Lecture 3-2: Spending: Request, Approval, Payment, Receipt
목차 25
- Lecture 1-1: Entrusted Money, Entrusted People
- Lecture 1-2: Who Does What with the Money
- Lecture 1-3: Why Openness Matters
- Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab: Mapping Our Money
- Lecture 2-1: A Budget Is a Ministry Plan
- Lecture 2-2: Building the Budget
- Lecture 2-3: Reserves, Cash Flow and the Seasons
- Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab: A Year's Budget for an Invented Congregation
- Lecture 3-1: Receiving and Counting Gifts
- Lecture 3-2: Spending: Request, Approval, Payment, Receipt
- Lecture 3-3: The Ledger and the Monthly Check
- Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab: Balancing an Invented Month
- Lecture 4-1: Never Leave It to One Person
- Lecture 4-2: Accounts, Cards and Cash
- Lecture 4-3: Checking: Audits and Warning Signs
- Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab: Finding the Gaps in a Procedure
- Lecture 5-1: Reporting to the Congregation
- Lecture 5-2: Designated Gifts, Charity Funds and Missions
- Lecture 5-3: Pay and Expenses for Ministers and Staff
- Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab: Reading and Writing a Year-End Report
(An invented example.) The youth leader of a mid-sized congregation needs paint for a room. She buys it on Saturday with her own money, because the shop is open and the room is needed on Sunday. On Monday she gives the treasurer a handwritten note: "Paint, a fair amount, please repay." The treasurer wants to help her. But the budget line for the room has already been used by the heating bill, the note has no amount that can be checked, and nobody approved the purchase. The leader is a good person who did a good thing. She is also now hurt, and the treasurer is uncomfortable.
The fault is not in either of them. The fault is that no path existed for spending money, or that the path existed and was not known. If a short, clear path had been written down and shared, the leader would have asked on Friday, the treasurer would have said yes or no, and the receipt would have been in an envelope on Monday.
This lecture gives that path. It has four steps: request, approval, payment, receipt. Each step is done by a different person where it can be, and each leaves a paper. The result is that every unit of money that leaves the congregation leaves a trail that two people could follow.
이 18분으로 얻는 것
- Describe the four steps in the path of a payment and say who does each.
- Explain why approval limits rise with the size of the payment, and who sets them.
- Describe how an advance is given and settled.
- Say what to do when money has been spent without approval, including in an emergency.
- Explain why the person who requests a payment does not also approve or make it.
Repay no one evil for evil. Respect what is honorable in the sight of all men." — Romans 12:17
World English Bible
A false balance is an abomination to Yahweh, but accurate weights are his delight." — Proverbs 11:1
WEB
Paul tells the Romans to care about what is honourable in the eyes of everyone, not only in their own eyes. A payment path serves this. The proverb is about honest measures in trade. A receipt that matches what was paid is a small honest measure.
1. Why a path at all
A path is a promise made in advance about how money will leave. It has three uses.
First, it protects the person who spends. The youth leader above did well, and she was left unsure whether she would be repaid. A path would have told her what to do.
Second, it protects the congregation. Money leaves only for purposes that were agreed, in amounts that were agreed, and for reasons that can be shown.
Third, it makes the monthly check possible. Lecture 3-3 explains how the ledger is matched with the bank statement. If payments are made without papers, the match cannot be made, and a difference becomes a mystery instead of a small task.
A path is not meant to slow ministry. A short path, used by everyone, is quicker than no path, because nobody has to argue afterwards about whether something was allowed.
2. The four steps
1. Request. The person who needs money says so, in writing. The request states what is needed, why, for which ministry or budget line, how much, and by when. A message to the treasurer, a short form, or an entry in a shared sheet will do. The point is that it is written down before the money is spent.
2. Approval. Someone with authority says yes or no, in writing. That person is not the one who asked. Approval checks three things: the purpose is one the congregation agreed to, there is money in the budget line, and the amount is reasonable. A "yes" can also be conditional: "Yes, but ask for a second quotation."
3. Payment. The money is paid by someone other than the person who approved it, and preferably by a method that leaves a record. A bank transfer or a cheque leaves a record by itself. Cash should be avoided where another method will do, and when cash must be used it is paid against a signed voucher. Where it is practical, the supplier is paid directly, and the person who ordered the goods does not carry the cash.
4. Receipt. The supplier gives an invoice or receipt, and the payer keeps proof that it was paid. The receipt is attached to the request, and both are filed. Then the payment is recorded in the ledger.
Four steps, three or four different people where the size of the congregation allows. In the smallest congregation, one person may do two steps, but the person who asks should not be the one who approves.
3. Approval limits by size
Not every payment needs the same level of approval. A small payment that is plainly within the budget should not need the governing body to meet. A very large payment should not rest on one person's signature. A sensible arrangement sets limits by size, written down and agreed by the governing body.
(An invented example.) A congregation might decide:
| Size of payment | Who may approve |
|---|---|
| Small, within a budget line | The leader of that ministry, with the treasurer's check that money remains |
| Medium | The treasurer and one other officer together |
| Large, or outside the budget | The finance committee or the governing body, by a recorded decision |
What counts as small, medium and large depends on the congregation's size, and the congregation fixes it. This course gives no figures, because a figure that suits a cathedral parish would be absurd in a house church and the other way round. The principle is that the bigger the payment, the more people look at it before the money leaves.
