Lecture 7-2: Spirit Baptism and Tongues: An Experience Becomes a Doctrine
목차 33
- Lecture 1-1: Building the System: Lutheran and Reformed Orthodoxy
- Lecture 1-2: Arminius, Dort, and the Doctrine of Grace
- Lecture 1-3: The Puritans: Holiness, Conscience, and the Crown
- Lecture 1-4: The Westminster Assembly and its Catechisms
- Lecture 2-1: The War That Discredited Holy War
- Lecture 2-2: Westphalia — A Peace Nobody Loved
- Lecture 2-3: Denominations — A Word for People You Cannot Destroy
- Lecture 2-4: An Errand into the Wilderness
- Lecture 3-1: The Revolt Against Cold Orthodoxy: Spener and Francke
- Lecture 3-2: Zinzendorf, Herrnhut and the Moravian Missions
- Lecture 3-3: John Wesley and the Methodists: Grace and Holiness
- Lecture 3-4: The First Great Awakening in North America
- Lecture 4-1: The Age of Reason and the Scientific Revolution
- Lecture 4-2: Deism and the Search for a God Nobody Has to Fight About
- Lecture 4-3: Biblical Criticism and the Quest for the Historical Jesus
- Lecture 4-4: Schleiermacher and the Liberal Century
- Lecture 5-1: William Carey and the Invention of the Missionary Society
- Lecture 5-2: Hudson Taylor, the China Inland Mission and the Cost of Going Inland
- Lecture 5-3: David Livingstone — Explorer, Abolitionist, Failed Pastor
- Lecture 5-4: Missions and Empire — The Argument That Will Not Settle
- Lecture 6-1: 1914 — The Year the Future Stopped Working
- Lecture 6-2: Barth's Romans and the Theology of the Word
- Lecture 6-3: The German Christians, the Confessing Church, and Barmen
- Lecture 6-4: Bonhoeffer — Costly Grace and Guilty Hands
- Lecture 7-1: Azusa Street, 1906
- Lecture 7-2: Spirit Baptism and Tongues: An Experience Becomes a Doctrine
- Lecture 7-3: The Second Wave: Renewal Inside the Old Churches
- Lecture 7-4: Why the South Grew
A movement can live on an experience for about one generation. After that it has to answer questions that experience alone cannot answer: what exactly happened to you, how would we know if it happened to someone else, who may preach, what do we teach the children, and who signs the deeds to the building.
Between roughly 1906 and 1920 Pentecostalism answered those questions, and in answering them it became something more definite and more limited than the thing at Azusa Street. This lecture follows that hardening. It has three parts: how the movement understood itself (as a restoration of the church in Acts rather than a new denomination); how it turned tongues into a doctrinal test; and how it organised, argued and split.
The lecture then stops and lays out a dispute that is still live. Whether tongues is the initial evidence of Spirit baptism is not a settled question, and the readers of this course sit on several sides of it. Section 3.4 gives four positions in the strongest form each can give itself. You are not being asked to choose one. You are being asked to be able to state all four so accurately that someone who holds one would say: yes, that is what I think.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Explain what early Pentecostals meant by restorationism, and how it shaped their claim to be recovering the church of Acts rather than founding something new.
- Describe how the doctrine of tongues as initial evidence was formulated, the texts it rests on, and what work it was doing for a movement that needed a boundary.
- Explain how the understanding of tongues shifted from missionary languages to a gift of prayer, and why that revision was forced.
- State the cessationist case and the Pentecostal reply, and describe how the movement organised into denominations — including the divisions of 1910 and 1916.
They were all filled with the Holy Spirit, and began to speak with other languages, as the Spirit gave them the ability to speak." — Acts 2:4
World English Bible
Every position in this lecture accepts this verse. The disagreement is entirely about what kind of sentence it is: a description of one founding morning, or a pattern the church should expect to repeat. Notice before you go further that the verse itself does not say which.
1. "We are not new": restorationism and its consequences
Early Pentecostals did not think of themselves as founding a denomination. They thought they were witnessing the return of something the church had mislaid.
The self-understanding was restorationist. On this reading, the church of Acts had apostles, prophets, healings, tongues and a congregation in which anyone might be used; somewhere after the apostolic age the institution accumulated power, learning and property and the gifts fell silent; and now, in the last days before the return of Christ, God was restoring what had lapsed. The point is not that they claimed novelty. They claimed the opposite. You are the innovation, they told the mainline churches; we are the old thing.
