Lecture 4-2: Hopes: Messiah, Resurrection and the Age to Come
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Second Temple Judaism" Means
- Lecture 1-2: The Sources We Have
- Lecture 1-3: Reading Sources Against Each Other
- Lecture 1-4: What Stones and Inscriptions Say
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Two Sources on One Event
- Lecture 2-1: The Persian and Hellenistic Ages
- Lecture 2-2: The Maccabean Revolt and the Hasmoneans
- Lecture 2-3: Rome Arrives; the House of Herod
- Lecture 2-4: Herod's Kingdom: Power, Building and Fear
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Chronicle
- Lecture 3-1: The Temple, the Priests and the Festivals
- Lecture 3-2: Synagogue, Torah and Daily Practice
- Lecture 3-3: Jews in the Diaspora
- Lecture 3-4: Galilee and Judea: Villages, Work and Language
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Letter and a House Rule
- Lecture 4-1: Groups: What the Sources Say, What the Textbooks Add
- Lecture 4-2: Hopes: Messiah, Resurrection and the Age to Come
- Lecture 4-3: Torah and Covenant: How Jews Understood the Law
- Lecture 4-4: Scripture in Many Hands
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Reading Groups
- Lecture 5-1: Rome and Judea
- Lecture 5-2: Cities, Households and Patronage
- Lecture 5-3: The Market of Religions and Philosophies
- Lecture 5-4: Associations, House Gatherings and the First Churches' Setting
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: An Inscription and a Letter
Ask a reader of the New Testament what the Jews of Jesus' time were waiting for, and the answer is often one word: the Messiah. It is a natural answer, because the Gospels use the word. But the sources outside the New Testament do not show one waiting-room with one expected guest. They show many hopes, held in different ways by different people, some of them with no clear figure in them at all.
This lecture follows three hopes through the sources: the hope for an anointed one (the meaning of the word Messiah), the hope for the dead, and the hope for the angels and the age to come. In each case it asks what the sources allow us to say, and where groups differed. It does not repeat the overview of BT501E, and it does not go deep into the genre of the apocalypse, which is for BT619E. Here the apocalypse is one strand among several in the Judaism of the time.
The principle of the week holds again. There were many voices, and no single list of "Jewish beliefs" fits the evidence. A reader who sees the variety reads the Gospels more accurately, because the Gospel scenes often stand inside an argument between those voices.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Explain what *Messiah* means and describe at least three different forms the hope for an anointed one took in the sources.
- Describe three views of the dead found in the sources and say which groups the sources link with each.
- Name the sources that speak of angels and say why the Sadducees' reported position stands out.
- Say what Mark 12:18-27 shows about a debate inside Judaism, and what it does not tell us about the groups.
- Explain why a statement such as "the Jews expected a warrior Messiah" is too broad to defend.
Many of those who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt." — Daniel 12:2
World English Bible
Those who are wise shall shine as the brightness of the expanse; and those who turn many to righteousness as the stars forever and ever." — Daniel 12:3
WEB
There came to him Sadducees, who say that there is no resurrection. They asked him, saying, “Teacher, Moses wrote to us, ‘If a man’s brother dies, and leaves a wife behind him, and leaves no children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up offspring for his brother.’ There were seven brothers. The first took a wife, and dying left no offspring. The second took her, and died, leaving no children behind him. The third likewise; and the seven took her and left no children. Last of all the woman also died. In the resurrection, when they rise, whose wife will she be of them? For the seven had her as a wife.” Jesus answered them, “Isn’t this because you are mistaken, not knowing the Scriptures, nor the power of God? For when they will rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage, but are like angels in heaven. But about the dead, that they are raised; haven’t you read in the book of Moses, about the Bush, how God spoke to him, saying, ‘I am the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob’? He is not the God of the dead, but of the living. You are therefore badly mistaken.”" — Mark 12:18-27
WEB
The first passage is one of the clearest statements of a hope for the dead in the Hebrew Scriptures. The second shows that hope under dispute in the time of Jesus. Between them lies the long period this course studies.
1. Many hopes, and a word that did not fix them
Messiah is a Hebrew word that means "anointed one". In the Hebrew Scriptures, a person is anointed with oil when set apart for a task: a king, a priest, sometimes a prophet. The word does not by itself mean a single end-time saviour. When the Greek-speaking world translated it, the word became Christos, from which we get "Christ". Over the period of this course, the word and the hope that gathered round it were used in several ways.
Look at what the sources show, one at a time.
A king from David's line. One writing of the first century BC, the Psalms of Solomon, is a set of Jewish poems that appear to answer the shock of Rome's arrival in Jerusalem. They pray for a king of David's house who would be righteous, who would cleanse Jerusalem of its unjust rulers, and who would trust in God more than in horses and weapons. The author's lean is plain: he writes against rulers he sees as corrupt, and the king he hopes for is the opposite of them. The hope is real, and it is a hope shaped by one writer's anger and grief.
