Lecture 1-4: How the Great Traditions Welcome
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Stranger in the Law and the Prophets
- Lecture 1-2: Jesus: Guest, Host and Stranger
- Lecture 1-3: The Early Church Learns to Welcome
- Lecture 1-4: How the Great Traditions Welcome
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Day You Were New
- Lecture 2-1: What a Stranger Sees
- Lecture 2-2: The First Conversation
- Lecture 2-3: Families with Children, and People Who Come Alone
- Lecture 2-4: Welcome in Different Kinds of Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Walk Your Own Entrance
- Lecture 3-1: The First Forty-Eight Hours
- Lecture 3-2: What You Ask For and What You Keep
- Lecture 3-3: Connecting People to People, and to the Church's Path
- Lecture 3-4: When Someone Stops Coming
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Ninety Days with One Person
- Lecture 4-1: Language, Culture and Migration
- Lecture 4-2: People Who Come from Other Churches and Traditions
- Lecture 4-3: People Wounded by the Church, and People with Doubts
- Lecture 4-4: Disability, Age and Access
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Welcoming Someone Unlike You
- Lecture 5-1: What You Hear Is Not Yours
- Lecture 5-2: Practical Help Without Dependency
- Lecture 5-3: Recognising Crisis and Passing It On
- Lecture 5-4: Safeguarding, Abuse and Reporting
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, Your Referral Map
No congregation invents welcome for itself. Every community inherits habits, some written down and some never spoken, from the generations before it. A parish with a stone porch, a monastery gatehouse, a house church with a kettle on, an assembly that meets in a school hall: each is the tail end of a long line of people who asked, in their own way, how do we receive someone we do not know?
This lecture takes a short, fair tour of how some great streams of Christian life have answered that question. We look at the Rule of Benedict, at Eastern Christian love of the stranger, at the Catholic parish and its path for those who wish to join, at the Reformation and Anabaptist traditions, and at the Pentecostal, African and Asian traditions of the extended household. The tour is meant to widen your imagination, not to give a winner. The lecture ends with the one question on which these traditions differ most sharply in practice: who may receive communion.
A warning before we start. Each of these streams is internally varied. What follows describes broad tendencies and well-known practices, and your own community may do things differently. Treat each section as a door into a tradition, not as a final description.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Describe one characteristic practice of welcome in each of the five streams in this lecture.
- State what the traditions share in their understanding of the guest.
- Name two ways in which the traditions differ in how they welcome.
- State fairly the disagreement over who may receive communion, and what this course requires of a welcomer.
Let brotherly love continue. Don’t forget to show hospitality to strangers, for in doing so, some have entertained angels without knowing it." — Hebrews 13:1-2
World English Bible
contributing to the needs of the saints; given to hospitality." — Romans 12:13
WEB
When she and her household were baptized, she begged us, saying, “If you have judged me to be faithful to the Lord, come into my house, and stay.” So she persuaded us." — Acts 16:15
WEB
The letter to the Hebrews sets love of the brother next to love of the stranger, as if they belonged together. Lydia, a businesswoman from Thyatira, does something every tradition in this lecture has tried to copy: she opens her house to the people who brought her the gospel.
1. Benedict: the guest is Christ
Benedict of Nursia lived in Italy in the sixth century and wrote a short rule for monks. Chapter 53 is about guests. Its first line is the best known: all guests who arrive are to be received as Christ, because Christ himself said that he was a stranger and was taken in. (Benedict is drawing on Matthew 25:35, which we read in lecture 1-2.)
What makes the chapter valuable is the detail. Benedict does not stop at the principle. He describes how the welcome goes:
- The abbot, or the monks, go out to meet the guest with every show of love.
- They pray together first and only afterwards exchange the greeting of peace.
- The head is bowed, or the body lowered to the ground, so that Christ is honoured in the person who has arrived.
- Water is poured over the guests' hands, and the abbot and the community wash their feet.
