Lecture 1-2: Kinds and Stages of Conflict
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Conflict Is Not Strange in the Church
- Lecture 1-2: Kinds and Stages of Conflict
- Lecture 1-3: Reading Your Own Reactions
- Lecture 1-4: Fault Lines: A Quick Look at Where Conflicts Start
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Conflict Map
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Matthew 18 in Its Context
- Lecture 2-2: Blessed Are the Peacemakers
- Lecture 2-3: Forgiveness, Apology, Restoration, Reconciliation
- Lecture 2-4: Before You Quote a Verse
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Checking the Verse
- Lecture 3-1: Hearing Both Sides
- Lecture 3-2: What a Lay Peacemaker Does and Does Not Do
- Lecture 3-3: Opening a Hard Conversation
- Lecture 3-4: Words That Calm and Words That Inflame
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Two Sides of One Story
- Lecture 4-1: Giving and Receiving an Apology
- Lecture 4-2: Talking About Forgiveness
- Lecture 4-3: After the Conflict: Trust and Community
- Lecture 4-4: Why Some Things Take Years
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting an Apology
- Lecture 5-1: Gossip and Rumour
- Lecture 5-2: Taking Sides and Triangles
- Lecture 5-3: Leading a Conflict Conversation in a Small Group
- Lecture 5-4: Online Groups and Messages
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Handling a Moment in the Meeting
When two people quarrel, it is tempting to ask only one question: who is right? A peacemaker needs two other questions first. What kind of conflict is this? and How far has it gone? The answers decide what a person beside can usefully do. A disagreement about a meeting time needs a different kind of help from a hurt that has been carried for years. A quarrel that began yesterday needs a different step from one where two groups no longer speak.
This lecture gives you two simple tools. The first is a list of five kinds of conflict. The second is a list of five stages. Neither is a law of nature. Real conflicts do not follow neat lines, and a single quarrel often has more than one kind in it. But a map, even a rough one, is better than walking in a fog. We follow one invented case through all five stages, and we end with signs that what you are looking at may not be a conflict at all, but harm.
이 20분으로 얻는 것
- Name five kinds of conflict and give a plain example of each.
- Describe five stages through which a conflict may move.
- Say, for each stage, one thing a person beside can do and one thing to avoid.
- Notice signs that a situation may be harm and not conflict, and say what to do next.
The beginning of strife is like breaching a dam, therefore stop contention before quarreling breaks out." — Proverbs 17:14
World English Bible
Be angry, and don’t sin.” Don’t let the sun go down on your wrath," — Ephesians 4:26
WEB
He who pleads his cause first seems right; until another comes and questions him." — Proverbs 18:17
WEB
Now I mean this, that each one of you says, “I follow Paul,” “I follow Apollos,” “I follow Cephas,” and, “I follow Christ.”" — 1 Corinthians 1:12
WEB
1. Five kinds of conflict
Most conflicts in a church or small group fall into one or more of five kinds. The names are plain on purpose.
1. Conflict about facts. People disagree about what happened or what is true. "Did the treasurer send the report?" "Was the meeting on Tuesday or Wednesday?" Facts can usually be checked. A conflict about facts is the easiest kind to settle, provided nobody has already decided the other person is lying.
2. Conflict about interests. People want different things, and there is not enough for everyone: a time, a room, money, a task, a place in a rota. Two people may each be reasonable and still want the same Saturday morning. A conflict about interests is often settled by finding a way for both to get part of what they need.
3. Conflict about values. People hold different convictions about faith or worship: what kind of music, how long a prayer should be, how a service should be ordered, what counts as faithful living. These are not "just preferences". For the person who holds them, they may feel like loyalty to God. A conflict about values cannot be settled by giving each side half. The first step is often to understand what each person is guarding.
4. Conflict about relationship. Someone has been hurt, ignored, misunderstood or disrespected, and the original subject hardly matters now. "He never greets me." "She talked about me behind my back." Often the surface subject (a rota, a song) is a carrier for a hurt underneath. A conflict about relationship is not settled by arguing about the surface.
5. Conflict about identity. People feel that their place in the group, their belonging or their dignity is at stake. A newcomer who feels unwelcome. An older member who feels pushed aside. A young person who feels no one takes them seriously. When identity is touched, people defend themselves strongly, even over small things, because it feels as if they are being rejected and not only their idea.