More than one anointed figure. Some writings among the Dead Sea Scrolls speak of an anointed figure in connection with the priests, and of another in connection with the people, and they seem to expect both. Other Scroll texts gather passages about a prophet, a king and a priest. Readers differ on how to put these together, and on whether these texts describe two figures, three, or one figure in several roles. What the texts allow us to say is this: the community that kept them hoped for leaders of more than one kind, and the priest had a place beside the king.
A prophet like Moses. The Hebrew Scriptures promise a prophet like Moses, and some groups waited for that. The Gospels show people asking whether Jesus or John was "the prophet". Not every hope for the age to come had a king in it.
A heavenly figure. A collection of visions in the book called 1 Enoch includes a passage, often called the Parables, in which a heavenly figure judges the world. Readers differ on when this section was written, and so on whether it can be used as background for the Gospels. We should treat it as one voice that shows how varied the imagination was, not as a ready-made explanation of any Gospel phrase.
No figure at all. Some writings hope for God's rule and for the renewal of the people without any anointed figure. Not every writer needed one.
Movements that gathered round claimants. Josephus tells of several men who led crowds in the countryside or into the desert, some claiming to be prophets, some acting like kings, and each promising that God would act. He writes about them with disapproval, as a man who believed such movements led his people to destruction. We should therefore read his reports as the words of a hostile outsider and not as a complete record of what the crowds hoped.
2. A case: Josephus and an unclear oracle
One short example shows how a hope could be read in two directions. In his account of the revolt, Josephus says that an unclear saying in the sacred writings, which spoke of a ruler arising from the land, helped to push many toward war. He writes that it was in fact fulfilled in the Roman commander who became emperor, and not in a Jewish leader. This is a very convenient reading for a man writing under the protection of that emperor's family. Whether the hope was as widespread as he says, and whether the saying was seen in this way by those who rose against Rome, we cannot test. What we can see is that a hope for the future was a political matter, and that the way a writer applied it depended on whose side he was on.
3. What was hoped for the dead
The sources show at least three different positions.
No life beyond. The New Testament and Josephus both report that the Sadducees held that there was no resurrection, and Josephus adds that they did not accept that the soul survives death. Some Jewish writings from this period also seem to expect no clear life after death. The book of Sirach, a book of wisdom from the early second century BC, does not seem to speak of a resurrection, and it is often read as expecting none. Many Hebrew Scriptures speak of the dead going down to a place of silence, and this older picture continued for some readers.
The soul lives on. A wisdom book written in Greek, probably in or near Alexandria, the Wisdom of Solomon, speaks of the souls of the righteous being in God's hand and of immortality. This language is close to the philosophy of the Greek world. Josephus, writing for Greek readers, uses the same kind of language: he describes the Essenes as believing that the soul is immortal, and he speaks of the Pharisees in similar terms with reward and punishment after death. We should hold his words with some care, since he is fitting the Jewish groups to what his readers would understand.
Resurrection of the body. The book of Daniel, whose last chapter is among the passages at the head of this lecture, says that many who sleep in the dust will awake, some to life and some to shame. Most readers think the book reached its present form in a time of persecution, when faithful people were being killed and it seemed that God's justice needed to reach beyond death. The second book of Maccabees tells of a mother and her seven sons who were put to death for refusing to break the Law. In the story, each son says, in some way, that God will raise the righteous. The author wrote to encourage readers in a hard time and to make heroes of the martyrs. The story may be shaped by that purpose, and it is still good evidence of a hope that was told and retold.
This is a point where readers will not agree, and it touches a book that is in some Bibles and not in others. The second book of Maccabees is counted as Scripture by the Catholic and the Orthodox churches, which call it deuterocanonical, a word meaning "of the second ". Protestant churches do not count it as Scripture, though many value it as a history and a witness to Jewish faith between the testaments. Each position has reasons, and the reasons concern which books the early church received and which the Jewish community kept. Lecture 2-2 returns to this. What this course requires is only that you read 2 Maccabees as a source, and that you do not rank the churches by how they count it.
The three positions are not three steps on a ladder, and nobody should read them as a development from "less" to "more" belief. The sources overlap. A Jewish reader in Alexandria might know the language of immortality and the language of resurrection both. And these are views the sources report. How many people held each, we cannot say.
4. Angels, spirits and the order of the world
The Hebrew Scriptures speak of angels, and in the period of this course they come into sharper view. The book of Daniel names angels such as Gabriel and Michael. The book of Tobit tells a story of a family guided by an angel who is later named Raphael. The 1 Enoch collection tells of angels who fell and of angels who report to God. At Qumran, several writings speak of angels standing with the community, and one of them, a rule, speaks of two spirits that struggle inside every person. Acts 23:8 reports that the Sadducees accepted no angel or spirit, and that the Pharisees accepted all of these.
What do we make of these reports? We can say that angels were an ordinary part of the language of faith for many Jews of the time, and that the Gospels' use of them belongs to that world. We should not say that every Jew believed in angels in the same way, or that the Sadducees' reported position was a general position. And we should not go from one passage in Tobit or in Enoch to the meaning of a line in the Gospels without showing a bridge between them. That would be to let the background overwrite the text.
