Lecture 5-3: Pay and Expenses for Ministers and Staff
목차 25
- Lecture 1-1: Entrusted Money, Entrusted People
- Lecture 1-2: Who Does What with the Money
- Lecture 1-3: Why Openness Matters
- Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab: Mapping Our Money
- Lecture 2-1: A Budget Is a Ministry Plan
- Lecture 2-2: Building the Budget
- Lecture 2-3: Reserves, Cash Flow and the Seasons
- Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab: A Year's Budget for an Invented Congregation
- Lecture 3-1: Receiving and Counting Gifts
- Lecture 3-2: Spending: Request, Approval, Payment, Receipt
- Lecture 3-3: The Ledger and the Monthly Check
- Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab: Balancing an Invented Month
- Lecture 4-1: Never Leave It to One Person
- Lecture 4-2: Accounts, Cards and Cash
- Lecture 4-3: Checking: Audits and Warning Signs
- Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab: Finding the Gaps in a Procedure
- Lecture 5-1: Reporting to the Congregation
- Lecture 5-2: Designated Gifts, Charity Funds and Missions
- Lecture 5-3: Pay and Expenses for Ministers and Staff
- Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab: Reading and Writing a Year-End Report
Few subjects in a congregation are harder to speak about than the pay of the people who serve it. Pay touches a person's home, their children and their sense of being valued. It also touches the givers, who may wonder whether the money is used well. So many congregations say nothing, or leave the matter to one person's memory, or settle it in a hurry at the end of a long meeting. Years later, the arrangement has no written record, and neither the minister nor the congregation can say how it began or who agreed to it.
This lecture does not say how much anyone should be paid. It gives no amounts and no legal rules, because both differ from place to place, from tradition to tradition and from year to year. It teaches a way of deciding, recording and reporting pay and expenses that protects the person, the givers and the treasurer alike. The principle of the week applies here as everywhere: people who gave have a right to understand what was done with their gifts. For the people who are paid, the same principle gives a second protection. A person whose pay was set by a written and open process cannot be accused of having set it for themselves.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why the person concerned, and their close family, should not decide their own pay alone.
- Describe a written process for deciding pay and reviewing it.
- Distinguish pay from the repayment of expenses, and describe a simple expense claim.
- Describe how a conflict of interest is declared and handled.
- State fairly the disagreements about who decides pay and how openly it is reported, and say what this course requires.
Let the elders who rule well be counted worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in the word and in teaching. For the Scripture says, “You shall not muzzle the ox when it treads out the grain.” And, “The laborer is worthy of his wages.”" — 1 Timothy 5:17-18
World English Bible
Even so the Lord ordained that those who proclaim the Good News should live from the Good News." — 1 Corinthians 9:14
WEB
I coveted no one’s silver, or gold, or clothing. You yourselves know that these hands served my necessities, and those who were with me. In all things I gave you an example, that so laboring you ought to help the weak, and to remember the words of the Lord Jesus, that he himself said, ‘It is more blessed to give than to receive.’”" — Acts 20:33-35
WEB
The first two passages say that those who labour in teaching and in proclaiming the Good News may properly be supported by those they serve. "Double honor" in the first passage is read by some as honour and respect, by some as honour that includes pay, and by some as pay itself. All the readings accept the saying that follows it: the worker is worthy of wages. The third passage shows Paul, in his farewell to the elders of Ephesus, who describes working with his own hands and wanting no one's silver or gold. Scripture therefore holds both: the right of the worker to be supported, and the freedom of a worker to give up the right. It sets no rate and no method. Neither passage is a rule for a particular congregation. Together they say that a congregation should neither deny honest support nor let anyone treat the support as a prize.
1. Three questions
When a congregation thinks about the pay of a minister or a member of staff, there are three separate questions, and mixing them causes confusion.
- Whether and how much. Does this role carry pay, and what is a fair arrangement? The answer depends on the work, on what the congregation can afford, on what is customary in the area and the tradition, and on the needs of the person's household.
- Who decides, and how. By what process, by which people, and on what record?
- What is shown, and to whom. What do the givers see, what does the governing body see, what stays between the person and the few who must know?
This lecture says almost nothing about the first question, because the answer is local. It says a good deal about the second and the third, because a poor answer to either harms people whatever the answer to the first is.
2. Traditions differ, and that is allowed
In some traditions the central body sets pay for all ministers, and the local congregation pays into a common fund. In others the local congregation decides, perhaps with a recommended scale. In some, ministers are unpaid or partly paid and earn their living from other work. In some, the minister is a religious who has taken a vow and the community holds the property in common. In some places, the status of a minister in law is employment. In others, it is not. Staff such as a musician, a caretaker or a secretary may be employed in one place and engaged for single tasks in another.
None of this is wrong. What matters is that the arrangement, whatever it is, is written down, known to those who need to know, and decided in a way that does not leave one person alone with their own interests. The rest of the lecture is about that.
