Lecture 6-3: The Virtues of Public Witness
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
- Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
- Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
- Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
- Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
- Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
- Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
- Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
- Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
- Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
- Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
- Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
- Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
- Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
- Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
- Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
- Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
- Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
- Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
So far this week we have asked what the church does in public and where. This lecture asks how. A church may serve, speak and tell what it believes, and still damage its witness by the manner. A true word spoken with contempt may close a door that a gentler word would have opened. A kind word spoken without truth leaves a neighbour deceived.
The lecture looks at five qualities that Christian traditions have long linked with public witness: truthfulness, humility, love, patience and the refusal of contempt, together with the harder skill of listening to opponents. It treats them as virtues, which means settled habits of character that are formed by practice, and not as rules to apply in a moment. It also asks a hard question that the traditions answer differently: when, if ever, may a believer speak sharply in public?
What these 23 minutes give you
- Explain what a virtue is, and why public witness needs virtues and not only correct opinions.
- Describe truthfulness, humility, love, patience and the refusal of contempt in plain words, with a sign of each in public speech.
- Describe what it means to listen to an opponent, and give three habits of doing it well.
- State fairly the main views on whether sharp public speech is ever right, each with a strength and a weak point.
- Say why these virtues do not require a believer to be silent, or to pretend to agree.
He has shown you, O man, what is good. What does Yahweh require of you, but to act justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God?" — Micah 6:8
World English Bible
but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ;" — Ephesians 4:15
WEB
Walk in wisdom toward those who are outside, redeeming the time. Let your speech always be with grace, seasoned with salt, that you may know how you ought to answer each one." — Colossians 4:5-6
WEB
What the text says. Micah says that God has shown what is good and asks for justice, the love of mercy and a humble walk with God. Paul, in Ephesians, says that we are to speak truth in love so that we may grow in every way into Christ. In Colossians he asks for wisdom toward those outside, for good use of time, and for speech that is always with grace, seasoned with salt, so that we may know how to answer each one. A tradition's reading. Many Christians read these verses as a short account of how to speak in public: truth, love, humility and fitting speech belong together. Some stress that "in love" is the manner in which truth is spoken, not a reason to soften it. Others stress that "truth" is the substance, and that love without it is flattery. The phrase "seasoned with salt" has been read as a call to speak with wit and flavour, and also as a call to speak in a way that preserves from decay and does not sting. The phrase "to answer each one" has been read as a reminder that no one answer fits every neighbour. Our judgement. These verses do not tell us what to say on any public question. They describe the way in which we say it. They also describe a whole life and not a technique: a person who speaks with grace has first been shaped by grace.
1. Habits, not tricks
There is a difference between a technique and a virtue. A technique is a skill that can be used for any purpose: a speaker can learn to use a gentle voice, a smile or a pause in order to win an argument. A virtue is a settled habit of character, formed over years, that shapes a person's whole conduct. A person who is truthful does not turn truthfulness on for a public occasion and off at home.
This matters because public witness is often judged by manner. Neighbours may forget what a church said and remember how it said it. Churches that learned the right words but not the habits have often found that the words did not last.
The traditions describe the formation of such habits in different ways. Some stress prayer and the sacraments, some the reading of Scripture, some the discipline of the community, some the example of those who have gone before. This lecture does not choose among them. It asks what the habits look like when seen in public.
2. Truthfulness
The first virtue of public witness is truthfulness. This means more than not lying. It includes:
- Saying what you know and no more. A claim of fact in public should rest on something you have checked. In an age when false and half-true claims move quickly, a church that passes them on, even for a cause it believes in, damages its own witness.
- Being fair to those you disagree with. To describe an opponent's view in a form its holders would not recognise is a kind of falsehood. The rule is old: state their view in the strongest form they would accept before you answer it.
- Admitting what is not known. "I do not know" and "I may be wrong" are truthful phrases, and a leader who never says them teaches others to claim certainty they do not have.
- Being honest about your own motives. A believer who speaks for the common good while also seeking a place of influence, or who gives to the poor to be seen, has not been fully truthful. Matthew 6 warns about this.
Truthfulness does not mean saying everything. There are things that should not be said in public because they belong to another's privacy or pain. But it does mean that what is said should not mislead.
