무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

CH102E Medieval Church History

Lecture 4-1: Avignon, and Then Two Popes

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

19분

For thirty-nine years, from 1378 to 1417, there was no way for an ordinary European Christian to know who the pope was.

Not "no easy way". No way. Two men — and after 1409, three — each held a valid-looking election, each had cardinals, each had kingdoms obeying him, and each excommunicated the others and everyone who followed them. Every Christian in Europe was excommunicated by somebody, and no available authority could settle which excommunication counted.

This lecture covers how that happened. It begins seventy years earlier, with a pope making the largest claim in the history of the office and being arrested almost immediately afterwards, and it follows the papacy to France, into a fiscal machine, and then into the schism that broke its credibility for good.

이 19분으로 얻는 것

  • Explain the significance of the collision between Boniface VIII and Philip IV, and why *Unam Sanctam* and Anagni belong in the same paragraph.
  • Describe the Avignon papacy and explain how its French character and its financial system damaged its spiritual authority.
  • Narrate how the Great Western Schism began in 1378 and why the Council of Pisa in 1409 made it worse.
  • Assess what the schism did to ordinary belief and to the standing of the papal office.

If a kingdom is divided against itself, that kingdom cannot stand." — Mark 3:24

World English Bible

Christ says this defending himself against the charge that he casts out demons by the prince of demons. His argument is that a power at war with itself is destroying itself. The fourteenth-century church supplied the demonstration.

1. Anagni, 1303: the claim and the arrest

Boniface VIII was in a quarrel with Philip IV of France about money. The king wanted to tax the clergy of his kingdom to fund a war; the pope said he could not without papal consent.

The quarrel escalated for seven years, and in 1302 Boniface issued Unam Sanctam, which ends:

"We declare, say, define and pronounce that it is altogether necessary to salvation for every human creature to be subject to the Roman Pontiff."

No pope has ever claimed more. It is the theory of chapter 1's papal primacy carried to its furthest possible point: not merely that the pope is the church's final judge, but that submission to him is a condition of being saved.

Philip's reply was not a theological treatise. In September 1303 his minister Guillaume de Nogaret, with an Italian faction hostile to Boniface, rode to the papal residence at Anagni, broke in, and held the pope prisoner for three days. Local people eventually drove them out. Boniface, who was about sixty-eight, died a few weeks later.

Sit with the sequence, because it is the whole lecture compressed.

The most extreme assertion of papal authority in history was followed within a year by a French official arresting the man who made it, and nothing happened to the official. No king came to the pope's aid. No army moved. The claim was absolute and the power behind it was gone.

Here is the underlying shift, and it is worth understanding rather than merely noting. The medieval papacy had grown powerful in a Europe of weak, fragmented rulers, where it was the only institution with continental reach — that was chapter 2's story. By 1300 that Europe no longer existed. France and England were becoming real states with taxation, bureaucracies, standing revenues and a growing sense of national identity. The papacy went on making claims calibrated for a world that had disappeared while it was talking.

That is the chapter's principle appearing for the first time: an institution's authority can be gone while its self-description is unchanged, and the people inside it are the last to find out.

2. Avignon: the church in France

In 1305 the cardinals elected a Frenchman, Clement V. He was crowned at Lyon, never went to Rome, and in 1309 settled the papal court at Avignon on the Rhône.

It was meant to be temporary. It lasted until 1377, through seven popes, every one of them French, who created cardinals who were also overwhelmingly French, who then elected the next French pope.

Two things followed, and neither was about doctrine.

First, the papacy looked like an instrument of the French crown. Whether it actually was is debated by historians; the Avignon popes were not simply puppets, and some resisted French pressure. But this was the century of the Hundred Years' War. To an Englishman, or a German, or an Italian, the universal father of all Christians was living in a French-speaking town, surrounded by French cardinals, while French armies fought their own. Perception was the whole of the problem, and perception was fatal.

Second, and more corrosively, Avignon became superb at money. A papal court in exile from its own territories had lost the revenues of the Papal States, and it had to be paid for. So it built the most sophisticated financial administration in Europe:

  • Annates — the first year's income from a benefice, paid to the papacy on appointment.
  • Reservations and provisions — the pope reserving the right to appoint to more and more offices, each appointment generating a fee.
  • Expectatives — the sale of the right to a benefice that had not yet fallen vacant.
  • Fees for everything else — dispensations, appeals, confirmations, absolutions.