Whether someone is an employee, and what that means for tax, social insurance, leave, notice and other duties, is a legal question that differs by country. This course does not answer it. Ask a local lawyer, an accountant or your denominational office early, before the arrangement is made and not after a problem.
3. A written process, and not the person concerned alone
The person whose pay is being decided does not decide it alone.
This is the central rule of the lecture. It is not a statement of distrust. It is a rule that any careful person would want for themselves. A minister who sets their own pay may choose well, and the congregation will still wonder. A minister whose pay was set by others, by a process anyone can see, can answer every question with: "This is what we agreed, and here is the record."
A simple written process has these parts.
- A small group that does not include the person. Often a few members of the governing body or the finance committee. If the minister is a member of the governing body, they leave the room for this item, and do not vote. In a denomination where a central body decides, it is that body, according to its rules.
- No close family on the group. A spouse, parent, child, sibling or business partner of the person is not a member of the group. The same goes for anyone who would gain or lose from the result.
- A clear brief. The group asks: what work is expected of this role? What can the congregation afford, in the light of the budget (lecture 2-2)? What do comparable congregations or the denomination customarily do? What does the household reasonably need? The answers are written down.
- A written recommendation to the governing body. The governing body decides, and the person concerned is not present for the decision.
- A written agreement with the person. It says what the pay covers, and what else is provided (housing, leave, expenses, and so on), and when it will next be reviewed. A letter signed by two officers and the person is enough. The agreement is kept in a safe place that more than one officer can reach.
- A review on a fixed schedule. A review each year or every few years, by the same process, so that pay does not slip behind or race ahead unnoticed.
- A record in the minutes that the decision was taken, without necessarily listing the amount if the congregation's rule on disclosure keeps it private (see below).
In a small congregation where everyone is related or the governing body is only three people, this is hard. The remedy is to bring in someone from outside: an adviser from the denominational office, a respected person from a neighbouring congregation, or a member who has no tie to the person. The outsider need not decide; they can read the written recommendation and say whether the process looks fair. A congregation with one unpaid leader and no staff may have nothing to decide, but the same care applies if a gift or allowance is ever given to that leader.
4. Expenses are not pay
Pay is what a person receives for the work. An expense is money the person spent for the congregation and is repaid. The line between them matters for honesty, and in many places for the law.
- Do not use expenses as a hidden salary. If a person is to be rewarded, reward them openly as pay. Repaying "expenses" that were never spent is a false statement on a record.
- Use a simple claim form. The date, what the money was spent on, the amount, and a receipt or a short note if no receipt is possible. The person signs.
- Someone else approves it. The treasurer approves the minister's claim. The chair approves the treasurer's. No person approves their own claim, whatever their rank.
- Repay promptly and in the ordinary way, by the same route as any other payment (lecture 3-2).
- Keep personal and congregational spending apart. Do not use the congregation's card or account for private purchases "to be repaid later". If it happens by mistake, tell the treasurer at once, and repay it with a note.
- Agree the rules for allowances in advance. Some congregations pay a fixed travel or hospitality allowance instead of claims. If so, write down what it covers. Ask a local adviser how an allowance is treated for tax.
- Treat a minister's discretionary fund like any charity fund (lecture 5-2): a record by case number, a second person who knows, a total in the report.
An invented example. (an invented example) An assembly's pastor drives to visit people in a hospital 40 kilometres away, about twice a month. The treasurer and the pastor agree in writing that distance is recorded on a simple log, and that the congregation repays it at a rate the finance committee has set, which it reviews each year. The log is signed by the pastor and checked by the treasurer. Nothing hangs on the amount. What matters is that the method was agreed, written and used the same way each month.
5. Conflicts of interest
A conflict of interest exists when a person who has a say in a decision may gain from it, or when their duty to the congregation might pull against another loyalty. It is not a fault. Almost every congregation, sooner or later, has one: a member of the committee who owns a business that quotes for the repair; a treasurer whose daughter applies for the post of organist; a minister whose spouse is asked to lead a paid programme.
A conflict is a problem only if it is hidden or ignored. A declared conflict can be handled with dignity. The practice is simple.
- Declare early and in writing, before the matter is discussed. Many congregations make this a standing item at the start of every committee meeting: "Does anyone have an interest in anything on today's list?"
- Leave the room for the discussion and the decision. Do not vote.
- Record it in the minutes: who declared, what the interest was, that the person left.
- Compare alternatives. If the congregation is to buy from or hire someone connected with a member, obtain at least one other quotation or description of alternatives, and keep it.
- Decide whether it can go ahead at all. Sometimes the answer is yes, with a record. Sometimes the answer is no, because the interest is too close. The group decides, without the person concerned.
A treasurer or a minister who declares an interest early is not showing weakness. They are showing the kind of person to whom a congregation can safely entrust its money. In a congregation where such declarations are normal, nobody is embarrassed by them. In one where they are rare, the first declaration is hard, and it is worth making anyway.