This had three consequences worth naming.
It made history optional. If eighteen centuries were a decline, there is little reason to study them closely. Early Pentecostal literature is thin on the , thin on the Reformation, and reads Acts as if it were written last week. That is a real intellectual cost, and Pentecostal scholars have spent the last fifty years correcting it from inside.
It made the movement radically lay. If the gifts are distributed as the Spirit chooses, then a labourer with the gift outranks a graduate without one. Lecture 7-4 shows what that did to church growth in places with no seminaries.
It set the clock running. The outpouring was read as a sign of the last days — the "latter rain" before the harvest — which produced enormous missionary urgency. It also produced a hundred years of adjusting expectations, and the movement's most sober historians now treat the eschatological pitch of 1906 as something the movement has had to learn to live without.
2. The doctrine takes shape: tongues as initial evidence
, defined
The distinctive Pentecostal doctrine can be stated in one sentence: the baptism in the Holy Spirit is an experience distinct from and normally subsequent to conversion, and the first outward sign that it has occurred is speaking in tongues.
Its scriptural case is drawn almost entirely from Acts, and it is a real case. At Pentecost the group speaks in tongues (Acts 2). When Cornelius and his household receive the Spirit, Peter's Jewish companions know it because they hear them speaking in tongues (Acts 10:44–46) — and that hearing is what settles the argument about admitting Gentiles. At Ephesus, Paul lays hands on about twelve men and they speak in tongues and prophesy (Acts 19:6). Two further episodes — Samaria in Acts 8, where Simon sees something that makes him offer money, and Saul in Acts 9, who later says he speaks in tongues more than anyone — are read as consistent with the pattern. From five episodes, a norm.
Now ask what the doctrine was for, because a doctrine is also a piece of social equipment.
It gave the seeker a finish line. Holiness Christians had spent decades praying for a second blessing with no way to tell whether it had come. Now there was an unmistakable marker.
It made the invisible visible — which was, structurally, exactly the argument Peter makes in Acts 11 when he defends the Gentile mission.
And, less comfortably, it gave a scattered movement a boundary. A body with no bishops, no seminaries and no property register needs some way of saying who is in. "Have you spoken in tongues?" did that work. It is not an accident that the doctrine was written down hardest at the exact moment the movement was incorporating: the Assemblies of God adopted its Statement of Fundamental Truths in 1916, and its article on the baptism in the Holy Spirit states that the baptism is witnessed by the initial physical sign of speaking with other tongues.
3. The revision the movement made honestly
Parham's original theory was that tongues were real foreign languages given for missionary work. It was preached from Azusa Street too, and people acted on it. Missionaries went out — to India, to China, to West Africa, to Japan — expecting to preach on arrival without study.
It did not work. Some came home. Some stayed and learned the language the slow way. The claim was tested in the most public way possible and failed.
What happened next is to the movement's credit, and it is worth teaching as a case study in how a doctrine gets repaired. Pentecostals did not abandon tongues; they re-described them, and they did it with Paul rather than Luke. In 1 Corinthians 14 tongues are chiefly addressed to God rather than to people, need interpretation to profit a congregation, and edify the speaker. In Romans 8:26 the Spirit intercedes in a way beyond words. So the primary sense of tongues shifted from xenolalia, a known human language for evangelism, to glossolalia understood as a language of prayer — a mode of address to God that runs past the speaker's own understanding. The missionary use was retained as an occasional testimony rather than the point.
The reason to dwell on this is not to praise anyone. It is that the sequence — claim, public failure, exegetical revision, retained core — is what doctrinal development actually looks like, in every tradition, when it goes reasonably well.
4. Four ways of reading the same texts
This is a point where readers will not agree, and it is not a disagreement between believers and unbelievers, or between the serious and the shallow. It is a disagreement among people who all take Scripture as their authority and have read the same passages carefully.
The classical Pentecostal position. Spirit baptism is a distinct experience after conversion, for power in witness, and tongues is its initial physical evidence. The strongest form of the case: in Acts, every time Luke narrates the reception of the Spirit in any detail, tongues appear, and in Acts 10 they function precisely as evidence — Peter's companions accept Gentile converts because they hear it. The obvious objection, Paul's question in 1 Corinthians 12:30, "Do all speak with tongues?", is met with a distinction that is not an evasion: Paul is asking about the gift of tongues exercised publicly in the assembly, which is given to some; the initial sign at Spirit baptism is a different function of the same phenomenon. Statements of faith in the Assemblies of God and many other classical Pentecostal bodies hold this position and have held it for over a century.
