Lecture 1-3: Why Openness Matters
목차 25
- Lecture 1-1: Entrusted Money, Entrusted People
- Lecture 1-2: Who Does What with the Money
- Lecture 1-3: Why Openness Matters
- Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab: Mapping Our Money
- Lecture 2-1: A Budget Is a Ministry Plan
- Lecture 2-2: Building the Budget
- Lecture 2-3: Reserves, Cash Flow and the Seasons
- Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab: A Year's Budget for an Invented Congregation
- Lecture 3-1: Receiving and Counting Gifts
- Lecture 3-2: Spending: Request, Approval, Payment, Receipt
- Lecture 3-3: The Ledger and the Monthly Check
- Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab: Balancing an Invented Month
- Lecture 4-1: Never Leave It to One Person
- Lecture 4-2: Accounts, Cards and Cash
- Lecture 4-3: Checking: Audits and Warning Signs
- Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab: Finding the Gaps in a Procedure
- Lecture 5-1: Reporting to the Congregation
- Lecture 5-2: Designated Gifts, Charity Funds and Missions
- Lecture 5-3: Pay and Expenses for Ministers and Staff
- Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab: Reading and Writing a Year-End Report
A member of a small congregation asks, at the end of a meeting, how much was spent on the roof repair. The chairman is surprised. Nobody has asked such a question for years. For a moment the room is quiet, and in that quiet two different thoughts pass through different minds. One person thinks: "Good question; we should have said." Another thinks: "Why is she asking? Does she think something is wrong?" (an invented example)
Both thoughts are common, and the difference between them is the subject of this lecture. Openness about money is a way of keeping faith with the people who gave. It is not a sign that anyone is suspected. The roots of this idea are old. In the earliest churches, gifts were collected, carried and distributed, and those who carried them took care that the way they did it could be seen.
Openness has limits, and they are real. A congregation does not publish the bank details that would let a stranger reach its account. It does not tell the world which family received help in a hard month. Many people give quietly and wish to stay unnamed. So the lecture asks two questions together: what must be shown, and what must be protected? The answers differ among Christians, and one section sets out the disagreement honestly.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Describe, from the Bible readings, how early believers took care that gifts were handled in a way that could be seen.
- Explain why openness is a part of faithfulness and not an accusation.
- Name three kinds of information that a congregation should normally show to all, and three kinds it should protect.
- State fairly the disagreement about how far to disclose, and what this course requires whatever view a congregation holds.
- Suggest two simple ways to make a small congregation’s accounts open to its members.
Now in those days, when the number of the disciples was multiplying, a complaint arose from the Hellenists against the Hebrews, because their widows were neglected in the daily service. The twelve summoned the multitude of the disciples and said, “It is not appropriate for us to forsake the word of God and serve tables. Therefore select from among you, brothers, seven men of good report, full of the Holy Spirit and of wisdom, whom we may appoint over this business. But we will continue steadfastly in prayer and in the ministry of the word.” These words pleased the whole multitude. They chose Stephen, a man full of faith and of the Holy Spirit, Philip, Prochorus, Nicanor, Timon, Parmenas, and Nicolaus, a proselyte of Antioch; whom they set before the apostles. When they had prayed, they laid their hands on them." — Acts 6:1-6
World English Bible
Not only so, but who was also appointed by the assemblies to travel with us in this grace, which is served by us to the glory of the Lord himself, and to show our readiness. We are avoiding this, that any man should blame us concerning this abundance which is administered by us. Having regard for honorable things, not only in the sight of the Lord, but also in the sight of men." — 2 Corinthians 8:19-21
WEB
I made treasurers over the treasuries, Shelemiah the priest, and Zadok the scribe, and of the Levites, Pedaiah: and next to them was Hanan the son of Zaccur, the son of Mattaniah; for they were counted faithful, and their business was to distribute to their brothers." — Nehemiah 13:13
WEB
But when you do merciful deeds, don’t let your left hand know what your right hand does, so that your merciful deeds may be in secret, then your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly." — Matthew 6:3-4
WEB
The first three readings show shared handling of gifts in the open. The fourth is placed beside them on purpose: it reminds us that some giving, and some help, is rightly done in secret. The lecture asks how both can be true.
1. A complaint about the distribution
Acts 6 begins with money, or what money buys. A daily distribution to widows was part of the common life of the first believers, and some widows were being passed over. The text says only that "a complaint arose". It does not say that anyone was dishonest. It says that a task was being done in a way that left some people unserved, and that those people, or others on their behalf, said so.
Three things in the account bear on openness.
First, the complaint was heard. It was not treated as an attack on the leaders. The Twelve gathered "the multitude of the disciples" and spoke to them. A community in which a person can say that someone is being overlooked, without being punished for saying it, has the first condition of openness: the freedom to ask.