3. Humility
Humility is not low opinion of oneself. In many traditions it means seeing oneself in the right proportion: as a creature, as a sinner who has received mercy, and as one who may be wrong. Micah joins it to justice: to act justly, love mercy and walk humbly with God.
In public life, humility has three signs.
First, the habit of asking whether I may be mistaken. A believer who is sure that the other side is entirely wrong should ask what the other side sees that he does not.
Second, the habit of remembering that the church has been wrong before. Churches in many places have, at different times, joined in or blessed things that later generations saw as wrong. A church that remembers this speaks of public matters with less certainty about its own judgement and more attention to those who criticise it.
Third, the habit of not speaking for the whole church when one speaks for oneself. A person who says "I think" is humbler than one who says "the church believes", when the church has said nothing.
Humility does not mean silence. A humble person may speak plainly, and may speak firmly. What makes the speech humble is that the speaker holds it open to correction.
4. Love
Ephesians 4:15 joins truth and love, and the traditions have long debated how. Some say love is the manner of speaking, and truth is the matter. Others say love is also the reason for speaking: that one who sees a neighbour harmed, or deceived, and says nothing, does not love him. Both agree that love without truth turns to flattery, and truth without love turns to cruelty.
In public speech, love shows in small signs. It shows in whether we speak to a person or only about them. It shows in whether we are willing to be seen with those we criticise. It shows in whether we would still help the person we have argued against, if they came to the door in need. Jesus's words about loving enemies (Matthew 5:44) are the hardest test, and the lecture does not claim that any church passes it fully.
Love does not mean agreeing, or pretending that differences do not matter. A parent who loves a child may say a hard thing. What love rules out is speaking in order to wound, or to win, or to be admired.
5. Patience
Public questions often take years. A church that has spoken once and sees no change may be tempted to speak louder, or to give up, or to turn to means it would not have chosen at first. Patience is the habit of continuing without either of those.
Patience in public witness has three parts. It means staying with a question after the first interest has faded, such as visiting the same neighbours, keeping up the same service, writing the same careful letter. It means allowing others time: a neighbour who has held a view for fifty years will not drop it after one conversation. And it means not requiring results as the proof of faithfulness. Galatians 6:9 says that we shall reap in due season if we do not give up. Many traditions read this as a promise about God's work, not a guarantee about any plan of ours.
Patience is not the same as delay. There are times when a wrong is so grave that waiting is itself a failure, and the traditions have said so. But more often than we like, hurry is the temptation.
6. The refusal of contempt
Contempt is the settled view that another person or group is beneath serious attention. It is a different thing from disagreement, anger or criticism. A person can disagree strongly with a view and still treat the one who holds it as a person. Contempt does not.
Contempt shows in small ways: a sneer in a sermon; a story told so that the opponent is always foolish; a joke that depends on the hearers sharing a dislike; a phrase that sums up a whole group in one insult; a refusal to learn what the other person actually believes. It is often easier to practise in a group of people who agree. A church whose members all hold one view may find that contempt for others grows without anyone choosing it.
The refusal of contempt does not mean refusing to judge. It means judging an argument and not despising a person, and remembering that the person is made in God's image and may be a believer too. A teacher can say "I think this view is mistaken, and here is why" and also say "those who hold it are not fools". A good test is whether the people we criticise could read what we have said about them and recognise themselves.
7. Listening to opponents
Listening is not a virtue of its own, but it is the road by which several of the others are reached. Truthfulness needs it, since we cannot state a view fairly without hearing it. Humility needs it, since we cannot learn we are wrong without it. Love needs it, since we cannot know a neighbour's need unless we ask.
Three habits help.
Ask, and then ask again. Begin with an honest question such as "What matters most to you about this?" and listen to the answer before saying anything. Then ask what you did not understand.
Say it back. Before you reply, say in your own words what you heard, and ask whether you have it right. This is slow. It is also the surest way to find out how little you had understood.
Look for what is shared. Opponents often share a concern while differing on the means. A nurse and a manager may both care that a clinic stays open, and differ about how to pay for it. Finding this does not remove the disagreement, but it changes its tone.
Listening does not mean you must agree, or give up your view, or stay in a conversation that has become abusive. A person who is being threatened or harmed is not obliged to listen. Nor does it require you to give equal time to every claim, including claims that deny the dignity of others. It asks that you hear before you answer.
