Lecture 1-4: 1054, and What Made It Permanent
목차 21
- Lecture 1-1: How East and West Became Strangers
- Lecture 1-2: Iconoclasm — Images, Empire and the Incarnation
- Lecture 1-3: One Word in the Creed — the Filioque
- Lecture 1-4: 1054, and What Made It Permanent
- Lecture 2-1: From Just War to Holy War
- Lecture 2-2: What the Crusades Cost
- Lecture 2-3: Poverty as Protest
- Lecture 2-4: Francis and Dominic
- Lecture 3-1: Faith Seeking Understanding
- Lecture 3-2: The Aristotle Shock
- Lecture 3-3: Aquinas and the Summa
- Lecture 3-4: The University
- Lecture 4-1: Avignon, and Then Two Popes
- Lecture 4-2: The Church That Nearly Got a Constitution
- Lecture 4-3: The Black Death
- Lecture 4-4: Going Around the Institution
The date everyone knows is 16 July 1054. The truth is that almost nothing about it deserves the weight it carries — and the reasons why are more instructive than the event.
The excommunications of that afternoon were not issued by a pope against a patriarch. They were issued by legates against one man and his associates, and the pope who commissioned them had been dead for three months. Under the church's own law that arguably voided their authority entirely. The document they left on the altar of Hagia Sophia contained charges that were partly false and, in one case, aimed at a clause the Eastern church had never adopted.
And yet the churches are still divided. So the question this lecture asks is not "what happened in 1054". It is why did this quarrel, unlike a dozen earlier ones, never heal?
The answer lies mostly after 1054, and mostly in things Christians did to other Christians with weapons.
이 18분으로 얻는 것
- Explain how the geopolitics of southern Italy and the reforming papacy of the eleventh century set up the collision.
- Describe how Humbert and Cerularius turned a dispute into mutual excommunication in Hagia Sophia.
- Explain why the Fourth Crusade of 1204 and the failed reunions at Lyons and Florence made the schism permanent.
- State the lasting consequences of the division, and the meaning of the mutual lifting of the anathemas in 1965.
See how good and how pleasant it is for brothers to live together in unity!" — Psalm 133:1
World English Bible
The psalm is short and it is about a household. Nothing in this lecture is about a household. That is the measure of the failure.
1. Southern Italy: where two churches shared a border
Every long-distance quarrel needs a place where the two sides actually touch. For Rome and Constantinople that place was the heel and toe of Italy.
Recall from lecture 1-2 that the emperor Leo III had transferred southern Italy and Sicily from Roman to Constantinopolitan jurisdiction. Three centuries later the region was a patchwork: Greek-rite churches under a Byzantine governor, Latin-rite churches nearby, and, from the 1040s, Normans — French-speaking mercenaries who had arrived as hired soldiers and stayed as conquerors.
The Normans conquered Greek-rite territory and installed Latin bishops, who required Latin practice, including unleavened bread in the Eucharist. Greek congregations found their being replaced by force of arms in territory that had been Orthodox for centuries.
Constantinople replied in kind. The patriarch Michael Cerularius closed the Latin-rite churches in Constantinople and required them to adopt Greek usage. His associate, Leo of Ohrid, wrote an open letter attacking the Latin use of unleavened bread — azymes — as a Judaising corruption of the .
This is where lecture 1-1's argument comes back with force. Neither side was inventing a theological quarrel to justify a political one. Each genuinely believed the other's practice was wrong. But the practices had become the flag, and each side was tearing down the other's flag in territory it controlled.
2. A reforming papacy in a fighting mood
The other half of the setup is that Rome in the 1050s was newly confident.
The Cluniac reform movement had spent a century arguing that the church must free itself from lay control — no more bishoprics sold, no more abbeys handed out by counts as favours. By the time of Pope Leo IX the reform party held Rome itself, and it had a programme: a purified church, governed from Rome, exercising a jurisdiction that ran everywhere.
Note the double edge. The best reformers of the eleventh century were also the strongest advocates of papal authority, because a papacy with real jurisdiction was their instrument for cleaning up the church. Reform and centralisation arrived together, and the men carrying them were not inclined to compromise.