Second, the solution was public. The seven were chosen "from among you" by the whole group, in front of everyone. The people did not wake up to find that someone had been put in charge of their gifts.
Third, the people chosen were known. They were "of good report". Those who handle shared goods are best chosen from among people whom the community already knows well enough to trust.
The text does not tell us that the seven kept accounts or published them. We should not say that it does. What it shows is the soil in which open accounts grow: a community that hears complaints, chooses carefully and does its common work in sight of its members.
2. Paul and the collection
Paul’s second letter to Corinth has the clearest text on this subject. Paul is organising a collection from several assemblies, to be carried to believers who were in need. He says that a brother "was also appointed by the assemblies to travel with us". The man who accompanied the gift was not chosen by Paul alone. The assemblies chose him.
Then Paul explains why: "We are avoiding this, that any man should blame us concerning this abundance which is administered by us." In plain words, Paul is arranging things so that no one can say he handled the money wrongly. And he states a rule: "Having regard for honorable things, not only in the sight of the Lord, but also in the sight of men."
Two points follow, and they are the heart of this lecture.
Paul did not think it was enough that he knew he was honest. He knew he was honest, and God knew it. Yet he arranged for others to see it. Faithfulness to God does not excuse a person from being seen to be faithful to people. Doing right, and making it possible for others to see that you did right, are two parts of one duty.
Paul was not suspected, and he did not act as if he were. He was not defending himself against a charge. He was acting early, before any charge could arise, so that the gift would be above reproach and the believers who gave would trust the way it was carried. Openness, for him, was a courtesy to the givers, a protection of the gift and a protection of his own name.
We must be careful not to say more than the passage says. It describes one collection, in one setting. It does not state how much a congregation must publish or in what form. But the pattern is clear: choose carriers openly, arrange so that nobody can reasonably be blamed, and care how things look to others as well as to God.
3. The treasurers of Nehemiah
Nehemiah 13 is an older example. Nehemiah finds that the portions due to the Levites "had not been given them", and that the people who did the work of the house of God had left to farm their fields. He restores the giving and appoints treasurers. His reason for choosing them is given in the text: "they were counted faithful". He then adds that "their business was to distribute to their brothers."
What does this show? That trust was placed in people whom others had judged faithful, that these people were named in the record, and that their task was to distribute, which is a task that can be seen to be done or not done. We should not claim more: the passage does not describe an audit or a report. It shows that the choosing of those who handle common goods was a public act, and that failure to distribute was noticed and put right.
4. Openness is not suspicion
Many people hear a request for openness as an insult. A treasurer may reason: "If I am asked to show the books, I am being doubted." A member may reason: "If I ask to see the books, I will be thought to doubt." Both are mistaken, but both are understandable, and a congregation must deal with the feeling as well as the principle.
The way out is to make openness ordinary and regular, and not a response to trouble. When a congregation shows its accounts every year, as a matter of course, no one asks why this year. A question about the roof is just a question. Where openness is rare, each request looks like a challenge. Where it is regular, a request is an interest.
Here are three reasons why openness is not suspicion:
- It protects the person who holds the money. A treasurer whose accounts are regularly shown cannot easily be accused unfairly, because the record is there.
- It honours the giver. To give is to trust. To show how the gift was used is to answer that trust with respect. The giver is not an investor demanding a return; the giver is a member of the body who gave and who wishes to understand.
- It helps the congregation decide. People who can see where the money went are better placed to judge what to do next. A congregation that knows the cost of its building can talk sensibly about repairs.
5. What is shown, and what is protected
Openness and privacy are not enemies. A sensible congregation uses both. The principle this course holds is:
Show the whole congregation how its money was used. Protect the private data of individuals. Let those who need to check be able to check.
What does that look like in practice? Here is a usual division. Your own governing documents and local law may change it.
Normally shown to everyone in the congregation:
- Total income and total spending, by main category (for example, building, staff, missions, benevolence, worship, teaching).
- What was planned and what happened (the budget and the actual result).
- The balance of money held at the year’s end, including any reserves, and the purposes of special funds.
Normally protected from general view:
- What any individual gave. This is private between the giver and God and, where necessary, the person who records it.
- The names of individuals or families who received help from a benevolence fund, and the circumstances of their need.
- Bank account numbers, passwords, access codes and anything that would help a stranger to reach the money.
Open to those who need to check, but not published:
- Bank statements, invoices and receipts, available to the finance committee, the reviewer or auditor, and the governing body.
- Individual giving records, available to the person who issues year-end statements to givers and, where law requires, to authorities.
- Pay records, in a way that your congregation’s rule provides (see below).
Notice that the first list gives the congregation everything it needs to understand the use of its money, and the second keeps back only what protects persons. The third list is the bridge. It makes sure that the people who must be satisfied that things are right can see the evidence.
