Lecture 4-3: After the Conflict: Trust and Community
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Conflict Is Not Strange in the Church
- Lecture 1-2: Kinds and Stages of Conflict
- Lecture 1-3: Reading Your Own Reactions
- Lecture 1-4: Fault Lines: A Quick Look at Where Conflicts Start
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Conflict Map
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Matthew 18 in Its Context
- Lecture 2-2: Blessed Are the Peacemakers
- Lecture 2-3: Forgiveness, Apology, Restoration, Reconciliation
- Lecture 2-4: Before You Quote a Verse
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Checking the Verse
- Lecture 3-1: Hearing Both Sides
- Lecture 3-2: What a Lay Peacemaker Does and Does Not Do
- Lecture 3-3: Opening a Hard Conversation
- Lecture 3-4: Words That Calm and Words That Inflame
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Two Sides of One Story
- Lecture 4-1: Giving and Receiving an Apology
- Lecture 4-2: Talking About Forgiveness
- Lecture 4-3: After the Conflict: Trust and Community
- Lecture 4-4: Why Some Things Take Years
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting an Apology
- Lecture 5-1: Gossip and Rumour
- Lecture 5-2: Taking Sides and Triangles
- Lecture 5-3: Leading a Conflict Conversation in a Small Group
- Lecture 5-4: Online Groups and Messages
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Handling a Moment in the Meeting
When a hard conversation is over, the work of the lay peacemaker is not over. People walk out of the room with an agreement, or a half-agreement, or a quiet "we will see". The next few weeks decide a good deal. Does the agreement hold? Does the group heal, or does it split into two tables at the next meal? What happens to the stories people tell each other? And what if, in the end, two people cannot work together?
This lecture looks at that time after. We cover following up on agreements, the life of a group when the conflict is over but its traces are not, the rumours that follow, and one of the least comfortable ideas in this course: that sometimes people part in peace without being reconciled. We read Acts 15:36-41, where Paul and Barnabas part after a sharp disagreement, and we are careful to say what that text does and does not tell us. We then ask what a group should keep from what it has learned.
One line must stand before the rest. Parting in peace is not an answer to harm. Where one person has been abused, threatened or exploited, the aim is safety and responsible help, not a calm farewell, and the person harmed is never expected to leave quietly or to stay and be near the one who harmed them. This lecture is about conflicts between people who both stand on level ground.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Describe a light and respectful way to follow up on an agreement and say what to do if it fails.
- Explain what a group may do, and what it should not do, in the weeks after a conflict, including how to treat rumours.
- State what Acts 15:36-41 says and what it does not say about who was right.
- Describe what "parting in peace" looks like, and explain why it is not an answer to harm.
- Write three or four ground rules a group could keep from a conflict it has been through.
After some days Paul said to Barnabas, “Let’s return now and visit our brothers in every city in which we proclaimed the word of the Lord, to see how they are doing.”" — Acts 15:36
World English Bible
Barnabas planned to take John, who was called Mark, with them also." — Acts 15:37
WEB
But Paul didn’t think that it was a good idea to take with them someone who had withdrawn from them in Pamphylia, and didn’t go with them to do the work." — Acts 15:38
WEB
Then the contention grew so sharp that they separated from each other. Barnabas took Mark with him, and sailed away to Cyprus," — Acts 15:39
WEB
but Paul chose Silas, and went out, being commended by the brothers to the grace of God." — Acts 15:40
WEB
He went through Syria and Cilicia, strengthening the assemblies." — Acts 15:41
WEB
If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men." — Romans 12:18
WEB
He who covers an offense promotes love; but he who repeats a matter separates best friends." — Proverbs 17:9
WEB
So then, let us follow after things which make for peace, and things by which we may build one another up." — Romans 14:19
WEB
Read the six verses of Acts 15 slowly. The writer tells what happened and does not say who was right. We return to that below.
1. Following up on an agreement
Suppose two members of a small group have talked, with a companion present, and have agreed on a few things: that messages about the group will not be sent to the whole thread, that the budget will be kept by a different person for a while, and that they will greet each other at meetings. The peacemaker may think, "Good, it is done."
It is not done. An agreement is a plan, and plans meet real weeks. A light follow-up keeps it alive and shows both people that someone cares how it goes.
Write it down briefly, if both agree. A few lines are enough: what was agreed, who will do what, and when you will check. Keep it simple. Do not write the story of the conflict. Do not write who was to blame. If either person would rather it was not written, do not write it. Give each person the same copy, so that nobody carries a private version.
Set a time to check. "Let us speak again in two weeks" is enough. A check is not an inspection. Ask each person separately, "How is it going? Has anything been hard?" Then listen. You are not collecting evidence for a case.
Expect a step back. Agreements often wobble. A person may forget, or may meet an old feeling at a meeting. A first lapse is not proof that the whole thing has failed. It is a reason to ask what happened and whether the agreement should change.
Know when to stop following. After a month or two, if things are steady, you may step back. Tell them so, and say that they may ask you again.