The sharpest of them was Cardinal Humbert of Silva Candida — learned, absolutely certain, and temperamentally incapable of leaving an argument unwon. Leo IX sent him to Constantinople in 1054 to negotiate. On the other side stood Cerularius, a patriarch of comparable stubbornness who had come to his office from a failed political conspiracy and was not disposed to defer to a Western cardinal.
It is worth saying plainly: the emperor in Constantinople wanted the negotiation to succeed. He needed a Western alliance against the Normans. The politics pointed toward agreement. The personalities did not.
3. Saturday, 16 July 1054
The talks failed almost immediately. Humbert circulated a polemic; Cerularius refused to meet him. Then, on 19 April, Pope Leo IX died in Rome. News reached Constantinople, and with it the obvious question of whether the legates still had a commission at all.
Humbert proceeded anyway. On the afternoon of 16 July, as the clergy of Hagia Sophia prepared for the liturgy, the legates entered, laid a bull of excommunication on the high altar, walked out, and shook the dust from their feet at the door.
The document is worth reading, and it does not flatter its authors. Its charges are a mixture of the serious, the trivial and the simply untrue — among them that the Greeks had removed the from the creed, which is precisely backwards, as lecture 1-3 showed. It anathematised Cerularius and his followers, not the Eastern church as such.
Cerularius convened a synod and anathematised the legates in return, likewise not the Western church as such.
So two limited excommunications, of questionable validity, issued by men acting largely on their own temper, became the conventional date of a schism between two churches. They became that only in retrospect. What made them retroactively enormous was what happened next.
4. 1204: the year the schism became unforgivable
If you take one thing from this lecture, take this. For the Eastern church, the wound is not 1054. It is 1204.
The Fourth Crusade set out for Egypt. Diverted by Venetian debt and a disputed Byzantine succession, it arrived instead at Constantinople, the largest Christian city in the world, and in April 1204 it took the city by storm and sacked it for three days.
What happened then was done to Christians, by Christians, in a crusade blessed by the church. Churches were stripped and their altars broken up for the metal. Relics were carried off across Europe — many are still in Western treasuries. The library and the accumulated art of nine centuries were burned or scattered. Contemporary accounts, Western as well as Greek, describe a prostitute seated on the patriarch's throne in Hagia Sophia singing bawdy songs.
A Latin emperor was installed and a Latin patriarch imposed. The Latin Empire lasted until 1261.
Pope Innocent III, who had neither ordered nor sanctioned the attack, condemned it in bitter terms. It made no difference to what it meant.
After 1204, reunion was no longer a theological problem. It was a problem of memory. A Greek Christian being asked to accept Roman authority was being asked to accept the authority of the institution whose armies had done this. Ordinary Byzantines who had gone on receiving communion from Latin priests for a century and a half stopped.
5. The reunions that were signed and rejected
Twice the churches were formally reunited, and twice it failed in the same way.
The Second Council of Lyons, 1274. The emperor Michael VIII, needing Western help against a threatened invasion, accepted union on Roman terms. His clergy and people rejected it. His own sister said her brother had sold their faith. The union collapsed with him.
The Council of Florence, 1439. With the Ottoman Turks at the walls, the Byzantine delegation negotiated seriously for months and signed a decree of union covering the Filioque, , papal primacy and the eucharistic bread. Mark of Ephesus alone refused to sign, and it was Mark whom the Byzantine faithful followed. The union was repudiated in Constantinople almost as soon as the delegates returned.
The pattern is exact and worth naming. Both unions were negotiated by rulers and hierarchs under military pressure, and both were rejected by the body of the church. Union imposed from the top in exchange for troops is not communion; it is a treaty, and the faithful knew the difference.
In 1453 Constantinople fell to the Ottomans. The bitter remark attributed to a Byzantine official on the eve — that he would rather see the Sultan's turban in the city than the cardinal's hat — may not be authentic, but it was remembered because it was true to how people felt.
6. Two churches, and a gesture in 1965
Nine hundred years of separation produced two genuinely different Christian worlds — in worship, in theological method, in the shape of authority, in what a Christian life is understood to be aiming at. The East continued as a communion of self-governing churches, the West as a single centralised jurisdiction. Nothing about that difference is superficial now.
Then, on 7 December 1965, at the close of the Second Vatican Council, Pope Paul VI and the Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras issued a joint declaration. It expressed regret for the offences of 1054 and removed the mutual excommunications from the memory of the church.