None of this was invented at Avignon and none of it was straightforwardly illegal. But the scale was new, and the effect was that ordinary Christians across Europe experienced the papacy chiefly as a bill. Petrarch, who lived there, called it the Babylon of the West, and it is his phrase — the Babylonian Captivity of the Church — that stuck. (Luther would reuse the phrase in 1520 for something quite different: the captivity of the sacraments. Do not confuse the two.)

Meanwhile Rome itself decayed, its churches unrepaired and its population fallen, while the men whose office was defined by that city lived seven hundred miles away.

3. 1378: how the schism actually began

Gregory XI, urged by Catherine of Siena among others, brought the papacy back to Rome in 1377 — and died in March 1378.

The conclave met in Rome for the first time in seventy-five years, and it met surrounded by a Roman crowd loudly demanding an Italian pope, on the reasonable grounds that another Frenchman meant another seventy years in Avignon. The cardinals, mostly French, elected an Italian: Bartolomeo Prignano, archbishop of Bari, who took the name Urban VI.

Then Urban VI turned out to be impossible.

He had been chosen as a competent administrator and became, on , a man who publicly humiliated cardinals in consistory, accused them of corruption to their faces, and announced sweeping reforms in a manner that suggested he was not entirely well. Contemporaries who supported him admitted his rages.

By August the French cardinals had left Rome, declared the April election invalid because it had been made under the duress of the mob, and elected one of their own as Clement VII. He established himself at Avignon.

Notice what makes this different from an ordinary disputed election. The same body of cardinals elected both men. Their argument was not about whether the election was proper in form but about whether the fear of a crowd invalidated it — a question of fact and of law on which reasonable people, then and now, disagree. There was no court of appeal, because the only court of appeal was the office in dispute.

Europe divided, and it divided along political lines with depressing exactness:

  • Rome (Urban VI): England, the Holy Roman Empire, Hungary, Poland, Scandinavia, most of Italy.
  • Avignon (Clement VII): France, Scotland, Castile, Aragon, Naples.

England for Rome and France for Avignon; Scotland, at war with England, for Avignon. Allegiance to the vicar of Christ mapped almost perfectly onto the alliances of the Hundred Years' War.

4. The thing that made it unbearable

Now the pastoral reality, which is where this lecture actually lands.

Each pope excommunicated the other and all his adherents. So every Christian in Europe was excommunicated by a man with a serious claim to be pope. Every priest was ordained by a bishop appointed by one of them. Every absolution, every Mass, every marriage was performed under an authority that half of Christendom held to be void.

For a church whose whole account of salvation ran through valid sacraments administered by validly ordained clergy in communion with the true pope, this was not an administrative inconvenience. It was a question about whether the machinery of salvation was working at all — and it went on for a generation, so that people were born, married and buried without it ever being resolved.

And here is the detail that did the deepest damage. There were saints on both sides. Catherine of Siena, who had done more than anyone to bring the papacy home, supported Urban VI at Rome. Vincent Ferrer, the great Dominican preacher, supported the Avignon line. Both were later canonised. Learned, holy people examined the same facts and reached opposite conclusions.

That is what taught Europe the lesson. Not that the papacy was wicked — Europe had survived wicked popes before, and would again — but that the question of who held Christ's authority on earth had become undecidable, and that neither sanctity nor scholarship could decide it. Once a claim cannot be checked, people stop treating it as a claim.

5. Pisa, 1409: three

By 1409 both lines had been going for thirty-one years, and both had elected successors, so the original two men were long dead and the institution had renewed itself twice over.

Cardinals from both obediences, despairing, summoned a council at Pisa. It deposed both reigning popes as schismatics and elected a third, Alexander V.

Neither of the deposed popes accepted the ruling, because neither recognised the council's authority to make it. Both had support. So the Council of Pisa, convened to end a schism between two popes, produced a schism among three.

It is worth being precise about why it failed, because lecture 4-2 depends on it. Pisa was summoned by cardinals, not by a pope or an emperor, and its authority to depose rested on exactly the theory it was trying to establish. It was arguing in a circle: the council may depose a pope because councils are superior to popes, which is what the council was assembled to demonstrate. The Council of Constance a few years later succeeded where Pisa failed largely because an emperor stood behind it and because it got one of the three claimants to convene it — which supplied the legitimacy Pisa lacked.

