무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

PT720E Crisis, Trauma and Suicide Prevention: Standing Beside, Staying Safe, Connecting to Help

Lecture 4-4: Faith, Trauma and "Where Was God"

목차 31
PT720E Crisis, Trauma and Suicide Prevention: Standing Beside, Staying Safe, Connecting to Help
제 0 장 · Introduction: Beside, Not Instead
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Beside, Not Instead
제 1 장 · Week 1: Standing Beside
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Crisis Is and What a Church Can Do
  2. Lecture 1-2: People in Crisis in Scripture, and God's Nearness
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Caregiver's Own Steadiness and Safety
  4. Lecture 1-4: Preparing Before It Happens
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Readiness Sheet
제 2 장 · Week 2: First Response
  1. Lecture 2-1: Safety First and Steadying
  2. Lecture 2-2: Listening, and Words to Leave Unsaid
  3. Lecture 2-3: Prayer and Scripture Beside Someone
  4. Lecture 2-4: Differences in How Crisis Is Shown: Culture, Age, Setting
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading and Rewriting a Conversation
제 3 장 · Week 3: Asking About Danger
  1. Lecture 3-1: Warning Signs and Common Myths
  2. Lecture 3-2: Asking Directly: The Basic Questions
  3. Lecture 3-3: General Principles of a Safety Plan
  4. Lecture 3-4: Staying With Someone: Presence, Handover and Follow-Up
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Practising the Question
제 4 장 · Week 4: Trauma and Care That Avoids Further Harm
  1. Lecture 4-1: How People React to Overwhelming Events
  2. Lecture 4-2: Safety, Choice and Trust
  3. Lecture 4-3: Avoiding Further Harm in Church Life
  4. Lecture 4-4: Faith, Trauma and "Where Was God"
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check of Our Practices
제 5 장 · Week 5: Suicide Prevention and Those Left Behind
  1. Lecture 5-1: Beyond Stigma
  2. Lecture 5-2: Speaking Responsibly: Sermons, Prayers, Notices and Posts
  3. Lecture 5-3: After a Death by Suicide: Beside the Family
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Congregation as a Whole: Community After a Loss and Ongoing Prevention
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Checking What We Say
제 6 장 · Week 6: Referral and Connection
  1. Lecture 6-1: Whom to Connect, and When
  2. Lecture 6-2: A Warm Referral
  3. Lecture 6-3: Confidentiality, Records and Its Limits
  4. Lecture 6-4: Caring for Caregivers and Learning After
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Crisis Response Plan

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

21분

After an overwhelming event, many people ask questions about God that they may never have asked before. Where was God? Why did God allow it? Is God angry with me? Is there anyone listening? Others find that they cannot pray at all, or that a hymn, a verse or a role of God that once comforted them now hurts. A church caregiver, who may feel obliged to defend God or to restore the person's faith, is likely to be afraid of these questions.

This lecture makes three claims. The question is allowed. The Psalms and the Gospels give it words. The caregiver's task is to stay beside the person with the question, not to answer it for God. And forgiveness must never be hurried or demanded. These claims need care, because on the last Christians disagree.

This course gives no diagnosis, treatment, medication or medical advice, and it does not replace professional care. Do not use what you learn here to label a person's faith or their reactions. Spiritual care and professional care are not rivals. A person may need both, and neither is a substitute for the other.

이 21분으로 얻는 것

  • Explain why the question "Where was God?" should not be silenced or answered quickly.
  • Describe how lament in Scripture gives a person words for anger, abandonment and waiting.
  • Say how forgiveness differs from excusing, from reconciliation and from trust, and why it cannot be demanded.
  • State fairly the main positions on forgiveness after harm, and what this course requires.
  • Respond to a person's anger at God in a way that stays beside them.

