무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

CH102E Medieval Church History

Lecture 4-2: The Church That Nearly Got a Constitution

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

21분

In 1415 the Council of Constance passed a decree stating that a general council of the church holds its authority immediately from Christ, and that everyone, of every rank, including the pope, is bound to obey it in matters concerning the faith, the ending of the schism, and the reform of the church in head and members.

Then it did what it said it could do. It removed three claimants to the papacy and installed a fourth, and Europe accepted the result. The schism of lecture 4-1, which nothing had been able to touch for thirty-nine years, was over.

Within thirty years the movement that achieved this had destroyed itself, and within fifty a pope had forbidden anyone even to appeal from a pope to a council. This lecture is about that rise and that collapse, and about what it cost the church to lose the argument.

Because here is the claim this lecture makes. The fifteenth-century church came close to becoming a constitutional institution — one in which the highest office is accountable to a representative assembly — and chose not to. Everything in chapter 5, and much of the sixteenth century, follows from that choice.

이 21분으로 얻는 것

  • Explain the circumstances that made conciliarism plausible, and identify its roots in canon law rather than in rebellion.
  • Describe the conciliar ecclesiology of Jean Gerson and Pierre d'Ailly.
  • State what *Haec Sancta* and *Frequens* decreed, and why each mattered.
  • Explain how the Council of Basel discredited the movement, and what the papal recovery meant for the possibility of reform.

The apostles and the elders were gathered together to see about this matter." — Acts 15:6

World English Bible

The Council of Jerusalem was the conciliarists' favourite text, and they read it plainly: when the early church faced a question it could not settle, the apostles and elders met, argued, and decided together. Their opponents read the same chapter and pointed out that James gave the ruling.

1. Not a rebellion — a lawyers' argument

An easy assumption

The first thing to correct is the assumption that conciliarism was an anti-papal insurgency invented by people who disliked the papacy.

It grew out of law, the church's own legal tradition, and it grew out of a technical problem the canonists had been chewing on for two centuries: what do you do about a heretical pope?

Everyone agreed a pope who fell into heresy could not remain pope. But who judges him? The canon lawyers' answer, developed long before the schism, was that in such a case the church as a body — represented in a general council — must act, because otherwise a heretical pope could never be removed at all and the church would be destroyed by its own constitution.

That was a narrow emergency provision. What the schism did was turn an emergency provision into a general theory, because the emergency had arrived and would not leave.

There were also sharper thinkers in the background. Marsilius of Padua, in the Defensor Pacis (1324), had argued that authority in the church belongs to the whole body of the faithful and that the clergy have no coercive jurisdiction at all — a radical position that most conciliarists were careful to distance themselves from. William of Ockham, writing during his long quarrel with the Avignon papacy, argued that neither pope nor council is infallible and that the faith might survive in a handful of believers.

The mainstream conciliarists were far more moderate than either. That moderation is what made them effective, and, in the end, it is also what made them losable.

2. Gerson and d'Ailly: the church is a body, and a body may act

The theory that mattered was worked out at the University of Paris, above all by Pierre d'Ailly and his pupil Jean Gerson, who was chancellor of the university and the most respected churchman in Europe in his generation.

Their argument runs roughly like this.

The church is a body, and Christ gave authority to the body. The pope holds real primacy, and it is genuinely from Christ — Gerson is not denying papal primacy. But it is given to him for the church, not over it and not for himself. Authority in the church is ministerial: it exists to serve the body's purpose, which is the salvation of its members.

Therefore power that destroys the church cannot be the power Christ gave. If a pope's exercise of his office is wrecking the church, the exercise is by that fact outside the commission. The body may act to preserve itself.

And the body acts through a general council, which represents the whole church and can therefore speak for it when the head cannot or will not.

Notice what kind of argument this is. It is constitutional reasoning — about where authority ultimately resides, how it is delegated, and what happens when the delegate fails — and it is being done inside the church three centuries before most of Europe applied the same reasoning to kings. Gerson and d'Ailly were not democrats and would have been baffled by the term. But the shape of the argument is the shape that later underwrites limited government, and historians of political thought have traced the connection for a long time.

Where conciliarism came from

This is a point where readers will not agree. Brian Tierney showed that conciliarism grew out of canon law rather than out of rebellion, and Francis Oakley has argued that it is a genuine constitutional tradition in Christian ecclesiology, forgotten rather than refuted - noting that Anglican, Presbyterian and Reformed polities all recognisably descend from this family of arguments. Others hold that it was an emergency doctrine which broke the moment it was asked to function as ordinary government — and point at Basel. Both readings have to account for the same events; you can decide which weight to give.

