asks for ultimate loyalty. Others read it as pointing to one final figure at the end of history. We do not need to choose among these in this course. What matters here is that the same New Testament that says "honour the king" also contains a picture of a power that has crossed a line and is not honoured but resisted by endurance. Notice also what the book asks of the believers: not armed rebellion, but faithful witness and endurance.
6. Putting them together: four questions
One useful way to read the passages together is to ask four questions of any situation.
- What is the authority doing? Is it doing the work Romans 13 describes, restraining wrong and rewarding good, or has it turned to something else?
- What is it asking of me? A tax, a rule, a duty is not the same as an order to worship, kill the innocent or stop proclaiming the gospel.
- Does this command fall on what I owe God? Honour for a ruler is different from worship, and the difference matters.
- If I refuse, how, and at what cost, and for whose sake? The refusals in Scripture are narrow, open and accepted at a cost. They are not a rejection of all order.
These questions do not give an answer. They give a way of thinking in which an answer can be sought honestly. Different people may answer them differently, which brings us to the contested point.
7. Three layers
Here is what the three layers look like on one passage, Romans 13:1-7.
- What the text says: every person is to be subject to higher authorities; authority comes from God; the ruler is God's servant for good; do not resist; pay taxes and give what is owed; for conscience' sake.
- What a tradition has drawn: some have drawn a strong duty of obedience and an order of society with God behind it; some a limit built into the very idea of authority; some a call to a disciplined, nonviolent attitude toward rulers while keeping loyalty to Christ first; some a call to pray for and serve the common good of the place where they live.
- Our judgement: how Romans 13 applies to a situation which Paul did not describe depends on how we weigh these passages together, and honest believers weigh them differently.
8. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: how Romans 13:1-7 relates to the passages that show refusal, and so how far it limits resistance. One strong reading holds that the passage means what it says: authority is from God, even flawed authority, and believers are to be subject, with refusal reserved for cases where obedience would be a sin, such as the apostles' case. Its strength is that it takes the plain words seriously and warns against the pride and bloodshed that follow when private persons decide when a ruler has failed. Its weak point is that the passage has been used to ask for silence in the face of grave wrong, and the text itself sets the ruler's work as the reward of good, which the reader may then use as a test.
A second reading holds that the passage defines authority by its purpose, so that a ruler who turns that purpose upside down loses the claim the passage gives. Its strength is that it fits the refusals in Scripture and it treats authority as accountable to God. Its weak point is that Paul does not say who judges when a ruler has crossed the line, and "I judge that the ruler has failed" can come too quickly, from a person who is angry or partial.
A third reading, found especially among those who stress the way of Jesus, holds that the passage asks for a particular kind of subjection: to accept the order and not take revenge, while refusing any command that contradicts Christ and accepting the cost. Its strength is that it joins Romans 12 and 13 and the story of the cross. Its weak point is that some ask whether it gives enough guidance when order itself is being used to hurt others, and what those who suffer are to do.
What this course requires is less than any of these readings asks. It requires that a student can say what Romans 13:1-7 says, can name two of the readings and state each as its holders would, and can say why one verse is not decisive. The course does not ask you to choose a reading, and it does not apply any of them to a particular government today.
Diagram 1. One Bible, many voices on authority
In short
- The Bible speaks about authority with several voices: subjection and honour, narrow refusal, and endurance against a power that demands worship.
- Romans 13:1-7 is written to a small community, sits between Romans 12:17-21 and 13:8-10, and describes the ruler as God's servant for good.
- 1 Peter 2:13-17 asks exiles to honour the king, and calls them free and also bondservants of God.
- The refusals in Exodus 1, Daniel 3 and 6 and Acts 4 and 5 are narrow: each falls on one command touching what is owed to God.
- Romans 13 is read as a plain duty of subjection, as a purpose that limits obedience, and as a Christlike subjection that refuses sin and accepts cost.
- Separate what the text says, what a tradition draws, and our judgement; no verse alone settles the question.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Setting of Romans 13 | A mixed community in the capital of an empire; the paragraph sits between the call to overcome evil with good and the call to love. |
| What the refusals share | Each concerns one command touching what is owed to God: killing the innocent, worship, prayer, proclamation. |
| Three layers | What the text says; what a tradition has drawn from it; our judgement. |
| Why no verse decides | The Bible speaks about authority in several voices to different people in different situations. |
One sentence to remember Scripture asks both for honour toward those in authority and for a loyalty to God that no authority may replace, and it leaves us to judge carefully how the two meet.
This week's action Read Romans 12:17 to 13:10 in one sitting, then Acts 5:27-32, and write one sentence on what each says and one on what you cannot decide from them alone.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why does the lecture say that a reader who stops at Romans 13 alone, or at Acts 5 alone, has not misread a verse but may have misread the Bible?
- What in the setting of Romans 13 (the readers, the surrounding chapters, the word "subjection") might change how you hear the paragraph?
- What do the refusals of the midwives, Daniel's friends and the apostles have in common? What do they not claim?
- Choose two of the three readings of Romans 13 in the contested paragraph. State each as its holders would, with its strength and its weak point.
- Apply the four questions to an invented case: a church-run clinic is told to stop treating one group of people. What would each question ask? (Use no real country or government.)