How long, Yahweh? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me?" — Psalm 13:1 (World English Bible) "How long shall I take counsel in my soul, having sorrow in my heart every day? How long shall my enemy triumph over me?" — Psalm 13:2 (WEB) "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me? Why are you so far from helping me, and from the words of my groaning?" — Psalm 22:1 (WEB) "For he has not despised nor abhorred the affliction of the afflicted, Neither has he hidden his face from him; but when he cried to him, he heard." — Psalm 22:24 (WEB) "Therefore when Mary came to where Jesus was, and saw him, she fell down at his feet, saying to him, “Lord, if you would have been here, my brother wouldn’t have died.”" — John 11:32 (WEB) "Jesus wept." — John 11:35

WEB

Psalm 13 begins with four "how long" questions, directed at God and not at a friend. Psalm 22 opens with words of abandonment, and its later verse (22:24) says that God has not turned away from the afflicted. The Psalms do not hurry from the first to the second. In John 11, Mary says to Jesus what many have said since, and Jesus, who is about to act, first weeps. He does not correct her. Psalm 13 goes on to speak of trust (verses 5 and 6); the lecture will say why a caregiver does not quote those verses to a person who has not reached them.

The question is allowed

(an invented example) Bao is a member of a house church in a large city. Some time ago something happened to his family, which he has never described to the church. At the Sunday meeting he sits through the songs without singing. One evening, helping the leader stack chairs, he says, "I used to think God was good. Where was he?"

The leader, Pastor Nkechi, could say many things. She could say that God had a plan, or that suffering builds character, or that Bao must not speak that way. She could quote a verse. She might begin to defend God. Any of these would feel like care to her. To Bao it might sound like: do not ask.

She says, "That is a real question, and I do not have an answer for you tonight. I am glad you asked me. Would you like to sit down for a while?" She does not try to reply. She stays. She says nothing more about God that evening, and a week later she asks whether he would like to talk again. He says yes.

Pastor Nkechi did several things right. She did not treat the question as an attack. She did not claim to know what she does not know. She did not leave. And she kept the way open for another conversation.

The Bible gives the question words

The Psalms are the church's prayer book, and a large share of them are laments: complaints to God, in God's presence, with God's own people listening. The person who says "where were you?" is not leaving the faith. They are praying in a way Scripture knows.

Psalm 13 asks "How long?" four times in two verses. It asks whether God has forgotten, whether God hides, how long the person must take counsel in their own soul. These are the questions of a person who still speaks to God, though they have little else left. Psalm 22 begins with the words of abandonment that Christians have heard for centuries on the lips of Jesus, and it goes on to describe the cry that is not answered by day or by night. Many other psalms do the same. They say what a person cannot say in polite church language.

Scripture does not hurry these prayers to a resolution, and neither should a caregiver. Some psalms of lament end in trust. Psalm 13 turns, in its last verses, toward trust and singing. That turning is genuine, but it comes in its own time, and it comes for the psalmist; it is not a rule that a sufferer must reach it by the end of the conversation. A caregiver should not quote the last verses of Psalm 13, or the later part of Psalm 22, to a person who is still in the first. The person may come to those verses; they should not be pushed to them. The last verses of a psalm can too easily be used as a way of escaping the first half of the prayer.

The Gospel of John gives a second picture. Both Martha and Mary say to Jesus the same words: if you had been here, my brother would not have died. Jesus does not argue with either. With Mary, he sees her weeping, is troubled in spirit, and then weeps himself. He does not say that it is God's will, or that they have little faith, or that Lazarus will rise. He shares the tears. The caregiver who wishes to follow him can begin there.

