FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL1E Christian Apologetics

Lecture 11-2: Identity, Meaning, and the Secular Age

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 37
STEL1E Christian Apologetics
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Apologetics Is, and Why It Matters
  1. Introduction: What Apologetics Is, and Why It Matters
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Foundations of Apologetics
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Meaning and Mandate of Apologetics
  2. Lecture 1-2: Faith and Reason Across Church History
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Apologist's Character
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Truth, Reason, and Revelation
  1. Lecture 2-1: What Is Truth?
  2. Lecture 2-2: Revelation and Reason
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Postmodern Challenge to Truth
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Four Approaches to Defending the Faith
  1. Lecture 3-1: Classical Apologetics
  2. Lecture 3-2: Evidential Apologetics
  3. Lecture 3-3: Presuppositional Apologetics
  4. Lecture 3-4: Reformed Epistemology
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Arguments for God's Existence
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Kalam Cosmological Argument
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Teleological Argument (Fine-Tuning)
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Moral Argument
  4. Lecture 4-4: Objections and Responses
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Reliability of Scripture
  1. Lecture 5-1: How the Canon Formed
  2. Lecture 5-2: Manuscript Evidence and Textual Criticism
  3. Lecture 5-3: Archaeology and Historical Corroboration
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Jesus Christ — History and Identity
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Quest for the Historical Jesus
  2. Lecture 6-2: Jesus's Self-Understanding
  3. Lecture 6-3: Lewis's Trilemma and Its Critics
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: The Resurrection
  1. Lecture 7-1: The Death of Jesus
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Minimal Facts Approach
  3. Lecture 7-3: Alternative Theories and Their Failure
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: The Problem of Evil and Suffering
  1. Lecture 8-1: The Logical Problem of Evil
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Evidential Problem of Evil
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Cross as God's Answer
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Science and Faith
  1. Lecture 9-1: Four Models for Relating Science and Faith
  2. Lecture 9-2: The Spectrum of Christian Views on Origins
  3. Lecture 9-3: Design Arguments and Their Scientific Critics
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: World Religions and a Secular Age
  1. Lecture 10-1: Religious Pluralism's Philosophical Claims
  2. Lecture 10-2: Exclusivism, Inclusivism, and Pluralism Compared
  3. Lecture 10-3: The New Atheism and Secular Objections
  4. Lecture 10-4: Engaging Other Religions and Worldviews Respectfully
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: Cultural Apologetics and the Apologetic Life
  1. Lecture 11-1: Cultural Apologetics - Story, Art, and Imagination
  2. Lecture 11-2: Identity, Meaning, and the Secular Age
  3. Lecture 11-3: Conclusion - The Apologetic Life

Jump to the key points ↓

19 min

Most of this course has answered objections that take a recognizable argumentative shape: a claim about cosmology, a claim about historical evidence, a claim about the coherence of a doctrine. Chapters 4 through 10 met those objections on their own ground. But a student who actually talks with a skeptical classmate, coworker, or family member will notice something the earlier chapters did not have room to name directly: a great many real objections to Christianity are not, at bottom, objections of that kind at all. "I just don't feel like that's me" and "your religion looks like it would make me less myself" are heard as often as, and sometimes more often than, "your cosmological argument has a flaw." This lecture asks why, using the philosopher Charles Taylor's account of what he calls the modern "secular age," and asks what an apologist does with an objection that is really about identity and meaning wearing the clothing of an intellectual one.

This lecture also turns, briefly, to a book written some three thousand years before Charles Taylor: Ecclesiastes. The Preacher's blunt catalogue of "vanity" and his claim that God has "set eternity" in the human heart describe a restlessness this lecture argues is not a peculiarly modern invention, even if modern culture gives it a distinctive shape.

What these 19 minutes give you

  • Explain Charles Taylor's concept of "expressive individualism" and state, in your own words, what it assumes about what it means to live authentically.
  • Describe, at a basic level, Taylor's distinction between a "porous" and a "buffered" self, and explain why he argues the modern West has moved toward the latter.
  • Explain why this lecture treats many students' actual objections to Christianity as objections about identity and meaning rather than, or in addition to, formal argument.
  • State Ecclesiastes 3:11's claim about eternity "set... in their hearts" and explain how this lecture connects it to Taylor's account of restless modern meaning-seeking, without collapsing the two into the same claim.
  • Identify one danger of over-applying this lecture's framework - treating every objection as secretly about identity, when some objections are genuinely and only intellectual.

He has made everything beautiful in its time. He has also set eternity in their hearts, yet so that man can't find out the work that God has done from the beginning even to the end.

Vanity of vanities," says the Preacher; "Vanity of vanities, all is vanity." What does man gain from all his labor in which he labors under the sun?

Ecclesiastes 3:11 (World English Bible)

Ecclesiastes 1:2-3 (WEB)

1. When the objection is not the objection

Earlier chapters of this course answered objections shaped like arguments: the kalam's premises, the minimal facts, the manuscript evidence, the logical and evidential problems of evil. Those objections deserve, and received, careful reasoned answers, and nothing in this lecture withdraws any of that work.