6. What actually happened here

Nothing in this lecture is a heresy, and almost nothing in it was even unusual. A pope quarrelled with a king about tax. A court moved and stayed. An administration got good at raising money. A conclave met under pressure and its members later regretted their choice.

Each of those is survivable. Together, over seventy-five years, they cost the papacy the one thing it could not replace, which was the assumption that its claims were checkable.

And nobody inside saw the scale of it. The Avignon popes did not think they were destroying the office; they thought they were administering it well, and by the standards of administration they were. The cardinals of 1378 did not think they were beginning a forty-year crisis; they thought they were correcting a mistake.

An institution can lose its authority faster than it built it, and no one inside notices in time.

The next lecture is about the most serious attempt anyone made to fix it — and about why the fix failed.


From One Pope to Three, 1302–1409 Each step ordinary and survivable. The sequence was not. 1302–03 Unam Sanctam — then Anagni The largest claim ever made, and the pope arrested by a king's minister within a year 1309–77 Avignon — seven popes, all French Annates, reservations, expectatives: the papacy is met chiefly as a bill 1378 The same cardinals elect two popes Urban VI in April; in August, "the mob made us do it" — Clement VII at Avignon ROME · Urban VI England · Empire · Hungary · Poland AVIGNON · Clement VII France · Scotland · Castile · Aragon Allegiance maps onto the Hundred Years' War — and there are canonised saints on both sides 1409 Pisa deposes both and elects a third — neither accepts Summoned by cardinals alone, its authority to depose rested on the very theory it was proving The loss was not holiness. It was the assumption that the church's central claim could be checked.

Diagram 1. Summary table

Date Event Consequence
1302 Unam Sanctam The furthest claim ever made for papal authority
1303 Anagni The claim shown to have no power behind it; Europe's new states have outgrown it
1309–77 Avignon Seven French popes; the papacy experienced as a French court and a fee schedule
1378 Double election Two popes, each elected by the same cardinals; no court of appeal exists
1378–1409 The schism Every Christian excommunicated by somebody; saints on both sides
1409 Council of Pisa Three popes; a council arguing in a circle cannot settle it

5. Going to the Sources

  • Boniface VIII, Unam Sanctam — two pages. Read the last sentence twice, then read the next item.
  • Catherine of Siena, Letters, to Gregory XI — an unlettered laywoman telling the pope to come home and to stop appointing corrupt men. The fiercest reform writing of the century, from inside.
  • Petrarch, the letters "without a name" on the papal court at Avignon — where "Babylon" comes from.
  • The manifesto of the French cardinals (1378), declaring the election of Urban VI void — read the actual argument about duress before deciding whether it was cynical.

핵심 요약

  • Boniface VIII issued Unam Sanctam in 1302, the largest claim for papal authority ever made. In 1303 agents of Philip IV arrested him at Anagni, and no one came to help.
  • By 1300 France and England were real states, but the papacy kept making claims suited to a vanished world of weak rulers.
  • Seven French popes ruled from Avignon from 1309 to 1377. The papacy looked French and grew expert at raising money, so many Christians met it chiefly as a bill.
  • In 1378 the same cardinals elected Urban VI and then Clement VII. Europe divided along the lines of the Hundred Years' War, and each pope excommunicated the other's followers.
  • There were saints on both sides: Catherine of Siena backed Urban, Vincent Ferrer backed Avignon. Who held Christ's authority became undecidable, and an unchecked claim stops being treated as one.
  • The Council of Pisa in 1409 deposed both popes and elected a third, but neither accepted. Its authority rested on the theory it was trying to prove.

Topic: How the papacy moved from the Unam Sanctam claim of 1302 to Avignon, the Great Western Schism and three rival popes.

Remember: The papacy lost the assumption that its central claim could be checked, and that loss was more serious than any single scandal.

Caution: Historians debate how far the Avignon popes were really tools of the French crown, and the lecture notes that none of the steps was a heresy.

One line to carry into ministry: An institution can lose authority faster than it built it, and the people inside are often the last to notice.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • *Unam Sanctam* and Anagni are a year apart. What does the pairing teach about the relationship between an institution's claims and its actual power?
  • The Avignon papacy was, by administrative standards, well run. Why did competence at raising money cost it more than incompetence would have?
  • There were canonised saints on both sides of the schism. What follows for how a Christian should treat the confidence of holy people on contested questions today?
  • The lecture argues the fatal loss was that the church's central claim became uncheckable. What claims does your own tradition make that could not be checked if they were false?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.