What a caregiver does not do

  • Do not defend God. God does not need the caregiver to win an argument against a person in pain.
  • Do not explain the suffering. "Everything happens for a reason", "God has a plan", "God never gives us more than we can bear", "it was God's will" and "God needed another angel" are sentences that people say to comfort themselves or others. To a person in the middle of the pain they can seem to say: the thing that happened to you was meant. Where harm was done by another person, such sentences can seem to excuse the harm. Leave them unsaid.
  • Do not quote a verse as a cure. Scripture is not a weapon. A verse offered in the middle of a lament, if it has not been invited, tells the person: stop.
  • Do not judge the person's faith. Anger, doubt, silence and an inability to pray are not signs of lost faith. Job's friends sat for seven days in silence and then spoke, and it was their speaking that went wrong (lecture 1-2).
  • Do not hurry to prayer. Ask first (lecture 2-3). If the person says that they cannot pray, the caregiver may offer to pray for them, quietly, and may say, "You do not need to say anything."
  • Do not assume what hurts. A person harmed by someone in a certain role may find it hard to hear God called by a name from that role. A song about a fire or a flood may undo someone. A church building, a ritual, a hymn may be hard to bear for a while. Ask what helps and what does not.

What a caregiver can do

  • Let the question stand. "I do not know either" is a more honest sentence than most explanations.
  • Name what you can say. "I do not know why this happened. I do know that I am here, and that I am not leaving." Presence is an answer of a kind.
  • Offer the Psalms, gently and only if wanted. "There are prayers in the Bible that sound like what you said. Would you like me to read one, or leave it?" A lament may be the first prayer the person can recognise as their own.
  • Offer your church's resources, not as a cure. For many traditions these include confession, anointing, a quiet church, a candle, silence, singing, a , the laying on of hands. Offer none of them as a way to be well again, and none without the person's consent. Be willing to hear "not now."
  • Say that others have asked this. The question is old and has been asked by believers for as long as there have been believers.
  • Keep watch for despair that changes into something more. Words such as "there is no point" or "God has left me and I have no reason to go on" may be lament, or they may be a sign of danger. If you fear it, return to lecture 3-2, ask calmly and plainly, do not carry it alone, and connect the person to professionals or emergency services.
  • Connect, and stay. Spiritual care is one part of care. Where reactions are lasting or hard to manage, help the person toward professional help, as lecture 4-1 said, and keep coming. A pastor or priest does not stop being a pastor or priest because a counsellor is involved.

Forgiveness: not hurried, never demanded

Forgiveness is central to Christian faith, and it is also one of the places where care can go badly wrong. A harmed person is often met, sooner than they can bear, with the word "forgive." The word is true; the timing and the pressure can be a second harm.

It helps to separate four things that are often run together.

  • Forgiving can mean letting go of a claim for revenge, and of the wish that the other person suffer. It may take a long time, and it may be done more than once.
  • Excusing means saying that what was done does not matter, or was not wrong. Forgiveness does not require this. A wrong can be named as wrong and also forgiven.
  • Reconciliation means a restored relationship. It needs two people, safety, truth told, and change in the one who did harm. It cannot be demanded of the one harmed, and it may never be possible or wise.
  • Trust is rebuilt only by what a person does over time. It cannot be commanded.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians hold that forgiveness is at the heart of the gospel and a path to healing, so that a harmed person who is encouraged toward it, kindly and early, is being offered a gift; they fear that bitterness that is left to grow can bind the person more tightly than the harm itself. Others hold that forgiveness cannot be hurried and that to press it is to ask the harmed person to carry what the one who did harm has not carried; they hold that safety, truth and justice come first, and that forgiveness comes, if it does, as a slow work, often more than once, and not on a schedule set by the church. Others hold that forgiveness is first of all God's work in a person, which the church can pray for and wait for, and which may begin only as a willingness to be willing. Each position has people who have been helped by it, and people who have been hurt by it. This course requires less than any of them does. Never demand forgiveness. Never press a harmed person toward reconciliation. Never silence the question, "Where was God?" Where harm is going on now, protection comes first. A caregiver may pray quietly for the person, and may say that the question of forgiveness can wait, and that it can be taken up later, if the person wishes, with someone they trust.