Do not carry messages. If one person says, "Tell him I am not angry," the temptation is to run to the other. Do that only if the first person has asked you to and you can say it exactly as given. Do not add to it. Better, encourage them to say it themselves.
2. It may not resolve at once
Some conflicts end in a conversation, with an apology, and a handshake. More often they thin out. The two people are polite. They avoid one another a little. Months later one of them says something kind. A lay peacemaker has to be ready for a slow ending, and sometimes for none.
This does not mean you did badly. Reconciliation depends on the people, and on the harm done, and on what each of them needs. It is not a prize the peacemaker earns. And as lecture 4-1 and lecture 4-2 showed, no one can be forced to apologise or to forgive.
What the lay peacemaker can do in the meantime is keep two things steady: respect (nobody is shamed, and nobody is spoken of as a villain) and doors (each person knows how to come back, and nobody has been told that they have lost their place).
3. The group after the conflict
A conflict in a group affects people who were never in the room. Some saw part of it. Some heard a version. Some are tired. Some were afraid. When the matter is over for the two main people, it may not be over for the others.
(an invented example) A choir had a dispute about who would lead the Christmas programme. After a hard month, two members, Ruth and Alan, agreed to share the work. At the first practice afterwards, nobody spoke much. The tenors sat apart from the sopranos. At the coffee break, someone whispered that "Ruth only agreed because the pastor leaned on her." A new member asked her neighbour what had happened and got a different story from each of three people.
This is common. What can help?
Say a short true thing. A leader may tell the group, "Ruth and Alan have talked and agreed on how to share the programme. Thank you for your patience. We will not go into the details, and we ask everyone not to." This respects their privacy and gives the group something to stand on. Say only what the two people have agreed may be said.
Do not ask people to choose. Do not ask, "Who is with whom?" And do not give speeches that declare a winner. A group that sees a winner will remember a loser.
Deal with rumours quickly and kindly. Proverbs puts it plainly: "He who covers an offense promotes love; but he who repeats a matter separates best friends." Lecture 5-1 takes gossip in full. Here, one thing: when someone tells you a rumour, you may say, "I do not think it is mine to pass on. It may help to ask them directly." Do not repeat it, even to correct it.
Give people time to be awkward. The first weeks after a conflict are often stiff. Do not demand cheerfulness. Do not make people hug. A simple greeting is a start.
Let people say that it was hard. Some have been frightened or sad. A short word in a meeting, such as "This has been a hard time, and some of us are tired. That is all right", makes room without opening the case again.
4. Parting in peace
Sometimes, after honest work, two people or two groups cannot go on together. One may leave the group, take on a different role, or move to a different congregation. We can call this parting in peace: separating without a fight, without attacks on character, and without damage to the people left behind. It is not the same as reconciliation. It is a way of ending that does not add new harm.
The Bible has a short, honest picture of this in Acts 15. Paul and Barnabas had travelled and preached together. Paul proposed to go back and visit the places where they had proclaimed the word. Barnabas "planned to take John, who was called Mark, with them also." Paul "didn't think that it was a good idea to take with them someone who had withdrawn from them in Pamphylia". Then: "the contention grew so sharp that they separated from each other." Barnabas took Mark and sailed to Cyprus. Paul chose Silas and went through Syria and Cilicia, "strengthening the assemblies".
What the text says. There was a disagreement about a person and about whether he was ready to go. It grew sharp. The two men separated. Each went with a different companion, and the work went on in two places.
What the text does not say. It does not say who was right. The writer does not blame Paul or Barnabas, and does not praise either. It does not say that they were reconciled later, or that they were not. It tells us that Paul was "commended by the brothers to the grace of God" as he set out, which tells us something about how the believers saw it, but we should not build too much on one phrase. Readers through the centuries have taken the story in different ways: some as a sad story of two good people who could not agree, some as an honest example that disagreement about a person can lead to different paths without ending the work, and some as a warning about how sharply even leaders can argue. The text allows each of these. It gives no verdict.
Other New Testament passages mention Mark again. The letter to the Colossians and the second letter to Timothy are given in Paul's name (scholars debate who wrote them), and they speak of "Mark, the cousin of Barnabas" with a note that the church there is to "receive him" (Colossians 4:10), and a late letter says, "Take Mark, and bring him with you, for he is useful to me for service" (2 Timothy 4:11). These verses show that Mark is later in Paul's circle and that his service is valued. They do not say how, or when, or whether anything was said between Paul and Barnabas. We should not tidy the story into a neat ending that the text does not give. This is a place where the story is pleasing in its shape, and the more pleasing it is, the more careful we should be.
For a lay peacemaker, the passage is not a model to copy or a rule. It is a permission to say that separation, in itself, is not always a failure of faith. Acts 15 tells of two people who parted over a real disagreement about a person, and neither is called an enemy of the church.
5. What parting in peace looks like
If two people, or a person and a group, are going to part, here is what a lay peacemaker can help to make possible.
- No attacks on the person. The reasons given are the ones the people themselves agreed to share. Nobody is called disloyal, proud or unspiritual.