3. Constance: the thing actually worked

The Council of Constance (1414–1418) succeeded where Pisa had failed, and lecture 4-1 explained the mechanism: it had the backing of the emperor Sigismund, and it was formally convened by one of the three claimants, John XXIII of the Pisan line, which gave it a legitimacy Pisa never had.

In 1415 it issued Haec Sancta:

This holy synod of Constance… declares that, being lawfully assembled in the Holy Spirit, constituting a general council and representing the Catholic Church militant, it holds power immediately from Christ; and that everyone of whatever state or dignity, even papal, is bound to obey it in those matters which pertain to the faith, the ending of this schism, and the general reform of the church of God in head and members.

Then it acted. John XXIII fled and was deposed. Gregory XII of the Roman line abdicated — but first, and this was a shrewd concession, he was permitted to convene the council himself, so that the Roman line could regard the assembly as legitimate. Benedict XIII of the Avignon line refused to go and was abandoned by everyone until he was, in the phrase of the time, a pope with a congregation of one. In 1417 the council elected Martin V, and the schism was over.

In the same year it passed Frequens, requiring general councils to be held at fixed intervals — the next in five years, the one after in seven, and thereafter every ten. That is a constitutional provision: it turns the council from an emergency instrument into a standing organ of government, meeting on a schedule regardless of whether the pope wants it.

For a moment, the Western church had a working constitution.

And in the same council, in the same years, Jan Hus was burned. Lecture 5-2 tells that story. Hold the two facts together now, because they belong together: the assembly that gave the church its most representative moment also killed a man who had come to it under a safe conduct. Constance was not a liberal parliament. It was a council of bishops solving a jurisdictional crisis, and it dealt with heresy the way councils of bishops did.

4. Basel: how the movement lost

The Council of Basel opened in 1431 under Frequens, and it began well — it was where the church came closest to reaching a settlement with the Hussites, which no one had managed by force.

Then it overreached, and the overreach is instructive.

Pope Eugene IV tried to dissolve it; the council refused and asserted its supremacy. The quarrel escalated into a straightforward contest of wills. Basel began behaving less like a constitutional assembly and more like a rival government: it legislated against papal revenues, which pleased princes and alarmed everyone who depended on the papal administration; its voting arrangements gave enormous weight to a crowd of lower clergy and academics, so that its decisions were increasingly made by men with no responsibility for anything; and it steadily lost its bishops.

In 1439 it deposed Eugene IV and elected an antipope, Felix V.

Look at what that means. The movement whose entire was ending a schism had created one. Basel had done to the church exactly what it existed to prevent, and it had done so not to save the church from a heretic but to win an argument about jurisdiction.

Meanwhile Eugene IV had convened a rival council at Ferrara, moved to Florence, and there achieved something Basel could not touch: a formal union with the Greek church (lecture 1-4 described how that union collapsed, but at the time it looked like the greatest ecumenical achievement in four centuries). The pope was reuniting Christendom while the council was dividing it. Princes drifted back to Eugene. Basel dwindled and Felix V resigned in 1449.

The papacy pressed its advantage. In 1460 Pius II — who as a young man had been a conciliarist at Basel and had written in its defence — issued the bull Execrabilis, condemning as "execrable" the practice of appealing from a pope to a future council, and forbidding it.

That closes the door. After 1460 there is no constitutional route by which the church can call its own head to account.

5. What the failure cost

Follow the consequence, because it is the reason this lecture matters more than its subject matter suggests.

Between 1378 and 1449 the Western church faced the most serious institutional crisis in its history, and it tried to solve it from within, by legal and representative means. That attempt succeeded once, in ending the schism, and then failed as a system.

And it failed on the second half of Haec Sancta. The council had claimed authority over three things: the faith, the schism, and the reform of the church in head and members. It delivered on the schism. It never delivered on reform. Constance discussed reform, referred most of it to the new pope, and dispersed; Basel's reform decrees became weapons in a jurisdictional war and died with it.

So the fifteenth century established two things by demonstration:

  • The church's abuses were widely acknowledged, in public, by its own leadership. Nobody at Constance or Basel was arguing that the sale of offices was fine.
  • The church had no mechanism capable of correcting them against the will of the papal court.

Put those together and you have the precondition for the Reformation. When reform through the constitution has been tried for seventy years and has failed, the next people who want reform will not try the constitution. They will appeal over its head — to Scripture, to a prince, to the conscience of ordinary Christians. That is exactly what chapter 5's figures do, and what Luther does a century later.

Luther, in fact, appealed to a general council in 1518, and was told that appealing to a council was itself forbidden — Execrabilis, doing its work.