Be precise about what that did and did not do. It did not restore communion; the churches remain separated and do not share the Eucharist. What it did was end the claim that the separation is maintained by a valid sentence of condemnation. The anathemas of 1054 are gone. What remains is nine hundred years of divergence, and 1204.
7. What actually divided them
This chapter began with the claim that 1054 was not a cause but a symptom, and the evidence is now in.
Two churches drifted apart in language until they could not read each other. They gave incompatible answers to the question of who decides. They allowed practice to become identity. They quarrelled over a word in a creed that neither had authority to settle alone. And then a moment of sheer bad temper in Hagia Sophia gave the drift a date.
None of that was yet fatal. What made it fatal was 1204 — the moment when one church did to the other something that could not be argued away. After that, every attempt at reunion was an attempt to negotiate with a memory.
When the defence of orthodoxy outgrows the love of the church, the body of Christ comes apart. And what breaks it, in the end, is rarely the doctrine. It is what people are willing to do to each other while defending it.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Year | Event | Why it mattered |
|---|---|---|
| 1040s | Normans latinise Greek churches in southern Italy; Cerularius closes Latin churches | Practice becomes territory; each side tears down the other's flag |
| 1054 | Humbert's bull laid on the altar of Hagia Sophia | A limited, doubtfully valid act that later became "the schism" |
| 1204 | The Fourth Crusade sacks Constantinople | Turns a quarrel into an injury; the decisive event for the East |
| 1274 | Second Council of Lyons | Union accepted by an emperor, rejected by the church |
| 1439 | Council of Florence | Union signed under Ottoman threat; Mark of Ephesus refuses; repudiated |
| 1965 | Joint declaration of Paul VI and Athenagoras | Anathemas lifted from memory; communion still not restored |
5. Going to the Sources
- The bull of excommunication of July 1054 — short. Read the charges and count how many are doctrinal.
- Nicetas Choniates, O City of Byzantium, on the sack of 1204 — an eyewitness. Difficult reading, and necessary.
- Geoffrey of Villehardouin, The Conquest of Constantinople — the same events from a Western crusader who saw nothing wrong. Read the two together.
- The Catholic–Orthodox Joint Declaration of 1965 — two pages. Note exactly what it lifts and what it leaves in place.
핵심 요약
- The excommunications of 16 July 1054 were issued by legates, after Pope Leo IX had died, against Cerularius and his associates only. Their charges were partly false, including one about the Filioque.
- The setting was southern Italy, where Normans imposed Latin practice on Greek churches and Cerularius closed Latin churches in reply. A reforming papacy, with Humbert as its sharpest voice, was ready for conflict.
- For the Eastern church, the deeper wound is 1204, when the Fourth Crusade sacked Constantinople. Innocent III condemned it, but afterwards reunion became a problem of memory.
- Reunions at Lyons in 1274 and Florence in 1439 were agreed by rulers under military pressure and rejected by the church. Mark of Ephesus refused to sign at Florence.
- In 1965 Paul VI and Athenagoras removed the mutual excommunications from the memory of the church. Communion was not restored, and the churches do not share the Eucharist.
- The lecture concludes that doctrine is rarely what breaks a church. It is what people are willing to do to each other while defending it.
Topic: This lecture asks why the quarrel of 1054 never healed, and finds the answer mostly in what happened afterwards, especially in 1204.
Remember: 1054 gave the division a date, but 1204 gave it a memory. After the sack of Constantinople, every attempt at reunion meant negotiating with that memory.
Caution: The 1965 declaration did not restore communion. It ended the claim that a valid sentence of condemnation keeps the churches apart, while the divergence remains.
One line to carry into ministry: Union imposed from the top under pressure is a treaty, not communion. Seek agreement the whole body can receive.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- The excommunications of 1054 were probably invalid and certainly limited. Why, then, is that the date everyone remembers? What does the church gain by having a date?
- The lecture argues 1204 mattered more than 1054. Test that claim: what would have to have been different in 1204 for the reunions of 1274 or 1439 to have held?
- Both reunions were agreed by rulers and refused by congregations. When is that refusal faithfulness, and when is it obstinacy? How would you tell from inside it?
- In 1965 the anathemas were lifted and communion was not restored. What does that gap say about what actually keeps churches apart?