Lecture 4-1: Groups: What the Sources Say, What the Textbooks Add
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Second Temple Judaism" Means
- Lecture 1-2: The Sources We Have
- Lecture 1-3: Reading Sources Against Each Other
- Lecture 1-4: What Stones and Inscriptions Say
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Two Sources on One Event
- Lecture 2-1: The Persian and Hellenistic Ages
- Lecture 2-2: The Maccabean Revolt and the Hasmoneans
- Lecture 2-3: Rome Arrives; the House of Herod
- Lecture 2-4: Herod's Kingdom: Power, Building and Fear
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Chronicle
- Lecture 3-1: The Temple, the Priests and the Festivals
- Lecture 3-2: Synagogue, Torah and Daily Practice
- Lecture 3-3: Jews in the Diaspora
- Lecture 3-4: Galilee and Judea: Villages, Work and Language
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Letter and a House Rule
- Lecture 4-1: Groups: What the Sources Say, What the Textbooks Add
- Lecture 4-2: Hopes: Messiah, Resurrection and the Age to Come
- Lecture 4-3: Torah and Covenant: How Jews Understood the Law
- Lecture 4-4: Scripture in Many Hands
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Reading Groups
- Lecture 5-1: Rome and Judea
- Lecture 5-2: Cities, Households and Patronage
- Lecture 5-3: The Market of Religions and Philosophies
- Lecture 5-4: Associations, House Gatherings and the First Churches' Setting
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: An Inscription and a Letter
Many textbooks give a tidy list. There were four groups in the Judaism of Jesus' time: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes and Zealots. Each has a short description, and sometimes a small table: the Pharisees believed in resurrection, the Sadducees did not, the Essenes lived in the desert, the Zealots wanted a revolt. The list is easy to learn. It is also a warning sign, because a picture this neat usually comes from the textbook and not from the sources.
Lecture 4-1 does not repeat the survey of the groups that you met in BT501E. It asks a different question: for each group, who tells us about it, for whom did that person write, and what did that person want? The answer changes how much we can say. For some groups we have a good deal. For others we have a few paragraphs written by outsiders. For one we have a library of the group's own writings, but we are not sure which group it was.
The week's principle comes first: Second Temple Judaism had many voices, and no textbook list of sects fits the sources perfectly. This lecture begins with the sources, and the sects come after.
이 27분으로 얻는 것
- Name, for the Pharisees, Sadducees and Essenes, the main sources that describe each group and the lean of each source.
- Explain why the Qumran writings are a different kind of evidence from the descriptions written by Josephus, and state the dispute about who lived at Qumran.
- Describe what Acts 23:6-8 says, what other sources add, and what remains conjecture.
- Give two reasons why the sentence "the Pharisees all believed..." is a claim to be handled with care.
- Say what other groups and movements appear in the sources besides the best-known three.
But when Paul perceived that the one part were Sadducees and the other Pharisees, he cried out in the council, “Men and brothers, I am a Pharisee, a son of Pharisees. Concerning the hope and resurrection of the dead I am being judged!” When he had said this, an argument arose between the Pharisees and Sadducees, and the assembly was divided. For the Sadducees say that there is no resurrection, nor angel, nor spirit; but the Pharisees confess all of these." — Acts 23:6-8
World English Bible
In three verses a Christian writer tells his readers how two groups differed. He is a useful source, and he is also a writer with a purpose. Keep both facts in mind through the lecture.
1. The problem with the list
When we say "the Pharisees", we usually mean a picture assembled from several places: a few verses in the Gospels, a few passages in Josephus, some lines in later rabbinic writings, and the habits of the textbook. Each piece was written by a different person for a different reader. When the pieces are laid together without asking who wrote each one, we get a group with clear edges that no ancient person ever drew.
There is a second problem. Josephus, our fullest outside witness, describes the groups with a Greek word that his readers knew for the schools of philosophy. He was writing for educated Greek and Roman readers, and he made the Jewish groups look like philosophical schools that such readers could understand. That helps us, and it also bends the picture. A group that was a movement, a family tradition or a party in politics may look more like a school of thought than it was.