- A fair handing-over. Keys, money, files, tasks and responsibilities are passed on in the open, with a short written list.
- A blessing, if it can be said honestly. "I wish you well" is enough. Do not require more.
- No recruiting. Each side keeps from drawing others away from the other or asking them to choose.
- Kept confidences. What was said in the conversations stays there.
- A door left open. "You are welcome back, if you want to come" may not be said by every person, but the group should not close the door on its own.
- No pretending. If the parting is sad, a plain "We are sorry this has happened" is better than cheerful speeches.
For those who leave, thank them for what they gave. Do not tell them that they have "left the faith" or "left God". Do not ask them to explain. If they want to keep in touch, welcome it; if they do not, do not chase.
For those who stay, there may be grief, anger or relief, and sometimes all three. A short time in which the group can say, "We have lost something", is not weakness. It is part of being a community.
6. When this is not the answer
Parting in peace belongs to conflicts of two people on level ground. It is wrong to use the phrase for harm.
If a person has been abused, threatened, harassed or taken advantage of, the aim is their safety and a responsible response. They are not asked to "part in peace" with the one who harmed them, and they are not asked to leave a place that is theirs while the one who harmed them stays. They are not asked to keep quiet for the sake of calm. Equally, a group that quietly lets a person drift away after a harm has not parted in peace; it has failed to protect. Lecture 6-1 and lecture 6-2 take these cases. If you are unsure whether you are looking at a conflict or at harm, say so to a responsible leader or someone with the right training; do not decide alone.
7. Keeping what you learned
When a conflict has passed, a group has a short chance to learn from it. Without this, the next conflict starts from nothing.
Keep it small. After some weeks, with those who were part of it and who wish to speak, ask three questions: What helped? What made it worse? What would we want to do differently? Do not ask who was to blame. Write down three or four ground rules that come from the answers. They are not laws. They are reminders.
(an invented example) After the choir dispute, the group wrote four lines on a card:
- Concerns about leading go to the leader first, by voice, and not in the message thread.
- When there is a disagreement, we say what we saw before we say what we think it means.
- We do not pass on what we hear about members who are not present.
- If anyone feels unsafe or afraid, they may speak to the pastor or a responsible person at once, and nobody will be asked to stay in the room.
Notice the last one. A group that has learned from conflict knows that some things are not for the group's peace.
8. Not being reconciled is not always failure
We can put the lecture's idea in one line. In a conflict between people on level ground, not being reconciled is not always a failure, and a clean parting can be a way of keeping faith with both people. A peacemaker who thinks that every conflict must end in friendship will tempt people to say things they do not mean. Better to ask what is true, and what is possible, and what each person can do without harm.
And in a case of harm, the same sentence must never be said. There, the aim is not a neat ending. It is safety, truth and care.
Diagram 1. After the conversation: four roads
Diagram 2. Acts 15:36-41: what it says and what it does not
| The text says | The text does not say |
|---|---|
| Paul and Barnabas disagreed about taking Mark | Who was right |
| The contention "grew so sharp" that they separated | That they were later reconciled, or that they were not |
| Each took a companion and the work went on in two places | That the parting was a failure, or a success |
| Mark is later named in Paul's circle (Colossians 4:10; 2 Timothy 4:11) | How, or when, Paul's view of him changed |
핵심 요약
- Follow up lightly: a brief written agreement, a check after about two weeks, a step back when things are steady, and no carrying of messages.
- Some conflicts thin out slowly, and some do not end in friendship; the peacemaker keeps respect and open doors.
- After a conflict, say one short true thing to the group, do not ask people to choose, and meet rumours with "ask them directly".
- Acts 15:36-41 tells of a sharp disagreement and a separation, and gives no verdict on who was right.
- Parting in peace means no attacks, a fair hand-over, no recruiting, confidences kept and a door left open.
- Parting in peace is never an answer to harm; there the aim is safety and responsible help (Week 6).
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Following up | Brief agreement, check after about two weeks, step back when steady, do not carry messages. |
| After a conflict, the group | One short true thing; no choosing sides; meet rumours with "ask them directly". |
| Acts 15:36-41 | A sharp disagreement over Mark; they separated; the text gives no verdict on who was right. |
| Parting in peace | No attacks, fair hand-over, door open; never a response to harm. |
One sentence to remember Where two people stand on level ground, a clean parting can keep faith with both; where there is harm, safety comes first.
This week's action Write three ground rules your group could keep from its last hard moment, and make sure one of them says what a person should do if they feel unsafe.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Why might a short, light check-in two weeks after a conversation do more good than a long meeting on the day?
- In the invented case of the choir, what did the leader's short statement do well? What might have gone wrong if the leader had said more?
- Read Acts 15:36-41 again. What do you want the text to say about who was right? Why is it useful that it does not?
- What is the difference between parting in peace and drifting away unnoticed after a hurt? What would you look for?
- What one ground rule would you want your own group to have? You may pass if you would rather not say.