Introduction: What Medieval Church History Is, and Why We Study It
목차 21
- Lecture 1-1: How East and West Became Strangers
- Lecture 1-2: Iconoclasm — Images, Empire and the Incarnation
- Lecture 1-3: One Word in the Creed — the Filioque
- Lecture 1-4: 1054, and What Made It Permanent
- Lecture 2-1: From Just War to Holy War
- Lecture 2-2: What the Crusades Cost
- Lecture 2-3: Poverty as Protest
- Lecture 2-4: Francis and Dominic
- Lecture 3-1: Faith Seeking Understanding
- Lecture 3-2: The Aristotle Shock
- Lecture 3-3: Aquinas and the Summa
- Lecture 3-4: The University
- Lecture 4-1: Avignon, and Then Two Popes
- Lecture 4-2: The Church That Nearly Got a Constitution
- Lecture 4-3: The Black Death
- Lecture 4-4: Going Around the Institution
Four and a half centuries, one church, and a story that runs uphill and then falls off a cliff.
This course covers the Western church from the schism of 1054 to the eve of the Reformation — twenty-one lectures across five chapters. In that time the church built the university, produced some of the most ambitious thinking in human history, launched wars it called holy, lost a third of Europe to plague, elected three popes at once, and burned the men who told it to go back to Scripture.
A word about the phrase "the Dark Ages". You will not find it in this course, because it is not a description of the Middle Ages. It is a description of what Renaissance writers wanted people to think about the Middle Ages, and it has survived mostly because it is short. The period that produced Aquinas, Chartres, Hildegard and Oxford was not dark. It was, in places, terrible — which is a different word and a more useful one.
이 18분으로 얻는 것
- Say why medieval church history has to tell the story of a brilliant summit and a sudden collapse at the same time, and why neither half makes sense alone.
- Explain how this course bridges CH101 (Early Church History) and CH201 (History of the Reformation).
- Understand how the course is arranged and how to work through it.
Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will not pass away." — Matthew 24:35
World English Bible
But the end of all things is near. Therefore be of sound mind, self-controlled, and sober in prayer." — 1 Peter 4:7
WEB
These two verses sit at opposite ends of this course. The second is what the fourteenth century believed it was living through. The first is what turned out to be true.
1. Where this course stands
Medieval church history is a bridge, and it helps to know what it connects.
CH101 (Early Church History) traced how orthodox doctrine came to be formed — the , the person of Christ, the . Those questions were settled, at enormous cost, by the councils. This course begins after the settlement and asks a different question: what did the Western church do with an orthodoxy it had inherited rather than fought for?
The answer is that it built. It built an institution of extraordinary reach, a body of law, a system of education, an international bureaucracy, a theology of breathtaking scope. And then, within two or three generations, that institution destroyed its own credibility so thoroughly that ordinary Christians stopped believing what it told them.
That collapse is not a footnote. It is the reason CH201 (History of the Reformation) has a subject at all. Luther did not appear out of nowhere in 1517. He appeared into a vacuum that four generations of failure had hollowed out.
2. A word about who is reading this
The Middle Ages are not neutral ground.
If you are Protestant, you probably inherited this period as a long wrong turn that ends when someone finally reads Romans properly. If you are Catholic, you inherited much of it as your own family history, including the parts a Protestant textbook treats as evidence for the prosecution. If you are Orthodox, the whole story begins with a wound — the West walking away — and the rest of it happens somewhere else.
This course does not pretend to have no position. It is taught in a Protestant school and the syllabus reflects that. What it does try to do is state each position in the form its own adherents would recognise, and mark clearly where a judgement is contested rather than settling it quietly in a subordinate clause. When you meet a paragraph beginning This is a point where readers will not agree, that is deliberate. Those paragraphs are not padding; they are where the honest work is.
3. What this course is, and what it leaves out
This is a history of institutions and ideas. That is a choice, and you should know it before you start, because it decides what you will and will not meet here.
You will get the papacy, the councils, the schism, the as an argument about what violence God authorises, the universities, scholastic method, and the men and women who challenged the institution and what happened to them.
You will not get much of the ordinary religious life of medieval Christians. Parish life, the shape of the liturgical year, care of the poor and the sick, the guilds, pilgrimage as people actually experienced it, popular devotion to the saints and to Mary, and the daily texture of monastic prayer are all largely absent. They are not absent because they are unimportant — for most medieval Christians they were Christianity, and the institutional quarrels in these lectures passed most people by. They are absent because a course of twenty-one lectures has to choose, and this one has chosen the structures and the arguments.
Two further limits, stated rather than hidden:
- Women appear mostly as people the institution excluded, because that is where the institutional record puts them. Hildegard, Catherine of Siena, Julian of Norwich, Marguerite Porete and the Beguines are here, and each of them deserves more than they get.
- The Eastern church leaves the story after 1204. Byzantine theology went on being creative for another two centuries; the fourteenth-century hesychast debates alone would fill a course. This one follows the Western church, and says so rather than implying the East stopped.
If what you want is the lived religion of medieval people, the best single corrective is Eamon Duffy's The Stripping of the Altars, and this course would be glad to be read alongside it.
4. The shape of the course
Chapter 1 begins with a division. East and West had been walking apart for centuries — in language, in theology, in their understanding of what a church even is. The mutual excommunications of 1054 were the moment the drift finally broke open. This is where the Western church becomes Western: alone, and free to develop without anyone to check it.
Chapters 2 and 3 are expansion and intellect. The crusades poured Europe's religious energy outward under the name of holy war, and the results were catastrophic in ways still being paid for. In the same century, and out of the same restlessness, mendicant orders arose that renounced property altogether. Meanwhile the scholastic theologians, from Anselm to Aquinas, built a synthesis of faith and reason so complete that it took three hundred years to come apart — and built the university to house it, an institution you are using a descendant of right now.