But an apologist who has only ever prepared answers of that kind will eventually meet an objection that does not fit the mold. A student says Christianity feels confining, or that its moral claims feel like an external cage placed over who they actually are, or that the whole framework feels like it belongs to a world they do not live in - and no amount of restating the kalam , however carefully, actually engages what is being said. This is not because the person raising the objection is being evasive or intellectually lazy. It is because, this lecture argues, the objection is real, and it is simply not the kind of objection chapters 3 and 4 were built to answer. Understanding why requires stepping back from any single argument to the deeper cultural assumptions a hearer brings to any argument at all.

2. Charles Taylor's account of the secular age

Charles Taylor, a Catholic philosopher, published A Secular Age in 2007 as an extended answer to a specific question: not "why do fewer people believe in God today," but something more precise - why has believing in God gone, across roughly five centuries in the West, from being nearly unavoidable to being one option among several equally available and equally contestable ones. Taylor calls this shift a change in the "conditions of belief" rather than simply a change in what people happen to believe.

Central to Taylor's account is a distinction between what he calls the "porous self" and the "buffered self." In earlier centuries, Taylor argues, the self was experienced as porous - open to forces, spirits, and meanings that came from outside and could act on a person almost involuntarily. A medieval villager did not experience their own mind as a sealed container; blessing, curse, grace, and demonic influence were live possibilities that could reach in from outside. The modern self, by contrast, is what Taylor calls "buffered": insulated, bounded, experienced as the sovereign source of its own meanings rather than as something meanings act upon from outside. This shift did not, on Taylor's account, simply remove God from the picture and leave everything else the same. It changed what a self fundamentally is taken to be.

Out of the buffered self, Taylor argues, grows what he calls "expressive individualism": the widespread modern assumption - held by many believers as much as by secular people, often without either group noticing they hold it - that being authentic means discovering an inner self that already exists within a person and expressing it outward, rather than conforming that self to something given from outside, whether a tradition, a community, or a revealed order. On this assumption, the deepest moral failure available to a person is not disobedience to God or violation of some external law, but inauthenticity - failing to be, or failing to express, who one "really" is. Taylor calls the resulting cultural space the "immanent frame": a shared background assumption, held even by many believers without quite noticing it, that meaning and value can in principle be fully accounted for within human experience, without needing to invoke anything transcendent, even though - and this is Taylor's own more hopeful qualification - the frame is, in his phrase, "cross-pressured": haunted from within by longings the immanent frame itself cannot fully explain or satisfy, which is part of why he does not regard secularization as a simple, one-directional story of belief's decline.

3. Why this matters for the objections students actually raise

Put Taylor's account next to the ordinary experience of an apologetics student, and a pattern becomes visible. When a classmate objects that Christianity's sexual ethics, or its claims about sin, or its call to submit to something outside the self "aren't really about" evidence or argument but about being told who to be, that classmate is very often speaking directly out of expressive individualism's assumption that authenticity means self-discovery and self-expression rather than conformity to anything given. The objection can sound, on its surface, like a moral or even a logical claim - "your religion is oppressive," "your religion denies who I am" - while actually functioning as an identity claim wearing argument's clothing. Answering it as though it were a dispute about evidence, the way chapter 5's response to -formation skepticism or chapter 7's response to resurrection skepticism proceeded, will very often simply miss the actual disagreement.

This does not mean the apologist should abandon reasoned argument when this kind of objection appears. It means recognizing that the deeper cultural background needs to be named and engaged directly, gently, and on its own terms - showing, rather than merely asserting, that the Christian account of the self (a self given, known, and loved by God before it does anything to earn that, and called into a community and a story larger than its own private self-expression) is not obviously a smaller or more confining account of what a person is than the modern alternative, and may in fact answer a longing the buffered, self-authorized self cannot fully satisfy on its own terms - the "cross-pressure" Taylor himself points to. That is an apologetic task, but it is not chapter 4's task. It requires the pastoral sensitivity chapter 8 modeled when the problem of evil turned from philosophy to a suffering person in front of the apologist, applied here to a different and quieter kind of ache.

4. Ecclesiastes and the older shape of the same restlessness

It would be a mistake, though, to treat this restlessness as a distinctly modern invention that Charles Taylor was the first to notice. Ecclesiastes, likely composed centuries before Christ, opens with the Preacher's famous refrain: "Vanity of vanities... all is vanity" (1:2, quoted above), followed immediately by a question that could be lifted, almost unchanged, into a modern conversation about meaning: "What does man gain from all his labor in which he labors under the sun?" (1:3, quoted above). The Hebrew word translated "vanity," hevel, literally means vapor or breath - something that is there and then, in an instant, is not, impossible to hold onto no matter how tightly gripped. The Preacher surveys wealth, wisdom, pleasure, and achievement in the chapters that follow and finds every one of them, on its own, exactly this insubstantial when death is taken seriously as the horizon every human project runs toward.