6. What actually happened here

The conciliar movement is the great missed chance of medieval church history, and the honest verdict has to hold two things at once.

It was right about the problem. An institution whose head cannot be held accountable by anything except his own conscience will, sooner or later, produce a head who has no conscience about it — and the fourteenth century had produced several.

And it was not adequate as a solution. At Basel it showed that an assembly can be as self-interested as a monarch, that a representative body without a settled constitution becomes a mob with procedure, and that a council which cannot govern itself cannot govern a church.

An institution can lose its authority faster than it built it, and no one inside notices in time. The corollary this lecture adds is harder: and the mechanism it builds to recover that authority may itself be lost while everyone is busy winning.


Conciliarism — the Constitution That Was Not Kept Not a rebellion: an emergency provision of canon law, turned into a theory The argument — Gerson and d'Ailly, Paris Authority is given to the pope for the church, not over it — so power that destroys the church is outside the commission 1415 · HAEC SANCTA — the council holds power immediately from Christ; all, "even papal", must obey What Constance delivered Three claimants removed, one pope elected. The schism ends, 1417. What it did not deliver "Reform in head and members" — referred to the new pope, and dropped 1417 · FREQUENS — councils on a fixed schedule: the emergency instrument becomes an organ of government 1431–49 · Basel destroys the case Bishops drift away · votes fall to men with no responsibility · it deposes Eugene IV and elects an antipope The movement that existed to end a schism had created one 1460 · EXECRABILIS — appealing from a pope to a council is forbidden. The door closes. The precondition for the Reformation, established by demonstration The abuses were publicly admitted · and no mechanism existed that could correct them against the papal court's will

Diagram 1. Summary table

Constance (1414–18) Basel (1431–49)
Why it had authority Backed by the emperor; convened by a reigning claimant Convened under Frequens, then in open war with the pope
What it achieved Ended the schism; elected Martin V; passed Frequens Nearly settled with the Hussites — then nothing
Where it failed Reform "in head and members" was referred away and lost Deposed Eugene IV and elected an antipope Felix V
Its shadow Burned Jan Hus, who came under safe conduct Discredited conciliarism itself
Result A constitutional moment Execrabilis, 1460: no appeal from pope to council

5. Going to the Sources

  • The decree Haec Sancta (1415) — one paragraph, and one of the most consequential paragraphs in Western church history. Read the list of three things the council claims authority over, then ask which of them it actually delivered.
  • The decree Frequens (1417) — shorter still, and the constitutional one.
  • Jean Gerson, On Ecclesiastical Power — the moderate case, argued by the man best placed to make it.
  • Pius II, Execrabilis (1460), read alongside Pius's own conciliarist writings from his Basel years — a document and its author's earlier self, worth reading in that order.

핵심 요약

  • Conciliarism grew out of canon law, from the question of how to judge a heretical pope. The schism turned that emergency rule into a general theory.
  • Gerson and d'Ailly argued that Christ gave authority to the church as a body. Papal primacy is real but given for the church, so a council may act when the head fails.
  • Constance, backed by Emperor Sigismund, issued Haec Sancta in 1415, removed the rival claimants and elected Martin V in 1417. Frequens required councils at fixed intervals.
  • Constance never delivered the reform it also claimed authority over. It also burned Jan Hus, who had come under a safe conduct.
  • Basel overreached, deposed Eugene IV and elected an antipope, creating the kind of schism it existed to end. Execrabilis in 1460 forbade appeals from a pope to a council.
  • Abuses were publicly admitted, yet no mechanism could correct them against the papal court. Later reformers therefore appealed over its head, to Scripture, princes and conscience.

Topic: The rise and collapse of the conciliar movement, which tried to make the church accountable through representative councils.

Remember: The church came close to a constitutional government in which its head answered to an assembly, then lost it, and the Reformation grew from that loss.

Caution: Historians disagree. Tierney and Oakley see a genuine tradition, forgotten rather than refuted, while others call it an emergency doctrine that broke at Basel. Do not call Constance a liberal parliament.

One line to carry into ministry: Reform that depends on one assembly or one office can fail; an institution needs ways to correct itself that outlast the crisis that created them.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Conciliarism began as a narrow provision for the case of a heretical pope. Explain how an emergency exception becomes a general theory, and what usually happens to it afterwards.
  • Basel showed that an assembly can be as self-interested as a monarch. Where does your own tradition's church government sit on that question, and what protects it?
  • *Haec Sancta* claimed authority over the faith, the schism and reform. It delivered on one. Why is delivering on the crisis but not the reform such a common institutional pattern?
  • After 1460 there was no constitutional route to correcting the papacy. If you had been a reformer in 1470 and knew that, what would you have done?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.