Lecture 5-4: Online Groups and Messages
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Conflict Is Not Strange in the Church
- Lecture 1-2: Kinds and Stages of Conflict
- Lecture 1-3: Reading Your Own Reactions
- Lecture 1-4: Fault Lines: A Quick Look at Where Conflicts Start
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Conflict Map
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Matthew 18 in Its Context
- Lecture 2-2: Blessed Are the Peacemakers
- Lecture 2-3: Forgiveness, Apology, Restoration, Reconciliation
- Lecture 2-4: Before You Quote a Verse
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Checking the Verse
- Lecture 3-1: Hearing Both Sides
- Lecture 3-2: What a Lay Peacemaker Does and Does Not Do
- Lecture 3-3: Opening a Hard Conversation
- Lecture 3-4: Words That Calm and Words That Inflame
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Two Sides of One Story
- Lecture 4-1: Giving and Receiving an Apology
- Lecture 4-2: Talking About Forgiveness
- Lecture 4-3: After the Conflict: Trust and Community
- Lecture 4-4: Why Some Things Take Years
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting an Apology
- Lecture 5-1: Gossip and Rumour
- Lecture 5-2: Taking Sides and Triangles
- Lecture 5-3: Leading a Conflict Conversation in a Small Group
- Lecture 5-4: Online Groups and Messages
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Handling a Moment in the Meeting
For many church groups, a large part of life now happens through messages and video calls. A small group has a message thread. A choir has a chat. A congregation has a page. These tools are useful: they carry news, prayer needs, reminders and encouragement. They also make conflict faster, wider and harder to repair.
A spoken sentence disappears. A written sentence stays. It can be read again at night by the person it hurt, it can be copied, and it can be sent to people the writer never thought of. Tone of voice and the look on a face are missing, so the reader supplies them, and a hurt reader supplies the worst. A late-night reply, written while tired, can do what a daytime talk would not.
This lecture is practical. It looks at why online conflict grows, at how to read a message that stings, at how to step out of a thread, at how to move a conversation to a calmer way, at the rules that protect privacy, at what to do as the person who runs a group, and at when to stop. It also marks the point at which a message is not a conflict at all but a harm. It uses no statistics, and it does not assume any particular app, since these change and differ from country to country.
이 23분으로 얻는 것
- Explain three reasons why conflict grows faster in messages than in speech.
- Use a short pause before replying, and rewrite a sharp message in a calmer form.
- Step out of a heated thread with a short sentence, and move the matter to a call or a meeting.
- State three privacy habits for group messages, including what not to forward or share.
- Recognise online messages that are harassment, threats or grooming, and say where to take them.
In the multitude of words there is no lack of disobedience, but he who restrains his lips does wisely." — Proverbs 10:19
World English Bible
There is one who speaks rashly like the piercing of a sword, but the tongue of the wise heals." — Proverbs 12:18
WEB
A fool vents all of his anger, but a wise man brings himself under control." — Proverbs 29:11
WEB
These sayings are old, and they fit well with a message screen. Many words make sin more likely; a rash word can pierce; a person who vents every anger is foolish; and the wise person takes control. None of them was written about telephones, and all of them are about the mouth, which is now also the thumb.
1. Why messages make conflict grow
Three features of written messages explain most of what goes wrong.
Tone is missing. When you speak, the other person hears your voice and sees your face. A message gives only words. "Fine." can mean agreement, anger, tiredness or hurt, and the reader chooses. When a reader is already upset, the reader will usually choose the harsh meaning. Short messages are especially risky. So are capital letters, a full stop after a single word, and a reply that is only a symbol.
Speed and distance. A message can be written in a minute, sent at midnight and read by twelve people. There is no pause in which the writer sees the other's face and softens. And distance makes it easier to write what one would not say to a person's face.
A permanent, shareable record. A message may be saved. Some apps allow a screenshot of a conversation to be taken and sent elsewhere. A private remark may be shown to the person it is about. Assume that anything you write in a group can reach anyone.
Also, in a group, an audience is present. A sharp remark in a thread is public, and people who might have been silent now feel they must reply or take a side (lecture 5-2). A quarrel that would have been two people's becomes everyone's.
2. Reading a message that stings
Before you reply to a message that has hurt you, try four steps:
- Stop. Do not reply for at least a short time. Put the phone down, walk, drink water. A night is better than a minute, if the matter can wait.
- Read it again, slowly, and offer the kindest reading you can. "Might this have been written quickly, or by someone tired?" You do not have to believe the kind reading, but you may find it is also a true one.
- Ask what you want. To be heard? To correct a fact? To be apologised to? To end the quarrel? A reply without a purpose is usually a reply that makes things worse.