When the person is not a victim, but a caregiver or a bystander

Some people carry questions about God because of what they saw, or did not do, or could not prevent. A pastor, an or a volunteer who was present at a hard event may be haunted by it. Do not tell such a person that they have nothing to be sorry about, nor that they have everything. Listen. Suggest that they too speak to a trusted person or a professional. Lecture 6-4 returns to the care of the caregiver.

Different traditions, the same posture

(an invented example) In an Orthodox or Catholic parish, a woman named Dalia may ask the priest whether she can still receive communion when she is angry with God. A priest who knows that anger and prayer are not opposites may say that she is welcome as she is, that her anger is itself spoken in God's presence, and that nothing needs to be settled today. In a Pentecostal prayer meeting, the same person might meet a well-meant call to "claim a breakthrough". A leader who knows that some sufferers cannot yet say that, who lets the person decline loud prayer and the laying on of hands, and who prays in a lower voice, has kept to the same posture. In a Baptist or Presbyterian small group, a leader may offer a psalm of lament and then, quietly, a cup of tea. The tradition provides the forms. The posture of staying beside is the same.

Not leaving

The Bible gives answers, but not always at the pace of the person asking. The caregiver cannot supply the answers that Scripture does not hurry. What the caregiver can supply is company, honesty and patience: someone who will stay in the room while the question is still open.


4-1. Answering "Where was God?"

When a person asks "Where was God?" Stay beside the question; do not answer for God Leave unsaid Defending or explaining God "Everything happens for a reason" "It was God's will" A verse offered as a cure Judging the person's faith Hurrying to forgive or reconcile Hurrying to pray Can say and do "That is a real question." "I do not know why. I am here." Offer a lament, only if wanted Offer your tradition's resources, not as a cure Ask what helps and what hurts Watch for despair; ask plainly if you fear it Connect to help, and keep coming No diagnosis, treatment or medical advice. Spiritual and professional care do not replace each other.

4-2. Forgiveness is not the same as these

Four things often run together Forgiving, excusing, reconciling, trusting Forgiving Letting go of revenge and of the wish that the other suffer. It can take long, and may be done more than once. Excusing Saying it was not wrong or does not matter. Forgiveness does not need this. A wrong can be named and also forgiven. Reconciling A restored relationship. Needs two people, safety, truth and change in the one who did harm. Never demanded of the one harmed. Trusting Rebuilt by what a person does over time. It cannot be commanded.

핵심 요약

  • The question "Where was God?" is allowed; the Psalms and the weeping of Jesus in John 11 give it words.
  • A caregiver stays beside the question and does not defend God, explain the suffering or offer a verse as a cure.
  • Forgiving, excusing, reconciling and trusting are different; forgiveness is never demanded and never hurried.
  • Readers differ on forgiveness; this course requires only that it is never demanded, reconciliation is never pressed and the question is never silenced.
  • Watch for despair that turns to danger; ask plainly, connect to help, and keep coming.
Front Back
The question "Where was God?" is allowed. Lament in the Psalms and Jesus weeping in John 11 give it words.
What to leave unsaid Explanations, "God's will", verses as a cure, judging faith, hurrying to forgive or to pray.
Forgiving versus reconciling Forgiving is letting go of revenge, and may take long; reconciliation needs two, safety and change, and is never demanded.
The requirement Never demand forgiveness, never press reconciliation, never silence the question; where harm is now, protection first.

One sentence to remember Let the question stand, and stay in the room.

This week's action Write down one sentence you could say to a person who asks where God was, and check that it explains nothing, defends no one, and stays.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • When have you heard someone silenced for asking where God was? What did the silencing teach everyone in the room?
  • Which sentence in the "leave unsaid" list do you find yourself most tempted to say, and what is the temptation protecting you from?
  • Which psalm of lament does your tradition use, and which does it leave out?
  • Why might forgiveness, offered too early, feel like a second harm? What would a patient church look like?
  • How would a person in your community know that their anger at God is allowed here?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.