So the method of this lecture is simple. We take each group in turn and ask three questions. Who tells us about it? What is their lean? What is left over when we have set the lean aside?
2. Josephus: who he was and why he wrote
Josephus is the main source for the groups, and he needs a careful introduction because we meet him in every week of the course.
He was a Jew of a priestly family from Jerusalem. He took part in the great revolt against Rome in the sixties of the first century. He was captured by the Roman side, he came to serve them, and afterwards he lived in Rome under the protection of the imperial family and wrote his books there in Greek. His histories, the Jewish War and the Antiquities of the Jews, and his autobiography, the Life, were written for readers who were mostly not Jews. He wanted to explain the Jewish people to them, to defend its customs, and to place the blame for the revolt on a few bad leaders instead of on the Jewish people as a whole. He also had to explain his own part in the story.
Here is one scene. Imagine Josephus in Rome, years after the war, working on the Antiquities. He has a long account of the groups to write, and he knows that a reader in the capital will ask, "What do these Jews believe about fate, the soul and what comes after?" Those are the questions that Greek readers asked of philosophers. So he arranges the groups around those questions. The result is useful, and it is shaped by the questions of his readers more than by the questions the groups put to themselves. His report was received, as far as we can tell, as a serious account in Greek and later in Christian circles, and it is the reason we know as much as we do.
Josephus tells us that he himself, as a young man, tried the three main ways of life before he settled on public life in the manner of the Pharisees. If he is right, he knew these groups from the inside. He is also an interested party, and in other places he speaks about the groups with the warmth or the coolness that suited his argument.
3. The Pharisees
Who tells us. Josephus describes them in his histories, with a tone that changes from book to book. The Gospels and Acts mention them often, usually in dispute with Jesus or the apostles, and one New Testament author who was a Pharisee tells us so in his own letter. Later rabbinic writings never call their own sages by a simple name that matches "Pharisee"; the link between the two is a question that scholars still argue about. We have no work that we can say with confidence was written by a Pharisee of this time and named as such.
What the sources say. They agree on a few points. The Pharisees were known for care about the Law and about what some called the tradition of the elders, an extra body of teaching about how to keep the written Law. They are said to have believed in a life after death and in angels. Josephus says that they had influence with the ordinary people, while the Gospels show them as teachers in the villages and in Jerusalem.
What the lean is. Josephus presents them in terms of a philosophical school and, in some places, as a party with political power. The Gospels present them in the heat of an argument: a debate between Jewish teachers over how to live the Law, and the writers are followers of one side. Lecture 6-2 returns to this. Neither source is neutral, and neither was trying to be.
What is left over. We can say that the Pharisees existed, that they cared deeply about how the Law is lived, and that they were part of the religious life of the time. We cannot say with confidence how many there were, how far they controlled ordinary people's habits, or whether every Jewish teacher who is called a "scribe" or a "teacher of the Law" in the sources belonged to them.
4. The Sadducees
Who tells us. Josephus and the New Testament, and later rabbinic writings with their own concerns. No writing that the Sadducees left behind has come to us, and nothing certain can be called theirs. Everything we know is what others said of them.
What the sources say. The Sadducees are linked with the priestly families and the Temple in Jerusalem. The New Testament has them in the company of the high priest. On the matter of the dead, Acts and the Gospels say that they denied the resurrection, and Acts adds angels and spirits, which Josephus supports in his own way when he says that they did not accept the survival of the soul. They are also said to have held to the written Law and to have refused the extra tradition that the Pharisees kept.
What the lean is. Every report comes from outsiders, some of whom were opponents. We should be slow to read the Sadducees as "rationalists", a label some books give them. It may be a fair summary and it may be a modern idea laid over thin evidence.
What is left over. A group connected with the Temple and its leading families, with a different view of resurrection and of tradition. Beyond that, we are mostly reading their opponents' reports.
5. The Essenes
Who tells us. Josephus describes them at some length, with real admiration. Philo, a Jewish thinker of Alexandria, mentions them in his own writing, as a model of a disciplined life. A Roman writer of natural history, Pliny the , mentions a community of this kind by the Dead Sea. The New Testament does not name them.