- Choose the right route. Should this be answered in the group, to the person alone, or by a call? Most stings should not be answered in the group.
(an invented example) In the Wednesday group's thread, Paolo writes at 11 p.m.: "Some people clearly don't care enough to prepare for the study." Ngozi, who was away with a sick child, reads this the next morning. She starts to write, "How dare you—", and then stops. She puts the phone down. At lunch she writes to Paolo alone: "Your message in the group hurt. I was at the hospital with my daughter on Tuesday. Could we talk by phone this evening?" Paolo replies within the hour with an apology: he had not known. Ngozi's first draft would have started a thread of thirty messages. The second took two.
3. Before and after
A sharp message can usually be rewritten. Some pairs follow. They are invented.
| Sharp | Calmer |
|---|---|
| "You never read what I send." | "I sent the schedule on Monday and I am not sure it reached everyone. Could you check?" |
| "Wow. Some people really have time to criticise." | (Not sent. Instead, a call: "I felt hurt by your comment about the music. Can we talk?") |
| "As usual, the leader decided without us." | "I would like to understand how the decision about the date was made. Could we talk about it at the next meeting?" |
| "Fine." | "I am not happy about this, but I need time to think. Can we talk tomorrow?" |
Notice that the calmer versions do not hide the feeling. They say what the person sees or feels, and they ask. They move toward a conversation. They do not make a verdict about the other person.
4. Stepping out of a thread
When a thread has turned sharp, a member or a leader can help by stepping out of it. This is a skill. Four short lines serve:
- "I think this is better talked about by phone. May I call you both tomorrow?"
- "I am going to step out of this thread. I would be glad to talk with anyone separately."
- "This is hard to settle in writing. Let us take it to our meeting on Thursday."
- "I can see that this matters to everyone. Let us pause until morning."
Say it once. Do not add a further argument. Do not wait for others to agree. If someone replies sharply, you may leave it unanswered.
If it is late at night, leave the thread and do not return until morning. Some groups agree a rule that arguments are not held in the thread after a certain hour. That kind of rule is much easier to make before trouble than during it (lecture 5-3).
5. Moving to a calmer way
A thread is a poor place to settle a hurt. A better way depends on the people and the place. Possible routes:
- A call, in which the voice carries tone. Some people dislike calls and prefer an exchange of short messages with time to think; ask what suits them.
- A meeting in person, in a public place or in the church, with a companion if wanted.
- A video meeting, when distance requires it. In video, avoid a recorded session unless everyone agrees. Agree who speaks when, and let each finish.
- A mediated conversation, with a person both trust, if both want one (lecture 3-2).
Cultures differ. In some, a call or a visit is a sign of respect and a written message is cold. In others, a written message gives space to think, and a sudden call feels like pressure. Ask the other person: "How would you like to talk about this?"
Do not use a call to pressure someone into silence or agreement. And if the other person has said they do not wish to talk, respect that, and leave it for a time or find another person to help.
6. Privacy in message groups
A message group holds many people's information. A few habits protect them.
- Do not forward or share what others have written without permission. A message written to a group belongs to its writer and the group. Do not send it elsewhere, and do not send a screenshot to anyone who is not in the group. The exceptions are where safety requires it, discussed below.
- Do not put private matters in the group. Health, family trouble, money, immigration status, a person's past: these should not be in a thread, even as a "prayer request" (lecture 5-1). Ask first.
- Do not add people without asking. To be added to a group of strangers, or a group where one is being discussed, is an unwelcome surprise. And do not remove someone from a group as a way to exclude them, unless there is an agreed reason. A person who finds themselves removed will usually feel it as an attack. If a person must leave a group for a reason, a leader should tell them privately.
- Do not post photographs of others (especially children) without the permission of the person or the parent. Laws and customs about images differ between places; follow your local law and your church's written policy.
- Do not use a group to speak about someone who is not in it. The same applies to a second, secret group formed to talk about the first.
If you are not sure whether to share something, ask the person it is about.
7. The person who runs the group
If you start or manage a message group, you have extra responsibilities and some tools. Apps differ, and some let an administrator limit who can post, mute a member for a time, or remove a message. These changes in the rules should be told to everyone. A few practices:
- Set a purpose and a few rules at the start, in the same way as ground rules for a meeting: what the group is for, when messages are welcome, that arguments are not held here, that private matters are not posted.
- Set quiet hours, so that nobody feels they must reply at midnight.
- Act early. Do not wait for a quarrel to grow. A word to one person early is far easier than a rebuke in front of fifty.
- Do not use your power to silence a person who raises a real problem. To remove a message or a member because it is inconvenient is not peacemaking. If a post is harmful, such as an insult, a threat or private information about someone, remove it and speak to the person; do not delete other people's concerns to make the group look calm.