The continuationist position that rejects initial evidence. The gifts, tongues included, were never withdrawn and are for the church now — but making tongues the required evidence of a second experience goes beyond the texts. The strongest form of the case is exegetical and has been pressed most sharply by Pentecostal scholars themselves: Gordon Fee, an Assemblies of God minister and one of the finest New Testament scholars of his generation, argued that Acts is narrative, that narrative does not by itself establish a norm, that Luke nowhere says tongues must accompany the Spirit's coming, and that Paul — the one apostle who writes doctrine about the Spirit at length — never mentions a subsequent Spirit baptism attested by tongues at all. On this view, insisting on the sign creates two classes of Christian and burdens sincere believers who have sought and not received. Charismatics in the historic churches, and much of the Third Wave associated with John Wimber, generally sit here.
The cessationist position. The revelatory and miraculous gifts had a specific function — to authenticate the apostles and their message while the New Testament was being given — and that function ended when the apostolic foundation was laid. The strongest form of the case is not "miracles are impossible"; nobody serious argues that. It is that Scripture treats signs as attached to bearers of revelation (2 Corinthians 12:12, Hebrews 2:3–4), that the church has a completed precisely so it no longer needs new attestation, and that a standing office of fresh revelation is in practice unaccountable. B. B. Warfield made this argument in Counterfeit Miracles (1918); John MacArthur has pressed it in Charismatic Chaos (1992) and Strange Fire (2013), with heavy weight on the pastoral damage he attributes to unverifiable claims. The obvious objection — that 1 Corinthians 13's "when that which is complete has come" more naturally refers to Christ's return than to the closing of the canon — is a real difficulty, and the more careful cessationists rest their case on the apostolic-attestation argument rather than on that verse.
The Catholic Charismatic position. Everything in the New Testament about the gifts stands, and Catholics may seek and exercise them — but "baptism in the Spirit" is not a second baptism and not a second reception of the Spirit. The Spirit is given in baptism and confirmation; what happens in the renewal is that a grace already given is released and becomes conscious and operative. The strongest form of the case: it holds the movement's experience without splitting the sacramental structure of Christian initiation, and it explains why a person who has been a Christian for forty years can nonetheless describe something new happening. Cardinal Léon-Joseph Suenens set this out in the Malines Documents from 1974; lecture 7-3 tells the story.
Now the point of setting these out. Notice that all four accept the authority of Scripture, all four can name the texts that press hardest against them, and none of the four is silly. Notice too that the question is genuinely consequential — it decides who may lead, what a congregation prays for, and whether a believer without tongues is treated as lacking something. In this course you will not be asked which of the four is right. You will be asked whether you can state a position you do not hold in a form its holders would accept.
5. Organising: 1914, 1916, and the cost of definition
Definition has a price, and the movement paid it twice within six years.
The first split was about . The earliest Pentecostals inherited the Wesleyan three-stage scheme: conversion, then entire sanctification, then Spirit baptism. In 1910 William H. Durham, a Chicago pastor, began preaching "the finished work of Calvary" — that sanctification is not a second crisis but the progressive outworking of what was accomplished at the cross, leaving two stages, not three. The Wesleyan-Holiness bodies (the Church of God in Christ, the Church of God of Cleveland, the Pentecostal Holiness Church) kept three. Durham's followers kept two, and it was largely from that side that the Assemblies of God was formed at Hot Springs, Arkansas, in April 1914.
The second split was about God. In 1913, at a camp meeting at Arroyo Seco in California, a preacher noticed that the baptisms in Acts are performed "in the name of Jesus Christ" rather than in the triune formula of Matthew 28:19. From that observation grew the "New Issue": a reading in which Father, Son and Spirit are modes of the one God who is Jesus, and in which converts should be baptised in Jesus' name and re-baptised if they were not. It swept through the young Assemblies of God with alarming speed. The 1916 general council adopted the Statement of Fundamental Truths partly to stop it — the statement is explicitly Trinitarian — and roughly a quarter of the fellowship's ministers left or were removed. They formed Oneness bodies that exist today and number in the millions.