And yet the same book that names this restlessness so starkly also names, in the same breath, its source: "He has also set eternity in their hearts" (3:11, quoted above). The restlessness Ecclesiastes describes is not, on the Preacher's own account, a malfunction or an illusion to be argued away. It is evidence of something real that has been placed in every human heart by God himself - an awareness of something beyond the merely immanent that the Preacher's own catalogue of vapor cannot satisfy, paired immediately with the sober qualification that a human being "can't find out the work that God has done from the beginning even to the end" (3:11) - the restlessness is real and God-given, but it does not by itself hand a person the full answer.

This is a place worth being careful rather than tidy. It would be an overreach to claim Ecclesiastes 3:11 is making Taylor's specific philosophical argument, or that Taylor's account of expressive individualism and the Preacher's ancient language of hevel are simply the same claim in two vocabularies three thousand years apart - they are not identical, and this lecture is not asserting that they are. What can fairly be said is narrower: both texts, in their very different ways and contexts, testify that the restless search for meaning a modern secular culture experiences as a peculiarly contemporary problem has a much older biblical witness, one that treats the restlessness itself as evidence of something real rather than as a problem to be argued out of existence.

5. A caution against overreach

This lecture's framework is genuinely useful, and it is also genuinely misusable. Not every objection a student raises is secretly, underneath its surface, an identity objection in disguise - some objections really are what they appear to be: a specific historical claim doubted, a specific argument's premise questioned, a specific piece of evidence found wanting. Treating every disagreement as covert identity work, so that no argument ever actually has to be engaged on its own terms, would be its own kind of evasion, and would make the apologist harder to take seriously rather than easier. The point of this lecture is not that argument no longer matters after ten chapters of it. It is that a wise apologist listens for which kind of objection is actually being raised - a claim to be reasoned through, or a longing to be recognized - and answers the one that is actually there.

The immanent frame, and what presses against it Charles Taylor's account, alongside Ecclesiastes 3:11 The immanent frame Meaning fully accounted for within human experience alone The buffered self Expressive individualism: authenticity = self-expression Cross-pressure Taylor: longings the frame cannot fully explain Eccl. 3:11 "eternity set in their hearts" - a given, not a flaw Not the same claim, in the same vocabulary, three thousand years apart Ecclesiastes and Taylor both witness to the restlessness; neither text is reduced to the other

6. Further Reading

  • Charles Taylor, A Secular Age (Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2007).
  • James K. A. Smith, How (Not) to Be Secular: Reading Charles Taylor (Eerdmans, 2014).
  • Carl R. Trueman, The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self: Cultural Amnesia, Expressive Individualism, and the Road to Sexual Revolution (Crossway, 2020).
  • Craig G. Bartholomew, Ecclesiastes, Baker Commentary on the Old Testament Wisdom and Psalms (Baker Academic, 2009).
  • Timothy Keller, Making Sense of God: An Invitation to the Skeptical (Viking, 2016).

In short

  • Many objections to Christianity are really about identity and meaning, not evidence. Answering them only with arguments can miss what the person is saying.
  • Charles Taylor, a Catholic philosopher, describes the shift from a "porous" self open to outside forces to a "buffered" self that sees itself as the source of its own meanings.
  • This produces "expressive individualism": authenticity means expressing an inner self, not conforming to something given. Taylor says this "immanent frame" is "cross-pressured" by longings it cannot satisfy.
  • Ecclesiastes names the same restlessness long ago ("vanity," Ecclesiastes 1:2-3) and says God "set eternity in their hearts" (3:11). The lecture says the two texts are not the same claim.
  • Not every objection is secretly about identity. A wise apologist listens for whether the objection is a claim to reason through or a longing to be recognized.

Topic: This lecture uses Charles Taylor's account of the secular age and Ecclesiastes to help apologists hear objections that are really about identity and meaning.

Remember: Listen first for what kind of objection is raised: a claim to be reasoned through, or a longing to be recognized. Then answer the one that is actually there.

Caution: Do not treat every objection as hidden identity work. Do not say Taylor and Ecclesiastes make the same claim. The lecture says they do not.

One line to carry into ministry: Ask gently what a person's objection is really about, and then answer that, with patience.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Can you think of a real conversation, your own or one you witnessed, where an objection to Christianity that sounded intellectual on the surface turned out, on reflection, to be more about identity or belonging? What made you notice the difference?
  • Taylor argues the modern "buffered self" experiences meaning as something it generates from within rather than something it receives from outside. Does this description match your own default way of thinking about authenticity, or does it feel foreign to how you actually experience yourself?
  • Ecclesiastes 1:2-3 and 3:11 sit in the same short passage - the sharpest statement of meaninglessness in the Old Testament, immediately followed by the claim that God has set eternity in the human heart. Why might the Preacher have placed these two claims so close together rather than treating them as separate arguments?
  • This lecture warns against treating every objection as secretly about identity. Can you think of an objection that really is a straightforward evidential or logical claim, where insisting it is "really" about identity would be a mistake?
  • Taylor describes the immanent frame as "cross-pressured" - haunted by longings it cannot fully satisfy on its own terms. Where, in the wider culture around you, do you see evidence of that cross-pressure - people living inside the frame but visibly unsettled by it?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.