Two cautions. First, a payment may not be split into small pieces to stay under a limit. If a large purchase is made in three parts, the three parts are one payment. Second, the limit applies to everyone, including the clergy and the officers. A rule that excuses the senior people teaches everyone else that the rule is about rank and not about care. If the pastor or priest needs money for a purpose, the pastor or priest makes a request like anyone else, and someone else approves it.
4. Who may not approve their own payment
A person never approves a payment to themselves, to a close relative, or to a business in which they have an interest. This is a plain rule, and it protects the person who holds it. Where such a payment is proper, such as repaying an expense or buying from a firm owned by a member, the person declares the interest, steps out, and someone else decides. Lecture 5-3 returns to this for pay and expenses.
5. Advances and settlements
Sometimes money is needed before the receipts exist: a youth camp, a conference trip, a visit to buy food for a feast. For this, congregations use an advance: a sum given to a named person before the event, for a named purpose.
An advance is safe when it follows five rules:
- It is requested and approved like any other payment, with the purpose and the amount.
- It is recorded as an advance (money out of the account but not yet spent), not as spending.
- The person who receives it signs for it.
- A date is set for settlement: the person brings the receipts and returns any money left over.
- No new advance is given to a person who has not settled the last one.
At settlement, the receipts and the money returned must add up to the advance. If they do not, the first assumption is a counting error or a lost receipt, and the person is asked, kindly, to help find it. If a receipt is truly lost, the person writes a signed note saying what was bought, where, when and for how much, and the treasurer marks it as an exception. An exception is allowed sometimes. It is not allowed as a habit.
6. When money has been spent without approval
It will happen. Someone spends before asking, or the event comes before the meeting, or the leak in the roof does not wait.
The approach has three parts.
Emergencies come first. If a pipe bursts at night, the person present acts. A congregation can make this easy by naming, in advance, one or two people who may spend up to a stated amount in an emergency without prior approval, provided they tell the treasurer within a day or two. This puts the emergency inside the path rather than outside it.
An unapproved spend that is not an emergency is a reason to repair the process, not to condemn the person. The treasurer or the committee asks what happened. Was the path unknown? Was it too slow? Was it ignored? If the path was unknown, tell people. If it was too slow, make it faster. If it was ignored, say gently and plainly that the path must be used.
Repaying such a spend is a decision, not an automatic duty. The finance committee or the governing body may decide to repay it, usually after the fact, with a note in the minutes. It may decide not to repay it. In either case the decision is recorded, and the person is told the reason. The youth leader above should be thanked, repaid if the committee decides so, and shown the path so that it does not happen again.
7. What a receipt is for
A receipt is not a bureaucratic ritual. It does three things. It shows that the payment went to the person and for the reason stated. It lets someone who was not present check it. And it protects the person who paid, because it is their answer to the question, "Where did the money go?"
Receipts differ by country and by supplier. In some places small traders give no printed receipts. Then the person who pays writes the note of what, when, from whom and how much, and, where possible, the seller signs or marks it. A written note is better than nothing, and it is clearly marked as a note.
A receipt for something personal must not be mixed in. Money for the congregation is not used for a private purchase, even if the person intends to repay it later. This protects the person from any suggestion that they borrowed.
8. The same path in a parish and in a small church
In a large parish with a staff, the path may be a printed form that moves from the ministry leader to the parish office, to the treasurer, and to the person who pays. Some parishes pay many bills through a diocesan office; in that case, the parish approves and the office pays, and the receipts are still kept in the parish.
In a small free church, there may be an who asks, a treasurer who approves, and a second elder who signs the cheque or confirms the online payment. In a house church with a very small group, the "path" may be three lines in a message thread: "I need this, for this, this much," "Approved," "Paid; receipt attached." The shape is the same. What matters is that it is written, that the person asking is not the person approving, and that the receipt is kept.
Diagram 1. The path of a payment
핵심 요약
- A payment follows four steps: a written request, approval by someone else, payment by a third person where possible, and a receipt kept with the request.
- Approval limits rise with the size of the payment; the congregation sets them in writing, and they apply to everyone, including the clergy.
- No one approves a payment to themselves, to a close relative, or to a firm in which they have an interest.
- An advance is recorded as an advance, signed for, and settled by a set date with receipts and any money left over.
- In an emergency, a named person acts and tells the treasurer; in other unapproved spending, the process is repaired first and the committee decides whether to repay.
- A lost receipt is replaced by a signed note, allowed as an exception and not as a habit.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four steps of a payment | Request, approval, payment, receipt. |
| Who approves? | Someone other than the person who asked; the level rises with the size, as set in writing by the congregation. |
| What is an advance? | Money given before spending to a named person for a named purpose, recorded as an advance and settled by a set date. |
| Money spent without approval? | Emergency: act and tell. Otherwise repair the process; the committee decides on repayment and records it. |
One sentence to remember A written request, a different person's approval, a payment that leaves a record, and a receipt kept: that is a trail two people can follow.
This week's action Write the path of a payment in your congregation in four lines, and mark the step that is most often skipped.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- In your congregation, how does a person get money for something the ministry needs? Is the path written, or does everyone have to ask someone?
- Who approves a payment in your setting? Is it ever the same person who asked?
- What counts as a small, medium and large payment where you serve? Who decided, and when?
- How do you handle an emergency purchase? Is there a person who may spend without waiting for a meeting?
- Think of a time money was spent without approval and the person was embarrassed. What would have prevented it? What would you say to that person now?
- The lecture says the limit applies to the clergy. What does your congregation do when the pastor or priest needs money for a purpose?