- A separate kitchen is provided for the abbot and the guests, so that the many guests who arrive at all hours do not disturb the monks. (A later chapter has the abbot's own table shared with guests.)
- Special care is given to the poor and to pilgrims, because the rich, Benedict says, command respect without anyone having to try.
Notice three things. First, the welcome is physical: water, bread, a bow. Second, the welcome is organised: a separate kitchen is not romantic, but it means the community can keep receiving people for centuries without wearing out. Third, the welcome has a person at the gate. In the same spirit, a later chapter asks for a wise, older monk to keep the door and answer promptly. These are not the things a person would write if welcome were only a feeling.
Benedict's rule has shaped lay communities and parishes as well as monasteries, and many Christians who have never lived in one know the phrase "received as Christ."
2. Eastern Christian love of the stranger
The Greek New Testament has a word for hospitality: philoxenia, literally "love of the stranger." It is the word behind "hospitality" in Romans 12:13 and Hebrews 13:2. Eastern Christian writers took it seriously, and Orthodox communities, in all their cultural variety, still treat the guest as someone to whom the household owes honour.
The tradition has a famous picture. The icon often called the Holy , painted by Andrei Rublev in the early fifteenth century, is based on the visit of the three men to Abraham in Genesis 18, the scene we read in lecture 1-1. Three figures sit at a table. In front of the table there is a place with no one in it. Many viewers read that empty place as an invitation to the person looking, though this is an interpretation and not a rule.
In the , a practice shows the same instinct. In many Orthodox parishes, at the end of the Divine Liturgy, a basket of blessed bread (antidoron) is shared with everyone present, including those who have not received communion. A visitor who cannot receive communion because of the community's practice therefore still has something placed in their hands. We will return to this when we reach the table.
3. The Catholic parish and the path of the catechumen
A traditional Catholic parish is defined by place: it belongs to the people who live inside its boundaries. That gives it a particular kind of openness. In principle the parish exists for the neighbour, whether or not the neighbour comes in.
Many English-speaking parishes also name the people at the door "ministers of hospitality." The name is worth noticing. A greeter in such a parish is performing a recognised service of the community, and not simply being friendly.
The most distinctive Catholic gift to the subject of this course is the catechumenate. After the Second Vatican Council the Church restored the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults (RCIA), a path by which an adult who is not yet baptised, or a baptised person coming to the Catholic Church, is walked towards the sacraments over a period of months or longer. It has stages: a time of inquiry, a time of formal learning, a period of preparation near Easter, and a period of reflection after initiation. A sponsor from the parish accompanies the person throughout. In many parishes the catechumens are sent out after the readings and sermon, with prayer and a companion, to study, because they are not yet baptised and do not yet share in the communion that follows.
Here welcome is built as a path with a pace, and the pace is set by the person's readiness, not by the community's wish to fill a seat. We will meet this again in lecture 3-3.
4. The Reformation and Anabaptist traditions
The sixteenth-century Reformers put the open Bible and the preached word at the centre of the gathering. For welcome, this meant that a stranger who came in was meant to understand what was said, because worship was in the language of the people, and to be taught. Reformed cities also became places of refuge: Geneva, for example, received many exiles from France and England, and their churches' care for refugees is part of their history.
The Anabaptist movements, which arose in the same century, were hunted by both Catholic and Protestant authorities, and many of their members were themselves refugees. They formed communities around the gathered household and the shared table. Some, such as the Hutterites, held goods in common. Today many Anabaptist-descended communities are still known for hospitality, mutual aid and the shared meal.
The Reformation traditions also developed careful rules about the Lord's Supper, and they differ among themselves. Some Reformed and Baptist communities have practised a "fenced" table, restricted to members or to those examined. Others, among them the Methodist tradition that comes from the Wesleys, are known for an open table. We will read more about this below.