What the sources say. They lived a disciplined common life, many of them in settled communities in the towns and villages. Sharing property and strict rules of purity and of sabbath belong to the reports. Some accounts speak of celibacy; one of them, in Josephus, adds that there was another branch that did marry.
What the lean is. The three outside writers wrote for readers outside the group and they all admire it. They are describing a way of life they saw as good, and each one fits the picture to his own argument: Josephus to a philosophical school, Philo to an ideal of virtue, Pliny to a curiosity of the shores of the Dead Sea.
6. The Qumran community: a different kind of evidence
In and after the late 1940s a large number of manuscripts were found in caves above the north-western shore of the Dead Sea. They are called the Dead Sea Scrolls. Near the caves lie the ruins of a settlement, called Qumran. Among the Scrolls are copies of nearly every book of the Hebrew Scriptures, other Jewish religious writings known and unknown, and a group of texts that look like the rules and the writings of a community: the Community Rule, the Damascus Document, a book about a final battle called the War Scroll, and commentaries that read the prophets as speaking of the community's own time.
This is a different kind of evidence. For the other groups we have outsiders' descriptions. Here we have the group's own writings (or the writings of a closely related group), copied and kept. They speak of a "community" with its own rules for entry, for property, for purity and for the calendar. They are bitterly critical of other Jewish leaders, in particular of the priests in Jerusalem.
Because these writings are the group's own, they are rich. For the same reason they are one-sided: they tell us how this group saw itself and its opponents, and they say little about the rest of the Jewish world.
Three kinds of evidence, three kinds of caution
An outsider's report (Josephus on the Sadducees): we know what was said about them, not what they said. A friendly outsider (Philo, Josephus on the Essenes): the picture is a good one, and it may be too good. The group's own writings (the Scrolls): we hear the voice, and the voice is partisan.
7. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: who lived at Qumran, and how far the Pharisees shaped ordinary life. Many scholars hold that the Qumran community was a branch of the Essenes, or closely linked to them, and they point to likenesses between the Scrolls and the reports of Josephus and Pliny on the Essenes: common property, strict purity, a disciplined entry, a place near the Dead Sea. Other readers hold that the likenesses are real but not enough to say "Essene" without more, since the Scrolls themselves never use that name, and since some details do not match: the Scrolls speak of marriage and children in some texts, and some scholars think the site was used for other purposes as well, for example as a pottery works or a country estate. Others again suggest that the Scrolls came from several groups, and that the collection was gathered or hidden by people we cannot name. On the Pharisees, one kind of reader holds that they shaped ordinary Jewish practice widely, citing Josephus' remark on their influence with the people. Another kind holds that this reflects Josephus' own interest, and that most villagers followed local customs of their own, learned from family and not from a party. Both readers are weighing the same few reports, and both can point to something in them.
What this course requires is less than either position requires. It requires that you say what the sources allow, which is that a community with such rules existed and its writings survive, and what they do not allow, which is a firm identification of that community or a firm count of any party's reach. Where a book says "the Essenes at Qumran" or "the Pharisees ruled the villages" as if it were settled, it is giving the most popular position and not a fact.
8. Other voices
Even the three best-known groups are not the whole picture. The sources point to others.
- Josephus speaks of a "fourth philosophy", a movement that held that only God was Israel's ruler, and that was prepared to resist Roman rule. He gives it a place in the road to the revolt. The label "Zealots" is often given to all such movements, but the sources use the word and the groups in different ways, so the textbook name may cover more than the evidence does.
- Josephus also names groups of bandits and of armed rebels in the years before the revolt. Whether they should be seen as religious groups, political groups or both is a question for lecture 5-1.
- The Gospels name scribes, "the chief priests" and the "elders", and in one place, the Herodians. These are roles and parties, and they do not always map onto the three groups of Josephus.
- Philo writes of a community of men and women outside Alexandria, the Therapeutae, who gave themselves to the study of Scripture and to prayer.
- The Samaritans are a separate people with their own Temple on their own mountain, and they appear in the Gospels and in Josephus. They are not a "group within Judaism" in the sense of this lecture, and the sources should not be forced into that form.
- Beyond all of these, most Jews belonged to none of the named groups. They were farmers, craftsmen, traders and pilgrims, who kept the Law as they had learned it at home.