Chapters 4 and 5 are collapse and daybreak. The papacy spent seventy years in Avignon and then split into two, and briefly three, rival popes. The Black Death killed perhaps a third of Europe and took the credibility of the sacramental system with it. On exactly those ruins, Wycliffe, Hus, Savonarola and Erasmus began the church back to Scripture. Every one of them died without seeing reform succeed. Two of them were burned. The fire they lit did not go out.
| Chapter | Period | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1054 | East and West divide; the West acquires an identity of its own |
| 2 | 11th–13th c. | The crusades expand outward; the mendicant orders reform inward |
| 3 | 12th–13th c. | Scholastic theology reaches its summit; the university is born |
| 4 | 14th c. | Avignon, the Great Western Schism and the Black Death bring the system down |
| 5 | 14th–15th c. | Wycliffe, Hus, Savonarola and Erasmus prepare the next century's reform |
5. Why the summit and the collapse belong in one course
Here is the question this course keeps asking, and the reason its two halves cannot be separated.
The crusades, the Summa Theologiae and the University of Paris are within about a hundred and fifty years of Avignon, the and the plague. The same institution produced the summit and the collapse, and it produced them almost in the same breath.
That is not an accident of chronology. The very things that made the medieval church strong — its legal reach, its intellectual confidence, its capacity to organise a continent — were the things that made its failure total when it failed. An institution with no reach cannot betray you at scale. This one could.
So the practical question for anyone reading this course from inside a church today is not "how did they get it so wrong". It is nearer to: what is my church currently very good at, and what would that same strength look like if it went bad?
6. How to work through this course
- Read in order. The lectures are cumulative; chapter 4 will not make sense without chapter 1.
- Read the primary sources. Every lecture ends with a short list under Going to the Sources — three or four texts, each an evening's reading, all available in English translation. This period is unusually well served. You can check almost everything this course tells you against the people who were there, and you should.
- Take the chapter quiz before moving on. There are five, one per chapter, plus a midterm after chapter 3 and a final at the end.
- Sit with the reflection questions. They are not comprehension checks. Several of them ask you to state a position you disagree with, in its strongest form. That is a skill this period rewards.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Period | Character | Chapter |
|---|---|---|
| 1054 | East and West divide; the West establishes its own identity | 1 |
| 11th–13th c. | The crusades expand outward; the mendicant orders reform inward | 2 |
| 12th–13th c. | The intellectual summit — scholastic theology and the university | 3 |
| 14th c. | Collapse through Avignon, the Great Schism and the Black Death | 4 |
| 14th–15th c. | The attempted reforms of Wycliffe, Hus, Savonarola and Erasmus | 5 |
5. Going to the Sources
Two short things to read before chapter 1, so you begin with medieval voices rather than only with ours.
- Bernard of Clairvaux, On Consideration, Book IV — a twelfth-century abbot telling a pope, in writing, that his court has become a law court and his office a burden. The medieval church's self-criticism was fierce and internal long before it was Protestant.
- The Rule of Saint Benedict, chapters 1–7 — the document that shaped Western monastic life for a thousand years. Short, concrete, and startlingly humane.
6. Where This Course Gets Its History
No lecture in this course is based on original research; it is a synthesis, and you are entitled to know whose. Each chapter overview lists the modern works its account leans on. For the course as a whole, four books will take you further than anything else:
- Diarmaid MacCulloch, A History of Christianity — the best single-volume survey in English, and generous to traditions other than its author's.
- R. W. Southern, The Making of the Middle Ages — old, and still the finest short account of how medieval Christendom actually thought.
- Eamon Duffy, The Stripping of the Altars — the lived religion this course leaves out, argued with force.
- Heiko Oberman, The Harvest of Medieval Theology — on the continuity between the late medieval church and the Reformation, against the idea of a clean break.
Where this course states a position that specialists dispute, it says so in the text and names who disputes it.
핵심 요약
- The course covers the Western church from 1054 to the eve of the Reformation. It is a bridge between early church history (CH101) and the Reformation (CH201).
- The same institution produced both the intellectual summit and the collapse, within about 150 years. Its strengths, such as legal reach and confidence, made its failure total.
- The course says openly that it is taught in a Protestant school. It tries to state each position as its own adherents would, and it marks contested judgements.
- It is a history of institutions and ideas. It leaves out most ordinary religious life, treats women mostly as excluded, and follows the Western church only after 1204.
- The five chapters run: the division of East and West, crusades and mendicant orders, scholastic theology, decline and collapse, then the dawn of the Reformation.
- Students should read in order, read the primary sources, take each chapter quiz, and answer the reflection questions, including arguing positions they dislike.
Topic: This lecture explains what the course covers, what it leaves out, and why the summit and the collapse of the medieval church belong together.
Remember: The same strengths that made the medieval church powerful made its failure total. The summit and the collapse came from one institution, almost in the same breath.
Caution: The course does not claim to have no position, and it leaves out most ordinary medieval devotion. It is not a full picture of medieval Christian life.
One line to carry into ministry: Ask what your church is very good at, and what that same strength would look like if it went wrong.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- The lecture argues that the medieval church's strengths and its collapse were the same thing seen twice. What is your own church very good at, and what would that strength look like if it went wrong?
- Wycliffe, Hus and Savonarola all died without seeing their movements succeed. What does that ask of anyone working for change in a church now?
- If Matthew 24:35 — "my words will not pass away" — is the sentence this whole course is built on, what does that imply about institutions?
- The doctrines fought over in CH101 (the Trinity, the person of Christ) are largely settled in this period. What replaced them as the thing worth fighting about, and what does that shift tell you?