5. Pentecostal, African and Asian households
Pentecostal worship is often unscripted: spontaneous testimony, extended prayer, the laying on of hands, open invitation to come forward. A newcomer in such a service may be called forward for prayer within the first hour. That can feel warm, and it can feel like a spotlight. Many Pentecostal congregations have grown among migrants and people on low incomes, and many have built networks of mutual help for those who arrive with little.
In many African societies, receiving a guest is a public duty. The guest is given the best of what the house has. Many African and diaspora churches use the language of the family, and for some members the church is, in practice, the kin they have left behind. In many Asian churches a shared meal after worship is a central part of the gathering, not an extra. Across these settings the extended household is the model: the stranger is received as a relative-in-waiting.
This tradition has a strength and a risk, and the people who live in it often name both. The strength is that a newcomer can be absorbed into a web of care very quickly. The risk is that the web can close, so that someone who does not yet belong to a family stays outside, and that being taken into a household can carry obligations the newcomer did not expect.
6. What they share, and where they differ
Put side by side, the five streams share a good deal.
- The guest is received as more than a guest. Benedict says Christ; the Eastern tradition says God's gift; the catechumenate says a person on a journey to God.
- Welcome is bodily. Water, bread, a bow, a seat, a meal, a hand.
- There is a named person or place. A porter at the gate, a minister of hospitality, a host family, an usher.
- There is a table. Each tradition finds its deepest welcome at a meal.
They also differ, and the differences are not defects.
- The pace. The catechumenate takes months; a Pentecostal altar call may take minutes. An extended household can take someone in on the first day.
- Who is host. In some, the community or its clergy; in others, the household of a member.
- How formal the welcome is. A written rite or an open conversation.
- What the guest may do at the table. Which brings us to the hardest question.
(an invented example) Mei and her husband, visiting a relative in a city, went to a Catholic parish for a funeral. They are Christians from a free church, and they did not know what to do when the line moved forward for communion. At the door, an usher had said quietly, "If you are not receiving, you are welcome to come forward with your arms crossed and the priest will give you a blessing, or you are welcome to stay in your seat." They stayed in their seats. No one looked. They told the relative afterwards it was the part they remembered best. Nothing about their belonging was claimed or denied. A sentence had been said in advance.
7. The table
"But let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of the bread, and drink of the cup." — 1 Corinthians 11:28 (WEB)
"For he who eats and drinks in an unworthy way eats and drinks judgment to himself, if he doesn’t discern the Lord’s body." — 1 Corinthians 11:29 (WEB)
This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is who may receive the bread and wine of the Eucharist or Lord's Supper, and it divides Christians who agree on almost everything else about hospitality.
The Catholic and Orthodox position, in its strongest form, is that receiving communion is the visible sign of a unity that already exists: the same baptism, the same faith, and communion with the same bishop and community. To offer communion to someone outside that unity would be to make a sign that says something untrue. It would also, on their reading of 1 Corinthians 11, place a burden on a person who has not been prepared. On this view, to guard the table is not to be unwelcoming; it is to take both the table and the guest seriously. Catholic practice allows limited exceptions in particular cases of need, decided by the priest. Orthodox churches likewise generally reserve communion to their own communicants.
The open-table position, in its strongest form, is that the table is Christ's, not ours, and that he ate with people of all kinds. Many Protestant communities invite all baptised believers, or all who come in faith, because they hold that the Supper is a and that a table which turns away a sincere believer contradicts the gospel it proclaims. The Wesleyan tradition, for example, has been known for this. The invitation is often phrased as an act of Christ, so that the welcome is his and not the congregation's.
A third position, held by some Baptist and Reformed communities, fences the table, reserving it for members of the local congregation or for those whose baptism and standing are known to the elders. Their reasoning is that the Supper is also an act of discipline and of communal accountability, and that to "discern the Lord’s body" (1 Corinthians 11:29) includes the community itself.
Each of these positions appeals to Scripture, to history and to a deep concern for the guest. None of them is a failure of hospitality in the eyes of the people who hold it.