A word of care. One conflict usually has several kinds in it. A dispute about the meeting time (interests) may carry a hurt (relationship) and a feeling of being unwelcome (identity). When you try to name the kind, do not pick one and stop. Ask: "What else might be inside this?" Naming the kind is a way of listening, not a way of labelling people.
2. Five stages of conflict
Conflicts often move through stages. Not every conflict passes through all of them, and they do not always come in order. But the pattern is common enough to be useful.
Stage 1: Disagreement. People see something differently and say so. Feelings are present but under control. People still listen to each other.
Stage 2: Feelings run high. The subject begins to matter more than it should. People feel tense, angry or hurt. They begin to talk about the disagreement a great deal, in private. They are less willing to listen. Small remarks are read as attacks.
Stage 3: Sides form. People begin to line up. Each person tells their account to friends, and friends begin to agree. The group starts to say "we" and "they". Messages go around. We think of the divisions in Corinth, where believers said, "I follow Paul", "I follow Apollos" (1 Corinthians 1:12).
Stage 4: Attacks on the person. The quarrel is no longer about the subject. People speak about the character of the other: "He is proud", "She is always like this", "They don’t care about anyone". Past events are collected as proof. Motives are guessed and then treated as facts.
Stage 5: Split. The relationship breaks. People leave, groups divide, or people stay but no longer speak. It may be quiet, or it may be loud.
The writer of Proverbs says, "The beginning of strife is like breaching a dam, therefore stop contention before quarreling breaks out" (Proverbs 17:14). A small hole in a dam can be mended with little effort. After the water is moving, it is hard to stop. Early help is worth more than late help. But do not use the verse as a rule that every person must run to stop every quarrel at once. Some disagreements are healthy, and some quarrels are not yours.
3. What a person beside can do at each stage
| Stage | What a person beside can do | What to avoid |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Disagreement | Listen to each person. Help them state what they want and why. Check the facts together. | Treating a normal disagreement as a crisis |
| 2. Feelings run high | Slow things down. Offer a calm place to talk. Invite people to speak one at a time. | Giving advice before you have heard; adding your own heat |
| 3. Sides form | Listen to everyone and take no side. Do not repeat what each side says about the other. Remind people there are two accounts. | Becoming part of a side; carrying stories |
| 4. Attacks on the person | Do not let attacks pass without comment, and do not answer with an attack. Suggest a break. Offer to talk with each person separately. Consider asking a pastor or experienced leader to help. | Agreeing with a judgement of someone’s character; debating who started it |
| 5. Split | Care for those who are hurt. Help people part with as little further damage as possible. Keep what was learned. | Forcing a meeting for the sake of appearances; blaming those who leave |
The same rule applies at every stage: listen to each person and take no side in the dispute. We think again of Proverbs 18:17: "He who pleads his cause first seems right; until another comes and questions him." The person who speaks to you first has shaped what you know. Wait to hear the other.
Notice also what Ephesians 4:26 allows. "Be angry, and don’t sin." The verse does not say anger is forbidden. It says what to do with it: do not let it settle and turn into something else. For a peacemaker, this is a good reason not to be alarmed when someone is angry. Anger is a sign that something matters. What matters is whether it is being carried into harm.
4. An invented case, followed through the stages
(an invented example) A mid-week prayer group meets in a church hall. Lucia, who has attended for twenty years, likes quiet songs and long silence. Samuel, who joined two years ago and is in his twenties, plays the guitar and likes lively songs. They have different ideas about how the group should start.
Stage 1. At one meeting Samuel says, "Could we start with something faster? It helps me wake up and pray." Lucia says, "I find that hard. I come after a long day and need quiet." Both speak calmly. The leader, Daniel, says they will try both. A person beside here might do what Daniel does: hear both, and offer a try-out. The conflict is partly about interests (the first ten minutes) and partly about values (how one comes to God).
Stage 2. The try-out does not go well. Lucia feels that the lively songs have won. Samuel feels the quiet part is too long. They begin to talk to others in the group before and after the meeting. At the following meeting both are curt.
Stage 3. Younger members start meeting Samuel in the car park to say they agree with him. Older members sit with Lucia and say the group is "losing its soul". Someone sends a message to the group chat with a long complaint. Both sides now say "they".
Stage 4. Someone says, "Samuel only wants to show off." Someone else says, "Lucia is stuck in the past and wants to control everything." These sentences are about people, not songs. Nobody mentions the first ten minutes any more.