Gifts of money or goods from members to a minister or a member of staff raise a similar question. Many congregations ask that any gift beyond a small token be mentioned to the chair or the committee. They do not forbid kindness. They protect the person from the later suspicion that a gift bought a favour.
6. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: who decides a minister's pay. Some hold that this belongs to the local congregation, through its council or a business meeting, because the congregation pays and knows the work. Their reasoning is strong: those who give should have a say in how their gifts are used, and a person who works among them is best judged by them. Others hold that the decision should lie with a central body, such as a bishop's office, a presbytery or a conference, because a local congregation may be too generous out of affection, too stingy out of habit, or too pressed by a single powerful member. Their reasoning is also strong: it gives ministers a measure of independence, and it stops a minister's pay from becoming a way to reward or punish what the minister preaches.
Many traditions use a mixture: a scale from the centre, applied by the local body. This course does not choose among these. It requires that, in whichever pattern, the decision is never taken by the person concerned alone, that there is a written process, and that the result is recorded.
This is a point where readers will not agree: how openly pay is reported. Some hold that a congregation should publish what each paid person receives. Their reasoning: the money comes from the givers; those who give have a right to know; openness prevents favouritism; and in some traditions the minister's pay has always been public. Others hold that the congregation should publish only the total cost of people (for example "staff and ministers: 22 units"), with detail seen by the governing body and the auditor. Their reasoning: pay is a private matter of a household; publishing it invites comparison, envy and pressure; and a small congregation's total may name one person anyway. Some hold a middle view: each member may ask to see the detail, on a stated rule, in private.
This course requires less than any one of these. Always show the total cost of staff and ministers in the report to the congregation, so that the largest line is never hidden. Let the congregation's own written rule decide how much further to go, apply the rule equally to every person, including the clergy and the treasurer, and make sure that the governing body and the person who checks the accounts see the full detail. If a member asks to see the arrangement, the rule says who answers and how.
7. In a parish and in a free church
In a parish, the pay of the priest or minister may be set by a diocese or a national body, and the parish council may have no say in the amount. Then the parish's work is to pay on time, to record it, and to handle expenses and allowances under the same rules. Staff of the parish, such as a secretary or a sexton, are often decided locally, and then the written process described above is the parish council's own.
In a free church the pastor may be chosen and paid by the members. There the pull of affection or of one strong voice is the greater risk, and the written process matters more. Where the whole membership meets to decide, the chair should present the group's written recommendation, the pastor and family should be absent for the discussion, and the minutes should record the decision.
In a very small assembly, the leader may be unpaid, and the group may give "love gifts" at times. The same care applies: say openly who collects it, record it, and let the group agree the method.
8. When there is a dispute
Sooner or later someone will feel that a person is paid too much or too little. Take that as a reason to look at the process and not as a reason to attack the person. A calm question to the chair, "Can we see how this was decided?", should receive a calm answer: the written recommendation, the date, the review date. If the process is sound, the answer comforts. If it is weak, the question has done its work. If the discussion becomes a quarrel between people, lecture 6-2 explains how to keep a possible wrong and a private disagreement apart.
Diagram 1. How pay is decided, and how expenses are claimed
핵심 요약
- The person concerned does not decide their own pay alone; the rule protects the person and the congregation.
- A written process has a small group without the person or close family, a written recommendation, a decision by the governing body, a written agreement and a fixed review.
- Pay and expenses are different: an expense repays real spending, needs a signed claim, and is approved by someone other than the claimant.
- A conflict of interest is declared early, the person leaves the room, it is recorded, and alternatives are compared.
- Whether pay is decided locally or centrally, and how openly it is reported, varies; the report always shows the total cost of staff and ministers.
- Whether someone is an employee and what that means is a local legal question; ask early.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The central rule on pay | The person concerned, and close family, do not decide it alone; a written process does. |
| Pay and expenses | Pay rewards the work; an expense repays money already spent, with a signed claim approved by someone else. |
| Handling a conflict of interest | Declare early, leave the room, record it, compare alternatives. |
| What the report always shows | The total cost of staff and ministers; further detail follows the congregation's written rule. |
One sentence to remember No one should set their own pay or approve their own claim, and everyone is safer when that is the rule.
This week's action Find out whether your congregation has a written process for deciding pay and a written rule on declaring interests. If either is missing, write down the first three lines of what it would say.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Is the way your congregation decides pay written down anywhere? If not, who would remember how it began?
- Who is in the room when a minister's pay is discussed? Who is out of it? Is that the right way round?
- Where do expense repayments in your congregation come from, and who approves them? Is there a person who approves their own?
- When was the last time someone declared an interest at a meeting you attended? What did it feel like, and what did the group do?
- Which view on reporting pay do you find stronger, openness about each person or only a total? What does the other view see that you might miss?
- In your setting, who outside the congregation could be asked to read a written recommendation about pay and say whether the process looks fair?