- Say who the responsible person is for concerns about the group.
- Be careful with young people. Adults should not hold private message conversations with children or teenagers that others cannot see. Your church's written policy, if it has one, and your local law set the standard. A group that includes minors should have more than one responsible adult in it.
8. When to stop
Some signs say it is time to stop posting:
- You have written three messages in a row to the same argument.
- You are writing while angry, at night, or tired.
- You are writing to prove a point and not to reach a person.
- The other person has said they do not want to continue.
- You notice you are checking the screen to see if they have replied.
Stopping is not losing. It is a form of the self-control that Proverbs 29:11 describes. If you need to say something and cannot decide how, write it and do not send it. Keep the draft for the next day, and then decide.
9. When it is harm and not a quarrel
Some online messages are not a conflict to be settled by a gentler reply. They are harm. Examples include messages that threaten violence, that repeatedly harass or insult a person, that spread private images or information without consent, that pressure a person for money or secrecy, or that an adult sends to a child in a private and secretive way. Some of these may be crimes where you live, and the local law differs.
What should a lay peacemaker do?
- Do not argue with the sender and do not try to catch them. You are not an investigator.
- Keep the record, but do not spread it. If a person has been threatened, they may need to keep the messages. Help them to save them, and not to send them to many people. Do not forward intimate images, above all of a child, to anyone, even in order to report them; ask the local agency or a responsible person how to give them.
- Help the person reach a responsible person: a pastor, a safeguarding officer in the church, a counsellor, or, where there is a crime or danger, the local agencies. Check your local law and agencies. Do not give legal advice.
- Do not ask the person who was harmed to reconcile with the sender. This is not a matter for "work it out between you".
- If there is danger now, or a person is talking of harming themselves, use your local emergency number and speak to a pastor. Do not give any detail of method.
10. A short note on video meetings
Video meetings add a few issues. People talk over each other because of delay. Some people cannot be seen or heard well, which makes them feel left out. A person at home may be sitting with a family member who can hear, so some topics are not safe for video. A host can ask people to use the "raise hand" feature, to turn the microphone off when not speaking, and to use the chat sparingly. The host can offer to speak to a person separately. If someone seems distressed on screen, the host can call them afterwards, as one would after a meeting in a room. And if someone says they cannot speak freely because of who is near them, believe them, and end the meeting for that topic.
11. Summary
Messages are quick, and conflicts in them are quick. The remedy is slow: stop, reread, decide what you want, choose the right route, and step out when you need to. Keep privacy. Run groups with a few clear rules. And be ready to tell the difference between a quarrel and a harm, because a harm needs a responsible person, and a gentler message does not help.
Diagram 1. Before you send
Diagram 2. Privacy habits for message groups
| Do | Do not |
|---|---|
| Ask before sharing someone's private matter, even as a prayer request | Post health, family, money or immigration matters of another person |
| Tell a person privately if they must leave a group | Remove someone quietly as a way to exclude them |
| Ask before adding someone | Add a person to a group where they are being discussed |
| Keep a record if you or someone is threatened | Forward threats or private images to many people |
| Have more than one responsible adult in a group with young people | Hold private, hidden message talks between an adult and a child |
핵심 요약
- Messages lack tone, travel fast, and leave a record that can be copied; in a group they also bring an audience.
- Before replying to a message that stings: stop, reread kindly, ask what you want, and choose the right route.
- Rewrite sharp messages to describe what you saw or felt and to ask, without a verdict on the person.
- To step out of a thread, say one short sentence and offer a call or meeting.
- Keep privacy: do not forward, add, remove or post about people without a reason and, where right, permission.
- Threats, harassment, private images and secret messages from an adult to a child are harms; keep the record and tell a responsible person.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why messages inflame | Tone is missing, speed and distance, a permanent record that can be shared, and an audience. |
| Four steps before replying | Stop; reread kindly; ask what you want; choose the right route. |
| Stepping out | One short sentence: "I think this is better by phone. May I call you both tomorrow?" |
| A harm, not a quarrel | Threats, harassment, private images, secret adult-to-child messages: keep the record, tell a responsible person, check local law. |
One sentence to remember A written word cannot be taken back, so take your time before you send it.
This week's action This week, before replying to any message that stings, put the phone down for ten minutes and ask what you want the reply to do.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Why does a short message such as "Fine." cause so much trouble? Think about a time, without naming anyone, when a message was read as harsher than it was meant.
- What are three situations in which you would not answer a message in the group, and which route would you choose instead?
- Which of the four step-out sentences would you be able to say? How might a person from a different culture hear it?
- If you ran a group, which three rules would you set at the start? Who should agree them?
- Why does the lecture say that a message to a child that is secret is not a conflict? Where would you take a concern of that kind?