9. A case: Paul in the council (Acts 23:6-8)
The passage at the head of the lecture is a good test of the method, because it uses what we have just learned. Take it in three columns.
What the text says. Paul, on trial before a council in Jerusalem, sees that part of it consists of Sadducees and part of Pharisees. He calls out that he is a Pharisee and the son of Pharisees, and that he is on trial concerning the hope and resurrection of the dead. The council divides. The narrator adds a short note for his readers: the Sadducees say there is no resurrection, no angel and no spirit; the Pharisees confess them all.
What other sources add. Josephus also describes disagreement between the two groups about the dead and the soul, in terms that fit Greek readers' questions. Outside the New Testament, nothing says that they ever met in a council in exactly this way. The Pharisees are also known in other sources to have accepted a life after death.
What is conjecture. Whether Paul's move was a skilful tactic, as some readers hold, or an honest statement of what he thought the dispute was really about, as others hold, the text does not say, and both readers take their reasons from other places in Acts. Whether every member of the council behaved as the verse describes, and whether the neat split of "Sadducee" and "Pharisee" was as sharp in real life as in the narrator's note, we cannot test. The narrator's note is itself evidence of how a Christian writer, writing for readers far from Jerusalem, summed up a difference. It is not a measurement of the groups.
Notice what the method does not do. It does not remove the passage, and it does not say that Luke is wrong. It gives the passage its proper weight: a good witness to a real difference over the resurrection, from one writer's side.
10. What to carry away
When a book says "the Pharisees believed...", you can ask four questions. Which source says so? Is that source friendly, hostile or distant? Does any group's own writing survive? Is the claim one that every member of the group could be expected to hold? Often the honest answer is "some sources say so, with a lean, and we cannot say more." That is a smaller answer than the textbook gives. It is also the one the evidence supports.
Diagram 1. Who tells us about whom
Diagram 2. Three questions for any group
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Who tells us about this group? | An outsider, a friend, an enemy or the group itself will each say different things. |
| For whom did that writer write? | Josephus wrote for Greek and Roman readers; the Gospel writers for believers; the Scrolls for the community. |
| What would the group itself say? | If its own voice survives, hear it; if not, say so and hold the report lightly. |
핵심 요약
- The textbook list of four sects is tidy; the sources do not agree with it perfectly. Ask who tells us, for whom and why.
- Josephus described the groups as philosophical schools for Greek and Roman readers; that helps and that bends.
- No writing survives that we can name as Sadducean; most of the Pharisees' picture comes from sources with a lean.
- The Qumran writings are the group's own voice, rich and one-sided; who lived there is disputed.
- The reach of the Pharisees over ordinary life is disputed; the sources allow less than many books claim.
- Acts 23:6-8 is a good witness to a real difference over resurrection, told from one writer's side.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Josephus on the groups | A Jewish author writing in Rome for non-Jewish readers; he describes the groups as philosophical schools. |
| The Sadducees' own writings | None survive that we can name; we know them from outsiders. |
| Qumran writings | The community's own voice: rules, commentaries, and a battle scroll; rich and one-sided. |
| Acts 23:6-8 | Paul divides a council over resurrection; the narrator explains the groups' difference to his readers. |
One sentence to remember Before you say what a group believed, say who told you so.
This week's action Take one sentence that begins "The Pharisees (or Sadducees or Essenes) believed..." from anything you have read, and write beside it who the source was and how it leans.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of a group in your own surroundings that is described by outsiders more often than by its own members. What would be lost if you knew it only from the outsiders?
- Why does it matter that Josephus described the Jewish groups in terms of philosophical schools?
- The Sadducees left us no writings of their own. How should that change the way we read what the New Testament and Josephus say of them?
- What is the difference between an outsider's description of the Essenes and the Qumran writings? What does each allow us to say, and what does it not?
- In the lecture the dispute about Qumran is shown from several sides. Which position seems strongest to you, and what would you need to see before you were sure?
- In Acts 23:6-8, what does the text say, what do other sources add, and what remains conjecture?
- Where have you seen a tidy list of groups, in a book, a sermon or a class? Which of the questions in this lecture would you now ask of it?