5. Apocalyptic hope: one strand
A good deal of what we have described belongs to the family of writings called apocalypses, from a Greek word meaning "uncovering". In an apocalypse, a seer is shown heavenly secrets and the end of history, often through visions, angels and strange images. Daniel is one; the 1 Enoch collection includes several more. These writings were often composed in times of pressure, to say that God is still in charge and will judge. They are one strand of the hope of the time. Many Jews who never read them, or who read them and held other hopes too, lived and prayed in other ways. For the genre and its interpretation, see BT619E.
6. A case: the question of the seven brothers (Mark 12:18-27)
The passage at the head of this lecture is a debate. The Sadducees put to Jesus a puzzle. It is built on a rule of the Law, that a man whose brother dies childless should marry the widow and raise up a child for his brother. A woman has seven husbands in turn. In the resurrection, whose wife is she?
What the text says. The Gospel writer introduces the questioners as people who say there is no resurrection. They tell the story with a purpose: it is meant to make resurrection look absurd. Jesus answers that they are mistaken, that those who rise are like angels in heaven and do not marry, and then he argues from the book of Moses, from the words spoken to Moses at the bush, that God is God of the living. He ends with a firm conclusion.
What the sources add. From Acts and from Josephus we know that the Sadducees were said to deny the resurrection, which fits the story. The rule of marrying a brother's widow is in the Law, and the Sadducees' puzzle stays within the written Law, which is how they are said to have argued. Jesus' reply also stays within the written Law, from the "book of Moses". This is a debate that makes sense in a Jewish world where people argued about the meaning of Scripture.
What is conjecture. Whether the Sadducees put exactly this question to Jesus in this way, we cannot test. Whether the Pharisees would have given the same answer, the passage does not say. Many readers see a gentle likeness between Jesus' view and the Pharisees' on the resurrection, and many see in the passage a distinct teaching of Jesus. Both readings take their reasons from other places in the Gospels. And, in this scene, the Gospel writer reports a stern verdict against the Sadducees; it is a verdict on one position in one argument, and lecture 6-2 returns to how such words must be read.
7. What to carry away
If you are asked, "What did the Jews of Jesus' time expect?", the honest reply begins, "Which Jews, and according to which source?" Some hoped for a king. Some for a priest and a king. Some for a prophet. Some for God alone to act. Some expected the dead to rise. Some hoped for the soul to live on. Some did not look beyond. The Gospels step into this crowd of hopes. They do not stand outside it, and they do not match any of it perfectly. That is what we mean when we say the New Testament was written in the world of Second Temple Judaism, and also why background should never be read as a replacement for the text.
Diagram 1. Three views of the dead, and the sources that report them
Diagram 2. Mark 12:18-27 in three columns
| What the text says | What the sources add | What is conjecture |
|---|---|---|
| The Sadducees deny resurrection and put a puzzle about seven brothers; Jesus answers from the book of Moses. | Acts and Josephus say the Sadducees denied resurrection; the puzzle rests on a rule in the Law. | The exact words of the exchange; how far the Pharisees would have agreed with Jesus. |
핵심 요약
- Messiah means "anointed one"; the sources show a king, a priest, a prophet, a heavenly figure, and some hopes with no figure.
- Josephus reports prophet-like and king-like leaders with disapproval; his reports are an outsider's view.
- The sources show three views of the dead: no life beyond, the soul living on, and resurrection of the body.
- The Sadducees are reported to have denied resurrection, angels and spirits; the Pharisees to have accepted them.
- Apocalyptic hope is one strand among several; the detail belongs to BT619E.
- Mark 12:18-27 is a debate within Judaism over resurrection, argued from the book of Moses on both sides.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Messiah | "Anointed one": a word used of kings, priests and prophets, which gathered several different hopes. |
| Psalms of Solomon | Jewish poems after Rome's arrival, hoping for a righteous king of David's house. |
| Three views of the dead | No life beyond; the soul lives on; resurrection of the body. |
| Mark 12:18-27 | A debate on resurrection between the Sadducees and Jesus, argued from the Law. |
One sentence to remember The Gospels step into a crowd of hopes; they do not stand outside it, and they match none of them perfectly.
This week's action The next time you read "the Jews expected...", write down which Jews, from which source, and how that source leans.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What does the word *Messiah* mean, and why is it not by itself a single clear expectation?
- The *Psalms of Solomon* hope for a king because of a particular experience. What does this suggest about hopes in general?
- Josephus applies an unclear saying to the Roman emperor. What does this show about reading a writer who lived under Roman protection?
- Name three positions on the dead found in the sources. Why is it unwise to arrange them as a ladder?
- Why can a story such as the mother and her seven sons be good evidence and also be shaped by the writer's purpose?
- In Mark 12:18-27, which parts of the debate rest on what the text says, and which on guesses?
- Where have you heard "the Jews expected..." said as if it were one thing? What would you ask now?