What this course requires is less than any one of these traditions requires, and it applies to all of them:
- Know how it works in your community. Learn the practice and the reasons from your priest or pastor.
- Tell the newcomer before the moment, gently and plainly, in a bulletin, a sentence at the door, or a note in the order of service. The worst place to learn the rule is in the aisle.
- Never shame anyone at the table. Do not stop a person in a line. Do not make a public correction. If something goes wrong, speak quietly afterwards, or tell the leader.
- Offer what your community does offer: a blessing, a seat, blessed bread, a word, a drink after the service.
- Leave questions about exceptions to the priest or pastor. A volunteer is not the person to decide a sacramental question.
Here are three examples of wording a welcomer might use or adapt.
- In our parish, communion is for Catholics who are prepared. You are welcome to stay and pray with us, and the priest will give a blessing to anyone who comes forward with arms crossed.
- In our church, we invite everyone who is baptised and who trusts in Christ to receive the bread and cup. If you would rather not, you are welcome simply to pass the plate.
- Our table is kept for members of our congregation. After the service, there is coffee, and we would be glad to sit with you.
Notice that none of them is apologetic and none is cold. Each states the practice in the community's own words, once, in advance, kindly.
Diagram 1. The great streams of welcome
Diagram 2. Communion practice, in broad outline
| Community type (broadly) | Typical practice about communion | Welcome that is still possible |
|---|---|---|
| Catholic | For Catholics who are prepared; limited exceptions decided by the priest | Blessing with arms crossed; a seat; a word afterwards |
| Orthodox | For members of the Orthodox Church who are prepared | Blessed bread (antidoron) in many parishes; a seat; a meal |
| Open-table Protestant | All baptised believers, or all who come in faith | A clear invitation; the choice to pass |
| Members-only ("fenced") | Members of the congregation, or those known to the elders | A word in advance; coffee afterwards; a place to sit |
Practice varies within each of these, between countries, and from one community to the next. Always ask your own priest or pastor how it works where you serve.
핵심 요약
- Every community inherits habits of welcome. Five streams in this lecture are Benedict, Eastern Christian, Catholic, Reformation and Anabaptist, and Pentecostal, African and Asian household traditions.
- Benedict's Rule received guests as Christ with a bow, prayer, water and a person at the gate. It also gave them a separate kitchen.
- The Catholic catechumenate is welcome built as a path, with a sponsor and a pace set by readiness.
- The extended household can take a newcomer in on the first day; its risk is that the circle can close.
- Traditions share the guest, the bodily sign, a named person and a table, and differ in pace, host and formality.
- On communion, tell the newcomer before the moment, never shame anyone at the table, and leave exceptions to the priest or pastor.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Rule of Benedict, chapter 53 | Guests received as Christ: prayer, a bow, washed hands, a person at the gate, a separate guest kitchen. |
| Philoxenia | Greek for "love of the stranger," the word behind "hospitality" in Romans 12:13 and Hebrews 13:2. |
| The catechumenate | A path of welcome with stages, a sponsor and a pace set by the person's readiness. |
| The course requirement on communion | Know how it works, tell the newcomer in advance, never shame anyone, and leave exceptions to the priest or pastor. |
One sentence to remember The great traditions agree that the guest is more than a guest and that welcome is bodily, and they differ most at the table, where our duty is to tell the truth kindly and in advance.
This week's action Write, in three plain sentences, what your community does about communion for someone who is new, and ask a leader whether it is right.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the five streams is closest to your own community, and which is furthest? What could your community learn from the furthest one?
- Benedict gives his guests a separate kitchen. What would be the equivalent in your community: something that makes it possible to keep receiving people without wearing out?
- The extended household welcomes quickly and may also close around its own. How might a community keep the first and avoid the second?
- In your own words, state the best argument for a guarded table and the best argument for an open one. Can you do it without a smile that gives your side away?
- If you were writing the three-sentence version for your community's newcomers, what would it say about communion?