A rule of thumb: ask, "Who needs to know this in order to do their part, or to trust that others have done theirs?" Share it with those people, and no wider than that.
6. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. Christians differ about how far a congregation should disclose, especially about the names of givers, the pay of staff and the help given to people in need.
Some hold that full disclosure is the better rule. They point to Paul’s concern to be seen to be honest, and to the plain fact that people trust what they can see. In their view, a congregation that publishes every salary and every large gift removes the ground for rumour. They add that secrecy about money tends to protect the powerful and to leave the ordinary member in the dark. This is a serious argument, and it comes from people who have seen harm done in the shadows.
Others hold that privacy should come first. They point to Jesus’ words that gifts to the poor should be done in secret, to the dignity of people who receive help and would be shamed by being named, and to the right of a giver to give quietly. Many add that the pay of a minister or a staff member is a private matter between the person and the body that employs them, and that publishing it invites comparison and envy. This is also a serious argument, and it comes from people who have seen harm done by exposure. In some traditions the oversight of accounts rests chiefly with a bishop or a higher office, and ordinary members are not expected to see detailed figures.
Between these lie many middle positions: publish totals and categories but not names; publish the pay of staff as a band or as part of a salary line; let a small elected committee see everything and report to the rest.
This course requires less than any one of these requires, and more than none. Whatever a congregation decides, it should: (1) show the whole congregation how the money was used, in at least the categories described above; (2) protect the private data of individuals, especially givers and people helped; and (3) make sure that those who need to check can check. How much more than this to publish is a matter for the congregation’s own governing documents, its tradition and its local law. Lectures 5-1 and 5-3 return to it for reports and for pay.
7. Making it ordinary: two small steps
For a small congregation that has never shown its accounts, a gentle start is enough.
Step one: one page, once a year. At a yearly meeting, give the members a single page showing what came in, what went out, by category, and what remains. Allow time for questions, and write them down. Answer those you can at once; promise a written answer to the others. Week 5 builds this page properly.
Step two: a standing invitation. Tell the members that anyone who has a question about the accounts may ask the treasurer or the chairman, and that a member of the finance committee will always be glad to explain. Then, when someone does ask, thank them. The first time a question is greeted with warmth, the habit begins.
8. In a parish and in a free church
In a parish whose accounts are partly kept by a diocese, the parish may show its local figures to its council or people, while the diocese publishes its own. Members may ask: what is the parish’s share of the whole? The openness is then two-layered, and each layer needs care.
In a free church the whole congregation may itself approve the accounts at a meeting. Here the risk is rather a lack of structure: the yearly page is never made, and the "openness" is the habit of everyone knowing everything about everyone. That is not really openness; it is chatter, and it often leaves out the very things that matter.
Diagram 1. Who sees what
핵심 요약
- Acts 6 and 2 Corinthians 8 show gifts handled in the open: the carriers were chosen by the community and arranged so that no one could blame them.
- Paul cared to be honest "in the sight of the Lord" and also "in the sight of men"; being faithful and being seen to be faithful are two parts of one duty.
- Openness is not suspicion; when regular and ordinary, it protects the treasurer, honours the giver and helps the congregation decide.
- Show the whole congregation how money was used, protect individuals’ private data, and let those who need to check be able to check.
- Readers differ on disclosing givers’ names, staff pay and help to the needy; this course requires the minimum above, not any one side’s maximum.
- A small congregation can begin with one page a year and a standing invitation to ask questions.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What did Paul arrange in 2 Corinthians 8? | A carrier chosen by the assemblies, so that no one could blame him for how the gift was handled. |
| Is openness suspicion? | No. Regular, ordinary openness protects the treasurer, honours the giver and helps the congregation decide. |
| The three groups of information | Shown to all (use of money), open to checkers (statements, receipts), protected (what individuals gave, who was helped, access details). |
| Where do readers differ? | How far to disclose givers' names, staff pay and help to needy people; this course asks for the minimum, not a side. |
One sentence to remember Be faithful with the money, and arrange things so that others can see that you were.
This week's action Draft, on one page and with invented numbers, the headings of a yearly report your congregation could show its members: income, spending by category, balance and special funds.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- How would a member of your congregation find out how the money was used last year? Is the way easy, hard or unknown?
- In 2 Corinthians 8, Paul arranges for others to see that he is honest. What does it say about a leader if he or she resists the same arrangement?
- Have you heard a question about money greeted as an insult? What would have made it an ordinary question?
- Which of the three lists (shown, protected, open to checkers) would your congregation find easiest to agree? Which hardest?
- State in your own words the strongest argument for full disclosure and the strongest argument for privacy. Which concerns do you share with each side?
- In your tradition, who is entitled to see the detailed accounts: every member, the governing body, a bishop or a higher office? Is that written down?