Lecture 1 of this course described the seventeenth century writing confessions to protect the gospel, at the price of the people who would not sign. Here is the same mechanism, three hundred years later, in a movement that thought of itself as the opposite of a confessional church. A body that defines itself in order to survive will lose the members who fall outside the definition. That is not a Pentecostal failing; it is what definition does.
6. What to take from this lecture
Between 1906 and 1916 a revival became a set of denominations with a written doctrinal test. It gained thereby: durability, missionary finance, schools, the capacity to outlive its founders — nearly everything that let it become the movement lecture 7-4 describes. It lost thereby: the improvised, unclassified, lay quality of the room on Azusa Street, and a good number of the people who had been in it.
Both halves are the ordinary cost of institutionalising anything. What is worth noticing is how fast it happened — ten years, from a stable to a statement of faith.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| What it holds | Where it is strongest | Where it is pressed hardest | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classical Pentecostal | Spirit baptism is subsequent to conversion; tongues is its initial physical evidence | Acts 10:44–46, where tongues actually function as evidence | 1 Corinthians 12:30 |
| Continuationist, non-evidentialist | The gifts continue; tongues is not a required sign | Narrative sets no norm; Paul's letters never teach the test | Luke's repetition of the pattern may be intentional |
| Cessationist | Sign gifts attested the apostolic foundation and have ceased | Signs are tied to bearers of revelation; the canon is closed | No text states the cessation; 1 Corinthians 13:10 resists the reading |
| Catholic Charismatic | The gifts are real; Spirit baptism is the release of baptismal grace | Preserves one initiation and one gift of the Spirit | Whether "release" names something or defers the question |
5. Going to the Sources
- The Assemblies of God, Statement of Fundamental Truths (1916, still in force with revisions). Two pages. Read the articles on the baptism in the Holy Spirit and on the initial physical evidence, and then read the Trinitarian article beside the 1916 Oneness controversy it was written against.
- B. B. Warfield, Counterfeit Miracles (1918). Public domain. Read the first lecture for the argument in its own terms — and note how much of his target is not Pentecostalism at all.
- Gordon D. Fee, Gospel and Spirit: Issues in New Testament (1991). The essays on Luke as historian and on the initial-evidence doctrine: a Pentecostal scholar dissenting from his own tradition's distinctive teaching, on exegetical grounds.
- The Oneness statement of faith of any of the major Oneness bodies, beside Acts 2:38 and Matthew 28:19. Whatever you conclude, read the argument rather than the caricature.
핵심 요약
- Early Pentecostals saw themselves as restoring the church of Acts, not founding a denomination. This made history optional, made the movement radically lay, and set an end-times clock running.
- The distinctive doctrine says Spirit baptism is distinct from and normally after conversion, with tongues as its first outward sign. It rests on Acts, gave seekers a finish line, and gave a scattered movement a boundary.
- When tongues as foreign missionary languages failed in the field, Pentecostals re-described them with Paul as a language of prayer. The lecture calls this an honest doctrinal repair.
- Four positions read the same texts differently: classical Pentecostal, continuationist without initial evidence (Gordon Fee), cessationist (Warfield, MacArthur) and Catholic Charismatic (Suenens). All accept Scripture, and the lecture asks readers to state each fairly.
- Defining the movement had a price. The finished-work dispute of 1910 and the Oneness controversy of 1916 cost it members, and about a quarter of Assemblies of God ministers left.
Topic: This lecture shows how Pentecostalism turned the Azusa experience into doctrine and denominations, and sets out four views on tongues.
Remember: Between 1906 and 1916 a revival became denominations with a written doctrinal test. It gained durability and lost some of its open, lay quality and some of its people.
Caution: The lecture does not say which of the four positions is right. It asks you to state a view you do not hold so that its holders would accept your statement.
One line to carry into ministry: Before you disagree with a view on the Spirit's gifts, state it so well that someone who holds it would say yes, that is what I think.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- The lecture claims the initial-evidence doctrine was doing social work as well as theological work — supplying a boundary to a movement that had no bishops or seminaries. Is that a criticism, an observation, or both?
- Pentecostals revised their doctrine of tongues after the missionary experiment failed. Name a claim your own tradition has quietly revised in the face of evidence, and say whether it was done as openly.
- Take the position on tongues furthest from your own and state it in three sentences its holders would accept. What did you find you had been mis-stating?
- The Assemblies of God defined itself in 1916 and lost a quarter of its ministers. When is that price worth paying, and who should decide?