8. Where readers will not agree: sharp speech
This is a point where readers will not agree: whether a believer may ever speak sharply in public, and if so when. We give two positions and a third that joins them.
One holds that Christians should always speak with gentleness, and that sharp or angry speech damages the witness of the church. Its strongest argument is that Paul and Peter ask for gentleness and respect (1 Peter 3:15-16 and Colossians 4:6), that Jesus told his followers to love enemies, and that sharp speech tends to harden those who hear it and to harm the speaker. Its weak point is that gentleness can become a way of avoiding hard truths, and that a call to speak "nicely" has sometimes been used to silence those who suffer wrong and are angry about it.
A second holds that there are times when plain, hard speech is required. Its strongest argument is that the prophets spoke sharply to those who oppressed the poor, that Jesus spoke strongly to some of the religious leaders of his day, and that those who are harmed have a right to say so without being asked to be calm. Its weak point is that the reasoning can be turned by anyone: nearly everyone who speaks harshly believes that this is one of the times when it is required, and the prophets' own claim to speak for God is not one that a modern speaker can easily make.
A third view says that the question should be asked of the purpose and the hearer. Sharpness spoken to those in power on behalf of the powerless, and spoken at some cost to the speaker, is different from sharpness spoken from a safe place at those who are already weak. Its strength is that it asks about who is being served. Its weak point is that these distinctions are hard to apply, and that people disagree about who is strong and who is weak in any given case.
What this course requires is that you can state each position fairly, say what it protects and where it is weak, and can say what you would ask of yourself before speaking sharply: Is this true? Is it needed? Who is helped? Would I say it to the person's face? Am I willing to bear the cost? The course does not decide the question for you.
9. What these virtues do not mean
The virtues of public witness may be misread, so three notes. They do not mean silence: a person may be truthful, humble and loving, and still say a hard thing. They do not mean false agreement: love does not require pretending that a disagreement is small. And they do not mean perfection: every believer fails at some of them, and the church's public witness has always been carried by people who needed forgiveness. A church that speaks of these habits does so as a community that is still learning them.
Diagram 1. Six habits of speaking in public
Diagram 2. Gentle, sharp, or by purpose: three positions
| Position | Strongest argument | Weak point |
|---|---|---|
| Always gentle | Scripture asks for gentleness; sharpness hardens hearers | Gentleness can avoid hard truths and silence the wronged |
| Sometimes plain and hard | The prophets and Jesus spoke strongly; the wronged may say so | Everyone thinks this is such a time; modern speakers cannot claim a prophet's authority |
| Ask about purpose and hearer | Asks who is served and who bears the cost | Hard to apply; people disagree about who is strong and who weak |
In short
- A virtue is a settled habit of character; public witness needs virtues and not only correct opinions.
- Truthfulness means saying what you know, being fair to others, admitting what you do not know and being honest about motives.
- Humility asks whether I may be mistaken, remembers the church's own failings and does not speak for the whole church.
- Love speaks to a person and not only about them; patience stays with a question; contempt judges a person and not an argument.
- Listening means asking, saying it back and looking for what is shared; it does not require agreement.
- On sharp speech readers will not agree; the course requires fair statement and a set of questions to ask oneself.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Virtue | A settled habit of character formed by practice, as opposed to a technique that can be used for any purpose. |
| Contempt | The settled view that another person or group is beneath serious attention; different from disagreement or anger. |
| Three habits of listening | Ask and ask again; say it back; look for what is shared. |
| Questions before speaking sharply | Is it true? Is it needed? Who is helped? Would I say it to the person's face? Can I bear the cost? |
One sentence to remember How we speak in public shows what we have become, so the manner of a church's witness is part of its message.
This week's action Before the next time you disagree with someone, say back to them in your own words what they said, and ask whether you have it right.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What is the difference between a technique and a virtue? Why might neighbours remember the manner of a church's speech longer than its words?
- Which of the six habits (truthfulness, humility, love, patience, refusing contempt, listening) is easiest for you, and which hardest? Say it in general terms.
- Why does the lecture say that to describe an opponent's view in a form its holders would not recognise is a kind of falsehood?
- State the three positions on sharp speech so that each would say you were fair. What would you ask yourself before speaking sharply?
- How do Micah 6:8, Ephesians 4:15 and Colossians 4:5-6 together describe a manner of speaking? What do they leave open?