Stage 5. The younger members begin their own meeting on another evening. The old group shrinks. Lucia stops speaking to Samuel. A subject that began as a question of how to open a meeting has divided a group.
What could have been done? At stage 1, the leader did well. At stage 2, a friend could have invited Lucia and Samuel separately to talk, listened to what each was guarding (quiet and rest; energy and welcome), and asked each, "What would help you most?" At stage 3, a member could have refused to join a side and said, "I'd like to hear from both of them." At stage 4, someone could have said, "We are speaking about each other now, not about the meeting. Let us pause." At stage 5, a person beside could have helped both groups part without shame, and have remained a friend to both. None of this is a magic cure. It only shows where a person standing beside has choices.
5. When it is not a conflict: signs of harm
Everything above assumes that two people stand on roughly equal ground. Sometimes they do not. This is why this lecture ends with signs that what you are looking at may be harm and not conflict. These signs do not prove anything, and you must not try to investigate. They are reasons to slow down, to stop trying to "bring both sides together", and to take the matter to someone responsible.
- A person is afraid of another person, or afraid to be in the same room.
- One person has more power, by office, age, money or spiritual authority, and uses it to silence or control the other.
- There are threats, intimidation, or physical harm.
- There is unwanted sexual contact or sexual talk, or a child or young person is involved in a way that troubles you.
- A person is told to stay quiet "for the sake of the church", to forgive at once, or that their report will "destroy" someone.
- The same person is named again and again by different people.
- A person says they have been hurt and then retreats, saying, "It doesn’t matter. Forget I said anything."
If any of these is present, do not try to arrange a meeting between the people. Do not ask the hurt person to forgive. Do not promise secrecy that you cannot keep. Listen, and do not investigate. Ask what the person needs, and help them reach someone responsible. If the person you would normally tell is involved, or you doubt that they would act, go to another responsible person or to an outside agency. If anyone is in danger now, call your local emergency number. If a child may be at risk, check your local law and your church’s written policy about whom to tell. Week 6 explains how.
One more thing. A lay person can misread the signs in both directions. Some people are cautious or quiet and are not being harmed. Some strong-sounding people have been hurt. You are not being asked to decide. You are being asked to notice, to listen without judging, and not to carry the matter alone.
Diagram 1. Five stages, and where a person beside can stand
Diagram 2. Five kinds of conflict
| Kind | The question underneath | A plain example |
|---|---|---|
| Facts | What happened? What is true? | Was the key handed back? |
| Interests | Who gets what is limited? | Two groups want the hall on the same evening |
| Values | What are we guarding? | How long should prayer be? What music is fitting? |
| Relationship | Who hurt whom? Who was ignored? | "He never greets me." |
| Identity | Do I belong? Am I respected? | A newcomer feels like a guest after a year |
핵심 요약
- Five kinds of conflict: facts, interests, values, relationship and identity. One conflict often holds more than one.
- Five stages: disagreement, feelings run high, sides form, attacks on the person, split. They do not always come in order.
- At every stage, listen to each person and take no side in the dispute. Early help is worth more than late help.
- Signs such as fear, threats, silencing, misuse of power or a child at risk point to harm, not conflict.
- If you see those signs, do not arrange a meeting. Listen, do not investigate, and connect the person to someone responsible.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Five kinds of conflict | Facts, interests, values, relationship, identity. |
| Five stages | Disagreement; feelings run high; sides form; attacks on the person; split. |
| A person beside at every stage | Listens to each, takes no side in the dispute, does not carry stories. |
| Signs it may be harm | Fear, threats, silencing, misuse of power, a child at risk: stop arranging meetings, listen, connect to help. |
One sentence to remember Ask what kind of conflict this is and how far it has gone before you ask who is right.
This week's action Pick one recent disagreement you know of, using no names, and write one line naming its kind or kinds and its stage.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of a past disagreement in a group you know. Which of the five kinds does it have in it? Is there more than one?
- In the invented case, at which stage did the conflict stop being about the meeting? How would you have noticed?
- Why is it useful to say "take no side in the dispute" even when one person seems clearly more reasonable?
- Proverbs 17:14 compares the beginning of strife to a breach in a dam. When might it be wrong to rush in and stop a quarrel?
- Which of the signs of harm would you find hardest to act on? Why? You may pass if you would rather not say.